Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naming convicted killers - Brianna

355 replies

Noangelbuthavingfun · 02/02/2024 07:39

...Ghey case. In favour of or against as it impacts their rehabilitation? I'm in favour of it - if you've committed a heinous crime you sign away all your rights to be protected in my opinion - what comes your way and being ousted is part of your lot.... I'm not talking about self defence type, rather premeditated and horribly evil crimes. But I think this should be a consistent theme and not just when some judges decide to....at the momentvits not consistent practice.
Aibu to think it's right to name and shame?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
coffeeaddict77 · 02/02/2024 20:47

Charlize43 · 02/02/2024 19:46

Naming them may at least make them feel shame knowing that everyone will know what they've done including people who they hope to impress or want them to think well of them. Shame may lead to reflection and then remorse.

Anonymity almost feels like they are getting away with it... 'That boy that I really fancied and tried to impress will never know that I'm really a monster capable of committing such horrific acts'

I very much doubt they feel shame.

SerafinasGoose · 02/02/2024 20:35

Iwasafool · 02/02/2024 16:44

Terrible isn't it. I can't imagine how horrific it must be to see your child arrested for murder and then sit in court listening to what they've done and then see them sentenced to decades in prison. I suppose the only thing that would be worse would be your child being the victim. I think the families have all suffered, all 3. One family will get sympathy and support and quite right too, the other families will be vilified and probably terrified by threats.

The families are secondary victims in all this. It must be devastating for them and allegedly Jenkinson's family have already been subject to death threats. Justice Yip made specific reference to the fact that she'd deferred naming the defendants until sentencing to allow all involved more time to adjust to the situation. She did, however, point out that harm to the families was not a factor she was able to take into consideration inline with the law.

As for Ratcliffe's father making his own column inches elsewhere, it does beg the question of what kind of home his son came from and what might possibly have turned him into the youth capable of doing what he did. The mother must be in a terrible place right now, and I do really feel for her.

For Brianna's mother to beg for restraint and compassion for those families, having sat through four weeks of the harrowing detail of what happened to her own daughter, speaks volumes about her dignity, strength and grace of character. She has to be an incredible woman.

Nottodaythankyou123 · 02/02/2024 20:35

girlfriend44 · 02/02/2024 17:22

It's not just being on your phone though is it?
It's what she's viewing on there. It's also about her notebook left long around and her previous expulsión

There's no discipline today either. Mother should have given up work or the father when she was expelled.
Why should another school take her on.
Look after your own child if they can't behave at school.
She didn't give a shit about upsetting her parents either.
Remember when you'd be scared to step Out of line, frightened and embarrassed at what your parents would think.
That has long gone. Children like this have not a care even for their own parents. No doubt she shall be expecting their support in her prison though.
Why didn't she want to make her parents proud of her? She ruined everyone's lives and all for what?

If she wanted to know what it was like to stab someone Why not try herself.

Ah yes, because there weren’t any murders back in your day when everyone was perfectly disciplined?
Or, just maybe, the prevalence of 24/7 rolling news and social media nowadays just means you hear about it far more than you used to. Children “like this” have always existed, you just may not have been as aware of it.

Notalldogs23 · 02/02/2024 20:30

They are legally children so I don't believe they should have been named until they are adults, if then.

What they did was appalling but blaming and hounding their families won't change what happened.

wildernesssw · 02/02/2024 20:20

Children are protected from the consequences of their actions for a reason - they are children and we recognise they are not fully responsible for what they do. It is the fact that they are children that makes them notorious, there are adults who have committed crimes just as horrendous but who have not got the publicity that this crime has. So, even though there are no reporting restrictions, they are more or less anonymous because the press hasn't latched on to them.

What value does naming them have, apart from selling news for 24/48 hours?

When they are released they will be given new identities.

Tigger1895 · 02/02/2024 20:20

I’m finding it difficult to understand why people are harping on about the families of the perpetrators. Anyone local will know who they are, so it’s not very outing and I’m sure they have already received abuse

Redpaisley · 02/02/2024 20:07

SoupDragon · 02/02/2024 07:51

I don't see what purpose it serves. Especially when they were 15. It punishes their family too for a start.

They are not normal kids. Plus families may or may not a role especially on case of Scarlett, the sadist girl, who was transferred from another school 4 months ago for giving a 13 year old.cannibis and then trying to poison Briana 2 weeks ago before actually killing her, not to mention creating a detailed plan of killing her on a piece of paper.
Id the parents didnt notice anything wrong woth their 15 year old, then they have failed the family of murdered kid too.

Op, I am in favour.

Ilikedoughnuts · 02/02/2024 20:04

Their identities have been know and all over social media since the murder so on one side I don't see an issue with it but on the other side I believe they deserve anonymity.
Then again, if they're ever let out they'll be given new identities anyway so it kinda seems irrelevant

Boke · 02/02/2024 19:58

youspinmerightround22 · 02/02/2024 17:56

His father was arrested in November and detained on suspicion of making indecent images and indecent exposure. He's in Manchester Crown Court on 23rd February.

Yes, sure, they come from decent upstanding families with nothing out of the ordinary to see...

Boke · 02/02/2024 19:57

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 02/02/2024 17:38

They had a list of other kids?? Where did you read that?

