Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should godparents pay for a child's upkeep?

518 replies

pureshoresss · 03/02/2024 07:01

Will try and keep this brief for fear of not making sense!

I have been asked to be a Godmother by a friend of mine. I was delighted and honoured. The child isn't a baby, but 3 years old. (4 soon). I was asked when the boy was 2 years old. In fact, the other Godparent was asked around the same time too.

My friend is a single mother. The father pays child maintenance, but it is not enforced and therefore sporadic.

But almost every time we speak she says things like:

"Oh, DS would love a new toy car!" (One of those ones that a child can sit and 'drive').

"DS has been asking for a bigger house!"

"DS keeps asking why we are poor!" (They aren't).

"Looks like the private school I had my heart set on for DS isn't going to happen..."

"I can't afford holidays for DS! He wants to go to Hawaii and Florida!"

"I keep telling DS that we can't get a bigger house and it makes him sad! He said all his friends have nice houses!"

"If I were you, I'd sell the Co and buy a nice house outright or help family/friends.... that's what I would do!"

All of the things are only on a materialistic scale. Most conversations are about money/money struggles. Yes, I have offered ideas/help as well as take them out often etc...

I do not have children, but does a 4 year old really ask questions such as the above? Are they aware of money (as a concept) or 'circumstances'?

I don't want to see my friend suffer and whilst I am financially better off, I am not rolling in it! At all! Yes; single parents DO have it tough, I am of course, aware of that. I do not live a flashy lifestyle, I do not spend unnecessarily, but I suppose it is also a 'privilege' to not be in any debt or have any CC balances. If anything, a lot of my money went towards private hospice care for when my mother passed.

These request to be Godmother coincided with me coming into a fair amount of money, but also off the back of going IPO etc... The other Godparent is enormously wealthy. I am not. Company money is still company money and the other money will be going towards my home.

The (other Godparent) lives in France though and my friend and I reside in the UK.

AIBU to think this is odd and a bit awkward? I am a giving person by nature (and by culture too) and I feel like I am meant to offer to pay for the child's upkeep. To be clear, I do give gifts and pay for all outings etc... but I feel bad still. Are Godparents meant to cover the costs of child raising too? Or certainly offer?

OP posts:
laveritable · 03/02/2024 10:59

Incredible OP! I could have written this post!!! I am in the exact same situation! I was asked to be a GM and since then; it has been one request after the other! when I could not live up to expectations, she now resents me! Be firm and learn to say NO!!!

Dibbydoos · 03/02/2024 10:59

Friend? Really?

Completely OOO.

Just do what you're doing in terms of visits and small presents, but you need to call her game a game by saying, "Wow, where's he getting these ideas from? It's a bit privileged thinking like that.
Of course you'll be able to go out to work soon so that may help you, but big dreams need big income."

I hope you can remain friends, but she def needs to be 'told' in the nicest way poss to stop with the fantasies thinking you'll fund her life!

Nanaof1 · 03/02/2024 10:59

@pureshoresss I think she is confusing you being a Godmother to being a Fairy Godmother. But her child isn't Cinderfella and unless you have mice that can sew, she's playing you.

She is hoping, that if you say yes, she can guilt-trip you into supporting her and her child with all the things she thinks they deserve and a lifestyle that is unobtainable, even for you, I bet.

I would have declined as soon as she mentioned selling your company so you could "help" family and friends. No real friend would ever, ever say that! She wants a hand-out and unless you want to be nagged into eternity, you should decline. Then she can concentrate on the super wealthy person in France. Heck, maybe she'll move there if they fall for her ploy.

caringcarer · 03/02/2024 10:56

I'm a Godmother to a couple of my nephews but I have 14 nieces and nephews. I have always been an involved Auntie and taken my nieces and nephews on days out, babysat them, and bought them birthday and Xmas gifts. I have helped out my 2 Godsons' a bit more over the years but when they were adults. When one of them was off work sick after a serious accident I helped him pay his mortgage. I did it quietly and certainly my other nieces or nephews were not told. I did also gave them more money when they got married. They will be left with some money in my will too.

MrsAvocet · 03/02/2024 10:53

I think that historically, if parents died and there was no suitable family member to take over the care of a child then the godparents would sometimes do so, but that certainly wouldn't be assumed nowadays.
As others have said,the vows are around supporting the parents in the Christian upbringing of the child, but in practice these days it's often just a recognition that the adult is someone who is close to the parents and will therefore probably be close to the child - a kind of special aunt or uncle type thing. I don't think most people really expect any major input from their children's godparents.

