Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should godparents pay for a child's upkeep?

518 replies

pureshoresss · 03/02/2024 07:01

Will try and keep this brief for fear of not making sense!

I have been asked to be a Godmother by a friend of mine. I was delighted and honoured. The child isn't a baby, but 3 years old. (4 soon). I was asked when the boy was 2 years old. In fact, the other Godparent was asked around the same time too.

My friend is a single mother. The father pays child maintenance, but it is not enforced and therefore sporadic.

But almost every time we speak she says things like:

"Oh, DS would love a new toy car!" (One of those ones that a child can sit and 'drive').

"DS has been asking for a bigger house!"

"DS keeps asking why we are poor!" (They aren't).

"Looks like the private school I had my heart set on for DS isn't going to happen..."

"I can't afford holidays for DS! He wants to go to Hawaii and Florida!"

"I keep telling DS that we can't get a bigger house and it makes him sad! He said all his friends have nice houses!"

"If I were you, I'd sell the Co and buy a nice house outright or help family/friends.... that's what I would do!"

All of the things are only on a materialistic scale. Most conversations are about money/money struggles. Yes, I have offered ideas/help as well as take them out often etc...

I do not have children, but does a 4 year old really ask questions such as the above? Are they aware of money (as a concept) or 'circumstances'?

I don't want to see my friend suffer and whilst I am financially better off, I am not rolling in it! At all! Yes; single parents DO have it tough, I am of course, aware of that. I do not live a flashy lifestyle, I do not spend unnecessarily, but I suppose it is also a 'privilege' to not be in any debt or have any CC balances. If anything, a lot of my money went towards private hospice care for when my mother passed.

These request to be Godmother coincided with me coming into a fair amount of money, but also off the back of going IPO etc... The other Godparent is enormously wealthy. I am not. Company money is still company money and the other money will be going towards my home.

The (other Godparent) lives in France though and my friend and I reside in the UK.

AIBU to think this is odd and a bit awkward? I am a giving person by nature (and by culture too) and I feel like I am meant to offer to pay for the child's upkeep. To be clear, I do give gifts and pay for all outings etc... but I feel bad still. Are Godparents meant to cover the costs of child raising too? Or certainly offer?

OP posts:
SheilaFentiman · 04/02/2024 09:40

VestaTilley · 04/02/2024 09:37

Er, no. It’s a religious role. If neither of you are Christian why have you done it?

No, financial support not expected. A toy on birthday and Christmas is more than enough.

Your “friend” sounds awful.

OP has stated she is a Christian

Thedance · 04/02/2024 09:39

No, you have absolutely no financial responsibility for her child.
Your friend doesn't actually sound much like a friend suggesting you sell your company to buy her a bigger house is extremely cheeky.

VestaTilley · 04/02/2024 09:37

Er, no. It’s a religious role. If neither of you are Christian why have you done it?

No, financial support not expected. A toy on birthday and Christmas is more than enough.

Your “friend” sounds awful.

Calliopespa · 04/02/2024 09:35

pureshoresss · 04/02/2024 01:34

Basically, I just wish it wasn't such an incessant topic as it is creating a really awkward atmosphere. If I offer her help in terms of practical solutions, she always has an answer that disputes what I'm saying. If I change the subject, I feel like a bad person/friend/godparent. If I offer encouragement, she backs off a bit - only to start up again soon afterwards.

All this leads me to think she is just expecting me to write a cheque and all her problems will be solved.

I think you are right OP and she is wanting a cheque.

I think the fact you are a churchgoer is potentially really helpful here as I think it offers a line into the topic to allow you to play things absolutely above board, not mislead her, not withdraw support from your side, but put an end to this hinting and hunting for, essentially, money.

I think you should have a cards on table conversation which might start with asking how she had envisaged your role in guiding him spiritually might play out. Will they start joining you at church? Or what had she had in mind? Then ( particularly if she’s a bit non capsico/ not bothered about those aspects, you can segue into saying you have had the feeling lately that maybe she had envisaged it as a financial role . That was not what, as a churchgoer, you understand the role to be and you had undertaken the role on the basis that you wanted to do a genuinely good job of being a spiritual guide and mentor and remain very happy - and honoured- to do so. However, if that’s not what she was seeking, you feel that maybe she might like to reconsider because perhaps her concept doesn’t fit well with the role you believed you were being asked to fulfil and that you aren’t in a position to fill a financial role. It’s honest, it’s not provoking conflict , if she isn’t angling for money it makes the point she’s coming across that way, and if she is, it makes the point she isn’t getting it. And it gives you an out if it becomes clear that was what she expected,

Crackoncrackerjack · 04/02/2024 09:32

Step away, she just wants to use you

Coldupnorth7 · 04/02/2024 09:02

Think you're getting a bit enmeshed in her drama.

