Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naming convicted killers - Brianna

355 replies

Noangelbuthavingfun · 02/02/2024 07:39

...Ghey case. In favour of or against as it impacts their rehabilitation? I'm in favour of it - if you've committed a heinous crime you sign away all your rights to be protected in my opinion - what comes your way and being ousted is part of your lot.... I'm not talking about self defence type, rather premeditated and horribly evil crimes. But I think this should be a consistent theme and not just when some judges decide to....at the momentvits not consistent practice.
Aibu to think it's right to name and shame?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Winter3000 · 03/02/2024 06:18

Flickersy · 02/02/2024 10:17

The public are entitled to know the whole story.

No we're really not.

What you mean is the public are nosy bastards and think they're entitled to the full story, which they'll claim some noble motivation for but what they really want is someone to throw proverbial rotten fruit at target their anger at.

Oh give over.

There's always one.

LuckyMum1989 · 03/02/2024 00:38

I have to admit, I find it challenging when people are named and shamed when being charged BEFORE going to trial and a verdict being reached.
The "what if they're innocent?" Vs "what it they're not?" tension is very hard to grapple with... if no evidence has heen heard yet etc.
People's lives can be ruined once their name is out there and it feels like "innocent until proven guilty" is a myth. But then.... it can take such a long time to a trial, you don't want to leave other people vulnerable and unaware either. What if they're guilty?
The problem is if charges are dropped the damage is already done and the media are not as prepared to clear someone's name as they are to drag it through the mud.
But in my opinion, once found guilty, it is a natural consequence - losing your right to anonymity.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 02/02/2024 23:02

i have read a few news reports online about the teenagers, that seem to make a big issue of diagnosis of ADHD and ASD. Along with the comments quoted I find this very worrying.... seeming to suggest in an obtuse way that teenagers with MH issues or are neurodiverse are somehow dangerous.
This kind of reporting and attitude cam only cause more stigmatisation, exclusion and bullying towards children and teenagers who are neurodiverse or are suffering with their MH.

Great point @Goinggreymammy There is another thread on here about the parents of these kids with lots of people blaming them for what their kids did. Both that and suggesting there must be MH or ASD issues are ways for people to distance themselves from terrible events and tell themselves it would never happen to them. But both are really wrong in my opinion and experience. And do a massive disservice to the vast majority of people with MH or ASD conditions.

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 02/02/2024 22:53

@PaperWalkAndTalk it's well known prisoners enjoy watching themselves is it??? How would you know that? Suppose you just made it up to suit your narrative

Goinggreymammy · 02/02/2024 22:53

Flickersy · 02/02/2024 11:36

Not PP, but do you really think sane, healthy, well-adjusted people just decide to murder someone for shits and giggles? If so it's remarkable how little murder there is.

I havent read the whole thread but i have read a few news reports online about the teenagers, that seem to make a big issue of diagnosis of ADHD and ASD. Along with the comments quoted I find this very worrying.... seeming to suggest in an obtuse way that teenagers with MH issues or are neurodiverse are somehow dangerous.
This kind of reporting and attitude cam only cause more stigmatisation, exclusion and bullying towards children and teenagers who are neurodiverse or are suffering with their MH.

easylikeasundaymorn · 02/02/2024 22:46

Fooshufflewickjbannanapants · 02/02/2024 07:48

It literally takes two seconds to google their names. If the judge names them they aren't losing their anonymity. It doesn't exist in this day and age

It's very easy to find their names NOW via social media etc. but in 10, 20 years a lot of that would be deleted, or just overwhelmed by the huge amount of new stuff created daily. So the argument is more that at the time they come to be released, if the names (and, as a result, photos) hadn't been published they would be buried maybe 30 pages back in google on an archived x thread, whereas now they will likely be the top search for the rest of their lives.

I'm against because if released they will almost definitely be given new names anyway, whereas their families, including innocent siblings etc. will be linked to them for the rest of their lives.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 02/02/2024 22:40

@PastIsAnotherCountry that is a scary link. Some I remember, some I dont. Which in itself feels shocking. And that does not include perpetrators of recent stabbings.

Redvelvet84 · 02/02/2024 22:38

James Bulger's killers were named but the annoying thing is they were so young at the time that you wouldn't have recognized them when they were released probably. That's the downside , I wish they had been older and so they would have been recognisable to everyone when they got out and their lives would have been hell, rightly so.

PaperWalkAndTalk · 02/02/2024 22:37

Boke · 02/02/2024 22:29

What do you mean there would have been? Do you mean there will be?

Real life crime is regularly dramatised now.

So my point is that by the time the poster claims that they'd be forgotten about, there would likely to have been a dramatisation of it and more notoriety and fame garnered from that.

It's well known that prisoners enjoy watching the dramatisations of themselves on TV whilst in prison.

I'm sure there's probably a TV writer already coming up with the script.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 02/02/2024 22:36

The killers are in jail, by the time they are released they may not be at the top of peoples consciousness any more and may well be given new identities. The people who will suffer now are the people who share their names, and may well have to move or change names.

Peanutpeanutbutterandjelly · 02/02/2024 22:33

@MoonWoman69 modern science absolutely does not allow cases do be proved 100% most of the time. Often they give an indication or a very clear probability that someone is linked to a crime scene. They are not definitive proof. Add in contamination, human error etc. On top of that, 'expert witnesses' in trials are often utterly dubious - this is a problem which is only just coming to light but it's not getting a lot of public attention.

Look even at the 'shaken baby' cases. Experts were so, so sure of themselves. Citing scientific statistics which seemed to prove people must be guilty. It was all later disproven science. This stuff happens a lot, in all manner of cases

Mamabear2424 · 02/02/2024 22:32

in favour name and shame

GirlMum40 · 02/02/2024 22:31

I am unsure how I feel about naming them.

I'm not sure what is to be gained when they are locked away for 20 years, other than the other inmates knowing. And if they ever get out they'll have new identities anyway.

The families lives will be ruined by it. While I don't hold as much sympathy for them as I do Brianna's family, obviously, I do feel for them.

There have been numerous debates on MN regarding checking teens/kids phones and messages and on reading our kids diaries etc. I admit I DO check my kids rooms and phones... (Eek) the threads on here have all mostly been "I wouldn't dare invade my kids privacy" type views. Ive felt like a bad parent at times .. now people are kind of suggesting parents SHOULD have been "snooping" and known their daughter was watching stuff, messaging, writing notes etc.... maybe they had an idea... But nobody can possibly seriously accurately predict their baby will grow up to be a cold blooded murderer and somehow step in and stop that.

Boke · 02/02/2024 22:29

PaperWalkAndTalk · 02/02/2024 22:24

In 10 years' time there would've been a BBC drama about them and their crime.

What do you mean there would have been? Do you mean there will be?

PaperWalkAndTalk · 02/02/2024 22:24

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 02/02/2024 14:28

There is rarely any fame or notoriety with 'killers' ... there's too many of them to remember... and in ten years or so if they are due to be released, most won't remember their names anyway.

In 10 years' time there would've been a BBC drama about them and their crime.

PastIsAnotherCountry · 02/02/2024 22:15

girlfriend44 · 02/02/2024 22:00

Apart from Mary Bell.there were no major crimes of children killing children like there are today.

Social Media, children being given phones to use as they wish, lack of parental control and discipline are at rock bottom.
It just gets worse and worse.
There isn't a week goes by without a stabbing happening either.

Shows how bad the discipline is now. They were allowed to sit and doodle, and read puzzle books during sentencing, not told to sit and straight and listen.
How much lower can we go? No respect no discipline.

Do you remember when parents wanted their kids to have a phone so they could phone them on the way to school etc and make sure they were safe etc. Perhaps a little payg phone.
Now parents have to buy phones that are capable of watching anything on the Internet, and they take no interest in what's going on even though they are paying for it?
Remember when they advised the family computer to be in the downstairs room so parents could at least be aware and be in the same room?
What happened to that?

Nowdays kids are in their rooms doing exactly what they want and viewing anything they want and messaging everybody while no doubt demanding the latest I phone etc.
It's dreadful. So glad I was born when I was.
You really have to ask should there be an age limit on a phone and all that it can access?
The mobile phone companies couldn't give a shit only interested in making money.

There have been more than I realised.

https://www.crimeandinvestigation.co.uk/articles/uks-scariest-underage-killers

International list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_youngest_killers

And plausibly a few "deaths by misadventure" while playing with friends etc. weren't. And, tbh, in some countries with readier access to weapons, some 'accidental discharges' might not have been.

The UK's scariest killer children

Cases of children and teenagers who murder are shocking and terrible, but unfortunately they do happen.

https://www.crimeandinvestigation.co.uk/articles/uks-scariest-underage-killers

MILTOBE · 02/02/2024 22:01

NotQuiteNorma · 02/02/2024 12:42

If they murdered your child, would you not want to know who they were?

That's ridiculous; of course Brianna's parents knew who the killers were - they were in court.

girlfriend44 · 02/02/2024 22:00

Nottodaythankyou123 · 02/02/2024 20:35

Ah yes, because there weren’t any murders back in your day when everyone was perfectly disciplined?
Or, just maybe, the prevalence of 24/7 rolling news and social media nowadays just means you hear about it far more than you used to. Children “like this” have always existed, you just may not have been as aware of it.

Apart from Mary Bell.there were no major crimes of children killing children like there are today.

Social Media, children being given phones to use as they wish, lack of parental control and discipline are at rock bottom.
It just gets worse and worse.
There isn't a week goes by without a stabbing happening either.

Shows how bad the discipline is now. They were allowed to sit and doodle, and read puzzle books during sentencing, not told to sit and straight and listen.
How much lower can we go? No respect no discipline.

Do you remember when parents wanted their kids to have a phone so they could phone them on the way to school etc and make sure they were safe etc. Perhaps a little payg phone.
Now parents have to buy phones that are capable of watching anything on the Internet, and they take no interest in what's going on even though they are paying for it?
Remember when they advised the family computer to be in the downstairs room so parents could at least be aware and be in the same room?
What happened to that?

Nowdays kids are in their rooms doing exactly what they want and viewing anything they want and messaging everybody while no doubt demanding the latest I phone etc.
It's dreadful. So glad I was born when I was.
You really have to ask should there be an age limit on a phone and all that it can access?
The mobile phone companies couldn't give a shit only interested in making money.

MoonWoman69 · 02/02/2024 21:57

I 100% agree with the death penalty. Many many years ago, there were a couple of people wrongly hanged for crimes they didn't commit, which was absolutely tragic.
But in this day and age, when we have the ability of pinpoint DNA profiling and can prove guilt beyond a shadow of a doubt, then to me, it should be a life for a life. No question. And all the people that bang on about "human rights"? Where were the victims human rights? Why should we have prisons full of murderers, some of whom cannot be released because they will remain a danger to the public? Prison isn't prison, it's a cushy number! It's basically full of prisoners sticking two fingers up at everyone on the outside! Three square meals a day, don't have to do anything you don't want to and that includes any kinds of therapy, believe it or not! Having worked with offenders, I know this to be true and a lot of them are smug about it.
Prisons are under run and overcrowded, this would solve a lot of problems all round, however unpopular an opinion it is. I bet that potential murderers would think twice about killing people if they had the threat of their own death as a consequence of being caught. There is absolutely no deterrent to committing crime in this country, we need something.

Isitautumnyet23 · 02/02/2024 21:41

notthatthis · 02/02/2024 13:28

I Respect your opinion. Mine is to keep them locked up forever. You can't rehabilitate a psycho.

Agree - neither should ever be released no matter how much it is claimed the are fully rehabilitated in 20/30+ years time. They are psychopaths and in my view will never be safe being released. It would be an incredibly dangerous decision to let these animals wander free in their 30’s or 40’s.

The country needs a vote on the death penalty and I would support that for these two. They cannot be viewed the same way that we view normal 16 year olds (despite what the laws say). They are just a few years older than my kids and I have no hesitation in saying that they don’t deserve to live for what they have done.

Lastofsummer · 02/02/2024 21:17

Ramalangadingdong · 02/02/2024 19:10

I think we do have to own responsibility for trans hatred. The conversation around trans is so toxic these days. This is a wake up call for all of us to watch what we say and more importantly how we say it.

Possibly the most sensible thing I've read on mn lately. No child is born transphobic, it's learned behaviour.

MoonWoman69 · 02/02/2024 21:04

Poor Brianna was killed by these two hideous creatures, name and shame I say, regardless of age. You commit murder, you waive the right to anonymity in my view.

FMLWTF · 02/02/2024 21:01

It doesn’t seem to matter to me. Anyone who knows them, knows what they’ve done. I doubt the names came as a surprise to any of their friends/families/aquaintances. Anyone who doesn’t know them, well, you still don’t.

threeisquiteenough · 02/02/2024 20:50

Couldn't care less about the individuals who commit murder, but I very much feel for their relatives.

Not this specific case, but if they had children etc. The stigma that would be attached. It is really not fair that the innocent family members suffer.

coffeeaddict77 · 02/02/2024 20:50

fleurneige · 02/02/2024 19:40

Can't stop thinking how children become evil like this?

And how aware the parents were of their violent nature and thinking?

Some people are born as psychopaths. It's not always anything to do with their background.