Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset?

163 replies

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 16:53

I’ve been doing a hobby for a couple of years. I have a disability which makes me quite isolated so my support worker recommended I should join a hobby. We meet every couple of months at different venues for organised events. I’m not best buds with anyone but I make polite chitchat and enjoy going.

I turned up to the Jan 2024 meeting to discover I was excluded from participating. They could have made arrangements for me to participate but hadn’t bothered and by that time it was too late to arrange. It touched a nerve because I’ve had discrimination my whole life. I got v upset and messaged the group WhatsApp to say I’m the only person who’s excluded and it’s disability discrimination.

A committee member replied and said the organiser didn’t even know I was disabled so how can it be disability discrimination, it just so happened on that occasion I wasn’t able to participate but it wasn’t on purpose. I said someone should have told me I wouldn’t be able to participate because I arranged and paid for transport, and was literally in the foyer by the time I discovered I couldn’t participate, so that was very upsetting for me and I cried. A couple of other members replied and said chin up, you need to be more resilient because life is full of setbacks like this, and examples of times when they couldn’t participate (not the same at all). Most said nothing.

Anyway… the annual membership fee is due on 31st Jan. I’ve been very sick so I didn’t realise the date. On 1st Feb I discovered I’d been removed from the WhatsApp group and Facebook group. I know that’s because I hadn’t paid the subs, but it just seemed so abrupt. No message to say “hey Bingoe have you forgot your subs are due, are you intending to still be a member, hope you’re ok”. Nothing.

AIBU to feel really upset? I know it’s a totally practical thing, you don’t pay you get kicked out… but honestly I just feel like nobody gives a shit. Of course I could just request to rejoin and pay the subs now, but I’m really hurt at the total lack of contact, just removing me with no notification. I also feel like maybe it’s because I got upset a few weeks ago and pointed out I’d been discriminated against, so now I feel like I’m being punished for calling them out.

My partner is saying they aren’t very nice and why would you want to keep being a member anyway, but like I said I’m very isolated and it was one of the few things I had.

OP posts:
Bingoe · 02/02/2024 18:30

I do think the museum were more at fault. I think THEY are the ones who failed in their duty, and they are the ones guilty of disability discrimination. But the reaction from the committee was cold and horrible.
That was my feeling. The museum offered the visit and the committee saw it as an easy win, let the curator arrange it and we’ll just turn up. They obviously thought everyone would be included, certainly that was what the original email sounded like. The museum didn’t intend to discriminate either, they just didn’t think.

But when I was excluded, the committee’s response was really cold, not taking any responsibility and criticising me for expecting them to have sorted it properly, and making legal sounding statements about “the museum does not guarantee access to any individual”.

I still think they were thrilled to have an excuse to just silently remove me from the group when I forgot to pay my subs. Cold again.

OP posts:
Bingoe · 02/02/2024 18:21

It’s a privately owned building, it’s only open to the public a few times a year. There was no info available on the web about access. In the past the secretary has always made an effort to include everyone. She knows I need wheelchair access, and X needs an accessible toilet, and Y and Z need a cafe with gluten free options, etc. We don’t need to check with her every time or contact the venue ourselves, it’s her job to arrange the visit for everyone, and it’s never been an issue.

The message from the secretary said the museum has called to offer us a private visit next weekend, Sarah the curator has said everyone is welcome, no need to confirm because there’s no limit on numbers, just meet in the car park at 11am. Then obviously it was Xmas and she never said to Sarah is there wheelchair access.

I get why they left me in the foyer, there was about 30 people ready to go in and I couldn’t get up the stairs. I think they perhaps did assume it would be accessible to all, they had just left it in the curator’s hands and were expecting everyone to be included. As a historic building they don’t legally have to be accessible if it’s not possible due to when it was built.

But then they said it wasn’t discrimination because the curator arranged it and she didn’t know I was disabled. When I said they knew and they should have told her, they got defensive and said it slipped through the net, we’re volunteers and it was Xmas. Then made it worse by getting really formal and saying the museum is a private entity and they don’t guarantee access to any individual, as if that makes it ok.

OP posts:
Catlander · 02/02/2024 18:21

rainydaysandwednesdays · 02/02/2024 18:08

It's all a bit dramatic. Crying in the foyer? Could you not have phoned to check there were provisions for you?

Imagine telling another minority group they can't enter a building because of their protected characteristic. Then the party they're with go ahead anyway.

It's not dramatic, it's discrimination and what sounds very much like bullying.

