Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset?

163 replies

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 16:53

I’ve been doing a hobby for a couple of years. I have a disability which makes me quite isolated so my support worker recommended I should join a hobby. We meet every couple of months at different venues for organised events. I’m not best buds with anyone but I make polite chitchat and enjoy going.

I turned up to the Jan 2024 meeting to discover I was excluded from participating. They could have made arrangements for me to participate but hadn’t bothered and by that time it was too late to arrange. It touched a nerve because I’ve had discrimination my whole life. I got v upset and messaged the group WhatsApp to say I’m the only person who’s excluded and it’s disability discrimination.

A committee member replied and said the organiser didn’t even know I was disabled so how can it be disability discrimination, it just so happened on that occasion I wasn’t able to participate but it wasn’t on purpose. I said someone should have told me I wouldn’t be able to participate because I arranged and paid for transport, and was literally in the foyer by the time I discovered I couldn’t participate, so that was very upsetting for me and I cried. A couple of other members replied and said chin up, you need to be more resilient because life is full of setbacks like this, and examples of times when they couldn’t participate (not the same at all). Most said nothing.

Anyway… the annual membership fee is due on 31st Jan. I’ve been very sick so I didn’t realise the date. On 1st Feb I discovered I’d been removed from the WhatsApp group and Facebook group. I know that’s because I hadn’t paid the subs, but it just seemed so abrupt. No message to say “hey Bingoe have you forgot your subs are due, are you intending to still be a member, hope you’re ok”. Nothing.

AIBU to feel really upset? I know it’s a totally practical thing, you don’t pay you get kicked out… but honestly I just feel like nobody gives a shit. Of course I could just request to rejoin and pay the subs now, but I’m really hurt at the total lack of contact, just removing me with no notification. I also feel like maybe it’s because I got upset a few weeks ago and pointed out I’d been discriminated against, so now I feel like I’m being punished for calling them out.

My partner is saying they aren’t very nice and why would you want to keep being a member anyway, but like I said I’m very isolated and it was one of the few things I had.

OP posts:
Bingoe · 02/02/2024 19:42

Spirallingdownwards · 02/02/2024 19:16

I am not sure it is discrimination rather it was an oversight to check whether it was accessible and relay that it wasn't. Would you have expected them to not go at all because you couldn't especially as it seems it opens on occasions only to private groups? Or would you have accepted an explanation that we have this rare opportunity to do this but unfortunately it isn't accessible to wheelchair users or would you have really take the stance if I can't go then none of you should?

It was unfortunate that they didn't apologise for not checking which could have saved you the wasted journey.

Cancellation of membership and removal from group for not paying subs as they fall due is a different matter. Would they have done this to anyone not paying on time? If you think no and it is because of the trip then you may have a case of discrimination now but perhaps as a group of volunteers they don't want the threat of the group being sued for discrimination?

I’ve already said I’m happy for others to go even if it isn’t accessible to me. I’m happy to be contacted and told this event isn’t suitable for me. What I’m not happy with is not being told, doing a 1hr round trip (and paying for it) only to realise in the foyer that I can’t get up the stairs. I’m not happy with the people who accepted the role of being organisers not doing the organising because it’s within 2 weeks of Xmas. And I’m not happy to be told I need to be more resilient when I point out discrimination and say how much it upset me.

OP posts:
LordEmsworth · 02/02/2024 19:40

@Spirallingdownwards I am not sure it is discrimination rather it was an oversight to check whether it was accessible and relay that it wasn't
That oversight is discrimination. That is the definition of indirect discrimination. The museum isn't accessible and can't make itself accessible; but they can tell prospective visitors, this venue is not suitable for those in wheelchairs or with mobility problems. Rather than assume that everyone in the group is healthy and able bodied. Why would you assume that a group of people doesn't have anyone with mobility issues?

@theconfidenceofwho I'm very sorry for your experience Op but it doesn't sound like it was deliberate on their part. "Not deliberate isn't a synonym for "ok and acceptable". And cold shouldering the OP and telling her to "be more resilient" was very* deliberate. I speak as chair of a voluntary organisation, the correct response is massive apologies and take steps to make sure it doesn't happen again.

theconfidenceofwho · 02/02/2024 19:26

I'm very sorry for your experience Op but it doesn't sound like it was deliberate on their part.

It is hard when you volunteer to run things & I can imagine they were very happy to have had someone else take that burden from them (at least for one activity) especially during the very busy period.

Could you contact them to offer to be on the committee also & help to organise the events?

WhatNoUsername · 02/02/2024 19:20

Talipesmum · 02/02/2024 18:45

I can see how it all happened that way, but honestly the organisers should have been hugely apologetic. Not dismissive. It’s inexcusable for your group committee to react in this way. Have they no heart or empathy? I’m so sorry this happened.

This. People without disabilities have no idea what it's like to get excluded from things constantly and just being told shit like "you should be more resilient". Fuck that. Their response is by far the worse thing about this.

