Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why am I being asked by the NHS if my 8 month old baby 'still identifies as the gender assigned at birth?'

266 replies

Beatricebotterx · 02/02/2024 20:44

We had a medical concern with our 8 month old baby, so I rang 111 for advice, we got directed to a lovely nurse to ask further questions, all going well until she asked....

'Does she identify as the gender assigned at birth?'

Oh wait a minute, let me just ASK her..

Surely parents wouldn't have made that decision to 'change the gender' of their baby?

What is going on, I understand the question may need to be asked for older teenagers/adults but a baby?!?!

Aibu to feel a bit annoyed and confused?

OP posts:
Riverlee · 08/02/2024 11:23

But gender is not ‘fixed’. Dress the same child in green combat trousers, green jumper and the same 200 adults will call them a boy. But their biology remains the same, they’re still male.

I’m currently wearing pink socks and a blue jumper, so what does gender dictate I am - male or female? That’s the problem with using gender to define someone, the more you delve into it, the more in the modern world it becomes meaningless.

Y0URSELF · 08/02/2024 11:23

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 10:45

And there is absolutely no issue with that. Take it or leave it.
but the OP is asking why would the NHS ask that question… and the answer is, because everyone is assigned a gender at birth. The gender associated with your biological sex. Some people, or parents, decide to change that gender. Some people pretend that gender doesn’t exist. Just about everyone agrees that gender is a CONCEPT…. The NHS don’t want to be drawn into ideological conversations about the validity of gender existence, gender translation or gender neutrality They just want to find out if you, or you parent, thinks your original gender assignment is the same now as the day you were born. Getting all upset about that seems a bit daft to me. You answer yes or no and move on with your life if it doesn’t apply to you or your kid….

Edited

You sounds really confused TBH and I can only assume you’ve never had baby. I’ve had several and I can assure you that no one ( in the NHS or anywhere else ) has assigned them a gender.

and you say

Like arguing you don’t have a name. Well you do. You might not like it. Or want it. But you were given a name…. At birth too, incidentaly

Please can you tell me which country assigns babies names at birth?

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 11:13

StarlightLime · 08/02/2024 11:07

Amelia will be a girl no matter how much hair she has or what clothes she wears.
Do you imagine dressing a boy in a pink baby grow will make him a girl? Interesting in it's extreme stupidity

Oh dear.

put a small child in a pink dress, paint it’s nails and call it Amelia. Ask 200 random adults what gender the child is.

now undress the child and reveal that Amelia has a penis. Ask the same adults to identify it’s sex.

if you think that most of those 200 adults would answer those questions differently then you believe gender assignment exists. You also believe that gender can differ to sex.

the IDEOLOGY you are trying to desperately to infer is that YOU believe every adult should only ever wait until the person reveals their vagina or penis before being called either male or female. Which I find pretty stupid to be honest.

StarlightLime · 08/02/2024 11:09

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 11:08

Omg that’s exactly what being assigned a gender is 🤣🤣 it’s almost like you have a really big point to make 😂ok ok you don’t think gender should be a thing 👍 got it 👍👍👍👍👍

You haven't got it at all. You're not in a country mile of it, actually. Sad.

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 11:08

Sunsetboardwalk · 04/02/2024 16:04

@slashlover there are indeed a set of stereotypes associated with being a boy or a girl. To say that is being "assigned a gender" is a bit of a reach.

Omg that’s exactly what being assigned a gender is 🤣🤣 it’s almost like you have a really big point to make 😂ok ok you don’t think gender should be a thing 👍 got it 👍👍👍👍👍

StarlightLime · 08/02/2024 11:07

Amelia will be a girl no matter how much hair she has or what clothes she wears.
Do you imagine dressing a boy in a pink baby grow will make him a girl? Interesting in it's extreme stupidity

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 10:52

StarlightLime · 08/02/2024 10:49

Nobody assigns anything, @Mittemucci Sex is observed at birth, that's all that's necessary.
If it's important to you to consider yourself having a gender identity that can be changed at will; crack on.

Other people think differently.

It’s not important to me. But everyone is assigned a gender 🤣🤣🤣 if your MIL buys you daughter a pink babygrow and gets upset if you shave five year old Amelia’s head then it’s probably because she has assigned a gender to her.

you can shout from the rooftop Amelia is biologically a girl but I will not confirm it to a socially constructed idea of what a girl means and shave its head until it’s old enough to decide for itself…. But everyone else still thinks Amelia’s a girl…..

StarlightLime · 08/02/2024 10:49

I'm over complicating it?? Christ alive...

Jovacknockowitch · 08/02/2024 10:49

Garlickit · 02/02/2024 21:07

Related: standard questions before my MRI scan:

Nurse: Are you pregnant?
Me: I'm 68 🤣🤣
Nurse: I have to ask men if they're pregnant 🙄🙄

Fucking ridiculous

StarlightLime · 08/02/2024 10:49

Nobody assigns anything, @Mittemucci Sex is observed at birth, that's all that's necessary.
If it's important to you to consider yourself having a gender identity that can be changed at will; crack on.

Other people think differently.

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 10:48

StarlightLime · 08/02/2024 10:42

No. On all counts. Just no. You're beginning to sound a bit simple, tbh.

But it is simple. I don’t understand why people like you want to over complicate it with ideology…..

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 10:45

Sunsetboardwalk · 08/02/2024 10:36

I don't have a gender identity. You can ascribe gender to me if you want, but I personally have no innate sense of gender.
To use your NI number example, someone can give me a NI number but it is not an intrinsic part of me.

