Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why am I being asked by the NHS if my 8 month old baby 'still identifies as the gender assigned at birth?'

266 replies

Beatricebotterx · 02/02/2024 20:44

We had a medical concern with our 8 month old baby, so I rang 111 for advice, we got directed to a lovely nurse to ask further questions, all going well until she asked....

'Does she identify as the gender assigned at birth?'

Oh wait a minute, let me just ASK her..

Surely parents wouldn't have made that decision to 'change the gender' of their baby?

What is going on, I understand the question may need to be asked for older teenagers/adults but a baby?!?!

Aibu to feel a bit annoyed and confused?

OP posts:
Messyhair321 · 03/02/2024 09:09

Wouldn't that be a standard question these days, I'd just say yes & move on

LilyBartsHatShop · 03/02/2024 09:06

Happyinarcon · 03/02/2024 03:09

These scenarios always remind me of this quote-

“Political correctness is communist propaganda writ small. In my study of communist societies, I came to the conclusion that the purpose of communist propaganda was not to persuade or convince, not to inform, but to humiliate; and therefore, the less it corresponded to reality the better. When people are forced to remain silent when they are being told the most obvious lies, or even worse when they are forced to repeat the lies themselves, they lose once and for all their sense of probity. To assent to obvious lies is in some small way to become evil oneself. One's standing to resist anything is thus eroded, and even destroyed. A society of emasculated liars is easy to control. I think if you examine political correctness, it has the same effect and is intended to.”

This is why it’s difficult to shrug and move on, because we are being forced to go along with something no one believes in.

I think it's more likely to pave the way for AI at the other end of the phone, or the other side of the triage desk, which will save alot of money. People are being weaned off any expectation of human sense or feeling in their interloctutor.

nonametheghost · 03/02/2024 08:36

MissDiagnosed · 03/02/2024 08:25

You get asked about gender, and then about gender identity on NHS forms in order to back-calculate your biological sex. There is only one marker in your notes - and it is a 'gender' marker and can be changed at will.

It is a nightmare - sometimes it is genuinely hard to tell people's biological sex because procedures/treatments get done privately (therefore not in the notes) and notes get redacted. And sex is vital to understanding risk of disease, blood test results etc etc etc - this should not even need to be spelt out. The NHS have capitulated to activists demanding gender override sex in documentation, and it is a mess.

So please please PLEASE can all the people who thinking asking a baby about gender identity or a man about the possibility of being pregnant- PLEASE complain. Healthcare people like me have been expressing concerns but until patients start complaining vociferously nothing will change. Complain in writing to your GP practice, your Trust, to your MP, to the local ICB. Please.

My suggestion would be that we record SEX (not observed, not assigned but established at birth - or earlier!) and ask 'do you have a gender identity?' and if yes then freetext for what it is. Other possibilities also make sense but in heslthcare sex is vital (even for transgender people) and we need to renew its primacy.

Well said! I feel for you all working in the health service I really do.

MissDiagnosed · 03/02/2024 08:25

You get asked about gender, and then about gender identity on NHS forms in order to back-calculate your biological sex. There is only one marker in your notes - and it is a 'gender' marker and can be changed at will.

It is a nightmare - sometimes it is genuinely hard to tell people's biological sex because procedures/treatments get done privately (therefore not in the notes) and notes get redacted. And sex is vital to understanding risk of disease, blood test results etc etc etc - this should not even need to be spelt out. The NHS have capitulated to activists demanding gender override sex in documentation, and it is a mess.

So please please PLEASE can all the people who thinking asking a baby about gender identity or a man about the possibility of being pregnant- PLEASE complain. Healthcare people like me have been expressing concerns but until patients start complaining vociferously nothing will change. Complain in writing to your GP practice, your Trust, to your MP, to the local ICB. Please.

My suggestion would be that we record SEX (not observed, not assigned but established at birth - or earlier!) and ask 'do you have a gender identity?' and if yes then freetext for what it is. Other possibilities also make sense but in heslthcare sex is vital (even for transgender people) and we need to renew its primacy.

Cloudy0 · 03/02/2024 07:50

I think that the questions are asked to all people regardless of age, which seems a bit silly, but I'm sure that there at some point in the future, a parent of a child that young will decide to change their gender.

I can see why they need to ask the question. I recently went to the doctor because I was in pain. I had no idea that it was caused by the birth of my child over 2.5 years ago, so was definitely related to being biologically female and I need to be treated as such. If people respond to questions about sex/gender with their chosen gender, it completely changes the ability to treat them correctly.