She can moan all she likes but it's good for kids to strive not have everything given to them.

My neighbours were uber-posh and the wife was always dissatisfied. It was mainly due to her family and friends having more money and things (like a crewed yacht). It's social anxiety. To me, they were pretty well off and she would have been happier not coparing herself to them. Her husband did not give af and was very happy, which incensed her more! I really liked them but it was tiring to listen to...

Boundaries!

Murdoch1949 · 04/02/2024 08:59

If you become a godparent, your focus will be the child. Presents at birthday, Christmas, Diwali etc for the child. As the child gets older you could take them for outings on your own, to give mum space. Avoid giving in to the emotional blackmail the mother seems to be using. It is not your responsibility to fund this child's life but to take a special interest in their well-being.

Justkeeepswimming · 04/02/2024 08:45

Does the child really want for all these things?

Possibly but it depends on their situation as to where the messaging is coming from.

Does the child go to school in an area where most of the other children in class are more wealthy?

Or does he go to school with peers that are matched in socioeconomic terms?

If the former it’s likely there are issues with the child feeling inadequate (the kids will come in showing off xyz and talking about fantastic holidays, or he’ll go to play dates at fantastic houses). However, Mum should not be reinforcing it with him.

If the latter, it is all Mum’s grabbiness.

JaneAustensHeroine · 04/02/2024 08:35

Myglassishalffullish · 04/02/2024 08:24

Having read the full thread you sound like such a lovely, warm, caring person and a wonderful friend and this is all absolutely wasted on this grabbing CF who sounds the absolute opposite.

Please don’t waste anymore energy on this one sided friendship and let her crack on trying to sponge off someone else xxx

Agree with this! You sound really lovely OP and that is all the more reason to step away because she isn’t!

Best to distance yourself now. And definitely do not take on a godparent role which she will see as a source of Christmas / birthday / other presents / school fees forever more.

Myglassishalffullish · 04/02/2024 08:24

Having read the full thread you sound like such a lovely, warm, caring person and a wonderful friend and this is all absolutely wasted on this grabbing CF who sounds the absolute opposite.

Please don’t waste anymore energy on this one sided friendship and let her crack on trying to sponge off someone else xxx

StoatofDisarray · 04/02/2024 08:22

No.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 04/02/2024 08:21

She’s bad enough now, she’ll really ramp it up if you do become his Godmother.

JaneAustensHeroine · 04/02/2024 08:17

I’d step (run) away from the friendship. The pleading / comments about what she doesn’t have and comparisons with others would be enough for me to distance myself. Like you say OP, she appears to be looking for a benefactor. I would definitely not put myself in a position of godparent where walking away could lead to me feeling guilty for not being involved in my godson’s life or to being accused of being a disinterested godparent.

She sounds awful and very grabby. Dreadful.

MotherOfHouseplants · 04/02/2024 07:54

Bottom line... I think even declining the GP role, it wouldn't make a difference to her hints.

You are going to have to say something. She clearly has the hide of a rhino and won’t stop with the hints. You could offer to take the child to a family-friendly event at your own church and use this to start a conversation about plans for the child’s baptism. As this point you can then say that you are honoured to be asked to provide spiritual support and guidance to the child, but you want to be absolutely clear that you are not in a position to support the child financially, and she should ask someone else if this is her priority.

Incidentally, if you are in the Church of England she needs to find another godparent anyway, of the same sex as the child. Three is the normal minimum and some priests do insist on sticking to this.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 04/02/2024 07:54

Or just laugh at the next hint “Wouldn’t we all love a holiday in Hawaii/ a big house paid for by someone else, I know I would, unfortunately I have to work for mine.”
“Listen to yourself, would you really sell up your business to give the money to someone else..really! 🤣🤣🤣 I don’t think so”
I don’t think the other Godparent is in any rush to come over, I think he knows he’s being played.

WHALESURPRISE · 04/02/2024 07:52

Great loss to you, that was meant to say!

WHALESURPRISE · 04/02/2024 07:51

It sounds like it won't be a great life to you if you step back from this friendship. It's a shame this person's greed is going to list her a valuable friendship but that's the way things go!