And there is absolutely no issue with that. Take it or leave it.
but the OP is asking why would the NHS ask that question… and the answer is, because everyone is assigned a gender at birth. The gender associated with your biological sex. Some people, or parents, decide to change that gender. Some people pretend that gender doesn’t exist. Just about everyone agrees that gender is a CONCEPT…. The NHS don’t want to be drawn into ideological conversations about the validity of gender existence, gender translation or gender neutrality They just want to find out if you, or you parent, thinks your original gender assignment is the same now as the day you were born. Getting all upset about that seems a bit daft to me. You answer yes or no and move on with your life if it doesn’t apply to you or your kid….

StarlightLime · 08/02/2024 10:42

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 10:30

Because everyone has a gender? Just like everyone has a national insurance number. Whether you want one or not, it’s been assigned. Of course you can opt out and pretend it doesn’t exist…. But it still does whether you agree with the terminology or not…. Clearly it exists otherwise it wouldn’t be on a nhs form. Like arguing you don’t have a name. Well you do. You might not like it. Or want it. But you were given a name…. At birth too, incidentally……

No. On all counts. Just no. You're beginning to sound a bit simple, tbh.

Sunsetboardwalk · 08/02/2024 10:36

I don't have a gender identity. You can ascribe gender to me if you want, but I personally have no innate sense of gender.
To use your NI number example, someone can give me a NI number but it is not an intrinsic part of me.

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 10:30

StarlightLime · 08/02/2024 09:35

Why are you constantly arguing with people when you haven't the first clue? 🤦‍♀️

Because everyone has a gender? Just like everyone has a national insurance number. Whether you want one or not, it’s been assigned. Of course you can opt out and pretend it doesn’t exist…. But it still does whether you agree with the terminology or not…. Clearly it exists otherwise it wouldn’t be on a nhs form. Like arguing you don’t have a name. Well you do. You might not like it. Or want it. But you were given a name…. At birth too, incidentally……

Orangeandgold · 08/02/2024 09:59

How would you answer that if you were unsure? Such a bizzare question to ask on the behalf of a baby. It must come from the angry small percentage of parents that are vocal and have made the decision to keep their child non binary until they can decide for themselves.

MamaAlwaysknowsbest · 08/02/2024 09:51

Riverlee · 02/02/2024 20:49

I would probably reply with a sarcastic reply ‘ I’ll just ask my dc that, shall I?’

LOL, they need more people reacting like that not only, but laughing them off , so they ( who are they really though? Who writes that crap? Surely not the poor little employees on 30 000 a year )

Riverlee · 08/02/2024 09:36

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 04/02/2024 14:40

Gender and sex are the same thing are they not?

In the past, the terms were more interchangeable. However, in recent years (especially since trans issues have arisen), sex is understood to be biological, ie,you’re born male or by female, whilst gender is understood to be whether you like wearing ‘boys clothes’ or ‘girls clothes’ to put it simply.

StarlightLime · 08/02/2024 09:35

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 09:11

stupid? That’s not very nice.

all kids have a sex.
all of them also have a gender, unless the parents care that much that they decide to opt out of a world wide social construct and define their kids as having no gender, or the commonly understood term … gender neutral…

Why are you constantly arguing with people when you haven't the first clue? 🤦‍♀️

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 09:11

Sunsetboardwalk · 06/02/2024 08:39

Stupid response. My children have a sex.

Edited

stupid? That’s not very nice.

all kids have a sex.
all of them also have a gender, unless the parents care that much that they decide to opt out of a world wide social construct and define their kids as having no gender, or the commonly understood term … gender neutral…

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 09:09

Y0URSELF · 06/02/2024 08:17

@Mittemucci

Ah cool I always wondered if there was actually people who did the whole gender neutral thing- was it hard?

I didn’t bring my children up gender neutral or as any kind of gender, because I don’t believe in gender ideology.

Why would it be hard - that’s like asking someone who is an atheist if it was hard to bring their child up as neither Shia nor Sunni Muslim.

It wasn’t hard to bring up my children as non Muslims because I’m not Muslim and I don’t believe in the teachings of Islam.

please oh please @Mittemucci tell me that you don’t have children ?

Eyyy? What… I misunderstand… you don’t believe in … gender?

if you kids don’t have a gender, then by definition… they are gender neutral…..?

Not quite sure how is this related to you kids not being muslim…. But I guess if your kids don’t believe in Islam, then be definition, they’re not muslim…

or is there some kind of deeper subtext statement your making here that I just don’t understand….

Sunsetboardwalk · 06/02/2024 08:39

Mittemucci · 06/02/2024 07:23

Ah cool I always wondered if there was actually people who did the whole gender neutral thing- was it hard?

Stupid response. My children have a sex.

Y0URSELF · 06/02/2024 08:17

@Mittemucci

Ah cool I always wondered if there was actually people who did the whole gender neutral thing- was it hard?

I didn’t bring my children up gender neutral or as any kind of gender, because I don’t believe in gender ideology.

Why would it be hard - that’s like asking someone who is an atheist if it was hard to bring their child up as neither Shia nor Sunni Muslim.

It wasn’t hard to bring up my children as non Muslims because I’m not Muslim and I don’t believe in the teachings of Islam.

please oh please @Mittemucci tell me that you don’t have children ?

Musomama1 · 06/02/2024 07:35

Justifiedcheese · 02/02/2024 21:02

Because it's a pro forma. Do you get agitated by questions about religion or level of education?

No. Wonder why not?🙄

But those questions don't assume you follow a certain religion. Those questions ask if you fundamentally follow a religion... or none at all.

Asking if your baby identifies as a gender is making the massive assumption that you believe in gender ideology.

Mittemucci · 06/02/2024 07:23

Sunsetboardwalk · 02/02/2024 23:32

When does that happen? Didn't happen to any of my children.

Ah cool I always wondered if there was actually people who did the whole gender neutral thing- was it hard?