Catlander · 02/02/2024 18:16

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 17:30

We visit different museums as a group. You don’t book, you just turn up at that date and time. Usually it’s organised by our group secretary, who makes an effort to make it suitable for everyone. But on this occasion it was organised by one of the museum staff who had reached out to the committee to ask if we’d like to visit.

This particular museum is open by appointment only. When I arrived they didn’t have ramps in place for wheelchair access. So I was left in the foyer by myself crying, after having arranged and paid for transport to get there.

I complained to the committee and they said it wasn’t discrimination because they hadn’t organised it, it was the museum curator, who didn’t know I was in a wheelchair. I said but you should have made sure she knew! They said it was just after the Xmas holidays and the committee are all volunteers with busy lives, and they hadn’t organised it the curator did. Yes provision should have been made for your wheelchair but it was arranged in a rush and this slipped through the net. While the group tries to include everyone, the museum is an independent entity and offers no guarantees that individuals will be able to access it on any given date.

The response seemed very formal and was obviously written by the committee as a whole before it was sent to me. The word “sorry” was not mentioned at all. In fact it sounded like they were criticising me for expecting them to have told the museum I’m in a wheelchair… “it was right after Xmas and the committee are volunteers with busy lives” implies “it’s unreasonable for you to expect us to have arranged this”.

Then that was followed up by my abrupt removal because I forgot to pay my annual subs due to being sick. No message to say “did you forget or are you leaving?” I suspect they were glad to have the chance to get rid of me, and I’ve got really upset again.

Anybody with an ounce of compassion would have stayed in the foyer with you until ramps were found. The fact they ALL left you sat there would make me never want to go back to that group again.

Start your own group?

FernGilly · 02/02/2024 18:09

OP they sound like cold hearted cunts, I would not be rejoining the group. You will genuinely be better off without them.

If I had had any part in organising this I would have been mortified and would probably be apologising for the rest of the day and would have taken you out to lunch there and then to make it up to you.

rainydaysandwednesdays · 02/02/2024 18:08

It's all a bit dramatic. Crying in the foyer? Could you not have phoned to check there were provisions for you?

Timeforabiscuit · 02/02/2024 18:07

Well that's just fucking crap! You are a fee paying member of a group and they've just not considered you at all.

The example of being more resilient boils my piss no end, you ARE BLOODY RESILIENT AND IT WOULD BE LOVELY IF YOU DIDN'T HAVE TO BE.

Righteous indignation aside, their organising leaves alot to be desired! Do you think you'd be able to nick the idea and set your own group up?
The group sounds pretty insular, and don't sound big on self reflection, so unless you proactively do the organising - I doubt you'd get far, is there anyone at the group you like spending time with? Or was it the excursions being organised which was helpful?

NotDoingOk · 02/02/2024 18:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This expression pisses me off no end. "Disability Card"

When someone expresses that they have been disadvantaged or prevented from accessing something because of a disability, they are not playing a fucking card. They are stating a fact.

RockyRogue1001 · 02/02/2024 18:06

@Bingoe I have a heart of stone, and I'm reading this thread almost crying at how you've been treated.
I'm so sorry this has happened to you. It's appalling. Absolutely appalling.

I do think the museum were more at fault. I think THEY are the ones who failed in their duty, and they are the ones guilty of disability discrimination.
But the reaction from the committee was cold and horrible. Not that they SHOULD have reimbursed you, but it would have been lovely if they had. And a "sorry" was certainly required, even if it was a "sorry this happened" rather than taking responsibility
I can't believe the group just went off and left you in the foyer. That's horrendous

I totally understand why you're upset, and I hope you're able to find an alternative group.

Sending you 💐 and love.

Actually, I've had a thought. May I pm you?

FourLeggedBuckers · 02/02/2024 18:04

That’s pretty appalling. A lot of museums aren’t great for accessibility - they should absolutely have investigated it, knowing they had a member with a disability. The volunteers with busy lives excuse is shit. You make time for basic accommodations, or you don’t do it at all.

It wouldn’t fly at any hobby group I’ve been in.

LifeExperience · 02/02/2024 17:59

I understand why you were upset, but mistakes happen. No one intentionally arranged things so that you couldn't participate; it was a mistake, and we all make them.

I have a disability, also, and I've learned that I must be my own advocate. Next time double-check on arrangements before you arrange transport.

WednesburyUnreasonable · 02/02/2024 17:54

OP, I understand completely why you are upset. I think, given this is a group run by volunteers, this is one of those situations where righteous anger - however right you may be - isn’t necessarily going to lead to the outcome you want.

