Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

21 year old daughter pregnant - help please

539 replies

MacciesApplePie · 02/02/2024 21:48

I’m fairly new to this so thought I would post where there’s most traffic.
As the title said my 21 year old daughter has told me tonight that she’s pregnant. She has talked it over with her boyfriend and they would like to keep it. I said I will support her whatever
She has just started a zero hours contract as a waitress and he is self employed as a gardener.
Her dad and I don’t have huge amounts of money but we do have a flat that was left to us by his mum (shared with his brother) that is currently rented it
Could anyone please advise me where to look for any benefits they can claim, and advise if they could potentially live in the flat (we can’t afford for them to live there rent free so maybe benefits). This is a big shock to me but I want to help them all I can. Thank you :)

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:38

Once the child is in full-time nursery/school both parents can fully commit to full-time work and getting ahead.

And yeah but often this doesn’t happen, a few years of universal credit and suddenly full time work plus little toddlers looks unappealing. Don’t believe me just check out some of the threads on here…

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:37

the birth rate is arguably below the optimal level. It's hardly a bad idea to have children when you're young and healthy

I’ll leave this as my final point because I know my opinions are wrongthink on here, but people having babies is only useful to society if those babies are set to become net contributors or full time workers themselves. If they’re brought up by families who rely on benefits and either never work or just do a few hours here and there, this is unlikely to happen.

coursey · 03/02/2024 15:35

This is a depressing thread. Yet more ‘benefits will take care of it all’.

But the birth rate is arguably below the optimal level. It's hardly a bad idea to have children when you're young and healthy - it's not good for the economy to take skilled labour out at peak earning years. Much better to do it when the alternative is being a bit shiftless and drifting through your early 20s (as I was!).

Once the child is in full-time nursery/school both parents can fully commit to full-time work and getting ahead. Children are wonderfully focussing.

The welfare system is intentionally there to look after people at points of vulnerability, because social insurance is a cheaper way of organising things than relying on charity or rich and tolerant parents. If wages are too low and jobs too insecure, we really need to fix that rather than people deferring their fertility, perhaps indefinitely.

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:35

izimbra · 03/02/2024 15:31

'Freeloaders'? So my son who's 20, has psychosis and leukaemia, has never worked and likely never will - he should be less entitled to state support if he needs it than someone who's been in employment and becomes ill?

BTW - you've also misrepresented the facts on welfare entitlement. It's absolutely not the case that an 18 year old single parent in France wouldn't be entitled to benefits because she hasn't worked or paid tax. There is some contributory element to unemployment benefit in many EU countries, but that's not the same as saying those who have not worked aren't entitled to state help.

They would be entitled to benefits but a very low amount. They take into account the contributions a person has previously made. I don’t think that’s wrong, unless a person is clearly very physically disabled and completely unable to work (ie your son, not just somebody who is depressed or doesn’t think a job would fit around the school run).

Nerurio · 03/02/2024 15:32

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:27

There is a sizeable contingent on Mumsnet that feels anyone who has a baby without owning a house in a desirable area, having a degree from a Russell group uni, 6 figure income and an expensive ring on your finger are basically feckless scroungers with feral children.

But there’s a massive difference between this and a pair of unmarried 21 year olds on minimum or unreliable income who decide to have a baby and are now just expecting the taxpayer to sort them out and keep them.

Where did OP say they are expecting the taxpayer to keep them, I missed that? She said she was looking into benefits, not that they had asked or would even be claiming. You do know that benefits can be income top up, DLA, PIP, etc. and not just UC for unemployed people?

Are you okay with those on minimum wage receiving UC top up on their wages, is it only those who aren't employed who are unacceptable?

izimbra · 03/02/2024 15:32

"They don’t just hand out generous benefits"

UC provides a subsistence income.

thebestinterest · 03/02/2024 15:31

coursey · 03/02/2024 15:28

I would be educating her on WHY it’s a terrible idea to do this to yourself unnecessarily, having access to world class healthcare

Which country is that then?

Compared to Ghana and most countries in the world, the healthcare in the UK is considered world class.

izimbra · 03/02/2024 15:31

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:23

Because they have a kind of insurance system where how much you get in benefits depends on how much you’ve worked and earned previously. They don’t just hand out generous benefits to freeloaders or 20 year olds that decide to have a baby despite paying minimum taxes for a matter of months.

'Freeloaders'? So my son who's 20, has psychosis and leukaemia, has never worked and likely never will - he should be less entitled to state support if he needs it than someone who's been in employment and becomes ill?

BTW - you've also misrepresented the facts on welfare entitlement. It's absolutely not the case that an 18 year old single parent in France wouldn't be entitled to benefits because she hasn't worked or paid tax. There is some contributory element to unemployment benefit in many EU countries, but that's not the same as saying those who have not worked aren't entitled to state help.

Sususudio · 03/02/2024 15:30

I find it amazing that people in the first world with access to healthcare and birth control and abortion CHOOSE to not utilize it 😭. Girls where I’m from have no choice but to birth babies they can’t afford over a slip up, but here? With the education and options they still choose to subject themselves to poverty. Odd!

I come from a similar country where often women have no education, no access to birth control, no choice but to have babies young, helped by their mums/MILs who live with them to help them, all condemning themselves to poverty and abuse.

It's really odd to see this held up as a loving and great way of life in the UK.

OpalOrchid · 03/02/2024 15:30

thebestinterest · 03/02/2024 15:26

These posts irk me to no end. In America they’d be known as welfare dependants and she’d be a welfare queen. It’s not a good situation to be intentionally putting yourself in.

I find it amazing that people in the first world with access to healthcare and birth control and abortion CHOOSE to not utilize it 😭. Girls where I’m from have no choice but to birth babies they can’t afford over a slip up, but here? With the education and options they still choose to subject themselves to poverty. Odd!

If my 21 yr old presented herself to me with this situation, I would not be finding ways to see how it could work. I would be educating her on WHY it’s a terrible idea to do this to yourself unnecessarily, having access to world class healthcare 😭😭

Edited

You would try and force her to have an abortion then?

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:29

…and I had my first at 27. Both in full time jobs. As long as people don’t rely on benefits for shaky reasons or neglect their children then I don’t care about their age, good luck to them, what I care about is people supporting themselves and caring adequately for their kids rather than making a mess for society to clean up.

coursey · 03/02/2024 15:28

I would be educating her on WHY it’s a terrible idea to do this to yourself unnecessarily, having access to world class healthcare

Which country is that then?

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:27

There is a sizeable contingent on Mumsnet that feels anyone who has a baby without owning a house in a desirable area, having a degree from a Russell group uni, 6 figure income and an expensive ring on your finger are basically feckless scroungers with feral children.

But there’s a massive difference between this and a pair of unmarried 21 year olds on minimum or unreliable income who decide to have a baby and are now just expecting the taxpayer to sort them out and keep them.

thebestinterest · 03/02/2024 15:26

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:08

This is a depressing thread. Yet more ‘benefits will take care of it all’.

These posts irk me to no end. In America they’d be known as welfare dependants and she’d be a welfare queen. It’s not a good situation to be intentionally putting yourself in.

I find it amazing that people in the first world with access to healthcare and birth control and abortion CHOOSE to not utilize it 😭. Girls where I’m from have no choice but to birth babies they can’t afford over a slip up, but here? With the education and options they still choose to subject themselves to poverty. Odd!

If my 21 yr old presented herself to me with this situation, I would not be finding ways to see how it could work. I would be educating her on WHY it’s a terrible idea to do this to yourself unnecessarily, having access to world class healthcare 😭😭

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:23

izimbra · 03/02/2024 15:20

Is though? Other countries have more generous welfare systems than the UK. The French spend an additional 50% more of their GDP on public spending than we do, and they don't have collapsing public services, record levels of homelessness, widening health inequalities like we have in the UK.

The state of UK public services and our housing situation didn't just happen by chance. They're the result of public policy decisions.

Because they have a kind of insurance system where how much you get in benefits depends on how much you’ve worked and earned previously. They don’t just hand out generous benefits to freeloaders or 20 year olds that decide to have a baby despite paying minimum taxes for a matter of months.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 03/02/2024 15:22

MasterBeth · 03/02/2024 14:28

You don't.

There is a sizeable contingent on Mumsnet that feels anyone who has a baby without owning a house in a desirable area, having a degree from a Russell group uni, 6 figure income and an expensive ring on your finger are basically feckless scroungers with feral children.

The reality is the most people are neither scroungers or Mumsnet wealthy on a 6 figure salary, and have perfectly happy children and home lives. Not everyone enjoys partying and constant travelling and don't feel they have missed out if they don't get to do this before having a family. I did some of those things before having my first at 26 and feel like I only did because it was expected. I have generally been much happier as a mum and now my children are much older doing chilled stuff, UK hols etc with DP and close friends.

You sound like a lovely mum and your DD and her DP sound like they are figuring out how to create a home etc for their baby, it's an exciting time for you all, enjoy it.

And as for the suggestions that mum should butt out, most of my friends have mums who are interested in these things for their children regardless of age, 20s, 30s, 40s when they have a baby etc.

I would certainly want to be a helpful nanna however old my children are, surely that's just part and parcel of being a family.

izimbra · 03/02/2024 15:20

Is though? Other countries have more generous welfare systems than the UK. The French spend an additional 50% more of their GDP on public spending than we do, and they don't have collapsing public services, record levels of homelessness, widening health inequalities like we have in the UK.

The state of UK public services and our housing situation didn't just happen by chance. They're the result of public policy decisions.

Nerurio · 03/02/2024 15:19

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:11

To the benefit bashers. Isn’t it good that we are all in the fortunate position to not have to claim benefits.

Not fortunate, just making decent decisions and taking responsibility for ourselves. I would be stunned if she was using reliable contraception (ie not ‘the pill where I take it when I remember’ or condoms ‘most of the time’).

Nice bashing of those on benefits, and you threw in some infantilisation while insulting their intelligence too. Nice.
It is obvious you don't know many people on benefits, let's hope you never fall on hard times yourself, because all the planning in the world doesn't protect you from the unexpected.

Dacadactyl · 03/02/2024 15:15

No, that's not what I'm saying. I was on the other thread fully in support of the 2 child cap and not allowing people to languish for years with their lifestyle being supported by the taxpayer forever more.

I do not believe benefits should take care of it all. I believe people should be able to avail themselves of support in times of need (just like all these people claiming childcare costs from the government are doing), but with a view to becoming self supporting in the near future.

MeinKraft · 03/02/2024 15:13

SloaneStreetVandal · 03/02/2024 14:50

You're being very blasé @MacciesApplePie, I'd be absolutely beside myself if it was my daughter. Both of them are, essentially, unemployed. Cost of living is crippling even the responsible young couples (ie those with their own home and decent jobs). Given that they're both young and healthy, I can't imagine they'll be entitled to any benefits.

She has a job as a waitress
He is a gardener

In what way are they unemployed?

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:12

izimbra · 03/02/2024 15:10

The welfare safety net is there for anyone who needs it because they can't earn sufficient money to meet their basic living needs, for whatever reason - because they're carers for young children or elderly people, because their wages are very low and insufficient to provide for their basic needs, because they're ill and can't work etc.

Yes and that’s why we have no cash and struggling services, but I digress.

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:11

To the benefit bashers. Isn’t it good that we are all in the fortunate position to not have to claim benefits.

Not fortunate, just making decent decisions and taking responsibility for ourselves. I would be stunned if she was using reliable contraception (ie not ‘the pill where I take it when I remember’ or condoms ‘most of the time’).

izimbra · 03/02/2024 15:10

SloaneStreetVandal · 03/02/2024 14:57

Utilising the benefits system when you're young and fit to work isn't akin to falling on hard times; the latter of which is actually what the system is designed for.

The welfare safety net is there for anyone who needs it because they can't earn sufficient money to meet their basic living needs, for whatever reason - because they're carers for young children or elderly people, because their wages are very low and insufficient to provide for their basic needs, because they're ill and can't work etc.

Sususudio · 03/02/2024 15:10

There is another thread on here where a 16 year old is planning a baby with her mum's loving support. Now that's depressing. ( Yes, TAAT etc etc).

Naptrappedmummy · 03/02/2024 15:09

SloaneStreetVandal · 03/02/2024 14:57

Utilising the benefits system when you're young and fit to work isn't akin to falling on hard times; the latter of which is actually what the system is designed for.

Agreed. Tired of everyone automatically seeing benefits as the answer to everything. The country is skint. They’re working ages, they should find full time jobs, rent a flat and support themselves.