Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would giving all children free school meals actually safe the public purse money long term?

342 replies

Kendodd · 02/02/2024 09:42

Really good quality, highly nutritional, tailored to children's needs and vegetarian. I know this would cost a lot, but if it improves the nations health long term, would it actually cost less?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 08:48

@rickyrickygrimes I wonder how many French children actually only eat the baguette and cheese though?
If they don't eat the full meal are they forced to sit all afternoon until they do?
Do teens come out of school and head to their nearest takeaway place (France has them too....🙄)?

Wasbedeudetetdas · 03/02/2024 08:48

Abergale · 03/02/2024 08:43

well firstly that’s bollocks because healthy vegetarians exist but secondly the whole point of this is it’s one meal of the day 5 days a week. .no meal, vegetarian or meat is going to be 100% of the nutrition a child needs for the day so you would be free to fill the rest of their nutritional needs of the day with meat if you deemed that appropriate.

Higher meat consumption is strongly correlated with obesity. We should be encouraging kids to eat less of it and normalise getting calories from other more nutritious sources. not continuing the status quo.

does anyone care that breakfast clubs are normally vegetarian? No, because it’s not labelled as such so they don’t even notice.

I didn't say healthy vegetarians don't exist.
I didn't suggest high meat consumption.
I didn't suggest the lunch would/should contain all the nutritional requirements.
Ideally it would be two healthy choices 4/5 days - one with meat or fish and one without, plus 1/5 meat free day with two veggie options.
Veggie options shouldn't routinely be those awful bland meat substitutes, but actual vegetables, pulses etc.
I didn't suggest continuing any status quo.
I didn't mention breakfast clubs.

Abergale · 03/02/2024 08:43

Wasbedeudetetdas · 03/02/2024 06:44

Some vegetarian meals/option - yes.
Exclusively vegetarian meals/options - no.
I'm all for using local produce and making it (mostly) healthy.

well firstly that’s bollocks because healthy vegetarians exist but secondly the whole point of this is it’s one meal of the day 5 days a week. .no meal, vegetarian or meat is going to be 100% of the nutrition a child needs for the day so you would be free to fill the rest of their nutritional needs of the day with meat if you deemed that appropriate.

Higher meat consumption is strongly correlated with obesity. We should be encouraging kids to eat less of it and normalise getting calories from other more nutritious sources. not continuing the status quo.

does anyone care that breakfast clubs are normally vegetarian? No, because it’s not labelled as such so they don’t even notice.

rickyrickygrimes · 03/02/2024 08:05

I think the ship has sailed in terms of getting children in the UK to eat healthier food in school settings. I just can’t see children who’ve got used to eating junk food, when they want, grazing through the day and not being made to eat what’s on their plates, settling for this. And their parents working make them.

im in France, two kids who are up into secondary now and school meals here are so different: the whole concept is just different. Choice is not a priority. French children are generally brought up to eat what they are given, no choice. And lunch is always a full meal of starter, main course, cheese, dessert. I work in a school and eat in the canteen often. The last meal I ate there was

Selections of salads: beetroot in vinaigrette, white cabbage in a pink peppercorn dressing, mushrooms in a tomato sauce, green salad.

choice of sauté de boeuf (beef stew) or white fish
choice of pumpkin gratin and / or green beans

small piece of cheese - Brie or raclette (it changes daily) plus a couple of slices of baguette or a plain yoghurt.

small piece of cake / small coffee mousse / fruit / flavoured yoghurt.

how many British kids would happily eat that ? Yet the great majority of kids in our school do.

Big differences.: no choice. There are no alternatives to the above. No sandwiches / rolls / crisps / sweets / muffins / etc. No baked potato bar, etc. No morning ‘snack bar’ (bacon rolls at school - really ?) in fact no morning snack. They start school at 8am and don’t eat lunch until 12 and somehow they survive. Nothing to drink in school other than water - no fizzy juice, no vending machines, no fruit juice, just water. Chips or a pizza slice might be served once per term. Burgers? Never. No packed lunches.

it costs to provide this quality of food. France has a means tested system of charging for such things - which the uk says would be too complicated / expensive to implement. I can’t see how : ours is taken from your income / tax return, which produces a coefficient that is applied to lots of means tested things like school trips, school lunches, in school childcare. I pay €4,22 per meal, my friend who’s on a low income pays €0,22 per meal.

Butterdishy · 03/02/2024 07:35

ODubhshlaine · 02/02/2024 21:53

Yes it is.
Or maybe benefits for those who receive them ieUC could be cut to allow for the free school meals, the kids would get a healthy meal but in losing part of the benefits it wouldn’t cost so much
The cost of sorting that out would be excessive too though
Plus There would be an absolute uproar. Weird suggestion anyway
So a non starter, back to it being too expensive and…..

……At some point responsibility for children's health needs to fall on the parents. Not constantly the state
Or maybe parents just birth children. The state can do everything else

9% of the NHS budget is spent on type 2 diabetes.
Of course in an ideal world parents would feed their kids properly, but they don't. You have to look beyond short term.

PrincessCharlette · 03/02/2024 07:10

They wouldn't eat it so you'd just be wasting more money and there are is enough of that in the public sector already.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 03/02/2024 06:44

Abergale · 03/02/2024 05:05

Exactly!

that was ops entire starting point but people have just jumped on the veggie label as bad.

Some vegetarian meals/option - yes.
Exclusively vegetarian meals/options - no.
I'm all for using local produce and making it (mostly) healthy.

NeedToChangeName · 03/02/2024 06:33

DinnaeFashYersel · 02/02/2024 14:08

All children (up to P5) in Scotland get free school meals

And that's one of the reasons why we Scot's get to pay more income tax.

It doesn't seem to be saving any money just costing the tax payer more.

Higher taxes in Scotland also fund university fees, prescriptions, personal care etc, not just FSM....

NeverDropYourMooncup · 03/02/2024 05:16

DragonFly98 · 02/02/2024 23:27

No both year 7 and year 12 would still get fsm until the end of year 13.

Not when there's a change of phase.

Abergale · 03/02/2024 05:05

DrCoconut · 02/02/2024 17:07

I'd rather my kids were fed vegetable based meals than cheap nasty meat which school meals inevitably will be.

Exactly!

that was ops entire starting point but people have just jumped on the veggie label as bad.

Abergale · 03/02/2024 04:42

Kendodd · 02/02/2024 14:10

In what way?

All the posters saying it’s not a nutritional meal without meat or their kid dislikes all veg or chucks half their dinner in bin anyway (presumably because they are full from high calorie processed crap snacks) like that’s normal.

being poor drives obesity in this country. Kids don’t need more calories they need more nutrition.

so I think your principal is great op but it would be undermined by parents and our general societies attitudes to food waste.

blackpanth · 02/02/2024 23:37

CaptainJamesIsHot · 02/02/2024 23:09

Oh Emma, give it a rest @blackpanth You’re like a broken record. 😅

ikr. Any opportunity. I’m surprised she hadn’t mentioned her dad, he’s a butcher you know and she needs meat. 🤣🤣🤣

Ahh keep on being childish its okay 🤣🤣

DragonFly98 · 02/02/2024 23:27

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/02/2024 23:22

Bit shit for Year 7s and Year 12, don't you think?

No both year 7 and year 12 would still get fsm until the end of year 13.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/02/2024 23:22

DragonFly98 · 02/02/2024 20:05

It will be available till the end of the school stage a child is at in March 2025. It doesn't end in 2025. If you are in reception or year 7 it won't end until 2031 or 2029 if in year 7 in 2025 and you leave school in year 11.

Bit shit for Year 7s and Year 12, don't you think?

CaptainJamesIsHot · 02/02/2024 23:09

Oh Emma, give it a rest @blackpanth You’re like a broken record. 😅

ikr. Any opportunity. I’m surprised she hadn’t mentioned her dad, he’s a butcher you know and she needs meat. 🤣🤣🤣

Flivequacle · 02/02/2024 22:56

Free school meals are a great idea - I'm in London so all my school's students eat FSM - the very rare child brings a packed lunch and that is invariably down to extreme fussiness or severe allergies or very specific dietary restrictions.

Making the meals vegetarian won't be cheaper - cheap meat is very cheap - but it would expand the the fibre, nutrients and vitamins on offer.

Fussy children will eat very poorly whether it is FSM or paid or pack-up. If they are fed a diet of fast food and UPF at home, they will find real food an adjustment. Most of the children eat pretty well, though.

Some parents kicked off when rules about the free, provided fruit at snacktime came in (and no snacks from home). Now the children attack the pears and satsumas and bananas on offer. It's nice to see them enjoying fruit.

Fsm should be the norm, and they should be better. Like any policy, to succeed it needs to be funded and implemented well.

Minymile · 02/02/2024 22:12

ODubhshlaine · 02/02/2024 22:07

My children had to have school meals. They were not allowed packed lunches.
If all schools do the same and they provide only healthy food. No crap, no chips, sponge pudding, ice cream etc etc etc.

Then the future population could be healthier
That doesn’t mean it is free. Parents still pay. Just because it’s healthy shouldn’t mean it has to be free.

Then someone needs to educate the parents who feed their children the unhealthy stuff for all the other meals

Agree.
If all that’s needed is healthy meals at school the Govn, Schools and parents need to insist on this. For the health of our kids!
There is no need , however , for it to be free just because it’s healthy.

More taxes on processed foods, sugar, salt etc. That might help the country to a healthier life.

GRex · 02/02/2024 22:12

We are in London, so school switched to free school meals for everyone. Now DS and friends all want packed lunch becuse the meals are over-cooked/ burnt. Facilities just aren't set up for suddenly feeding all the kids. When the kids then won't eat it, it's a waste of money.

In principle I agree with all kids getting a free meal when needed, but maybe better to focus that on simple breakfasts, milk and fruit and implement carefully so schools can actually cope.

ODubhshlaine · 02/02/2024 22:07

Kendodd · 02/02/2024 21:26

I think you might be ignoring the potential savings from this. If good food improves health then that would safe money long term? Also you say taxes would have to go up, but parents would be savings on lunch money. If we are going to invest in anything in this country, we'll what would be more important than our kids health. It's all very well saying parents should feed kids better, well plenty are feeding them crap or not feeding them at all, for whatever reasons.

My children had to have school meals. They were not allowed packed lunches.
If all schools do the same and they provide only healthy food. No crap, no chips, sponge pudding, ice cream etc etc etc.

Then the future population could be healthier
That doesn’t mean it is free. Parents still pay. Just because it’s healthy shouldn’t mean it has to be free.

Then someone needs to educate the parents who feed their children the unhealthy stuff for all the other meals

Minymile · 02/02/2024 22:02

Butterdishy · 02/02/2024 18:35

Last year we spend £1.4bn on fsm (means tested and ks1). To extend to all up to year 11 would cost an additional £2.5bn.
Consider that the NHS budget was £180bn, is it really too expensive?

Of course it is.
Parents should be feeding kids not the tax payers constantly.

Free school meal provision is being reduced again anyway because there’s no money. It won’t be extended further.

ODubhshlaine · 02/02/2024 21:53

Butterdishy · 02/02/2024 18:35

Last year we spend £1.4bn on fsm (means tested and ks1). To extend to all up to year 11 would cost an additional £2.5bn.
Consider that the NHS budget was £180bn, is it really too expensive?

Yes it is.
Or maybe benefits for those who receive them ieUC could be cut to allow for the free school meals, the kids would get a healthy meal but in losing part of the benefits it wouldn’t cost so much
The cost of sorting that out would be excessive too though
Plus There would be an absolute uproar. Weird suggestion anyway
So a non starter, back to it being too expensive and…..

……At some point responsibility for children's health needs to fall on the parents. Not constantly the state
Or maybe parents just birth children. The state can do everything else

NextOnePlease · 02/02/2024 21:51

There would be no time for 1000+ kids to eat a served meal at secondary school. The queues are massive already and lunchtimes are often only 30 minutes long.

Mamaraisedadoughut · 02/02/2024 21:31

I've spoken to people who have run school kitchens, the problem is by the time kids have started school, many are set into habits of eating so poorly they won't eat proper food if they haven't had it at home.

Though, I do also know children who have had feckless parents who haven't fed them particularly well, who's bones have broken very easily and repeatedly... the parent said something about poor nutrition being the reason.

So could save the NHS money, potentially the benefit system money, eventually BUT just like another thread here, when will parents start to take responsibility of their children?

Kendodd · 02/02/2024 21:26

Minymile · 02/02/2024 18:14

It’s unaffordable. Taxes would need to go up
Vegetarian only would be the only affordable way and hopefully as they would be eating it from the day they start school they would be used to it.
It also means less wastage and not having to provide so many options hence less cost in production too.

But overall, it’s too expensive.

I think you might be ignoring the potential savings from this. If good food improves health then that would safe money long term? Also you say taxes would have to go up, but parents would be savings on lunch money. If we are going to invest in anything in this country, we'll what would be more important than our kids health. It's all very well saying parents should feed kids better, well plenty are feeding them crap or not feeding them at all, for whatever reasons.

OP posts:
Hubblebubble · 02/02/2024 21:25

@notknowledgeable I didn't realise that all schools had moved to a cashless system. That's good.

Swipe left for the next trending thread