Next time she brings up a comparison of your finances, could you maybe ask her incredulously "why do you think I'm so rich?" If she thinks she's got the wrong end of the stick re: your weath, she might back off a bit.

I'd also pointedly make reference to your role as godparent being for SPIRITUAL guidance, and make any gifts to the child religious ones - a book of Bible stories, a day trip to a cathedral perhaps? (The look on the mums face should bed good for a giggle 😄)

Wasbedeudetetdas · 04/02/2024 07:46

I'm sorry OP.
I think maybe you're starting to realise how she's basically trying to use you and how she has somehow convinced herself that she's entitled to any financial assets you might have.
I'd decline this offer to be GP, and also keep shutting down every conversation where she tries to tell you what her child 'needs'. Stop paying every time you go out too, because that isn't 'normal' either - she should definitely be offering to contribute.
In all honesty the friendship might not survive this, but is it really a friendship you want to save?
It's nice to be nice, as the saying goes, but it sounds like she's manipulating, or at least trying to manipulate, your generosity.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 04/02/2024 07:42

I would turn down her request. It will be a difficult conversation to have but it needs to be said.
Tell her that after careful thought you come to realise you can’t provide the level of support she is expecting. It isn’t your responsibility to provide houses, holidays, private education or expensive toys. This is the parents responsibility. Not the Godparents.
Id suggest she applies to CMS for child maintenance from the boys real father on a more formal arrangement. He should be supporting his child, the pair of them are failing this child.

pureshoresss · 04/02/2024 07:41

MN* not MM.

OP posts:
pureshoresss · 04/02/2024 07:40

P.S. I finally learned what 'CF' means on here. I am so late to the MM lingo!

OP posts:
pureshoresss · 04/02/2024 07:37

Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 07:01

Op I think I'd start asking questions about when is the mother going to take LO to church?
And bring up the GP role is about religious guidance and support.

I don't think the friendship is going to survive the fallout from her constantly asking for money or making heavy hints.

But I think it's time to call her out on it. Make sure you buy something religious- like a book of children's bible stories for the up and coming birthday or Easter.

I agree. I don't think the friendship will survive the heavy hints (almost daily). She has not asked outright for money, but I almost wish she would so I could shut this down. Even if it does survive, it's more about having some boundaries - which I fully accept is on me.

I don't even think the godparent role is the aim here. I think it's secondary to her, but as I'm a church-goer, maybe I was a good fit.

I think it's about having a benefactor for her DS first and foremost. (Certainly since my parents passed and the Co went public). Lots of people had their hands out in the years following my parents' passing and she knew about this at the time as I told her it was so disheartening. I imagine that's why she's not directly asked, but hinted.

All of this is why I asked in my OP if GPs were expected to give/offer financial support. As some posters have said, yes and no.

Yes - in that some give money in cards/for birthday/in ISAs and help out here and there. But nothing on the scale of holidays abroad and homes etc...

No - in that some people think Christmas/Birthday gifts and cards suffice. Which is obviously generous and thoughtful. To clarify, I do send gifts at Christmas and Birthdays - and then some as well as paid/pay for days out.

But more than the 'material' - and above all else; it's about guidance and support and religious/moral values. I fully respect that. Obviously.

Bottom line... I think even declining the GP role, it wouldn't make a difference to her hints.

OP posts:
Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 07:01

Op I think I'd start asking questions about when is the mother going to take LO to church?
And bring up the GP role is about religious guidance and support.

I don't think the friendship is going to survive the fallout from her constantly asking for money or making heavy hints.

But I think it's time to call her out on it. Make sure you buy something religious- like a book of children's bible stories for the up and coming birthday or Easter.

ThanksItHasPockets · 04/02/2024 06:50

Hang on, I missed that the child hasn’t actually been baptised, so OP is not even a godparent yet?! She is a ‘godparent designate’ at best.

I am not sure I would accept the request tbh, OP.

TellMeWhoTheVillainsAre · 04/02/2024 01:57

I wouldn't call her out on it. I just wouldn't comment at all. She is hinting but not asking you outright. So you can play dumb and pretend you're not picking up on the hints. A new (small) toy occasionally is ok. Nothing big though. If she asks you outright for cash just tell her you don't have it. She may suspect your financial situation but she's not going to know for definite. You may have inherited and then blown it all on the horses for all shr knows.
Don't get dragged into her mess. Sounds like she's not doing too badly for herself. Her boy will be fine. He doesn't need a bigger house and big sit on cars. She's not struggling massively. She just wants more than she has. That's fine, but you don't need to be the one who provides it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread