Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this what social mobility looks like? Multimillionaire sister / benefit dependant sister

140 replies

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 08:48

A friend of mine in council accommodation entirely reliant on benefits has a sister who is a multimillionaire.

I have been aware of this situation for over a decade, and find it unusual. They seem to be on good terms and visit each other's houses. I know rich sister helped poor sister out once or twice with train fare to family events, but nothing more than that, I don't think.

They come from a fairly average middle class home, father a professional, mother worked part time. Parents remained in their middle class home until father died and mother moved into nursing home.

Both are graduates, both are single mums.

The only time I am aware of it causing any problems are when one cousin ( from council flat) got into trouble at school for "lying" about who her aunty is - she was telling the truth but no one believed her.

I suppose in a truly socially mobile society, this should be common, but I think it is an unusual situation. Perhaps it is more common that I think.

YABU - this is how it should be, and/or this situation is common
YANBU - this is rare.

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:01

If she gives the sister cash she will lose her benefits I’m guessing? So to give her any significant help would mean either she would be financing the sister for life, or she would give the sister a leg up and the sister would have to then find a job to continue the lifestyle. Maybe she’s lazy, has no intention of working and would rather stay on benefits than take a handout which would mean she loses them 🤷🏼‍♀️

underneaththeash · 03/02/2024 14:58

JustFrustrated · 03/02/2024 09:14

This is a depressing read.
Not entirely true either.

It’s not at all. The majority of people I know in my town (Beaconsfield) had normal or low income childhoods and did well for themselves.

My DH is from a council house in the north and just worked had at school, choose a well paid career and worked really hard at it.

Gowlett · 03/02/2024 14:45

Even very rich & famous people have tried to help out family members with issues (not just financial). Life’s not that simple.

lifeispainauchocolat · 03/02/2024 14:00

Crispedia · 03/02/2024 13:57

Not the main point of OP’s post, but if I was a multi millionaire and my siblings had no addiction problems (which I would try and support them with) I would given them some financial support. Even my brother who I am not that close to. What’s the point of having lots of money and not sharing it with people you care about.

Edited

The thing is, it's not always that simple. Giving money to family can cause all kinds of rifts and drama, even when relationships were previously good.

Crispedia · 03/02/2024 13:57

Not the main point of OP’s post, but if I was a multi millionaire and my siblings had no addiction problems (which I would try and support them with) I would given them some financial support. Even my brother who I am not that close to. What’s the point of having lots of money and not sharing it with people you care about.

HollyKnight · 03/02/2024 13:51

It has nothing to do with class /social mobility. They are individuals. It doesn't matter that they have the same parents and had the same upbringing, they are still individuals with their own unique personalities. Having the same start in life doesn't mean you'll have the same life.

ApoodlecalledPenny · 03/02/2024 13:31

How can there be no job she’s suited for? In a multimillion pound company you’ll have everything from HR to PAs, to receptionists. And depending on the company, logistics. I temped for Richard Branson once, his sister was his PA. There’s always A job. Doesn’t have to be doing whatever high flying thing the company does overall. And this is a degree level educated person - there would be something she could do.

maddening · 03/02/2024 13:27

I think that the disparity is greater because they have gone different directions from their start point - both started middle class, one went up the other down.

Ibizafun · 03/02/2024 13:25

quisensoucie · 03/02/2024 09:41

@notknowledgeable I am struggling to understand why this is any of your business, nor why you choose to broadcast yourfriend's social situation all over a national forum.

Why are you on this national forum? You were obviously interested enough to answer, so perhaps others may be interested too?

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 03/02/2024 13:22

Redpaisley · 03/02/2024 12:27

But in OP you called poorer sister your friend and towards the end called them cousins and now saying you know her through her ex. Why not decide once what relationship you want to show you have with her.

Anyways, if I have a sister with a child dependant on state benefits, I would find a role in my international business. It cannot be a ricket science company considering rich sister started it before finishing college. The business has expanded internationally, poorer sister is educated - she can work in a lot of supportive functions in the organisation. It happens in family businesses, celebrity world, you try to help your own. Your reaction to this possibility was strong.

Based on what the op has said it is her ex-sil (brothers ex-wife) who she is good friends with.

lifeispainauchocolat · 03/02/2024 13:19

I think it's pretty common for siblings to end up leading very different lives. Your upbringing only plays a small part in who you become as an adult, after all.

AgnesX · 03/02/2024 13:18

Having money or otherwise won't change their social class really. Nouveau riche and all that. It will benefit their children though. Class change always takes a generation (IMO, I don't have any stats to base that on).

Londonrach1 · 03/02/2024 13:17

Sounds like they have a lovely relationship. It's not that rare.

Bluenotgreen · 03/02/2024 13:14

I can't imagine being a multi millionaire and not helping my sister financially if she were struggling.

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 03/02/2024 13:10

User2356542 · 03/02/2024 09:13

It's obviously very rare but there are also not enough details. In a true socially mobile society, the sister needs to be a self-made multimillionaire in an industry that is related to her degree and that everyone has access to. Is this the case?

If her ex-partner (or their family) was involved in any way then she has not achieved social mobility, she was just lucky or looks attractive. Did her business receive any starting investment/capital from her former partner? Did she get any lump sum or high value asset as part of the divorce?

