Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would giving all children free school meals actually safe the public purse money long term?

342 replies

Kendodd · 02/02/2024 09:42

Really good quality, highly nutritional, tailored to children's needs and vegetarian. I know this would cost a lot, but if it improves the nations health long term, would it actually cost less?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
notknowledgeable · 02/02/2024 21:07

Hubblebubble · 02/02/2024 20:24

It would be wonderful for neglected secondary school children who aren't sent in with any lunch money. Unlike primary school, that goes unnoticed

Nobody brings money in, it is all on account, and clearly recorded what money each child has, and what they spend it on - I have a few that eat nothing but kitkats.

Hubblebubble · 02/02/2024 20:24

It would be wonderful for neglected secondary school children who aren't sent in with any lunch money. Unlike primary school, that goes unnoticed

Sceptre86 · 02/02/2024 20:19

The food actually has to be consumed. Kids don't get very long in the lunch hall to be able to eat and even then lots don't eat all their meal. I'm on a group for disney and the amount of British parents with children that are fussy eaters or only eat plain foods like chicken nuggets is unreal. A poster from another European country commented on it and got villified and before you say it not all kids have sen.

We are in Scotland and my kids opt for a packed lunch despite the universal free school meals for kids of their age. The vegetarian options consist of meat substitutes which they don't like.

If you are talking about England then surely they could look at Scotland and see if it is actually having any benefit long term what the uptake is like and the levels of waste and whether it actually helps kids overall.

DragonFly98 · 02/02/2024 20:05

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/02/2024 18:59

Well, for those who are raging at the notion of ensuring teenagers get fed, they can be reassured that FSM provision is being removed again - the transitional protection that ensured eligibility for FSM for the duration of a school phase is being removed and it's going back to only being available (outside the infants/the vote winners) to far lower incomes and not being fixed for their entire time in one phase. So if somebody works, they'll automatically have too much money to pay for them. And if there's a glitch in their benefits, they'll automatically lose them.

It also means that schools will lose thousands in pupil premium, as that FSM entitlement means that they receive additional funding from the local authority.

Say hello to kids going hungry again in the summer term of 2025. And schools even more broke than they are already in trying to plug the gaps in welfare and attainment.

It will be available till the end of the school stage a child is at in March 2025. It doesn't end in 2025. If you are in reception or year 7 it won't end until 2031 or 2029 if in year 7 in 2025 and you leave school in year 11.

RandomMess · 02/02/2024 19:58

We need a complete rethink on education and meals in school, this is so inspiring

m.youtube.com/watch?v=0qY6KIortCc

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 02/02/2024 19:20

If you have a child then the absolute minimum you are required to do is provide food for it. Parents should fund food not school.

blackpanth · 02/02/2024 19:15

Meant to say keep scrolling*

blackpanth · 02/02/2024 19:15

On*

blackpanth · 02/02/2024 19:14

NextOnePlease · 02/02/2024 18:43

Yabu for saying vegetarian

Oh Emma, give it a rest @blackpanth You’re like a broken record. 😅

If you don't like my comments just don't comment and I'm allowed to have an opinion 🤣 and you can see loads of here have the same one

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/02/2024 18:59

Well, for those who are raging at the notion of ensuring teenagers get fed, they can be reassured that FSM provision is being removed again - the transitional protection that ensured eligibility for FSM for the duration of a school phase is being removed and it's going back to only being available (outside the infants/the vote winners) to far lower incomes and not being fixed for their entire time in one phase. So if somebody works, they'll automatically have too much money to pay for them. And if there's a glitch in their benefits, they'll automatically lose them.

It also means that schools will lose thousands in pupil premium, as that FSM entitlement means that they receive additional funding from the local authority.

Say hello to kids going hungry again in the summer term of 2025. And schools even more broke than they are already in trying to plug the gaps in welfare and attainment.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 02/02/2024 18:50

BlueGrey1 · 02/02/2024 14:37

@Butterdishy

A possible solution would be to have a meeting /online tutorial with the parents at the beginning of the school year on what to provide in a balanced healthy Lynch and what not to, then issue them with a pdf of affordable lynch options and items that should or shouldn’t be included, the talk could include an area where the importance of having a healthy lunch / breakfast is stressed in relation to their performance in school and overall health

Can't see how that would be much use. Mine have school dinners anyway, ours are actually alright, but also I don't see any reason to think school are better qualified than I am to decide what's an appropriate packed lunch for my DC. Nor have I any interest in getting budgeting advice from them. If they're banning an item, like if they have to go nut free or whatever, fine, just send a notification home. Rather use the money on something that will actually be engaged with.

NextOnePlease · 02/02/2024 18:43

Yabu for saying vegetarian

Oh Emma, give it a rest @blackpanth You’re like a broken record. 😅

Butterdishy · 02/02/2024 18:35

Minymile · 02/02/2024 18:14

It’s unaffordable. Taxes would need to go up
Vegetarian only would be the only affordable way and hopefully as they would be eating it from the day they start school they would be used to it.
It also means less wastage and not having to provide so many options hence less cost in production too.

But overall, it’s too expensive.

Last year we spend £1.4bn on fsm (means tested and ks1). To extend to all up to year 11 would cost an additional £2.5bn.
Consider that the NHS budget was £180bn, is it really too expensive?

Minymile · 02/02/2024 18:14

It’s unaffordable. Taxes would need to go up
Vegetarian only would be the only affordable way and hopefully as they would be eating it from the day they start school they would be used to it.
It also means less wastage and not having to provide so many options hence less cost in production too.

But overall, it’s too expensive.

Natsku · 02/02/2024 17:39

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/02/2024 17:19

Are all of those Gs for gluten free food? Apart from being pissed off with only a carrot and pineapple salad on Tuesday, I'd be chuffed as nuts with that - our school can't even manage one GF meal (I saw the state of the coeliac child after they'd had their special 'gluten free' meal - a few months later, the kitchen manager tried to present a salad as gluten free by taking the croutons off the top of the serving bowl. and after some training, could then present their latest 'this is gluten free' ingredients list with barley at the end.

That's terrible! My daughter has coeliac disease, thankfully gluten free diets are well understood and catered for where I am. Most days the school lunch is GF anyway, and on the days it isn't she always gets a proper GF alternative, and all the children with allergies get trays to limit cross contamination from crumbs on the tables (they took trays away from everyone at the beginning of the school year, because of the electricity costs from washing them I guess, but gave them back to the children with allergies after one coeliac girl got a reaction from crumbs on the table)

That said, at my school they accidentally labelled the normal spinach pancakes as GF ones but luckily I thought they looked to good to be GF and double checked before taking!

Kendodd · 02/02/2024 17:26

blackpanth · 02/02/2024 16:14

75% of the world population are meat eaters.

So 25% are not.

OP posts:
11NigelTufnel · 02/02/2024 17:24

@Vettrianofan I didn't say it was a magic wand that would cover childcare for all at all times. It wouldn't help me on the days i start work early. I live about an hour from a big city, so it wouldn't help any of the parents who work there and need to commute either. Just that it would help some. Plus I think the bigger benefit is for the children that aren't too hungry to learn.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/02/2024 17:19

Rewis · 02/02/2024 12:56

@Deathraystare this inspired me to go see what my old school has to offer next week. I have to say that back then dessert on 2 days in a week was unheard of and I'm pretty sure mango chicken would have been too modern 😅 and then bread, milk and water with that food.

Are all of those Gs for gluten free food? Apart from being pissed off with only a carrot and pineapple salad on Tuesday, I'd be chuffed as nuts with that - our school can't even manage one GF meal (I saw the state of the coeliac child after they'd had their special 'gluten free' meal - a few months later, the kitchen manager tried to present a salad as gluten free by taking the croutons off the top of the serving bowl. and after some training, could then present their latest 'this is gluten free' ingredients list with barley at the end.

Caffeineislife · 02/02/2024 17:07

Yes to free school meals for all. It would certainly ensure all children get a decent meal every school day. I worked in a London Borough where this was standard and it really helped with take up for school dinners for the older year groups. It also made lunchtimes simpler as almost everyone had school lunch rather than pack ups so there wasn't all the lunchbox monitoring ect.

It would need to be funded properly and preferably made on site.

I don't agree with just vegetarian, meat is part of a healthy diet and in many low income homes is the part of the diet that is lacking due to the cost of meat. However, I am completely on board with the stipulation that the vegetarian equivalent should be as substantial as the meat main. It should not just be jacket potato or cheese sandwich. It should be an equally nutritional hot offer.

DrCoconut · 02/02/2024 17:07

I'd rather my kids were fed vegetable based meals than cheap nasty meat which school meals inevitably will be.

MoreDangerousThanAWomanScorned · 02/02/2024 17:06

Absolutely no one has accidentally killed a child with a vegetarian diet. There have been tragic cases involving very strict vegan diets but even then they have to be bizarrely strict (just fruit and veg or not giving a young baby suitable milk) and the parents have mental health issues. Any sort of balanced vegetarian diet is fine for kids; balanced vegan takes more effort but is perfectly doable. The vast majority of children who are malnourished come from meat-eating families - that's not to suggest at all that the meat causes the malnourishment, just that the two are unconnected.

Vettrianofan · 02/02/2024 17:03

11NigelTufnel · 02/02/2024 15:41

I would provide free breakfast for all, not lunch. In primary, it would help parents work by having breakfast club type childcare from say 8am. For all ages, providing breakfast would stop children being distracted by hunger and help them learn. Waiting until lunch means they are only full up to learn for a couple of hours in the afternoon. The parents who can drop their kids off earlier can then go to work for 9 and earn more, thereby being taxed more. All round win and cheaper than lunches.

What about those who start work at say 6am/7am? That's them excluded from that wee set up, isn't it? Not everyone works 9 til 5 Monday to Friday.

dearymcdearface · 02/02/2024 16:57

Boomboom22 · 02/02/2024 16:51

Veggie sausages are disgusting like cardboard and terrible for you.nothing like real sausage. There is no meat! Meat alternatives are terrible

Parents have accidentally murdered their children by neglect through feeding them veggie or vegan diets so it's not actually a laughing matter. Meat and protein are absolutely essential for children. It's actually bad parenting to make your child veggie due to your wrong beliefs about veggies being healthier.

Yes, you said that already. I have said nothing about parents murdering their kids with veggie sausages. Muslim children usually pick this alternative. If not, as you can read in this sausage case there are alternatives every day. One veggie. One meat or fish. Good, right?

Would giving all children free school meals actually safe the public purse money long term?
DrCoconut · 02/02/2024 16:57

@Passingthethyme allergies aren't being fussy. They can make you really ill or even kill you.

Boomboom22 · 02/02/2024 16:51

dearymcdearface · 02/02/2024 16:00

Look again. There is a veggie and a meat alternative most days. Are you saying kids can’t eat sausages, chili con carne or moussaka? Or vegetables? Then it’s you that has a big problem, not the kids in my country.

Veggie sausages are disgusting like cardboard and terrible for you.nothing like real sausage. There is no meat! Meat alternatives are terrible

Parents have accidentally murdered their children by neglect through feeding them veggie or vegan diets so it's not actually a laughing matter. Meat and protein are absolutely essential for children. It's actually bad parenting to make your child veggie due to your wrong beliefs about veggies being healthier.

Swipe left for the next trending thread