Prunesqualler · 03/02/2024 10:50

No it’s not a Godparents responsibility to finance lifestyle
Its their responsibility , in a very literal sense, to offer emotional and religious support.
Shes hinting I would say, especially given the timing of your ‘upgrade’.
Ignore it and offer advice

AnaMRT · 03/02/2024 10:50

She is taking advantage of you! I have a child that age and him and his two siblings never once said those things at that age. When she says next that DC is asking for a bigger house and he is so sad that his friends have this and that. Just ask the follow up question. Oh no! What are you going to do about it? How are you going to provide that? She’s had the child so she should try and improve her financial situation. It’s not your responsibility!

nightmareXmas · 03/02/2024 10:48

I don't believe a child of that age would make such comments. Children aren't aware of the comparative sizes of houses until much later on, and are generally happy in their own homes unless something is badly wrong.

Your friend is having you on in an attempt to prime you for requests for financial support in the future.

I'm childless and have had experience of being targeted as a godparent for this reason. There is an expectation that you will spend some of the money you have 'saved' from not having children on theirs, and perhaps leave a legacy to them, which makes me really cross. If you think you might struggle to resist the pressure, I would decline.

334bu · 03/02/2024 10:46

And no 4 year old in the history of the world said those things or understands those concepts.

This👆

CharlesChickens · 03/02/2024 10:44

BlunderMifflin · 03/02/2024 07:04

Birthday and Christmas presents! The odd trip out maybe.

This.

wellhello24 · 03/02/2024 10:43

No.

What a cheeky bitch! I could never do that to someone. She also doesn’t sound like she’s struggling that much either. Grabby cow.

And no 4 year old in the history of the world said those things or understands those concepts. She’s also a liar & manipulative

Citrusandginger · 03/02/2024 10:43

I would be so tempted to troll the CF.
Friend^ DS wants a bigger house/holiday to Disney. ^
You: Oh, would you like to me to give him some spiritual guidance and teach him that isn't very Christian?

On a more serious note, my DP both died in an accident when I was small, so I was adopted by my Godfather/Uncle & his wife. So I don't actually think it's crazy to ask GP who are financially stable. But that's a world away from paying for the DM's luxury lifestyle.

mirax · 03/02/2024 10:42

Dear Op, it is heavy and pointed hints now when you are not even officially the godparent. If you persist in not picking up the hints, I guarantee that it will be outright pleas for loans or gifts. The child whom you love may be used a bargaining tool and access denied. There is a whole world of hurt heading your way and the child will be harmed too. Please think twice about this godparent role. Decline the role but still maintain the same level of involvement or try to.

I am asian, Indian. I had relatives who'd use their children to demand gifts from my mother. "Tell grandma you want diamond earrings for your birthday!" When people show you who they are, take note.

DeeLusional · 03/02/2024 10:42

She sounds like a user, also sounds like she thinks you are a lot better off than you are. Many years ago I knew a woman who asked a titled friend of ours (daughter of an earl) to be her daughter's godmother. Thing is though, she had spent years beforehand slagging off this friend. Being a godparent was a religious thing, maybe one might expect to get a better present from a godparent than from other relatives but not to have them buy you a house!

Saz12 · 03/02/2024 10:39

I dont believe her DS is asking for a bigger house and the like. The most would be "Kevin has an AMAZING race car bed!!!" or "Nigel has a swing in his garden!!!" or whatever. When mine was that age, they didnt even consistently make the leap between what Kevin had and what they could have.

Even if is peculiarly materialistic at the age of 3, it still doesn't mean you should pay.

If you're very good friends, can you tell her? Either you cant afford these things for her dc either, you're not a regular churgoer anymore so dont want to be Godmother, etc.

BenditLikeVictoria · 03/02/2024 10:38

@pureshoresss She is not your friend. She is using you. You seem like a lovely, giving person and she’s taking advantage of that.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 03/02/2024 10:36

Agree the son should be or should soon be at an age where you can spend time with him without her which might he'll.

And that before you formally become a godparent set expectations about what the role of a godparent is. Tell her you view it as a child to have regular contact with, and religious guidance. If she says any different to this then tell her no, you love her son but to you and to the church a godparent is mostly about a special relationship and spiritual guidance and if she doesn't see it as that then it could cause issues. Is she religious?

AnonyLonnymouse · 03/02/2024 10:35

Outside the Christian context, I always thought it meant giving them a birthday present each year then helping them get work-experience or an internship much later on!

Grrrpredictivetex · 03/02/2024 10:33

pureshoresss · 03/02/2024 10:02

For those asking, no the christening hasn’t taken place yet but apparently is in the works. Apparently it’s about getting the other godparent over. As per my OP, he lives in France. I’m not sure that’s entirely the reason, but it hasn't bothered me too much - as regardless, the child/mother live in the same city as me.

To answer the other questions… I am not overly religious. But I do still go to Church 3-4 times a year. I used to go to Church with my mother who is (was) Christian Indian. She passed away after a long illness - passed in hospice. So whilst she was sick and after her passing, I struggled to go as often as I did (as she was the person I went with).

My father was Hindu. He’s also no longer with us.