Spirallingdownwards · 02/02/2024 19:16

I am not sure it is discrimination rather it was an oversight to check whether it was accessible and relay that it wasn't. Would you have expected them to not go at all because you couldn't especially as it seems it opens on occasions only to private groups? Or would you have accepted an explanation that we have this rare opportunity to do this but unfortunately it isn't accessible to wheelchair users or would you have really take the stance if I can't go then none of you should?

It was unfortunate that they didn't apologise for not checking which could have saved you the wasted journey.

Cancellation of membership and removal from group for not paying subs as they fall due is a different matter. Would they have done this to anyone not paying on time? If you think no and it is because of the trip then you may have a case of discrimination now but perhaps as a group of volunteers they don't want the threat of the group being sued for discrimination?

LordEmsworth · 02/02/2024 19:13

There are quite a lot of people on this thread who don't understand what discrimination is. 🙄I have helpfully googled it for you, so you can see that the OP has experienced both indirect discrimination and victimisation: https://www.gov.uk/discrimination-your-rights/how-you-can-be-discriminated-against

Honestly OP, I'd be sending the committee a letter pointing out that they are breaching the Equality Act; that you appreciate the time and work they put into running the group, but they are not exempt from either the laws of the UK, or being human beings with empathy and compassion; point out that any of them might become disabled in their lifetime; and tell them how sad you are that they have excluded you from the group rather than address the issue. I appreciate you might not want to, and frankly they are twats. Have you thought of starting your own group?

Discrimination: your rights

It is against the law to discriminate against anyone because of their sex, religion, disability or certain other personal characteristics ('protected characteristics')

https://www.gov.uk/discrimination-your-rights/how-you-can-be-discriminated-against

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 19:09

I pay membership to the group for them to organise outings. They’re aware of my needs and the needs of others. So I don’t think I should have to organise it myself - that’s their role. It’s not left to chance - I’ve paid a fee to a group to organise it on my behalf.

OP posts:
LadyKenya · 02/02/2024 19:05

spanishviola · 02/02/2024 18:40

This 100%. It shouldn’t have been difficult for the museum to put a ramp in place so you could access it too. I’ve been excluded from events from a group I’m a member of because of stairs. When I mentioned it I was told ‘it’s only this once.’ No-one should be excluded ever. Once is too much.

It is not possible for all public buildings to be accessible for all, due to historic building designs etc. They would say that on the website. This particular museum did not have a website according to the OP, but they must have a way of being contacted to check accessibility, surely? This is something that the OP cannot leave to chance.

TheSnowyOwl · 02/02/2024 19:02

I agree with you OP and I think that given you pay membership and the outings are organised, it’s reasonable to expect to be accommodated without having to double check everything yourself.

However, I think removing you from the WhatsApp group when you didn’t pay is to be expected. A reminder would have been nice but given those running the group can’t remember to do what they should in terms of accommodation, it’s not surprising that they can’t think of best practice either. I also suspect they might have thought you left as a result of the last trip and it wasn’t something you had overlooked.

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 18:59

I totally understand it was an oversight. They assumed it would be suitable for everyone. It was the curator who failed to communicate that wasn’t the case. Or maybe she did but the committee failed to pass that info on to me because of it being Xmas.

Like I said, what peed me off was the lack of apology. They took no responsibility and said the curator wasn’t at fault either. Then blamed me for expecting them to have done the job they signed up for, making excuses that they’re volunteers and it was Xmas.

Yes you’re right… it’s hardly surprising that when I didn’t pay up on time they just quickly removed me and didn’t follow up. That’s what happens when you speak up for yourself instead of just allowing discrimination to pass unchallenged.

OP posts:
ForgottenPasswordNewAccount · 02/02/2024 18:58

As someone involved in a volunteer organisation organising events and days out. It is a very thankless job. So I am not going to comment on the actual event.

Would you consider joining the committee and arranging future events so this never happens again?

RockyRogue1001 · 02/02/2024 18:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

FourLeggedBuckers · 02/02/2024 18:49

spanishviola · 02/02/2024 18:40

This 100%. It shouldn’t have been difficult for the museum to put a ramp in place so you could access it too. I’ve been excluded from events from a group I’m a member of because of stairs. When I mentioned it I was told ‘it’s only this once.’ No-one should be excluded ever. Once is too much.

Historic buildings are a valid accessibility problem - no ramp can accommodate for a spiral staircase. I wouldn’t blame the museum - they are limited by practicalities of architecture.

The organisers though are appalling. You don’t allow a member of your club to turn and find its not accessible like that. You investigate it for them, or at least mention it to the museum staff who you’re in contact with. To double down on that after the fact by dismissing the OP’s feelings and trying to make excuses without apology. That’s bloody shit.

HundredMilesAnHour · 02/02/2024 18:48

It sounds like it was an accidental oversight on their part. Like you not paying your membership was an accidental oversight on your part. Not great but people are human and forgot things at times, especially if very busy or unwell.

But you've turned it into quite a drama with your accusations of discrimination. Especially given that they usually make an effort to accommodate everyone and you know that. Hardly surprising that they didn't chase after you when you didn't pay considering recent events.

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 18:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Pointing out that they fucked up by not telling me I couldn’t be accommodated isn’t “playing the disability card”. It was a 1hr round trip and it cost me quite a bit, plus it was really upsetting for me.

OP posts:
glittercunt · 02/02/2024 18:46

UpendedPineapple · 02/02/2024 18:37

But it isn't anyone's job. They're volunteers and a mistake was made. It's completely understandable that you're upset, but I don't think there was any malice.

Absolutely is someone's job.

I'm a volunteer and have done volunteering for different organisations of different levels of size.

I'm also a wheelchair user with other access needs on top.

Whilst yes things do slide, people fall through the cracks sometimes etc, it absolutely is our job to make sure we are accessible or at least communicating when something isn't.

If we had had this trip offered, the museum would have been asked about their accessibility & whether amendments could be made. Someone would have communicated with OP.

OP I've experienced this, and whatever reasons they give, a big sincere 'sorry' is absolutely what should have been given, no ifs and buts.

Talipesmum · 02/02/2024 18:45

I can see how it all happened that way, but honestly the organisers should have been hugely apologetic. Not dismissive. It’s inexcusable for your group committee to react in this way. Have they no heart or empathy? I’m so sorry this happened.

Dacadactyl · 02/02/2024 18:44

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 18:30

I do think the museum were more at fault. I think THEY are the ones who failed in their duty, and they are the ones guilty of disability discrimination. But the reaction from the committee was cold and horrible.
That was my feeling. The museum offered the visit and the committee saw it as an easy win, let the curator arrange it and we’ll just turn up. They obviously thought everyone would be included, certainly that was what the original email sounded like. The museum didn’t intend to discriminate either, they just didn’t think.

But when I was excluded, the committee’s response was really cold, not taking any responsibility and criticising me for expecting them to have sorted it properly, and making legal sounding statements about “the museum does not guarantee access to any individual”.

I still think they were thrilled to have an excuse to just silently remove me from the group when I forgot to pay my subs. Cold again.

I think they're making statements like that because you said about disability discrimination on the day. I suspect their response would've been different if you'd not reacted in the manner you did.

That's not to say you were wrong to feel excluded, but if it was an oversight (and with Christmas I can understand how it happened) I think they may also be wondering why you didn't give them the benefit of the doubt.

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 18:43

UpendedPineapple · 02/02/2024 18:37

But it isn't anyone's job. They're volunteers and a mistake was made. It's completely understandable that you're upset, but I don't think there was any malice.

I also don’t think there was any malice. But I also think if you accept a role organising something, even if you’re a volunteer, then it’s not reasonable to say “I didn’t organise it because it was Xmas and I was busy”.

OP posts:
Bingoe · 02/02/2024 18:40

The example of being more resilient boils my piss no end, you ARE BLOODY RESILIENT AND IT WOULD BE LOVELY IF YOU DIDN'T HAVE TO BE.
What peed me off was being told that normal people not being able to do something all the time is the same as me being excluded without being told I couldn’t participate, after I’d gone all the way there. Barbara missing the last visit because she had the flu is not the same as me missing a visit because the committee (who took on the role of organising) didn’t do their job of making sure there was access for all members and informing me if there wasn’t.

OP posts:
spanishviola · 02/02/2024 18:40

FourLeggedBuckers · 02/02/2024 18:04

That’s pretty appalling. A lot of museums aren’t great for accessibility - they should absolutely have investigated it, knowing they had a member with a disability. The volunteers with busy lives excuse is shit. You make time for basic accommodations, or you don’t do it at all.

It wouldn’t fly at any hobby group I’ve been in.

This 100%. It shouldn’t have been difficult for the museum to put a ramp in place so you could access it too. I’ve been excluded from events from a group I’m a member of because of stairs. When I mentioned it I was told ‘it’s only this once.’ No-one should be excluded ever. Once is too much.

UpendedPineapple · 02/02/2024 18:37

But it isn't anyone's job. They're volunteers and a mistake was made. It's completely understandable that you're upset, but I don't think there was any malice.

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 18:36

Anybody with an ounce of compassion would have stayed in the foyer with you until ramps were found
There weren’t any ramps, there were spiral staircases and stuff so the building just wasn’t accessible. I totally get that the only option was for me to ring to be picked up again, and I wouldn’t have wanted anyone else to miss the visit. I was just really upset because I thought I was included and I was really looking forward to it, and then suddenly it’s the same old shit about being excluded again.

OP posts:
DDivaStar · 02/02/2024 18:34

Of course they should have made arrangements for your access, but they are human it may have just slipped their mind. You also could have checked with them or the venue that it was accessible.

You had complained and been upset, maybe they just assumed you no longer wanted to participate when you didn't pay your subs.

Its unfortunate but non of it sounds on purpose or malicious.

UtterlyButterly2048 · 02/02/2024 18:33

Whilst I am sure it wasn’t done in malice, I can see why it was really shit for you op. Shit that there was this “over sight” in the first place, shit that they couldn’t just say - “oh god, I’m so sorry, I completely forgot” and shit that no one offered to stay with you and maybe go somewhere else instead and meet at the coffee shop later. I do not think for one minute you are playing any kind of “card” - you couldn’t get up the bloody steps!
On balance, i don’t think I would go back. Perhaps find a more formally organised group where these things don’t get “forgotten”?