Sorry to be cynical, but in most cases where a relatively young woman has achieved great success, there is some personal connection to a man (or men) along the way. Whether it be as a partner, divorce settlement, inheritance etc.

If she truly earned her millions via a high-powered salaried job or a startup she created entirely herself then hats off and she deserves a lot of respect and accolade. However the in itself is a total outlier, especially also being a single mum, so it's not a situation that is replicable by other single mums in similar positions.

"Sorry to be cynical, but in most cases where a relatively young woman has achieved great success, there is some personal connection to a man (or men) along the way. Whether it be as a partner, divorce settlement, inheritance etc"

Aren't you a delight?!.

BertieBotts · 03/02/2024 13:07

I don't know how usual it is, but a similar situation happened in my family - my mum has always struggled with employment due to MH issues whereas her brother who is very confident (and honestly, quite controlling/bullying) has been very successful in business.

On my dad's side, my dad came from a military family with some money, he has been fairly average/middle class over his life but his sister married into another military connection and they have had a higher income because of that.

FreddyGD · 03/02/2024 13:06

Gillypie23 · 03/02/2024 12:47

I'm not sure what your point is. It's none of your business. Do you think the rich sister should be buying poor sister a house and paying her bills.

If I was the rich sister I would without a doubt be buying my sister a house and helping her out. Multi millions of pounds and not making my sisters life more comfortable just wouldn’t happen.

FreddyGD · 03/02/2024 13:04

Blanketenvy · 03/02/2024 09:28

I find it odd. I can't imagine being a multi millionaire and not buying a sibling a nice place to live (if they wanted) unless there is some complex backstory, but in my family we help each other out in different ways and are aware that our own financial success or lack of is due to health/disability/circumstance and not just eg irresponsibility.

This.

LonginesPrime · 03/02/2024 13:03

I honestly don't think where you end up is a product of where you start or qualifications, it's aptitude, attitude and drive.

Aptitude and drive can obviously increase one's income, but it won't protect someone from ending up on benefits through having a disabled child or developing a disability themselves, for example.

There could be any number of reasons that someone ends up on benefits at a given point in time, and I find the comments by some PPs on this thread suggesting that people on benefits must have "made bad decisions" to get there rather tasteless and naive.

Gillypie23 · 03/02/2024 12:47

I'm not sure what your point is. It's none of your business. Do you think the rich sister should be buying poor sister a house and paying her bills.

RoseGoldEagle · 03/02/2024 12:38

Do you mean it’s unusual because you’d expect the multi millionaire sister to help the sister on benefits out? Or just unusual that they’re in such different financial positions? It would be even more unusual if they’d both independently before multi millionaires, so it doesn’t seem that unusual that someone who made a lot of money has a sibling who didn’t. It sounds like they have a healthy dynamic to me.

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 12:36

Redpaisley · 03/02/2024 12:27

But in OP you called poorer sister your friend and towards the end called them cousins and now saying you know her through her ex. Why not decide once what relationship you want to show you have with her.

Anyways, if I have a sister with a child dependant on state benefits, I would find a role in my international business. It cannot be a ricket science company considering rich sister started it before finishing college. The business has expanded internationally, poorer sister is educated - she can work in a lot of supportive functions in the organisation. It happens in family businesses, celebrity world, you try to help your own. Your reaction to this possibility was strong.

sorry, dont understand what you are talking about or where you think I have contradicted myself!

But, no, this second sister is not suited for any sort of role in this organisation at all. She has none of the required skills or qualifications. You seem to think anyone can be shoehorned in anywhere with enough lubricant of nepotism, but completely impossible here.

OP posts:
ChanelNo19EDT · 03/02/2024 12:27

Fairly common, having children with somebody that you have to leave (guilty) can bring you down a class.

Not always but it can. One minute I was trying to disguise the fact I'd been to private school! (In some circles, not all), the next I was excluded from the inclusion if you keim because I was a bit broke. Why was I a bit broke? Because I was a single mum. I'll never know with absolute certainty which was the reason that saw me a bit marginalised, at times.
It's always subtle. And people have the right not to include you, notice you, care two hoots about you.

But yes I think I went down a level, socio economically because I had children with not just the wrong man but an awful man.

A cautionary tale!

All of my relatives married people they met on the rowing team or on the debating team and they have maintained or even exceeded the socio economic level they were born into.

Redpaisley · 03/02/2024 12:27

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 10:17

No I am not angry. This is actually my relative's ex, so we are good friends and I am Aunty to her children

But in OP you called poorer sister your friend and towards the end called them cousins and now saying you know her through her ex. Why not decide once what relationship you want to show you have with her.

Anyways, if I have a sister with a child dependant on state benefits, I would find a role in my international business. It cannot be a ricket science company considering rich sister started it before finishing college. The business has expanded internationally, poorer sister is educated - she can work in a lot of supportive functions in the organisation. It happens in family businesses, celebrity world, you try to help your own. Your reaction to this possibility was strong.

Damaged27 · 03/02/2024 12:22

What are you actually trying to say or ask, I'm confused? Yes adults earn different amounts of money and have different jobs this includes siblings.