Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can have a Tory government and Brexit or we can have the NHS. Which do you choose?

160 replies

verdantverdure · 02/02/2024 20:13

YANBU I'm not a millionaire so I chose the NHS.

YABU I am a millionaire so I don't need the NHS and I choose Brexit and Tory government.

OP posts:
NoCloudsAllowed · 20/02/2024 08:55

caringcarer · 19/02/2024 15:12

The NHS was set up to give medical care to patients. The food bill alone must be astronomical. People should pay for their own food. There is way too much waste. A shortage of nurses and carers on the ground means too much paid absence leave because of stress and too much money spent on the likes of diversity zars and trust leaders. We should be training more nurses and doctors every year so in 4-5 years time things would ease off. We'd need less agency nurses who cost a lot more than permanent staff yet can't do many simple procedures.

@caringcarer I don't think people should pay for their own food.

However when DS was in hospital last year, the food was disgusting to the point of being barely edible. I remember thinking what a colossal waste it was to transport, store, cook, carry round the hospital, just for sick people to sigh at it and leave it so it can be carried off to a big bin and taken off for recycling or landfill or whatever.

One edible, nutritious meal a day that gets eaten would be preferable to three inedible ones that get binned.

DS was only 3, so it's not like he's a connoisseur or anything. Example - pasta they apparently cook in troughs of water in the oven until it's floppy and sticky. It's just something you would never want in your mouth. Hospital makes things harder to digest anyway as you're sitting around all day.

Alcyoneus · 19/02/2024 23:38

Here’s the latest gem. NHS says that drug induced chest milk from men is just as good as women’s breast milk. So the NHS has enough money to validate paedos who want to sexually abuse children this way but not enough money to do basic healthcare.

Goldenbear · 19/02/2024 20:48

Nancy1906 · 19/02/2024 19:36

Precisely, because apparently governments can print money until the cows come home!

Who do you think benefits from this debt, the asset rich (very rich) again!

BobbyBiscuits · 19/02/2024 19:40

Would you choose cancer, or knowing the cure to cancer? What a weird question. Would you choose dog shite or ice cream? Hmmm...

Nancy1906 · 19/02/2024 19:36

EasternStandard · 19/02/2024 18:25

Jesus weren’t you on here during covid?

The amount of posts demanding sectors were closed

Then people demanding cash payments for COL crisis

Whatever people got they wanted more

Precisely, because apparently governments can print money until the cows come home!

CoatRack · 19/02/2024 19:22

bombastix · 19/02/2024 16:50

@CoatRack - not voting in the next election then?

Lol no. The choices are:
Annihilate the country within a matter of years.
Annihilate the country within a few more years.

Not a democracy fan over here.

Justifiedcheese · 19/02/2024 18:31

verdantverdure · 02/02/2024 20:25

Did you not see the Channel 4 piece of the NHS Crisis @Shouldgetupearlier?

12 hour waits on a trolley didn't used to be a thing.

But they are now.

Wrong. My father died after a wait longer than that in 2002. There was a recognised crisis then.

EasternStandard · 19/02/2024 18:25

verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 18:23

The Tories have borrowed a frightening amount of money but somehow managed not to provide adequate basic services.

Where has it all gone?

Jesus weren’t you on here during covid?

The amount of posts demanding sectors were closed

Then people demanding cash payments for COL crisis

Whatever people got they wanted more

verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 18:23

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 14:28

The last time they were in they borrowed money to fund it, which is now hobbling the current NHS.

I don't think that will work this time.

Labour has a lot to answer for in that, and also because any time anyone talks about a real structural overhaul (to something like a French model) they freak out and make it politically impossible.

The Tories have borrowed a frightening amount of money but somehow managed not to provide adequate basic services.

Where has it all gone?

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 19/02/2024 18:09

LoobyDop · 19/02/2024 15:42

I have voted quite definitively for the NHS and against Brexit in every election ever, as have all the people who are likely to respond to your question. I’m not quite sure what you’re trying to prove.

