Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would giving all children free school meals actually safe the public purse money long term?

342 replies

Kendodd · 02/02/2024 09:42

Really good quality, highly nutritional, tailored to children's needs and vegetarian. I know this would cost a lot, but if it improves the nations health long term, would it actually cost less?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
BringItOnxxx · 03/02/2024 18:13

Hubblebubble · 03/02/2024 16:24

When I worked in South Korea the school meals were so healthy and varied. But a typical meal would be; always a broth type soup, rice (white or purple), kimchi, a meat/fish/tofu/egg dish and with sides like acorn jelly, marinated quails eggs or nori. They ate it all up because its what they were used to. If UK kids were regularly served a healthy lunch 5x a week, they'd become used to it and eat it.

Edited

Exactly, the problem is entirely self made. Although I believe that, due to the industrial revolution, we became more malnourished and removed from the land and growing of good. We became accustomed to beige diets.

Hubblebubble · 03/02/2024 16:24

When I worked in South Korea the school meals were so healthy and varied. But a typical meal would be; always a broth type soup, rice (white or purple), kimchi, a meat/fish/tofu/egg dish and with sides like acorn jelly, marinated quails eggs or nori. They ate it all up because its what they were used to. If UK kids were regularly served a healthy lunch 5x a week, they'd become used to it and eat it.

Natsku · 03/02/2024 15:20

ODubhshlaine · 03/02/2024 10:57

Is this a Steiner school

No, its just a normal Finnish school

Wasbedeudetetdas · 03/02/2024 11:29

Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 11:00

@ODubhshlaine the problem is one persons "healthy" is another persons "evil food".
I've seen on threads about packed lunches on here and people being criticised for giving a perfectly normal lunch of a ham and cheese sandwich followed by a yogurt.

Indeed. It's crazy. That's fine, especially if part of an overall balanced diet.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 03/02/2024 11:28

Again, because myths are still being perpetuated, food isn't always automatically healthier or better for the planet just because it's vegetarian.

ODubhshlaine · 03/02/2024 11:03

Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 11:00

@ODubhshlaine the problem is one persons "healthy" is another persons "evil food".
I've seen on threads about packed lunches on here and people being criticised for giving a perfectly normal lunch of a ham and cheese sandwich followed by a yogurt.

Blimey, ! I just don’t get that.

Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 11:00

@ODubhshlaine the problem is one persons "healthy" is another persons "evil food".
I've seen on threads about packed lunches on here and people being criticised for giving a perfectly normal lunch of a ham and cheese sandwich followed by a yogurt.

ODubhshlaine · 03/02/2024 10:57

Natsku · 03/02/2024 10:50

It is good. I remember when I was in school picking litter was a punishment which made us think badly of it. Here its something you do to take pride in your school and its surroundings. Sometimes they go cleaning the forest next to the school too.

Is this a Steiner school

Natsku · 03/02/2024 10:50

ODubhshlaine · 03/02/2024 10:34

That’s fantastic. I’ve read that other countries do this too.

It is good. I remember when I was in school picking litter was a punishment which made us think badly of it. Here its something you do to take pride in your school and its surroundings. Sometimes they go cleaning the forest next to the school too.

Kendodd · 03/02/2024 10:39

Thelnebriati · 03/02/2024 10:27

How sad that they stopped the whole scheme instead of just providing one nutritious meal a day.

I know.
But you can see, just from this thread alone, all the objections even to the idea of feeding children better. And as for the idea that children will just buy fast food on the way home, well where do they get the money for that? Parents give it to them. As I said, children eat crap food making them fat and unhealthy because adults give it to them. And regarding education, people know already. Who doesn't know that KFC is bad for you and vegetables are good for you? Nobody!

OP posts:
ODubhshlaine · 03/02/2024 10:34

Natsku · 03/02/2024 09:59

Cleaning their own schools is good, teach them how to clean and keep places clean. At my DD's school each month different classes clean the surrounding area of the school (i.e. the playgrounds), and at the end of the school year an even bigger clean of the playgrounds is done by everyone.

That’s fantastic. I’ve read that other countries do this too.

LlynTegid · 03/02/2024 10:31

It won't stop the visits to McDonalds and other unhealthy so-called fast food places that are the real cause, along with the proportion of children being brought up in poverty.

ODubhshlaine · 03/02/2024 10:31

Fluffycloudsfloatinginthesky · 03/02/2024 09:42

My daughter told me in her secondary school people complained there were no healthy options. They brought them in at lunch but now they are not selling and then canteen staff are complaining they are losing money on them!

all the options need to be healthy.

ODubhshlaine · 03/02/2024 10:27

Butterdishy · 03/02/2024 07:35

9% of the NHS budget is spent on type 2 diabetes.
Of course in an ideal world parents would feed their kids properly, but they don't. You have to look beyond short term.

Short term is - the state paying for lunches

Long term is -
-the state feeding them all meals or educating parents, ( that rarely works).
-However raising taxes on salt, sugar and unhealthy foods such as those that are processed might.
-Along with banning unhealthy additives such as aspartame which other countries have been doing for years.

Lunches alone won’t solve the issue long term.

Thelnebriati · 03/02/2024 10:27

How sad that they stopped the whole scheme instead of just providing one nutritious meal a day.

Kendodd · 03/02/2024 10:04

determinedtomakethiswork · 03/02/2024 09:50

I heard a really interesting program on the radio about an experiment carried out in Sweden. They provided a free school lunch and the children could eat as much as they wanted - the food was very healthy and sugar-free and not beige.

They noticed two things: the children ate far more than they expected and the results of tests showed that their afternoon performance had greatly increased. They then did the same with breakfast and the test results showed morning performance massively increased.

They were then going to do an evening meal. However politicians said that if the children were having three big free meals a day, then benefits should be cut slightly to accommodate that. There was an uproar from the families and the whole scheme stopped.

Isn't that interesting and sad. I scheme that had such obvious benefits for children scrapped because adults want the money.

OP posts:
MoreDangerousThanAWomanScorned · 03/02/2024 10:03

Fluffycloudsfloatinginthesky · 03/02/2024 09:42

My daughter told me in her secondary school people complained there were no healthy options. They brought them in at lunch but now they are not selling and then canteen staff are complaining they are losing money on them!

This is unfortunately a continual cycle where I work (a university) - complaints that there aren't enough healthy/meat-free options, so they put more in/turn one of the catering outlets into a salad bar etc, then they get dropped after six months because they're not selling enough. Six months after that the calls for more healthy options begins again...

Part of the problem is that one of the reasons that mass catering is often stodgy, carby stuff is that it's much easier to make on a big scale and keep hot. Fresh, vegetable based food is (I think) much nicer but it tends to showcase the quality of its ingredients which is a problem if the budget is small. Cheap salads are really not great and nor can they sit around.

Natsku · 03/02/2024 09:59

Cleaning their own schools is good, teach them how to clean and keep places clean. At my DD's school each month different classes clean the surrounding area of the school (i.e. the playgrounds), and at the end of the school year an even bigger clean of the playgrounds is done by everyone.

Kendodd · 03/02/2024 09:54

Abergale · 03/02/2024 04:42

All the posters saying it’s not a nutritional meal without meat or their kid dislikes all veg or chucks half their dinner in bin anyway (presumably because they are full from high calorie processed crap snacks) like that’s normal.

being poor drives obesity in this country. Kids don’t need more calories they need more nutrition.

so I think your principal is great op but it would be undermined by parents and our general societies attitudes to food waste.

Sadly I think you're right. There's been loads of 'my kids don't eat that food' posters even dismissing salad a 'rabbit food'. These are the attitudes our children are growing up with. Bottom line, children eat crap food that makes them fat and unhealthy because adults give it to them. And from this thread plenty of adults are willing to lobby for their right to continue to feed children crap.

There's also definitely an undercurrent of I feed my children well and won't be paying to feed better any children whose parents don't feed them well.

Vegetarian, for all those objecting to this, multiple reasons for this. It's cheaper, it's healthy (I would also exclude UPF/meat substitutes) it would be easier, meet religious requirements, better for the planet. There's plenty of time for meat in the rest of the week and I'm sure even the most rampant meat eaters aren't going to argue children need meat at every meal for good health (considering 25% of the planet are vegetarian ).

For what it's worth, I'm not vegetarian myself and my own children are right at the end of their school career so this policy wouldn't benefit me or them. It would benefit others though. If lunchtime is too short, then it needs extending and if this means extending the school day, so be it. I also really like the Japanese idea of children cleaning their own schools.

OP posts:
determinedtomakethiswork · 03/02/2024 09:50

I heard a really interesting program on the radio about an experiment carried out in Sweden. They provided a free school lunch and the children could eat as much as they wanted - the food was very healthy and sugar-free and not beige.

They noticed two things: the children ate far more than they expected and the results of tests showed that their afternoon performance had greatly increased. They then did the same with breakfast and the test results showed morning performance massively increased.

They were then going to do an evening meal. However politicians said that if the children were having three big free meals a day, then benefits should be cut slightly to accommodate that. There was an uproar from the families and the whole scheme stopped.

Fluffycloudsfloatinginthesky · 03/02/2024 09:42

My daughter told me in her secondary school people complained there were no healthy options. They brought them in at lunch but now they are not selling and then canteen staff are complaining they are losing money on them!

rickyrickygrimes · 03/02/2024 09:41

@Needmorelego Some of them do, sure. And plenty will load up on pasta and skip the salad. And yes teens that can leave school will buy stuff to eat - but there are no chip shops, no Greggs, fast food chains are expensive here, no cheap chicken shops, afaik etc. There are plenty boulangerie selling sandwiches, but again they are expensive - €5-6 per sandwich. Ditto kebabs - which are probably the most popular fast food - it’s not cheap. Most teens either eat in the canteen, as it’s cheap and their parents pay, many come home (mine do) and eat something out the freezer or that I’ve left. DS often goes to a friends house and they cook as a group - they make attempts at chicken curry etc. Cheap takeaway food doesn’t really exist in the same way here, and portions are much much smaller. And they usually get a decent lunch break: DS 13 gets 1,5hrs, DS 16 gets anything btw 1hr to 2/3 hrs.

And it’s as much what isn’t made available that’s important and the lessons they are being taught about food. They are being taught all through primary and into secondary that snacking between meals isn’t necessary, that salad and veg are normal everyday foods to eat, that eating what is put in front of you is normal, that you don’t need juice with every meal. These lessons stick, they are reinforced at home and this produces a nation that eats its greens because that’s normal.

Natsku · 03/02/2024 09:36

Big differences.: no choice. There are no alternatives to the above. No sandwiches / rolls / crisps / sweets / muffins / etc. No baked potato bar, etc. No morning ‘snack bar’ (bacon rolls at school - really ?) in fact no morning snack. They start school at 8am and don’t eat lunch until 12 and somehow they survive. Nothing to drink in school other than water - no fizzy juice, no vending machines, no fruit juice, just water. Chips or a pizza slice might be served once per term. Burgers? Never. No packed lunches.

That's what makes it work in Finland too, there's no menu options, no unhealthy snacks (in lower years they can take in a small snack for the afternoon though if they have a longer day, like a sandwich or some fruit), everyone eats the same (special diets aside, in which case they get the closest possible version according to their dietary requirements, though when its blood sausage my coeliac DD gets normal sausage rather than GF blood sausage for some reason, maybe cost). In 6 and a half years of school she has never had chips or pizza there, it just doesn't happen. And its the same in nursery too (in my town literally the same as the same kitchen provides the school and the nursery lunches) so children get used to it from a young age which must help a lot with fussiness.
Teenagers don't get supervised at lunchtime though and some will skip lunch and go to the shop to buy junk food, but there's always going to be some amount of teenagers like that no matter what system (although my town is drawing up new school plans at the moment and one of the options they are considering is moving the school to a different area and one of the pros they give for that choice is that the teenagers won't be able to go to the shop at break time!)

Wasbedeudetetdas · 03/02/2024 09:07

Abergale · 03/02/2024 09:01

And I never mentioned vegetarian substitutes. Although they are often less full of fat and salt than their meat counterparts it wouldn’t really normalise getting nutrition from non meat sources or be much cheaper than meat which defeats the point for this exercise.

If you think they don’t need meat to be healthy why so insistent it should be a choice nearly every day? Should we make sure bread is to?

I didn't say you did mention meat substitutes - I was clarifying my stance, seeing as you decided to invent my opinion for me on your previous comment. As it is, many of the substitutes are bland processed mush - I've tried lots of them, while I was a vegetarian and as a meat eater. Actual vegetables are so much tastier.
Do you understand the meaning of the word choice? If you do then you'll understand why there should be a choice to eat foods people actually enjoy eating. Lots of people eat meat and fish, and it's perfectly healthy to include it in a balanced diet. Nobody will be forced to eat it though - they can choose the veggie option on any day.

Abergale · 03/02/2024 09:01

Wasbedeudetetdas · 03/02/2024 08:48

I didn't say healthy vegetarians don't exist.
I didn't suggest high meat consumption.
I didn't suggest the lunch would/should contain all the nutritional requirements.
Ideally it would be two healthy choices 4/5 days - one with meat or fish and one without, plus 1/5 meat free day with two veggie options.
Veggie options shouldn't routinely be those awful bland meat substitutes, but actual vegetables, pulses etc.
I didn't suggest continuing any status quo.
I didn't mention breakfast clubs.

And I never mentioned vegetarian substitutes. Although they are often less full of fat and salt than their meat counterparts it wouldn’t really normalise getting nutrition from non meat sources or be much cheaper than meat which defeats the point for this exercise.

If you think they don’t need meat to be healthy why so insistent it should be a choice nearly every day? Should we make sure bread is to?