It may be too late, but if you want to continue to participate (and you may not!), I’d go back to their snooty email and say you understand they are volunteers and it slipped through the net on this occasion blah blah blah but it had a really negative impact on you and you’d like to know what processes can be put in place to avoid access needs being overlooked again, even if that’s as simple as establishing it’s always going to be on you to arrange (not ideal) or a template line in the organising emails asking members to flag any potential issues with the arranging volunteer (better). And if they didn’t meet you halfway or their responses continue to make you feel awful, then at that point I’d say fuck them and try to find something else.

Dacadactyl · 02/02/2024 17:53

@Bingoe in your shoes (and if you wish to continue being part of this group) I'd contact the secretary and say you were hurt that no one thought to remember you. But that you'd like to continue being part of the group etc etc.

I think you might have to chalk it up to being a genuine oversight and that it wasn't done with any malice.

Bestyearever2024 · 02/02/2024 17:52

Then when I pointed out it was awful to let me pay for transport and travel all the way there only to be left crying in the foyer, they basically didn’t say sorry, said it isn’t discrimination and made out I’m unreasonable for expecting them to have made arrangements for all members to be able to participate.

I understand that this is horrible for you abd I'm sorry about that

I'm a bit confused as to why YOU couldn't check the facilties and elevator situation yourself

Clarinet1 · 02/02/2024 17:51

I’m sorry you’ve been through so much OP. This sounds very thoughtless and hurtful of the group not to have made sure you were catered for. I also think that a museum organising visits should have it as part of their booking procedure to check whether anyone in the group has particular access requirements so there is blame on both sides.
In terms of the subs, I might give them the benefit of the doubt that you just fell foul of an automatic cut off but, as PP have said, perhaps your relationship with this group is now soured and you might be happier joining something else. Don’t give up though, you’ll find something you enjoy and makes you happy!

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 17:47

MagentaRocks · 02/02/2024 17:29

Agree it depends on what the activity was, did they know in advance there would need to be an adjustment for you to do it.

They do know I’m in a wheelchair. The secretary usually picks museums which are accessible, and she picks a cafe afterwards that’s suitable for other members with food allergies, so basically she ensures everyone is included. But on this occasion it was the museum who offered the group a visit, and they called over Xmas, and the committee was too busy with their own lives to remember to communicate that they had a member who needs wheelchair access.

Then when I pointed out it was awful to let me pay for transport and travel all the way there only to be left crying in the foyer, they basically didn’t say sorry, said it isn’t discrimination and made out I’m unreasonable for expecting them to have made arrangements for all members to be able to participate.

OP posts:
thaegumathteth · 02/02/2024 17:43

Hmm tbh OP I'm disabled and always check access anywhere before I go. In an ideal world we wouldn't need to of course but it's the way things are.

I do think given they're volunteers you probably shouldn't have went in with discrimination and just said 'in future could you let me know access problems please'. I'd contact the museum too and ask why they have no access.

Tbh maths subs thing is fair enough.

Concestor · 02/02/2024 17:40

The visit thing is shit. They should have arranged access for you and it is discrimination not to do so. They have a disabled member and they know that, so they should have told the museum. Their non apology is also shit.

The subs thing though, I think that's just process compounded by the fact they likely thought that you had decided to leave over the museum incident.

If you want to still go, then contact them and arrange to pay up, then in future for every visit ask them about access, or contact the museum yourself to check.

I'm sorry they have been so shit, non disabled people just don't get it unless they have a friend or family member who is disabled (which is how I know).

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 17:40

It obviously took courage for you to join and make the effort to be sociable
It did take me a lot of effort. In my life I’ve had a lot of bullying and being excluded, and my support worker has encouraged me to put myself out there, saying the world is more supportive of disability nowadays. Then the same thing happens again, everyone walks off up the stairs and leaves me crying, and I basically get told I’m unreasonable for expecting to be included. Then to top it off, others start saying stuff like I need to be more resilient and “I missed the last museum visit because I had the flu, you can just go to the next one” which isn’t the same at all and totally misses the point!