Lots of posts seem quite keen to get rid of the NHS…

OP posts:
Jovacknockowitch · 19/02/2024 18:01

ChaosAndCrumbs · 03/02/2024 08:00

Actually, lots of economists would argue that’s not true. There’s a particular approach the Tory party use to persuade the public they need austerity and to claim there’s not money to go around. It tends to involve the idea of dangerous debt and too much public spending, the idea we’ve broken Britain by taking too much from the Government’s purse, the idea the welfare system is a drug and people don’t seek to get out of it and you’re either a hard worker whose worked to get your money or a lazy good-for-nothing who hasn’t. These things aren’t necessarily true. They’re a particularly narrative that comes into play in order to encourage society to conform to austerity. It also tends to mean people tend to say “but what can they do about schools/the nhs/social services, when there isn’t any money?” It doesn’t mean there actually isn’t any money that can be reorganised and found, it’s just a narrative we’re told.

100%, this started with Thatcher who recognised that by saying complex issues were simple, thick people would believe her nonsense and vote for her, in spite of her very obvious integrity bypass.

Goldenbear · 19/02/2024 17:50

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 14:28

The last time they were in they borrowed money to fund it, which is now hobbling the current NHS.

I don't think that will work this time.

Labour has a lot to answer for in that, and also because any time anyone talks about a real structural overhaul (to something like a French model) they freak out and make it politically impossible.

Of course, nothing to do with the existing government at all, the Conservatives have been in power for 14 years, nearly a decade and a half!

NHS decline and mismanagement is obviously not anything to do with contracts to the private sector, who correspondingly happen to be Tory Donors, more wealth driving up the bank balances of the few- in 2023 one of the Conservatives’ biggest ever donors has profited from £135m of contracts with the Department of Health and Social Care in under four years! Then there is the 10 billion on unusable PPE, the procurement process used the “VIP lane” priory system through which potential PPE suppliers referred by MPs, ministers, or civil servants could gain quicker access to contracts! It is just the continuous flow of money to the very wealthy, the wage stagnation of the rest of us, diminishing assets for the majority and inequality that of course means the NHS cannot survive without looking more broadly at the systemic problems of a British political and economic system that sees the very rich get richer year upon year and the middle and working classes poorer year upon year! Close the tax loopholes, tax the very wealthy- 10 million plus wealth tax, land value tax etc are all examples of how to redistribute wealth and the corresponding power for political decisions and ensure public services that are used by a majority survive. We are seeing Dickinsean levels of inequality that we mostly seem happy to not challenge and it's getting worse, the average house in the UK currently costs around nine-times average earnings. The last time house prices were this expensive relative to average earnings was in the year 1876- so many similarities now to Dickens' Victorian Britain, if we continue on this path, there will be many children experiencing the plight of 'Tiny Tim' with parents unable to afford healthcare for their children! The future may look very bleak as Dickens describes in A Christmas Carol,

“I see a vacant seat,” replied the Ghost, “in the poor chimney-corner, and a crutch without an owner, carefully preserved. If these shadows remain unaltered by the Future, the child will die.”

bombastix · 19/02/2024 16:50

@CoatRack - not voting in the next election then?

CoatRack · 19/02/2024 16:39

bombastix · 19/02/2024 16:12

@CoatRack / ime the only people still enjoying this kind of sniff are those who are well off enough not to care, or Reform voters. Democracy is a continuation not a moment in time

It's a continuation as long as you don't like the result, and everyone who disagrees with you is a bad person, I get it 👌

Pumpy001 · 19/02/2024 16:23

Nhs... always and forever..

bombastix · 19/02/2024 16:12

@CoatRack / ime the only people still enjoying this kind of sniff are those who are well off enough not to care, or Reform voters. Democracy is a continuation not a moment in time

Headstarttohappiness · 19/02/2024 16:01

ChaosAndCrumbs · 03/02/2024 08:00

Actually, lots of economists would argue that’s not true. There’s a particular approach the Tory party use to persuade the public they need austerity and to claim there’s not money to go around. It tends to involve the idea of dangerous debt and too much public spending, the idea we’ve broken Britain by taking too much from the Government’s purse, the idea the welfare system is a drug and people don’t seek to get out of it and you’re either a hard worker whose worked to get your money or a lazy good-for-nothing who hasn’t. These things aren’t necessarily true. They’re a particularly narrative that comes into play in order to encourage society to conform to austerity. It also tends to mean people tend to say “but what can they do about schools/the nhs/social services, when there isn’t any money?” It doesn’t mean there actually isn’t any money that can be reorganised and found, it’s just a narrative we’re told.

This.
I find it incredible how many people are falling for this narrative. Incredible and worrying. The next election is not a dead cert for Labour even after last week’s results.

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 15:54

thesurrealist · 19/02/2024 15:43

I've spent years in NHS management. I'm tired of all the lazy arguments about how inefficient we are and how wasteful we are. Very tired of the pointless restructures for political reasons that do no good for patients or staff. Sick of the lack of money to make any meaningful changes.
Sick of patient expectations and the media.
I'd welcome a new system, mostly because then maybe I'll be paid what I'm worth and not the peanuts the government thinks I should be thankful for. If patients have to pay, then they will have more respect for the services they use.
Of course millions will die, especially vulnerable people, because any sort of insurance system will mean people can't afford healthcare, but if that's what you all want, then bring it on.

But why do you think that?

It is a bit, I don't know, odd, that people so keen on how great Europe is don't seem to notice that many European health care systems, which have significant private sector elements, function really well, better than the NHS.

I don't think anyone is suggesting a system which is just cash in hand for users.

EasternStandard · 19/02/2024 15:44

LoveAHamSandwhich · 19/02/2024 15:26

You don't understand the trouble that Gordon Brown's precious PFIs got the NHS into, because he wanted to keep debt off the balance sheet. I understand.

That was a blinder

For Labour not the tax payer

thesurrealist · 19/02/2024 15:43

I've spent years in NHS management. I'm tired of all the lazy arguments about how inefficient we are and how wasteful we are. Very tired of the pointless restructures for political reasons that do no good for patients or staff. Sick of the lack of money to make any meaningful changes.
Sick of patient expectations and the media.
I'd welcome a new system, mostly because then maybe I'll be paid what I'm worth and not the peanuts the government thinks I should be thankful for. If patients have to pay, then they will have more respect for the services they use.
Of course millions will die, especially vulnerable people, because any sort of insurance system will mean people can't afford healthcare, but if that's what you all want, then bring it on.

LoobyDop · 19/02/2024 15:42

I have voted quite definitively for the NHS and against Brexit in every election ever, as have all the people who are likely to respond to your question. I’m not quite sure what you’re trying to prove.

CoatRack · 19/02/2024 15:41

bombastix · 19/02/2024 15:36

Brexit is the drug of choice for old rich white people; just say no kids.

Average democracy enjoyer

DelilahBucket · 19/02/2024 15:39

luckylavender · 19/02/2024 14:55

It wasn't in the dire straits it is now, not by any stretch of the imagination. Waiting lists were the best they'd ever been. To suggest otherwise is wrong.

Yes for a little while and then Labour made changes for the worse and then the Tories came in and had to mop up the mess. The waiting lists were already going up sharply until the end of the Labour government, and things had been changed so severely nothing could be done to slow that down. Not to mention during the last Labour government we had one of the highest year on year population increases. It was an explosion waiting to happen. COVID sped things up.

In 2011 I had an accident. I sat and waited a whole day and most of the night, sat in a corridor, I couldn't walk and wasn't even given pain relief. How is that any better than now? I went through 14 months of having painkillers thrown at me with no resources to find out what was wrong with me. Had I not been able to afford private healthcare I would still be in a wheelchair now.

It was not this fantastic rose-tinted situation everyone makes out it was. The NHS is very different now. It began in an era when people took better care of themselves, the population was much lower. People on Mumsnet weren't telling others to go to A&E for an ear infection. There didn't need to be a department for every little thing. Not everything was ensconced in red tape requiring twelve pages of paperwork for a single appointment and a risk assessment checked by three members of "management" before a wet floor sign could be put out.

bombastix · 19/02/2024 15:36

Brexit is the drug of choice for old rich white people; just say no kids.

luckylavender · 19/02/2024 15:34

As far as I'm aware this isn't Twitter / X so I have zero interest in the back and forth. But as a general rule I believe that any Labour government is better than any Tory government. It's not a faith, it's 62 years of lived experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread