Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset?

163 replies

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 16:53

I’ve been doing a hobby for a couple of years. I have a disability which makes me quite isolated so my support worker recommended I should join a hobby. We meet every couple of months at different venues for organised events. I’m not best buds with anyone but I make polite chitchat and enjoy going.

I turned up to the Jan 2024 meeting to discover I was excluded from participating. They could have made arrangements for me to participate but hadn’t bothered and by that time it was too late to arrange. It touched a nerve because I’ve had discrimination my whole life. I got v upset and messaged the group WhatsApp to say I’m the only person who’s excluded and it’s disability discrimination.

A committee member replied and said the organiser didn’t even know I was disabled so how can it be disability discrimination, it just so happened on that occasion I wasn’t able to participate but it wasn’t on purpose. I said someone should have told me I wouldn’t be able to participate because I arranged and paid for transport, and was literally in the foyer by the time I discovered I couldn’t participate, so that was very upsetting for me and I cried. A couple of other members replied and said chin up, you need to be more resilient because life is full of setbacks like this, and examples of times when they couldn’t participate (not the same at all). Most said nothing.

Anyway… the annual membership fee is due on 31st Jan. I’ve been very sick so I didn’t realise the date. On 1st Feb I discovered I’d been removed from the WhatsApp group and Facebook group. I know that’s because I hadn’t paid the subs, but it just seemed so abrupt. No message to say “hey Bingoe have you forgot your subs are due, are you intending to still be a member, hope you’re ok”. Nothing.

AIBU to feel really upset? I know it’s a totally practical thing, you don’t pay you get kicked out… but honestly I just feel like nobody gives a shit. Of course I could just request to rejoin and pay the subs now, but I’m really hurt at the total lack of contact, just removing me with no notification. I also feel like maybe it’s because I got upset a few weeks ago and pointed out I’d been discriminated against, so now I feel like I’m being punished for calling them out.

My partner is saying they aren’t very nice and why would you want to keep being a member anyway, but like I said I’m very isolated and it was one of the few things I had.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 02/02/2024 21:39

Usually it’s organised by our group secretary, who makes an effort to make it suitable for everyone.

I think given you acknowledge that they normally make an effort to make sure it's suitable for everyone, I would have made your initial message to them less confrontational.
I'd have approached it by first acknowledging that you appreciate that they normally do that, then said how disappointed you were not to participate, then concluded by asking if they can keep you informed and if that is the case in the future events then they let you know so you know not to come.
You'd have probably got a lovely apology back and they'd have it at the back of their mind to make sure in future places are accessible.
I'd also have gone for polite email/message to organiser rather than the whole group.

There are times when it's right to go straight for the confrontational approach. But I don't think this was one of them. If I'd been the organiser, I'd have thought "heck, after all the times I've checked so carefully, made sure everything was okay, and the one time I forget I get that reaction." It's very tiring being the organiser; often all you get are complaints when things go wrong.

So yes, they shouldn't have done it, but I think you escalated it in a way that was ultimately unhelpful.

Dacadactyl · 02/02/2024 21:36

@LordEmsworth in OPs first post she says the organiser didn't know she was disabled.

From that, I took it to mean that either the person from the group that the museum approached was unaware of OPs disability.

OR, more likely, the museum contacted the group member and this group member just presumed the museum would have disabled access (as I would have done myself)

OR, it was Christmas time, the museum contact came as a surprise to the volunteer, she had a lot on, OP slipped her mind and she forgot to mention it.

That's the benefit of the doubt I'm talking about.

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 21:36

chantelion · 02/02/2024 21:29

So you went in guns blazing accusing everyone of discrimination and spoiled it for yourself when they have taken care to include you in every other visit.? I think as it was upsetting for you, your reaction was completely unfair towards them and I don't blame them from removing you. Why would they contact you after you made bold accusations at them?
It was as simple as they said, it was over Xmas time , it was offered to them and it slipped people's minds. If 'you' didn't even check for access, why are you placing such a higher expectation of the group to check? They haven't done this to you before, so why assume the worst of the group?

So if I’m discriminated against, I should avoid mentioning it if it’s not happened previously? Because they might regard it as unfair if I point out the discrimination and that might result in me being excluded. Right.

Btw I’m expecting them to check because they’re the organiser and I’ve paid them.

OP posts:
LordEmsworth · 02/02/2024 21:32

What "benefit of the doubt"?

The organiser didn't check whether the venue was accessible, when they knew the OP had specific needs. Where is the doubt?

The organiser should have taken 2 mins to ask "oh by the way, one of our members uses a wheelchair, can she attend". And 2 more minutes to message the OP and say " I am sorry that the venue isn't accessible for you, hope you can join us next time".

Not thinking of doing that means they were discriminating. It is indirect discrimination. It may not have been intended, but that does not make it ok. There is no doubt to give them the benefit of. The OP pays to be part of the group, why do you think she doesn't deserve to be treated with basic decency?

chantelion · 02/02/2024 21:31

So you acknowledge it wasn't malice yet accused people of discrimination and expect them to be nice to you? Yabvu.

chantelion · 02/02/2024 21:29

So you went in guns blazing accusing everyone of discrimination and spoiled it for yourself when they have taken care to include you in every other visit.? I think as it was upsetting for you, your reaction was completely unfair towards them and I don't blame them from removing you. Why would they contact you after you made bold accusations at them?
It was as simple as they said, it was over Xmas time , it was offered to them and it slipped people's minds. If 'you' didn't even check for access, why are you placing such a higher expectation of the group to check? They haven't done this to you before, so why assume the worst of the group?

KidwithADHD · 02/02/2024 21:28

sorry to hear this OP.

as pps have said, this wasn’t personal and not designed to exclude you. However, it did exclude you and the volunteers made a mistake.

It sounds like they are doubling down in the way people do when they are a bit embarrassed and know they’ve mucked up.

All this ‘oh you need to be more resilient’ is to make them feel better that none of them stayed with you, and went on to enjoy the tour without you.

unfortunately, I suspect they have got a bit scared about the legislation and were perhaps worried that saying sorry was an admission of guilt.

Dacadactyl · 02/02/2024 21:23

@Bingoe maybe they did remove you because of the museum incident. Maybe they felt that you didn't give them the benefit of the doubt, so they didn't bother to give you the benefit of the doubt with the subs either.

Dazedandfrazzled · 02/02/2024 21:23

Jf20 · 02/02/2024 20:45

I don’t agree, it’s a for fun hobby group and the volunteer offering to organise simply made a mistake. A very unfortunate one, but a mistake all the less. Discrimination is prejudiced treatment of someone due to a difference, I think in this instance she literally didn’t think.

I agree, I think it was miscommunication and oversight, I'm also embarrassed to say that I would assume all facilities have disabled access. Unfortunately the reaction should've been an apology and not an excuse/argument. It seems like both parties have taken offence at each other and it may be time to find another group

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 21:20

I’m just saying I think they should have let me know I couldn’t be included before I travelled there. I realise it was an oversight but I think the appropriate response is an apology. Not making an excuse like “at the end of the day the committee members are all volunteers who are busy with their own lives and jobs and also it was the Xmas holiday period”. As if I was the one who was being unreasonable for having expected them to organise it properly.

FWIW I do think if someone who was well liked (a committee member perhaps) forgot to pay their subs, the others would have messaged and said “have you forgot, hope you’re not leaving?” Not removed them without a word as they did to me. And I do think it’s because I complained about this incident.

OP posts:
RockyRogue1001 · 02/02/2024 21:18

SilverBranchGoldenPears · 02/02/2024 20:24

Tbh I think it’s the responsibility of everyone in a club to ensure that the activities that the club does fit them on any given day or week.
It is not the responsibility of the committee or other members. They could’ve said sorry certainly, but I do think we’re not being told the whole story. Do you have form for hyperbole or being difficult with them?

For clarity. I think we are being given an one-sided view. You may be suffering discrimination for all we know but simultaneously being disabled does not mean that you can’t be difficult person also and this may also be the case here.

Edited

It is, of course, absolutely true and accurate to say that just because you are <insert here> old/black/disabled/whatever you are also NICE.
Nasty people exist anywhere and everywhere.
As do nice people, of course.

Your post, however, is a massive reach....

Your post basically says
You might not be a nice person
Therefore I'm assuming you're NOT a nice person
Therefore it's all your fault

Scautish · 02/02/2024 21:02

Kittylala · 02/02/2024 20:54

I have a disability - but its my responsibility to make sure my needs are met.
Also it doesn't sound like you make the effort to make friendships.

No it’s not your responsibility. Obviously guidance and practical suggestions are good but we need to move from this standpoint of disabled people apologising and kowtowing to non-disabled sensitivities.

as a society we need to constantly question why we are not more inclusive.

the attitudes displayed by so many on this thread demonstrate exactly why life is so hard for so many disabled people. It’s sickening.

Kittylala · 02/02/2024 20:54

I have a disability - but its my responsibility to make sure my needs are met.
Also it doesn't sound like you make the effort to make friendships.

CrocusSnowdrop · 02/02/2024 20:50

Discrimination doesn't have to be deliberate. This was discrimination, on the part of the museum (they assumed none of the members would have a problem with stairs) and the volunteers (they had time to organise the excursion, but not for everybody - even if they didn't mean it, it still happened). Clearly the volunteers got defensive when it was pointed out, instead of listening, apologising, and learning for next time.
And for all the people saying "why didn't you check yourself", OP makes a very valid point that they shouldn't have to when they've outsourced this to a group. Do you realise how exhausting it is to have to ring up before every social event, trip out, restaurant visit? And half the time they say "yes we're accessible" and then aren't when you get there anyway.
As for "disability card" - what rubbish. Being excluded from somewhere due to lack of accessibility isn't "playing the disability card", it's facts.

I'm really sorry this happened to you OP. I hope you can work with your support worker to find somewhere else to go.

Lovingitallnow · 02/02/2024 20:47

I would imagine most people with disabilities have buckets of resilience and everyone is entitled to have the cup run dry every so often. Especially when you're treated poorly. The polite and human thing to do would be to wholeheartedly apologise to you and for soMeone to wait in the foyer with you. Unfortunately it looks like this group is full of oddballs and you'd be better off finding a new one.

Jf20 · 02/02/2024 20:45

Scautish · 02/02/2024 20:34

You shouldn’t have played the disability card from the off. It just puts everyone on the back foot because in all likelihood that just isn’t true, however much you may feel it is.

im sorry OP. It absolutely is discrimination and this post is an excellent example of denial of such.

@BananasInThreePieceSuits ignorance of what is construed as discrimination is not a defence. I find your attitude very offensive.

I don’t agree, it’s a for fun hobby group and the volunteer offering to organise simply made a mistake. A very unfortunate one, but a mistake all the less. Discrimination is prejudiced treatment of someone due to a difference, I think in this instance she literally didn’t think.

Jf20 · 02/02/2024 20:43

I understand why this was upsetting for you, but I’m really not sure this wa discrimation and I’m concerned about your repeated accusations against the group. It does seem likely this was just an unfortunate oversight, but you do appear to be blaming the organiser , who is a volunteer, and simply responded to this over Xmas, for not checking, when you yourself didn’t check and could have done.

you also know you can just pay the subs and join again, there is no big deal there.

i think I would urge you to consider that this wasn’t malicious, it was an unfortunate oversight, and it was you who didn’t pay the subs, also unfortunate. And you can just pay now and join again.

its just a hobby group op, volunteers organising stuff for fun, she made a mistake, thats all.

Scautish · 02/02/2024 20:34

You shouldn’t have played the disability card from the off. It just puts everyone on the back foot because in all likelihood that just isn’t true, however much you may feel it is.

im sorry OP. It absolutely is discrimination and this post is an excellent example of denial of such.

@BananasInThreePieceSuits ignorance of what is construed as discrimination is not a defence. I find your attitude very offensive.

Wednesdaysphiltrum · 02/02/2024 20:27

Bingoe · 02/02/2024 18:48

Pointing out that they fucked up by not telling me I couldn’t be accommodated isn’t “playing the disability card”. It was a 1hr round trip and it cost me quite a bit, plus it was really upsetting for me.

I’m really sorry, OP. I’m also sorry for the ableist bullshit you’re getting on here.

Dazedandfrazzled · 02/02/2024 20:25

It sounds like miscommunication that's escalated? It sounds like you were unintentionally excluded and your first response was to say I’m the only person who’s excluded and it’s disability discrimination. and this got their back up (I understand why you assumed this, but equally it would be upsetting to be accused of this if ita untrue, particularly in a group setting), then by not paying they assumed you were angry and didn't want to be part of the group. I'd just have a concern with the person face to face or phone if possible, as text isn't the best way to communicate and I'm sure it will be sorted out.

SilverBranchGoldenPears · 02/02/2024 20:24

Tbh I think it’s the responsibility of everyone in a club to ensure that the activities that the club does fit them on any given day or week.
It is not the responsibility of the committee or other members. They could’ve said sorry certainly, but I do think we’re not being told the whole story. Do you have form for hyperbole or being difficult with them?

For clarity. I think we are being given an one-sided view. You may be suffering discrimination for all we know but simultaneously being disabled does not mean that you can’t be difficult person also and this may also be the case here.

Watercolourpapier · 02/02/2024 20:21

What shitty people to leave you crying in the foyer.

Jinglesomeoftheway · 02/02/2024 20:17

I'm so sorry to hear how you were treated - sounds like they showed absolutely zero empathy when you turned up and had no access. Even if somebody didn't feel it was their fault, I can't believe the organiser didn't apologise or treat you kindly. A little compassion would have gone a long way.

You need to weigh up whether attending in future will cause you too much upset/anxiety and therefore best left alone, or if you can put it behind you and enjoy the hobby as you once did xx

Lwrenn · 02/02/2024 20:17

@Bingoe sorry this happened to you Bingoe, sounds absolutely shit.
As if being a wheelchair user isn't difficult enough with places being inaccessible, to feel left out of things must be really tough for you. You have done brilliantly getting out and about and you didn't deserve this setback.
I wish people remembered that our every single persons physical ability is borrowed to those of us lucky to get it, mobility issues gets us all of we age and the fact we don't make the world more accessible just shows how ignorant we are at times.

I've always found galleries and cinemas have had excellent accessibility, more so than museums. Do you like history generally? Maybe some local historians near you have talks in accessible places? Obviously I'm not sure we're you're based but if you're comfortable to tell us maybe we've posters who can recommend you things to get you out more? Don't stick to one group you're not feeling apart of. You deserve nice pals x

C152 · 02/02/2024 20:01

I'm pissed off on your behalf, OP. Yes, it is disability discrimination, but you will rarely get able bodied people to see that their assumptions are discriminatory. The group you are part of are totally in the wrong and so is the museum. I agree with your DH. I wouldn't return to that particular group, but I would try to find another one (I do know how hard that can be).