Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can have a Tory government and Brexit or we can have the NHS. Which do you choose?

160 replies

verdantverdure · 02/02/2024 20:13

YANBU I'm not a millionaire so I chose the NHS.

YABU I am a millionaire so I don't need the NHS and I choose Brexit and Tory government.

OP posts:
LoveAHamSandwhich · 19/02/2024 15:34

Anyway, I don't understand your point OP. Because we have all those three things - a Troy govt, Brexit, and the NHS.

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 15:28

luckylavender · 19/02/2024 15:20

@TempestTost - you're a Tory. I understand

Well, that's a convincing defense of your view that Labour will improve things and it's all the Tories fault.

Is that purely a matter of belief for you? Labour says they are Good and Caring, so it must be so? That is an impressive faith.

LoveAHamSandwhich · 19/02/2024 15:26

luckylavender · 19/02/2024 15:20

@TempestTost - you're a Tory. I understand

You don't understand the trouble that Gordon Brown's precious PFIs got the NHS into, because he wanted to keep debt off the balance sheet. I understand.

LoveAHamSandwhich · 19/02/2024 15:24

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 15:16

The Canadian model is in as much trouble as the NHS, I suspect because it's very similar.

Ha! There we go. But, oh no, the blessed NHS must be preserved at all costs! Even though we can't actually meet those costs...

KnittedCardi · 19/02/2024 15:21

verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 14:12

There's never been waste on the scale of the last few years.

Mainly because it's not waste. It's corruption and fraud.

It's the government setting things up for the private sector to get our country's money in return for substandard goods and services at stupidly inflated prices.

The asylum system is one of the set ups they use.

The reason Tory donors such as Serco are making record profits out of housing refugees is that the playing field has been rigged to guarantee record profits.

  1. Government policies have hugely increased the number of asylum seekers.
  1. Government policies maximise the amount of time asylum seekers have to stay in asylum accommodation.

More people multiplied by more time = more of our money going into the bank accounts of Tory donors.

The private sector is not the enemy. The country would not run without the private sector. Pensions are invested in the private sector, we need them to make profits so they pay tax and dividends. Yes, of course they have to provide good service, but they have to be allowed to make a reasonable profit.

luckylavender · 19/02/2024 15:20

@TempestTost - you're a Tory. I understand

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 15:16

LoveAHamSandwhich · 19/02/2024 15:10

I'd let go of the NHS. There is a reason that not one single country in the rest of the world has decided to copy the NHS... It's a disaster. Give me the French or Canadian model any day.

The Canadian model is in as much trouble as the NHS, I suspect because it's very similar.

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 15:15

luckylavender · 19/02/2024 14:52

@TempestTost - so it's Labour's fault? Not the Party in power for 14 years? The Party who created the NHS...🤔

That isn't really what I said, and you seem to have a very simplistic idea of there being one party "at fault".

My point was this - the NHS under Blair, which you brought up as a properly funded, functioning system, was only able to achieve that because they brought in the PFI system. That's essentially a loan from the private sector.

The NHS, today, is still paying these off, huge amounts of money, and that is money that is not available for other things. So yes, some of the pinch now is because of retroactively paying for the NHS under TB. He has been very clever in arranging things so that would appear to have happened under someone else's governance.

The last Labour government before that, the UK overspent and was in the hole to the degree that they had to get an IMF loan to prevent a real economic collapse. This was a major part of the reason that the Tories in the early 80s had to institute such draconian austerity measures - that is the trade-off when you accept those kinds of loans, your economic policy is now largely decided by the people providing the money. Much like Greece more recently with EU money.

The Tories certainly haven't covered themselves with glory, but I don't really understand where this bizarre idea that Labour will fix things, or did much better, comes from. They are very much part of this boom/austerity cycle, and in any case, they are currently promising nothing for the NHS. I can't convince myself either that the situation would have been better had Labour been in charge of Covid management, I suspect they'd have dug an even deeper economic hole.

caringcarer · 19/02/2024 15:12

The NHS was set up to give medical care to patients. The food bill alone must be astronomical. People should pay for their own food. There is way too much waste. A shortage of nurses and carers on the ground means too much paid absence leave because of stress and too much money spent on the likes of diversity zars and trust leaders. We should be training more nurses and doctors every year so in 4-5 years time things would ease off. We'd need less agency nurses who cost a lot more than permanent staff yet can't do many simple procedures.

LoveAHamSandwhich · 19/02/2024 15:10

I'd let go of the NHS. There is a reason that not one single country in the rest of the world has decided to copy the NHS... It's a disaster. Give me the French or Canadian model any day.

EasternStandard · 19/02/2024 15:07

verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 14:48

Because Brexit is a millstone around our neck and our economy can’t stand to lose 5% off GDP AND endure the inflation caused by all the extra Brexit costs AND manage on lowered tax revenue because of lowered trade volumes, AND cope with the lowered trade volumes themselves , AND the cost of subsidising industries to stay here in a broken Brexit-hobbled economy, AND all the businesses going bust because of the Brexit-hobbled economy.

But mostly because we live in a democracy and the majority don’t want Actual Brexit, they wanted the Fantasy Brexit they were promised.

Actually most of us don’t want any kind of Brexit at all.

This is the Get The Tories Out election.

The next one will be the Get Brexit Undone election.

Another five years…

All those polls (and threads) and not a jot on shifting it for this GE

caringcarer · 19/02/2024 15:06

Iwantmyoldnameback · 02/02/2024 20:41

You're doing well if you get a trolley to wait on!

I was thinking of something I saw on TV news a while ago with an old lady waiting standing up leaning against the wall, and then she sat on the floor to wait. I bet she'd have loved a trolley to lie on.

NoCloudsAllowed · 19/02/2024 15:03

Ummm... I hate Brexit and I hate the Tories, I hope they're wiped out and the party breaks up and never again darkens our national doorways.

But - Brexit had cross-party support. Labour has wisely stayed quiet on it but to my mind, Jeremy Corbyn and his Labour party hold a huge amount of responsibility for it, their half-arsed remain campaigning was a decisive factor in the outcome. Plenty of left-wing people hate the EU because they see it as capitalist and overbearing.

The NHS is a complicated beast and I wouldn't be averse to some kind of privatisation if it meant better healthcare, so long as it stayed affordable. We always hold up the example of the US but other social democratic countries have privatised systems that function well.

I hope Labour get in and make the country better and fairer, and move closer to Europe. However there's no magic fix - it's that kind of thinking that gave us Brexit in the first place.

verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 15:02

DelilahBucket · 19/02/2024 14:50

I love how many people think that the NHS wasn't in dire straits under Labour (because let's face it OP it is VERY clear you are a Labour supporter). I had no qualified midwife available for the birth of DS because there was a severe staff shortage. That was 2008.
I also love how many people think throwing money at it will help.
No idea what Brexit has got to do with anything. What's done is done with that one. It's not like those that voted for us to leave have realised it was a stupid mistake, they will never see it.

Brexit costs our country billions every month.

So it’s always going to come up when people say “we can’t afford” something.

Brexit makes it harder to pay for the things we as a country used to be able to afford.

Kind of like how the £500 a month the Tories “Fiscal Event” added to our mortgages makes it harder for households to pay for things we used to be able to afford.

OP posts:
luckylavender · 19/02/2024 14:55

DelilahBucket · 19/02/2024 14:50

I love how many people think that the NHS wasn't in dire straits under Labour (because let's face it OP it is VERY clear you are a Labour supporter). I had no qualified midwife available for the birth of DS because there was a severe staff shortage. That was 2008.
I also love how many people think throwing money at it will help.
No idea what Brexit has got to do with anything. What's done is done with that one. It's not like those that voted for us to leave have realised it was a stupid mistake, they will never see it.

It wasn't in the dire straits it is now, not by any stretch of the imagination. Waiting lists were the best they'd ever been. To suggest otherwise is wrong.

verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 14:55

kirbykirby · 03/02/2024 08:17

I predict that not long after Labour get in we will have a means tested NHS whereby the middle classes will have to pay for all care (on top of their taxes) to fund the ever increasing demand. By the year 2041 there will only be 16 taxpayers left in the UK.

That’s interesting,

Do you have a link for the timeline of the abolition of VAT, car tax, council tax, National Insurance, and the taxes on gambling, alcohol and cigarettes etc?

OP posts:
luckylavender · 19/02/2024 14:52

@TempestTost - so it's Labour's fault? Not the Party in power for 14 years? The Party who created the NHS...🤔

DelilahBucket · 19/02/2024 14:50

I love how many people think that the NHS wasn't in dire straits under Labour (because let's face it OP it is VERY clear you are a Labour supporter). I had no qualified midwife available for the birth of DS because there was a severe staff shortage. That was 2008.
I also love how many people think throwing money at it will help.
No idea what Brexit has got to do with anything. What's done is done with that one. It's not like those that voted for us to leave have realised it was a stupid mistake, they will never see it.

verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 14:48

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 14:37

You think this because.....?

No party is talking about this, and the EU looks to be going into rather a period of crises.

Because Brexit is a millstone around our neck and our economy can’t stand to lose 5% off GDP AND endure the inflation caused by all the extra Brexit costs AND manage on lowered tax revenue because of lowered trade volumes, AND cope with the lowered trade volumes themselves , AND the cost of subsidising industries to stay here in a broken Brexit-hobbled economy, AND all the businesses going bust because of the Brexit-hobbled economy.

But mostly because we live in a democracy and the majority don’t want Actual Brexit, they wanted the Fantasy Brexit they were promised.

Actually most of us don’t want any kind of Brexit at all.

This is the Get The Tories Out election.

The next one will be the Get Brexit Undone election.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 14:37

CagneyAndLazy · 19/02/2024 14:34

The NHS is not simply fucked due to a lack of money - it gets tons of it - it's fucked for many, many reasons.

Once it's gone we can have something much more sensible, like many other European countries have.

Which of those countries spend less than us on healthcare would you say?

OP posts:
TempestTost · 19/02/2024 14:37

verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 14:22

Somebody will reverse Brexit.

Obviously.

Somebody has to.

We just don't know who it will be yet.

You think this because.....?

No party is talking about this, and the EU looks to be going into rather a period of crises.

CagneyAndLazy · 19/02/2024 14:34

The NHS is not simply fucked due to a lack of money - it gets tons of it - it's fucked for many, many reasons.

Once it's gone we can have something much more sensible, like many other European countries have.

verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 14:33

Alcyoneus · 02/02/2024 20:53

What a genuine question without any political agenda at all. Not.

If you wanted to start a Brexit bashing thread, why not just start one. Why the pathetic attempt at trying to sound clever.

You'd like me to talk about the political issues that affect all of our lives without being political at all? Grin

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 19/02/2024 14:30

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 14:28

The last time they were in they borrowed money to fund it, which is now hobbling the current NHS.

I don't think that will work this time.

Labour has a lot to answer for in that, and also because any time anyone talks about a real structural overhaul (to something like a French model) they freak out and make it politically impossible.

Yep PFI won’t be back. We’re still paying it now

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 14:28

luckylavender · 11/02/2024 21:11

Well the last time they were in charge of the NHS it was ranked best in the world.

The last time they were in they borrowed money to fund it, which is now hobbling the current NHS.

I don't think that will work this time.

Labour has a lot to answer for in that, and also because any time anyone talks about a real structural overhaul (to something like a French model) they freak out and make it politically impossible.