It was reported on extensively throughout the trial.

Boke · 02/02/2024 19:55

Ramalangadingdong · 02/02/2024 19:10

I think we do have to own responsibility for trans hatred. The conversation around trans is so toxic these days. This is a wake up call for all of us to watch what we say and more importantly how we say it.

Who is the we you're referring to?

SerafinasGoose · 02/02/2024 19:54

There's an interesting podcast by Sky on Amazon Prime that approaches this question, called 'Should children who kill be named?' It features lawyers clarifying the law plus a journalist who was in court throughout the trial in the Bulger case.

The law is clear that naming minors at the point of conviction isn't a question of retribution, but of whether public interest in particular cases outweighs the wellbeing of the defendants. Justice Yip decided that on this occasion it does, but has made decisions in other cases not to name the defendants.

The anonymity of Jenkinson and Ratcliffe lapses in 2025 in any event, which would only have stirred up interest again once the dust has settled on the case. The level of public interest wouldn't determine the outcome, but the benefit to the public in discussing and learning from the situation, would. It seems it's on this basis that the decision was made.

Anonymity is incredibly hard these days in any event: their names have been all over the internet for months. Brianna Ghey's father, interestingly enough, appeared on the podcast saying that he was against naming them. Initially he had been for it, but as things played out he changed his mind, saying he doesn't want the identities of his daughters' murderers forever connected with her name. In some sense he felt that would be giving them the last word, whereas it would be preferable in his eyes for them to be locked away and forgotten about.

Boke · 02/02/2024 19:54

peakygold · 02/02/2024 19:24

Did you see their mugshots? Proper wrong'uns.

What is it in particular about their faces that makes them stand out to you as criminal?

Charlize43 · 02/02/2024 19:46

Naming them may at least make them feel shame knowing that everyone will know what they've done including people who they hope to impress or want them to think well of them. Shame may lead to reflection and then remorse.

Anonymity almost feels like they are getting away with it... 'That boy that I really fancied and tried to impress will never know that I'm really a monster capable of committing such horrific acts'

GotMooMilk · 02/02/2024 19:43

It’s dreadful. Obviously for Brianna and her family- she’s one of the ‘victims’ I think you really get a sense of her personality and what she’s like which is so sad. And obviously for the families of the killers- more so the boy who I don’t get the impression would have done it if he wasn’t encouraged by the girl. Horrible all round.

fleurneige · 02/02/2024 19:40

Can't stop thinking how children become evil like this?

And how aware the parents were of their violent nature and thinking?

coffeeaddict77 · 02/02/2024 19:34

Blinky21 · 02/02/2024 19:24

Having worked with young offenders, I'm against it. It serves no one. It makes it more difficult for them to be purposeful members of society should they ever be released and it punishes their families. Why spend taxpayers money giving them new identities should they be released?
Naming is only to fulfill the salacious appetite of the press, who are the ones who petition for it. I know this having also worked in news.

People will know who they are anyway. I'm sure it was all over social media and I think people will notice that they have disappeared from the area so would have put two and two together.
Plus these young offenders are clearly evil psychopaths who can't become useful members of society.

Mariposistaaa · 02/02/2024 19:31

They are scum. RIP Breanna

Flickersy · 02/02/2024 19:26

peakygold · 02/02/2024 19:24

Did you see their mugshots? Proper wrong'uns.

They look like regular ordinary teenagers (sans makeup).

The idea that particular facial features indicate criminality has been regarded as hokum for decades.

peakygold · 02/02/2024 19:24

Did you see their mugshots? Proper wrong'uns.

Blinky21 · 02/02/2024 19:24

Having worked with young offenders, I'm against it. It serves no one. It makes it more difficult for them to be purposeful members of society should they ever be released and it punishes their families. Why spend taxpayers money giving them new identities should they be released?
Naming is only to fulfill the salacious appetite of the press, who are the ones who petition for it. I know this having also worked in news.

Grandmasswag · 02/02/2024 19:21

It’s weird to think they may be released at the age of 35. That’s still very young and enough time to live a quite a full life. Assume they will be given new identities, so does it matter if we know their names or not? Awful for their families too.

Bananasatchristmas · 02/02/2024 19:21

Halfmanhalfcake · 02/02/2024 16:22

Genuine question, for those saying they blame Jenkinsons parents, what could they honestly do? You see countless threads on here from people begging for help from GPs, Cahms etc to no avail. By all accounts she came from a perfectly loving family.

Should they have locked her up? Taken her to the police? (Who’d presumably said there was no evidence of her having done anything so wouldn’t be able to help).

Honestly interested to know.

Completely agree. This site is flooded with the above. I can’t speak for the Jenkinson parents but my god, we just do our best and are at the mercy of the system. Honestly interested to know what would have been done. I can’t imagine they thought, no matter how troubled their girl was, it would lead to this.

PiggieWig · 02/02/2024 19:21

I saw an interview with the head teacher of the school where Brianna and the girl went. She was saying now the anonymity order has been lifted they are able to have much more open conversations with the pupils and wider community, offering reassurance, answering questions etc.

That has to be a good thing. These types of crimes affect whole communities.

Swipe left for the next trending thread