OP posts:
Kaleidoscope2 · 02/02/2024 17:39

I think you're right to be upset on the basis of the meeting at the museum, I can't imagine ever leaving someone in a foyer when they've obviously made an effort to join in an activity. I actually think it's a really weird response by the group generally to not think that was a pretty crappy experience for you regardless of the why and what fors of whose fault it was whether the curater or them. I'm with your boyfriend, they don't sound the nicest or the most accommodating. I know it's easier said than done but look for other interest groups and perhaps articulate ahead of participating you need wheelchair access/ can only attend events where that's feasible just so they have it in advance and can't feign ignorance. I get why you're upset and I'm sorry your experience wasn't what you hoped it would be

SleepingBeautySnores · 02/02/2024 17:38

I echo the previous post, did you know which museum you were going to OP? If so, then as a disabled person myself, I would have phoned ahead to make sure that suitable accommodations would be made for me beforehand. I do get the impression that you knew where you were going in order to have arranged transport, but maybe I'm wrong, and how could the committee say they didn't know you were disabled if you're in a wheelchair, as they've clearly seen you before?

Dacadactyl · 02/02/2024 17:38

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 17:30

We visit different museums as a group. You don’t book, you just turn up at that date and time. Usually it’s organised by our group secretary, who makes an effort to make it suitable for everyone. But on this occasion it was organised by one of the museum staff who had reached out to the committee to ask if we’d like to visit.

This particular museum is open by appointment only. When I arrived they didn’t have ramps in place for wheelchair access. So I was left in the foyer by myself crying, after having arranged and paid for transport to get there.

I complained to the committee and they said it wasn’t discrimination because they hadn’t organised it, it was the museum curator, who didn’t know I was in a wheelchair. I said but you should have made sure she knew! They said it was just after the Xmas holidays and the committee are all volunteers with busy lives, and they hadn’t organised it the curator did. Yes provision should have been made for your wheelchair but it was arranged in a rush and this slipped through the net. While the group tries to include everyone, the museum is an independent entity and offers no guarantees that individuals will be able to access it on any given date.

The response seemed very formal and was obviously written by the committee as a whole before it was sent to me. The word “sorry” was not mentioned at all. In fact it sounded like they were criticising me for expecting them to have told the museum I’m in a wheelchair… “it was right after Xmas and the committee are volunteers with busy lives” implies “it’s unreasonable for you to expect us to have arranged this”.

Then that was followed up by my abrupt removal because I forgot to pay my annual subs due to being sick. No message to say “did you forget or are you leaving?” I suspect they were glad to have the chance to get rid of me, and I’ve got really upset again.

This changes things somewhat. I do think it is bad form of them not to have told the museum that a member is in a wheelchair, but I actually think the committee would've been reasonable to assume that a museum was accessible to all.

In your shoes my beef would 100% be with the museum! Surely they have to have accessibility arrangements for wheelchair users by law?

Nicknacky · 02/02/2024 17:35

Did you know what museum you would be visiting?

5128gap · 02/02/2024 17:34

You're the person with the disability, you know how you were treated, so people shouldn't need details of exactly what happened so THEY can judge if you were discriminated against. I'm sure we can afford you the respect of taking your word for it! So I'd be echoing your husband here and suggesting you move on from this group. At the very least I think a more supportive and friendlier environment would be a better fit.

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 17:30

We visit different museums as a group. You don’t book, you just turn up at that date and time. Usually it’s organised by our group secretary, who makes an effort to make it suitable for everyone. But on this occasion it was organised by one of the museum staff who had reached out to the committee to ask if we’d like to visit.

This particular museum is open by appointment only. When I arrived they didn’t have ramps in place for wheelchair access. So I was left in the foyer by myself crying, after having arranged and paid for transport to get there.

I complained to the committee and they said it wasn’t discrimination because they hadn’t organised it, it was the museum curator, who didn’t know I was in a wheelchair. I said but you should have made sure she knew! They said it was just after the Xmas holidays and the committee are all volunteers with busy lives, and they hadn’t organised it the curator did. Yes provision should have been made for your wheelchair but it was arranged in a rush and this slipped through the net. While the group tries to include everyone, the museum is an independent entity and offers no guarantees that individuals will be able to access it on any given date.

The response seemed very formal and was obviously written by the committee as a whole before it was sent to me. The word “sorry” was not mentioned at all. In fact it sounded like they were criticising me for expecting them to have told the museum I’m in a wheelchair… “it was right after Xmas and the committee are volunteers with busy lives” implies “it’s unreasonable for you to expect us to have arranged this”.

Then that was followed up by my abrupt removal because I forgot to pay my annual subs due to being sick. No message to say “did you forget or are you leaving?” I suspect they were glad to have the chance to get rid of me, and I’ve got really upset again.

OP posts: