Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can have a Tory government and Brexit or we can have the NHS. Which do you choose?

160 replies

verdantverdure · 02/02/2024 20:13

YANBU I'm not a millionaire so I chose the NHS.

YABU I am a millionaire so I don't need the NHS and I choose Brexit and Tory government.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
verdantverdure · 08/03/2024 16:03

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/03/2024 11:47

Actually they were in the '90s under the last majority conservative goverment.

Funny that!

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 06/03/2024 21:27

Which is why the OBR has revised their expectation of annual net migration up from 245k to 315k a year in the medium term. The economy depends on it.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 06/03/2024 19:38

There does seem to be an wilful ignorance on the topic of how Immigration is about the only thing propping our economy up.

Statistically people feel less confident about the economy and how it will affect their living costs and job security under the Tories so have fewer babies.

OP posts:
izimbra · 04/03/2024 14:51

"No-one has an effective answer to top heavy populations, mass immigration"

Immigration is the part of the answer to declining birth rates and top heavy populations.

Realists know this. Xenophobes and the right won't acknowledge it because it's politically unpopular.

Really suggest you look beyond the Daily Telegraph for intelligent and insightful debates on migration.

This is a good place to start

https://podcast.app/exodus-and-revelations-the-truth-about-migration-with-prof-hein-de-haas-e344298276/?utmsource=ios&utmm_medium=share

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/03/2024 11:47

verdantverdure · 02/02/2024 20:25

Did you not see the Channel 4 piece of the NHS Crisis @Shouldgetupearlier?

12 hour waits on a trolley didn't used to be a thing.

But they are now.

Actually they were in the '90s under the last majority conservative goverment.

Alexandra2001 · 04/03/2024 11:45

Dressinggownonthefloor · 03/03/2024 23:37

This is the best summing up of the state that the world is in right now that I've read for a long time

That, arguably is the state of the World but it doesn't mean we in the UK cannot do things differently.

The money is there, right now, to rebuild education, health and transport & in doing so, improve productivity.

Other European countries, whilst facing similar challenges are not in the mess we are in.

We in the UK can vote for terminal decline or vote for a change in political priorities.

The "oh we are all fucked" brigade just want us to think there is no alternative so we vote back in the Tories, its all they ve got left after 14 years of total failure.

Dressinggownonthefloor · 03/03/2024 23:37

KnittedCardi · 11/02/2024 21:31

It doesn't matter. The entire West is in managed decline. No-one has an effective answer to top heavy populations, mass immigration or declining quality of life. The planet is warming, pretty much everyone has rowed back on doing anything about it, because it will lead to further decline, the Middle East, Russia and China are in chaos, and no-one else can do anything about that. The American voters have a choice of two dementia ridden idiots to set the world agenda. Who is in charge of UK Plc is a fairly mute point.

This is the best summing up of the state that the world is in right now that I've read for a long time

izimbra · 03/03/2024 23:29

Thisisnotarehearsal · 02/03/2024 16:07

As a floating voter, I find this such an odd way to frame the question.

Clearly choosing who to vote for is nowhere near this simplistic.

Otherwise you could frame it as, you can have Kier Starmer who thinks some women have a penis, or you can have Sunak who actually understands reality.

If you pick one single issue, of course it is easy to make one party look unpalatable. It's probably unhelpful to encourage people to view politics in such a binary fashion.

Trans women may have a penis, and many of us accept trans women as women.

verdantverdure · 03/03/2024 07:56

Thisisnotarehearsal · 02/03/2024 16:07

As a floating voter, I find this such an odd way to frame the question.

Clearly choosing who to vote for is nowhere near this simplistic.

Otherwise you could frame it as, you can have Kier Starmer who thinks some women have a penis, or you can have Sunak who actually understands reality.

If you pick one single issue, of course it is easy to make one party look unpalatable. It's probably unhelpful to encourage people to view politics in such a binary fashion.

You can’t equate what the Torieshave done to the NHS leading to more of us suffering and dead to mouthing a slogan surely?

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 02/03/2024 19:46

Wallywobbles · 01/03/2024 06:13

I just can't see how with the current COL crisis and the amount of poverty in the UK that the vast majority of people can afford the giant tax hike it would take to save the NHS.

I live in France and despite the massive amount of tax that is ring fenced for our health service it is less good than it was 30 years ago.

And 30 years ago it was already in a different league to the UK. I remember being sent for a mammogram and them saying this afternoon or tomorrow and being stunned. Now it would be at least a 2 week wait for a routine one.

What tax hike is this?

We can have a Tory government and Brexit or we can have the NHS.  Which do you choose?
OP posts:
Thisisnotarehearsal · 02/03/2024 16:07

As a floating voter, I find this such an odd way to frame the question.

Clearly choosing who to vote for is nowhere near this simplistic.

Otherwise you could frame it as, you can have Kier Starmer who thinks some women have a penis, or you can have Sunak who actually understands reality.

If you pick one single issue, of course it is easy to make one party look unpalatable. It's probably unhelpful to encourage people to view politics in such a binary fashion.

QueenMegan · 02/03/2024 16:03

Anything relating to public services and social care from children to adults is imploding.

People generally do not realise how awful it is.

Even though we never might need such services it still costs us all that's what so many fail to comprehend l. It can no longer be considered fit for purpose like many services not just the NHS

The Tories under Thatcher did exactly the same but her greedy populist I'm alright Jack appeals to the masses. We are in a far worse state than ever she left the country in.

Alexandra2001 · 02/03/2024 16:00

TizerorFizz · 01/03/2024 23:58

I am not against private companies or profits. Let’s face it, doctors going to Australia for double the money don’t give a fig either. No nhs there. We have dual standards. In 2010 I have no doubt the data was limited. The NHS was crap then too! Except Labour had paid GPs loads more and at the same time patients could not get appointments .After hours working disappeared . Great for them but poor for patients and they then raked in money from the Cons by running businesses and retiring at 55 with giant pension pots. At the moment productivity is woeful.

11 people waited 12 hrs or more in AE in 2009/2010 to be seen.

In 2023, it was 55k.

Productivity is poor due to lack of staff, high sickness rates (Stress) an ever older population, more complex medical needs inc obesity.

Alexandra2001 · 02/03/2024 15:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 02/03/2024 11:10

NHS of course as I am not a selfish git.

TizerorFizz · 01/03/2024 23:58

I am not against private companies or profits. Let’s face it, doctors going to Australia for double the money don’t give a fig either. No nhs there. We have dual standards. In 2010 I have no doubt the data was limited. The NHS was crap then too! Except Labour had paid GPs loads more and at the same time patients could not get appointments .After hours working disappeared . Great for them but poor for patients and they then raked in money from the Cons by running businesses and retiring at 55 with giant pension pots. At the moment productivity is woeful.

izimbra · 01/03/2024 23:13

TizerorFizz · 01/03/2024 14:22

So what would Labour do? Oh I know, spend money they don’t have. We are so close to our income just repaying loans we have no wriggle room. Millions of people have higher mortgages and cannot find more for tax. Uni for dc costs more. Everything costs more. We either accept we make changes to the NHS or it’s the slow route to oblivion. I’d rather have a reduced nhs offering and do it well. Being wedded to an outdated system laughed at by everyone else is no good when we are all getting old with the young not earning enough for homes of their own, let alone huge tax hikes. Labour will not be able to do anything without howls of protest.

It’s easy for those who have enough to say they’ll pay more, but when people cannot afford a home, will they really want to pay higher taxes? I doubt it.

Plus we need to be able to pop off the planet if we wish - I don’t want to be kept alive by the nhs. From what I’ve seen it’s a living slow painful death. No thanks.

As I pointed out - the NHS had high rates of patient satisfaction in international comparisons in 2010 before the Conservatives got in and started their programme of trashing/privatising public services.

This is from the Nuffield Trust research from 2018:

"While data is limited, the NHS seems to be relatively efficient, with low administrative costs and high use of cheaper generic medicines. • The NHS appears to perform well in managing certain long-term illnesses, including diabetes. • Health care spending in the UK is slightly lower than the average in comparable countries, both in terms of the proportion of national income spent on health care and in terms of spending per person. • The UK has markedly fewer doctors and nurses than similar countries, relative to the size of its population, and fewer CT scanners and MRI machines."

The NHS doesn't do well on cancer, heart disease and stroke outcomes.

We also have poor public health and growing health inequality in the UK.

None of these things are beyond improving, if your first priority isn't working out how to increase possibilities for private profit in healthcare provision.

izimbra · 01/03/2024 23:04

sleepyscientist · 01/03/2024 21:13

This, I would go Tory - education, security and health as spending priorities. Cut the welfare state in half or more. No social care (we won't be using it we have a plan if it comes to that point). Education is under funded in our town yet the council is renovating leisure centres and planting trees!

So who would you leave destitute in order to 'cut the welfare state in half'?

izimbra · 01/03/2024 22:57

"The NHS is finished. We need a new funding methodology. Why can’t we have the same system in lots and lots of European countries where healthcare is partly funded via insurance."

Following figures come from Statistica

In 2022 UK public spending on healthcare per head of population was $4479 and private spending was $1013. That includes all the billions spent on shite PPE and useless Test and Trace.

In 2022 French public spending on healthcare per head of population was $5510. They spent slightly less than the UK on private healthcare.

Figures for Germany: $6929 per head, and $40 more a year per head on private healthcare.

Food for thought, no? (BTW - 2019 statistica survey shows French were less satisfied with their healthcare than Brits)

izimbra · 01/03/2024 22:48

ltappleby · 02/02/2024 20:57

I won’t be voting Conservative but I don’t support the NHS in its current form. I really wish it could be transformed into a Continental or Australian model of health care.

In 2010 70% of Brits were satisfied with their NHS care, compared to 74% of Australians. So just behind Australia.

That figure for the NHS is now 29% and falling.

How could we have let that happen?

Heatpumphero · 01/03/2024 22:41

The NHS is finished. We need a new funding methodology. Why can’t we have the same system in lots and lots of European countries where healthcare is partly funded via insurance. They have excellent healthcare systems and do t have to pay through the nose like they do in America for it.

But any suggestion that we do something like this is immediately hurled out in disgust. I don’t get the drs that praise the NHS to the hilt then complain their don’t get paid as much as other counties. That’s because other countries have a health insurance system. You can’t want the current funding model and overseas drs salaries. It doesn’t work like that. It’s either / or instead.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 01/03/2024 22:02

sleepyscientist · 01/03/2024 21:13

This, I would go Tory - education, security and health as spending priorities. Cut the welfare state in half or more. No social care (we won't be using it we have a plan if it comes to that point). Education is under funded in our town yet the council is renovating leisure centres and planting trees!

You do know the Tories are in power now do you?

sleepyscientist · 01/03/2024 21:13

Tatumm · 01/03/2024 09:30

Even millionaires may need the NHS in an emergency.

This, I would go Tory - education, security and health as spending priorities. Cut the welfare state in half or more. No social care (we won't be using it we have a plan if it comes to that point). Education is under funded in our town yet the council is renovating leisure centres and planting trees!

Swipe left for the next trending thread