It’s not uncommon for Asians to fight over the bill and usually the person who is older pays. Especially if they earn more, which is often the case anyway if they are older. I tend to always pay for her - and I don’t mind that as I truly do like the child and spending time with him. When I’ve gone to their place; she always offers food and drinks etc… so it’s fine on that front. But I suspect by paying all the time, it has set a precedence. To be fair, we also do non-costly/free things to as he (shocker!) loves going to the park etc...

In terms of the context of such hints; I don’t care if it’s a moan here and there. Or even more often than ‘here and there’! We all moan to our friends and god knows there’s a lot to moan about in the UK these days! But this is relentless and so pointed - and I feel just generally awful. Especially as it’s always centred around the boy - who I love. “I need to get a house… for DS.

“DS has been asking for a bigger house....and keeps asking. I can't provide for him...”

“I found a house (that DS would love)… but it is out of my price range…”

I suppose I was more curious (as you can see from my previous posts) about whether or not children are actually aware of financial discrepancies. He’s 3, (going on 4 soon) and many parents of children aged 3-4 have kindly given their perspective(s) on this (for which I’m very grateful!)

Where is the son's father? Maybe when she makes these comments suggest perhaps the father needs to up his maintenance as it's the parents responsibility to provide for their children.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 03/02/2024 10:32

No in my experience a child doesn't say those things. They might ask a question like 'why does x have house with two living rooms' or 'why does x have his own bedroom' (if they share). But generally just accept an answer (because they have more money to buy a bigger house). They are far more interested in what toys the other child has and other things that are different to their own house (eg if their friend has something that changes colour which they've never seen before, or a bunk bed, that can be fascinating when you're 3/4).

A child that age will not ask to go to hawaii or florida as they won't have any concept of what it means. They would be just as excited about going to a caravan in the UK at that age (genuinely). Or they might say it but not understand it (my child said they wanted to go to somewhere like Venezuela or Cameroon at that age...because they were given those countries at a football sweepstake. They then said Poland because one of their friends was going there. They then said the moon after they did a space topic). I'm fortunate enough to be able to afford holidays for my kids and when you ask them what they like best it's always something like 'bunk beds', 'the ice cream shop' or spending time with family that they don't see often

So you are right to question it as your friend is massively exaggerating and trying to guilt you into thinking her son feels like he is missing out. He isn't. A 4 year old may comment on those things (eg can say him saying he wants a toy car if his friends have one) but can be easily persuaded out of stuff as well (we don't have anywhere to keep the car or use the car as it needs so much space. Why don't we look at a new scooter for your birthday and we can use that anywhere).

Also why is she mentioning school fees (that she had had her heart set on) - was that ever even a remote possibility? For most people on a low or medium or even a single parent on a reasonably high income, private school wouldn't even cross their mind (other than if household income is below a threshold she may be able to apply for a bursary if he is bright)

I know this may be culturally normal for you but I'd hazard a guess that the cultural norms go both ways (respect, looking after your elders etc) and I fear you won't get that two way relationship with her. It is not respectful to exaggerate to the point of lying about what her son needs / really wants, to try and get things out of you that she wants, but doesn't need (she might be desperate for a break but most families can't afford to take their kids to Florida). I think someone who respected you wouldn't lie or exaggerate and wouldn't pressure you. They would also do things for you when they were able

What are you going to do about it OP? I would definitely rein in the meet ups where you pay for everything for a start, it might be a cultural norm for you but remember it isn't for her and she is now expecting this to extend to ridiculous areas of her life

toomanyleggings · 03/02/2024 10:31

This is barmy. I actually feel a bit worried reading this that my kids godparents may have felt pressurised when I asked them. I didn’t even think of them buying my kids things. Dd1’s godparent always sends a tenner or some books at Christmas and birthday and dd2’s godmother similar. I think that is more than generous!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/02/2024 10:31

No!

It happens that I asked a particular couple to be DS’s godparents and they are quite well off. I asked them because they are my friends and it happens that one of them is the same religion as me.

But I would never have thought in a million years to ask them to give me money or help me out! They are my friends not an ATM.

They are better off partly because they don’t have children to be honest! 😂

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 10:31

Nope.
Tenner at Christmas and for birthdays
£50 for 18th; £100 for 21st.
We are unusual I think because we have five between us and the parents are still close friends. DS's godparents came to his wedding.

Maray1967 · 03/02/2024 10:29

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/02/2024 09:13

Even when I was christened many decades ago it was often a custom that didn’t mean much - especially given nominally C of E parents - godparents were often uncles and aunts who’d generally provide some sort of Christmas and birthday presents if you were lucky. But nothing to do with religion or church-going.

That may well be what many people think, but godparents should think carefully about the vows they are taking. I have no godparents as my DM knew that none of their friends were churchgoers. I only picked committed Christians for our DC godparents.

SheilaFentiman · 03/02/2024 10:29

It’s great that you really like the child!

Do you feel able to spend time with him alone? Maybe take him to the park and give the mum a break - and you a break from hearing her woes?!