Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naming convicted killers - Brianna

355 replies

Noangelbuthavingfun · 02/02/2024 07:39

...Ghey case. In favour of or against as it impacts their rehabilitation? I'm in favour of it - if you've committed a heinous crime you sign away all your rights to be protected in my opinion - what comes your way and being ousted is part of your lot.... I'm not talking about self defence type, rather premeditated and horribly evil crimes. But I think this should be a consistent theme and not just when some judges decide to....at the momentvits not consistent practice.
Aibu to think it's right to name and shame?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
MarkWithaC · 02/02/2024 16:39

WhyAmINotCleaning · 02/02/2024 16:34

This thread is galling. Mumsnet has been instrumental in whipping up ttans hatred. Too late now.

Nice try.

WhyAmINotCleaning · 02/02/2024 16:34

This thread is galling. Mumsnet has been instrumental in whipping up ttans hatred. Too late now.

Fluffywhitecloudsinthesky · 02/02/2024 16:31

@Halfmanhalfcake I agree. Plenty of teens are very badly behaved, out of control, need serious psychiatric intervention, have been violent or harmed family members- but it is incredibly hard to get anyone to act, or listen. We have these threads on here quite frequently of parents who are in despair.

Plenty of teens watch True Crime, even I watch stuff about serial killers Everyone is fascinated by it, judging about the amount of YouTube and Netflix content on it, and so having books/watching serial killer material isn't enough in its own right to act- and what act could they take.

I always remember the killing in Plymouth of that big guy who went on the rampage and killed his own mum before killing random people in the street. She had phoned the police several times herself saying he's lost touch with reality, he has a gun, he is a danger to everyone. So it turned out. What more could she have done? Everyone just wrote down what she said, and she paid the ultimate price knowing she had an out of control son.

Some of the cod psychology on here is terrible. Yes, if you have trauma/child abuse, this might make you more vulnerable to problems later on, but plenty with both go on to live normal upstanding lives and parent well. Equally, there are children who just go 'wrong' for unclear reasons, there are lovely parents with children with personality disorders or psychopathy and that is not always their fault.

SinnerBoy · 02/02/2024 16:27

Iwasafool · Today 16:08

It's hard to understand the mentality of people who'd do that to kids who have done nothing wrong. Says something about them.

Well quite, as we all know, there's never been a shortage of idiots and arseholes. Some of the attitudes on this thread, to the effect, "Tough shit on the families, the murderer should have thought of that," are rather depressing.

Halfmanhalfcake · 02/02/2024 16:22

Genuine question, for those saying they blame Jenkinsons parents, what could they honestly do? You see countless threads on here from people begging for help from GPs, Cahms etc to no avail. By all accounts she came from a perfectly loving family.

Should they have locked her up? Taken her to the police? (Who’d presumably said there was no evidence of her having done anything so wouldn’t be able to help).

Honestly interested to know.

TheMarzipanDildo · 02/02/2024 16:21

Lilacshade · 02/02/2024 14:23

There is an argument for deliberately not naming killers in order to deny them fame and notoriety.

I think this might be relevant in this case. The girl at least was serial killer obsessed.

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 02/02/2024 16:20

@Andthereyougo

I find it Interesting how you just asked that question about the girl.... and not the boy

Iwasafool · 02/02/2024 16:13

Andthereyougo · 02/02/2024 15:55

Not long enough imo.

Serious question , does anyone know if say the girl is released in her 30s, given new identity and then gets pregnant would there be any additional checks? Would SS know she had a child or is it you’ve done your time, off you pop? (I’m assuming even with a new identity employment would be difficult, no working with children) is that right?

Mary Bell had a daughter after she was released and was bringing her up. That was reported when her identity was revealed and she had to tell her daughter why they were being moved and having new identities. That must be a difficult conversation.

Iwasafool · 02/02/2024 16:08

SinnerBoy · 02/02/2024 08:00

Yes, I see that. At high school, there were 3 brothers and sisters whose dad murdered someone. They ended up leaving the area, because of the abuse and bullying they got, despite them being entirely innocent.

It's hard to understand the mentality of people who'd do that to kids who have done nothing wrong. Says something about them.

JudgeJ · 02/02/2024 16:07

Pigeonqueen · 02/02/2024 08:55

It makes no difference to their rehabilitation to be honest either way. If they decide to release them and give them new identities they’ll never be found - Robert Thompson in the James Bulger case is a good example of this.

More waste of public money, protecting killers.

SoundTheSirens · 02/02/2024 16:04

Andthereyougo · 02/02/2024 15:55

Not long enough imo.

Serious question , does anyone know if say the girl is released in her 30s, given new identity and then gets pregnant would there be any additional checks? Would SS know she had a child or is it you’ve done your time, off you pop? (I’m assuming even with a new identity employment would be difficult, no working with children) is that right?

If she were ever granted parole, she would be on licence for the rest of her life and subject to licence conditions, one of which will be to remain in contact with her supervising probation officer. Conditions can vary from ex-prisoner to ex-prisoner but that is a standard licence condition.

Posted too soon, so ETA: if her probation officer believed any future child to be at risk, they would involve SS.

BestBadger · 02/02/2024 16:02

Swizzlersandtwizzlers · 02/02/2024 14:51

This last line, exactly. If any siblings involved I do feel sorry for them, but not the parents.

I read a fair bit of true crime and studied criminology in uni. I also had to work with children and teens with behavioural issues. Vast majority of the time their family has a major hand in it.

One kid I worked with used to routinely threaten staff in quite a sinister way, and the mum was basically like oh why is my son so horrid.

I had read their case files and the mum had let a series of boyfriends physically abuse him. She protected the other kids but not him. And she wondered why he had such rage inside of him?

There are exceptions but I don’t believe it’s the norm for these kind of teen killers to have parents who are blameless.

Wow

RhubarbGingerJam · 02/02/2024 15:58

But I think this should be a consistent theme and not just when some judges decide to....at the momentvits not consistent practice.

I think rather than blanket yes or no to naming giving guidelines to judges - who'll have seen all the evidence and seen all the reports and who are in the best place to judge potentially nuanced situations -is the best way.

Andthereyougo · 02/02/2024 15:55

Psychoticbreak · 02/02/2024 15:22

Scarlett: 22yrs minimum less remand time
Eddie: 20yrs minimum less remand time

Not long enough imo.

Serious question , does anyone know if say the girl is released in her 30s, given new identity and then gets pregnant would there be any additional checks? Would SS know she had a child or is it you’ve done your time, off you pop? (I’m assuming even with a new identity employment would be difficult, no working with children) is that right?

Tinkerbyebye · 02/02/2024 15:42

SoupDragon · 02/02/2024 07:51

I don't see what purpose it serves. Especially when they were 15. It punishes their family too for a start.

@SoupDragon

you can say the same for any trial from shoplifting to murder. And in this case the age is irrelevant, and they are now 16 hence being named as it should be

Briannas family have to live with the fact they will never see her again, theirs can visit them as they languish in jail. Why should Brianna’s family be known and talked about and their families not! That’s further punishment for Brianna’s family as the culprits families move on unknown if they are not named

its right to name them

DyslexicPoster · 02/02/2024 15:41

I don't think people like that can be rehabilitated. Do you really want them walking about age 40 something? Still fit healthy and mobile enough to kill more people they befriend? It's not like they be freed as oaps. People need to be protected not these skuz buckets

MarnieMarnie · 02/02/2024 15:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/02/2024 15:38

The wider public could always easily find out with a couple of clicks.

billycat321 · 02/02/2024 15:34

Everyone at their school must know who they are and therefore the identity of their families and where they live. That is where it matters. Irrelevant whether the wider public are told.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/02/2024 15:29

Are their parents in court now that they have been named I wonder?

Yes, reports say it was mostly family members in the public gallery, Brianna's and the two killers'.

PaulCostinRIP · 02/02/2024 15:23

It looks like the killers legal representation tried to push ADHD and anxiety as being mitigating factors.

Looks like the judge has seen through that little game -

www.facebook.com/share/v/eyRHeiNmPnzQUtBL/?mibextid=KsPBc6

Psychoticbreak · 02/02/2024 15:22

Scarlett: 22yrs minimum less remand time
Eddie: 20yrs minimum less remand time

SoundTheSirens · 02/02/2024 15:07

You can't rehabilitate these sorts of people and tbh why should we rehabilitate them?

Anyone who thinks like this should probably avoid ever shopping in Boots, Tesco, Timpson, Pret a Manger, the Co-op, Greggs...they and others all employ rehabilitated prisoners and yes, that sometimes includes murderers.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 02/02/2024 14:56

I don’t see what good it does. They’ll be behind bars and everyone who sees them day to day will already know.
The only ones who it will impact on day to day are their innocent family and former friends.
When they are eventually released they will be given new lives and their families will carry on living with everyone around them knowing.
I get that it’s an open secret where they are but it doesn’t give the families a chance to move and start again.

SammyScrounge · 02/02/2024 14:53

SoupDragon · 02/02/2024 07:51

I don't see what purpose it serves. Especially when they were 15. It punishes their family too for a start.

All local people will have known for ages the identity of the killers, their schoolmates, teachers,neighbours etc etc

Swipe left for the next trending thread