Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why am I being asked by the NHS if my 8 month old baby 'still identifies as the gender assigned at birth?'

266 replies

Beatricebotterx · 02/02/2024 20:44

We had a medical concern with our 8 month old baby, so I rang 111 for advice, we got directed to a lovely nurse to ask further questions, all going well until she asked....

'Does she identify as the gender assigned at birth?'

Oh wait a minute, let me just ASK her..

Surely parents wouldn't have made that decision to 'change the gender' of their baby?

What is going on, I understand the question may need to be asked for older teenagers/adults but a baby?!?!

Aibu to feel a bit annoyed and confused?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nanny0gg · 10/02/2024 09:26

Mittemucci · 10/02/2024 02:53

Yes you are correct.
everybody has a sex.
everybody also has a gender. Except those people who choose not to accept the concept of gender. Deciding that gender does not apply to YOU personally does not mean the whole concept doesn’t exist.
even if you don’t think it should.

Yes gender exists. But sex is more important in a medical setting

Mittemucci · 10/02/2024 02:53

Nanny0gg · 09/02/2024 16:45

Everyone has a SEX, which is the relevant point.

Especially in a medical setting

Yes you are correct.
everybody has a sex.
everybody also has a gender. Except those people who choose not to accept the concept of gender. Deciding that gender does not apply to YOU personally does not mean the whole concept doesn’t exist.
even if you don’t think it should.

Mittemucci · 10/02/2024 02:50

Karensalright · 09/02/2024 16:12

@Mittemucci just curious, if you dated somebody, who told you what their gender was A and when you got down to it, their sex turned out to be B, would you be bothered?

By getting down to it, I assume you mean sex.
I think if a man who was born a man omitted telling me he was married u til the point of intimacy that would also be upsetting.

your question is about disclosure and honesty before sex- not sexual preference.

I assume you are trying to ask me if I am sexually attracted to gender diverse people or not- and I’m not quite sure why that is relevant.

I don’t think my individual preferences should be applied to the population as a whole. I’m happy to roll with the majority.

we live in a society where gender diversity and allowances for such is accepted by the majority. Hence an innocuous question on a form. I do wonder why some people have such insecurities around it….

justteanbiscuits · 09/02/2024 20:07

Nanny0gg · 09/02/2024 16:43

But it's medically incorrect! In a medical environment!

Your SEX is observed at birth, not assigned.

It is medically USEFUL information though if you're a clinician though.

Notthisone · 09/02/2024 16:52

Changingplace · 02/02/2024 20:49

Why is it a standard question though? Why has this become so enshrined within a medical environment?

Because sadly the centre are obsessed with measuring EDI and demographics rather than gathering some of the harder to collect patient experience and qualitative data that really informs improvement.
I say this as someone who has worked in the NHS for almost 20 years. I can appreciate why knowing who is or isn't accessing services can be useful for wider public health however it boggles my brain that such focus is put on this when there are many other things that they should be looking at to help services recover and improve.
Another reason is practical, it would be a very challenging and expensive task to develop individual forms for different groups so in many ways better to ask a question that isn't relevant than miss a question that is.

Nanny0gg · 09/02/2024 16:46

Josette77 · 09/02/2024 04:26

It's extremely rare, but there have been cases of biological men being diagnosed with endometriosis.

That's very weird about the nurses and doctors though... I'm surprised they would refer to him as a girl just because he has long hair! That's ridiculous.

How?

Endometriosis is a disease in which tissue similar to the lining of the uterus grows outside the uterus. It can cause severe pain in the pelvis and make it harder to get pregnant. Endometriosis can start at a person's first menstrual period and last until menopause.

How many men have a uterus?

Nanny0gg · 09/02/2024 16:45

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 10:30

Because everyone has a gender? Just like everyone has a national insurance number. Whether you want one or not, it’s been assigned. Of course you can opt out and pretend it doesn’t exist…. But it still does whether you agree with the terminology or not…. Clearly it exists otherwise it wouldn’t be on a nhs form. Like arguing you don’t have a name. Well you do. You might not like it. Or want it. But you were given a name…. At birth too, incidentally……

Everyone has a SEX, which is the relevant point.

Especially in a medical setting

Nanny0gg · 09/02/2024 16:43

justteanbiscuits · 02/02/2024 20:49

Because it's a one size fits all form. They ask the same questions for everyone. If you think about how many people each person must speak to each day, it's so much easier for them to just ask all the questions.

But it's medically incorrect! In a medical environment!

Your SEX is observed at birth, not assigned.

Karensalright · 09/02/2024 16:12

@Mittemucci just curious, if you dated somebody, who told you what their gender was A and when you got down to it, their sex turned out to be B, would you be bothered?

Y0URSELF · 09/02/2024 12:19

Theunamedcat · 08/02/2024 20:28

i was "educated" the other day apparently born males can get endometriosis i was so gobsmacked i couldnt speak

in other NHS crazy my son has long hair and a stutter (so uses me to communicate) drs and nurses repeatedly refer to him as a girl even when we were in with a suspected torsion (testicular) i spent a lot of time saying things like "HE" and by the end i was saying "still a boy" they kept trying to send me out the room so "she" could speak in private he stuttered out NO! i felt like i was being threatened and i dont know why! 😶the surgeons on the other hand had total hair envy and were happy to call him he.....he looks like he belongs in a heavy metal band btw

One of the many bad things about this rise in gender ideology / religion is that children and adults who are in the slightest way “ gender non conforming “ are constantly asked by others “ what are your pronouns? “.

In this way, these woke people are busy monitoring how much we all comply with their personal beliefs about how women / men / girls / boys should present in terms of hair, clothing, make up, jewellery etc.

It’s very controlling.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 09/02/2024 09:48

That's very weird about the nurses and doctors though... I'm surprised they would refer to him as a girl just because he has long hair! That's ridiculous.

And dangerous especially if they were trying to usher his parent out of the room to discuss the issue.

Theunamedcat · 09/02/2024 07:57

Josette77 · 09/02/2024 04:26

It's extremely rare, but there have been cases of biological men being diagnosed with endometriosis.

That's very weird about the nurses and doctors though... I'm surprised they would refer to him as a girl just because he has long hair! That's ridiculous.

Honestly ds is used to being described as a girl it's annoying to him but not as annoying as short hair apparently 😂

Genuinely didn't know about the men and endometriosis thing!

Garlickit · 09/02/2024 07:18

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 20:12

👍Jesus, you just re wrote what I said.

Oh, you came back.
I rewrote what you said as a question, to confirm that I'd understood your meaning. So thanks for confirming you had no idea how babies are made!

My second paragraph was the opposite of what you'd said. An embryo's sex is formed before it has even 10 cells, and can be identified.

Josette77 · 09/02/2024 04:26

Theunamedcat · 08/02/2024 20:28

i was "educated" the other day apparently born males can get endometriosis i was so gobsmacked i couldnt speak

in other NHS crazy my son has long hair and a stutter (so uses me to communicate) drs and nurses repeatedly refer to him as a girl even when we were in with a suspected torsion (testicular) i spent a lot of time saying things like "HE" and by the end i was saying "still a boy" they kept trying to send me out the room so "she" could speak in private he stuttered out NO! i felt like i was being threatened and i dont know why! 😶the surgeons on the other hand had total hair envy and were happy to call him he.....he looks like he belongs in a heavy metal band btw

It's extremely rare, but there have been cases of biological men being diagnosed with endometriosis.

That's very weird about the nurses and doctors though... I'm surprised they would refer to him as a girl just because he has long hair! That's ridiculous.

Theunamedcat · 08/02/2024 20:28

i was "educated" the other day apparently born males can get endometriosis i was so gobsmacked i couldnt speak

in other NHS crazy my son has long hair and a stutter (so uses me to communicate) drs and nurses repeatedly refer to him as a girl even when we were in with a suspected torsion (testicular) i spent a lot of time saying things like "HE" and by the end i was saying "still a boy" they kept trying to send me out the room so "she" could speak in private he stuttered out NO! i felt like i was being threatened and i dont know why! 😶the surgeons on the other hand had total hair envy and were happy to call him he.....he looks like he belongs in a heavy metal band btw

Mittemucci · 08/02/2024 20:12

Garlickit · 08/02/2024 14:25

Fascinating, @Mittemucci. So the sex of a child has nothing to do with the sex chromosome (X or Y) delivered by the sperm accepted by the egg (X)?

By the way, preimplantation genetic testing of lab-fertilised embryos can identify the sex of each embryo, which have fewer than 10 cells at this point.

👍Jesus, you just re wrote what I said.

Garlickit · 08/02/2024 19:19

YetAnotherSpartacus · 08/02/2024 15:49

Also sex is not defined at conception. You may need a biology lesson there

I was going to ask for some word salad with extra twisty bits to explain this but I see it has already been provided with a side of bonkers.

Beautifully put 😂 And, just like that, the expert on nonexistent reproductive science disappeared!

BreakingAndBroke · 08/02/2024 16:13

They are obviously just reading from a script to tick a box so they can say that you've been asked the question. I called 111 for my DS once as he had a rash and they asked me "is the patient breathing?" As if the patient had stopped breathing, but I just wanted to talk about the rash first!

AlmaCogansFrockFan · 08/02/2024 16:08

As a 70 something woman I'm glad to say that at both MRI scans I have had I was NOT asked if I might be pregnant

YetAnotherSpartacus · 08/02/2024 15:49

Also sex is not defined at conception. You may need a biology lesson there

I was going to ask for some word salad with extra twisty bits to explain this but I see it has already been provided with a side of bonkers.

CharlotteBog · 08/02/2024 14:50

ThankGoditsChristmas · 02/02/2024 20:49

I work for the NHS and we have to ask pregnant "women" if they identify as male or female.

Are you allowed to tell us how many identify as men?

chopinwaltz26 · 08/02/2024 14:42

Sex, well either female or male.
Gender, according to all the languages I know, is masculine, feminine or neuter.
Babies, well I doubt very much at 8 months that they "identify" as anything other than a pooing, peeing, cooing, crying, smiling, eating pod.

BIossomtoes · 08/02/2024 14:38

HowDoTheyGetThroughLife · 08/02/2024 14:02

The world has gone mad! I had a hospital appointment yesterday, and I was asked if I was pregnant or had given birth in the last 3 months - I'm almost 65!

It’s standard. It happens to me and I’m older than you. I grin and make a joke about it.

Garlickit · 08/02/2024 14:30

HowDoTheyGetThroughLife · 08/02/2024 14:02

The world has gone mad! I had a hospital appointment yesterday, and I was asked if I was pregnant or had given birth in the last 3 months - I'm almost 65!

But surely you could get pregnant if you identified as 25?

Swipe left for the next trending thread