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 03/02/2024 07:47

But medically you are either make or female. You can't change that so we are we pretending?

IDontDrinkTea · 03/02/2024 07:45

111 asked if my 6 month old could be pregnant 🙃 it’s very definitely a one-fits-all form

AboutYouAndPeru · 03/02/2024 07:44

Tumbleweed101 · 03/02/2024 00:51

My dad has cancer treatment medications, he’s in his 70’s, and has to confirm he isn’t pregnant to be allowed them!

DH had an MRI on his knee. The poor woman doing it said ; 'I apologise, but I am required to ask this question... could you be pregnant?'.

It's a nonsense and makes fools of everybody. And if you do not know why they are asking (institutional ideological capture) then it lowers faith in the professionalism and plain fucking common sense of the person you are trusting with your health.

In years to come i believe strongly that this will be taught in schools as a 'wtaf were they thinking?' way.

Wife2b · 03/02/2024 07:42

Batshit.

saffy2 · 03/02/2024 07:33

I think it’s just a set of questions and they don’t deviate at all. When my daughter was 10 days old I called 111 and they asked me if she was behaving normally for her. And I said I don’t really know, I don’t know her, she’s only just over a week old. And they said well we need an answer please. And I was like 🤷🏽‍♀️😂 she has no normal!
I think it’s just they have a script and must ask every question.

Sweden99 · 03/02/2024 07:33

Alcyoneus · 02/02/2024 20:47

Because they have been captured by Marxist loons and dodgy child groomers who pretend to champion inclusivity but basically have sinister aims. And all this lunacy is paid for the by the taxpayer. Madness.

How does this relate to Marxism?

ElizaMulvil · 03/02/2024 06:50

Sunflowergirl1 · 03/02/2024 06:08

It’s unfortunate the NHS wastes time and money on this utter shite. My MIL got asked if she was or could be pregnant. She asked the nurse why she was asking when she knows she is over pension age FFS. She said was part of an “inclusivity” drive and they are not allowed to assume! I just fucking despair and makes me glad we have decided to leave this mad country.
No wonder the govt wants the NHS to get rid of the dickheads being paid vast amounts of money to propagate this bollocks

The Conservative Government is in charge. They make their Conservative rules. The NHS is obeying their Conservative instructions.

Write to your Conservative MP / Conservative Health Minister/ Conservative PM Rishi Sunak.

110APiccadilly · 03/02/2024 06:46

I was asked, on the Census form, how DD1 would describe her national identity. She was about four months old at the time. The temptation to write goo goo ga was strong.

ElizaMulvil · 03/02/2024 06:43

Happyinarcon · 03/02/2024 03:09

These scenarios always remind me of this quote-

“Political correctness is communist propaganda writ small. In my study of communist societies, I came to the conclusion that the purpose of communist propaganda was not to persuade or convince, not to inform, but to humiliate; and therefore, the less it corresponded to reality the better. When people are forced to remain silent when they are being told the most obvious lies, or even worse when they are forced to repeat the lies themselves, they lose once and for all their sense of probity. To assent to obvious lies is in some small way to become evil oneself. One's standing to resist anything is thus eroded, and even destroyed. A society of emasculated liars is easy to control. I think if you examine political correctness, it has the same effect and is intended to.”

This is why it’s difficult to shrug and move on, because we are being forced to go along with something no one believes in.

The UK Government is in charge. The Government is Conservative - not Communist. Current political correctness is down to Conservative policy. A way to divide and conquer as you rightly say.

The dominant culture in any society reflects the ruling class of that society. Take it up with Mr Sunak.

Nothing whatsoever to do with Communism 'from each according to their talents, to each according to their needs'. Marxists are materialists - believe in economic reality not 'political correctness'.

PurBal · 03/02/2024 06:34

My 10 day old was asked the same.

MissTrip82 · 03/02/2024 06:32

There are some rather stupid replies here. And some real naivety about reality. Yeah men get asked if they’re pregnant before a scan, because trans men might be and staff don’t necessarily know if you are one (depends on the approach adopted by individual hospitals to patient ID). As for the posters guffawing at the idea of a ten year old smoking…….you’re very fortunate that idea is hilarious.

There are some people here who’d clearly be shocked by the range of ages across which I’ve seen patients with STIs or drug use.

A rude sarcastic response is fine; intelligence, good manners or an awareness of the world outside your home aren’t being assessed.

nonametheghost · 03/02/2024 06:31

@AllGrownUp1465 taking the morale highground by using this poor teenager's murder to shutdown discussions about valid concerns regarding gender ideology (that people have a right to an opinion on) is very disingenuous. Of course everyone is appalled by Brianna's murder. Also, your belief that she was targeted for being trans is unsubstantiated as the murderers had many kids on their 'kill list,' and being trans does not appear to have been a particular motivation. But, even if she was targeted for this reason, using her murder as emotional blackmail to shutdown valid critique or questioning of gender ideology in any context shows your faux- outrage for what it is - purely based on an agenda.

Sunflowergirl1 · 03/02/2024 06:08

It’s unfortunate the NHS wastes time and money on this utter shite. My MIL got asked if she was or could be pregnant. She asked the nurse why she was asking when she knows she is over pension age FFS. She said was part of an “inclusivity” drive and they are not allowed to assume! I just fucking despair and makes me glad we have decided to leave this mad country.
No wonder the govt wants the NHS to get rid of the dickheads being paid vast amounts of money to propagate this bollocks

JessPess · 03/02/2024 06:05

Just a quick comment to say that I completely get in the majority of scenarios there is a really obvious answer to these questions and it seems a ridiculous/funny ask, but there are rarer scenarios where having this information up front is really helpful, including in babies, where say the genetic sex and biological sex have not been the same due to genetic/developmental differences and this has caused other health issues which has caused somebody to call 111…

Having said that, I don’t know whether that question in the 111 call is there for those rarer medical scenarios or is a social thing.

GoneAlready · 03/02/2024 05:21

Beatricebotterx · 02/02/2024 22:35

Well of course it goes without saying!

I just find it strange that there is no common sense / limited flexibility with these questions, the poor staff members end up getting the brunt of the frustration of members of the public because the questions end up being stupid!!

The fact that a nurse above said that they have to ask all men if they are pregnant, when they must have on their medical records that their sex is male, and therefore biologically impossible, blows my mind!

It is indeed batshit, but the problem is that the NHS allows people to change the sex marker on their NHS records. And it’s a relatively easy process, I think.

So there are female people who are officially male on their medical records, and vice versa.

No one in the NHS seems to have thought this through: never mind the confusion this can cause, and the inconvenience for the great majority, it might actually create dangers for patients, given that some screenings are sex specific and some test results, for example, have different variables for each sex.

It’s actual sex that should be recorded on medical records IMO, not this ridiculous system where sometimes it means actual sex, and sometimes it means the sex somebody wants to think they are, and nobody knows WTF is going on.

But as others have said, this is the level of ideological capture in the NHS (and the civil service, our education system, the police, judiciary, media, etc etc etc) today. Not good.

BestBadger · 03/02/2024 05:15

Anele22 · 02/02/2024 23:32

Wow! So someone has an opinion that differs from yours and they're what? Suffering some sort of mental health breakdown and off their meds? What a disgusting comment.

It's not. It comes from a place of genuine concern. I didn't mention mental illness, you did, there are plenty of medications which cause confusion.

It's an incoherent rant which suggests considerable confusion. I mean, "dodgy child molestors" who thinks there are non-dodgy child molesters?

banananas1999 · 03/02/2024 04:54

YANBU its the same with the terms chest feeding and birthing person instead of breastfeeding and mother. And the other mad stuff thats going on,not going to mention that would like this account to stay active for little longer.

BestBadger · 03/02/2024 04:50

It's not. Don't even try that shit. It comes from a place of genuine concern. I didn't mention mental illness, you did, there are plenty of medications which cause confusion.

It's an incoherent rant which suggests considerable confusion. I mean, "dodgy child molestors" who thinks there are non-dodgy child molesters?

CanadianJohn · 03/02/2024 04:20

This is not new, but is probably worse now.

I had a vasectomy in 1972, and was asked to sign a form "I understand by this operation I may become sterile".

This was in Canada, btw. Probably to deter a lawsuit if someone changed his mind.

MariaVT65 · 03/02/2024 03:46

I believe NHS 111 has a separate team for under 5s. So someone should at least be having the common sense to remove that question for all these calls. If anything it’s a complete waste of time when lots of people need help. I’d also assume someone is not doing their job properly if they asked me that about my kids.