Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed that those on UC have more disposable income

461 replies

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:07

Myself and DH both work full time and have one child in nursery that we are paying for. We have a household income of just under £100k. After taxes, mortgage, student loan, NI, pension deductions and bills we are not actually left with a huge amount of disposable income. We are in the south east.

Brother in law and his partner have just had their first baby and announced that SIL will not be returning to work for at least 3 years. BIL earns roughly £30k and they live in social housing (lucky them). They will get around £900 a month in UC + no childcare bill.

So whilst we are running around like headless chickens trying to keep on top of things and juggle professional jobs, house renovations and parenting. My SIL will have the pleasure of sitting at home with no stress enjoying her baby. (SIL is known to be very lazy and also took the whole of her pregnancy off sick due to anxiety.)

At this point I just feel so deflated, and am wondering what the point is of working hard and being self sufficient. Funny thing is in laws think we are the lucky ones, when I don't actually think we are here. The system needs to change as there is no incentive to work.

OP posts:
Iwantmyoldnameback · 02/02/2024 09:45

Surely SIL won't be expected to look for work if she has anxiety issues?

Lougle · 02/02/2024 09:42

MorningSunshineSparkles · 02/02/2024 07:59

There is no chance in hell they’re getting £900 a month in universal credits unless one of them is severely disabled. You might want to check your earning cap limits for benefits too. So fucking sick of the lies that are spread, OP is just another idiot trying to benefit bash. 10 mins googling would tell anyone what they needed to know.

If you had googled, or even read the full thread, you would have seen that they will be getting £900 on UC. It's because their rent is high.

AcridAndStanLee · 02/02/2024 09:41

DiamondsArentFood · 02/02/2024 08:24

Op is very bitter, but ultimately, if they can live and have spare income on 1/3rd your income, you're doing something wrong.. or you actually have spare income really... But you pay a lot of it to a pension or savings every month.

OP has childcare that SIL does not. I'll bet that's the difference. It really does add up.

DiamondsArentFood · 02/02/2024 09:39

Mambo19866 · 02/02/2024 09:31

Ffs just google it bt offer half price broadband 20 pound a month for those on benefits. Ask ovo about their social tier tariff it exists im still using it ffs.

Can you link to the OVO tariff?

I just.looked and the cheapest quote they offer is £147 a month, I currently.pay £69 with octopus.

TeaKitten · 02/02/2024 09:33

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 08:02

The day she found out she was pregnant was the day she got her sick note and didn't work for 9 months.

Not sure why you keep wanting to reconfirm that you think she’s lying. You still just sound jealous and unpleasant.

Sunshine322 · 02/02/2024 09:32

suspiriana · 02/02/2024 08:43

How is OP better off than SIL?

She might eventually have an "asset" but she will have paid huge amounts of money for it (from post-taxed income), will have to pay for her own housing renovations, maintenance etc. If she falls on hard times she will have to sell up and downsize (and pay £££ stamp duty again). If she loses her job and can't pay the mortgage she will have to sell up and downsize (and pay stamp duty). Benefits won't pay her mortgage, only possibly some mortgage interest so she would have to pay off the capital. She has no security of tenure (see points above). She doesn't get to live in central London and probably has a much smaller home than SIL in comparison to what she is paying in mortgage costs (which are really high since interest rates have increased).

In contrast, SIL has;

Massively subsidised housing in prime central London, a secure tenancy which means she doesn't have to worry about being evicted or not being able to pay the mortgage as if husband loses his job UC will continue to pay the rent and being evicted is as likely as being struck by lightning in social housing, all renovations done for free by the council (brand new kitchen every xx number of years), no care home fees in later life, no inheritance tax if house is worth over a certain amount as they don't own it, can pass on the tenancy as an inheritance with no inheritance tax to pay. They basically have the equivalent of a million pound home that is theirs for life with all the benefits of home ownership and none of the burdens.

The husband can also take a lower paid job as they don't have a mortgage to cover and still get topped up handsomely in benefits.

Seems to me that actually OP is completely correct and there is absolutely no incentive to better oneself. Sounds like SIL and BIL are actually the rich ones.

Sil and her husband are paying £1000 a month rent, possibly over a period of 40 years and that is a huge amount of ‘dead’ money. Im definitely not sold on the idea that sil is better off.

DiamondsArentFood · 02/02/2024 09:31

Wasbedeudetetdas · 02/02/2024 09:08

I hope you are getting all the help you are entitled to because that sounds like a lot of of 'normal' things you are going without - if you don't mind me asking, are you having to pay a lot extra on rent where you live? No worries if you think me nosey because I kind of am. I know the COL is hitting everyone, but it seems like you have shaver pretty much every cost right back, but your (limited) income must be going on something? I agree though that some folk have no idea how tight it is to be surviving on a benefit like UC, and to suggest someone on £100K is worse off than someone on UC is absolutely wild!

It goes on general living tbh.

I think some people think that UC is just for food and such, but it isn't, it includes rent.

If you take out the rental element, you're left with:

An adult over 25 gets £368.74
If they have a kid they get £315.00 (born before 6 April 2017)
£269.58 (born on or after 6 April 2017

That's not a lot for a single person and a child to live well.

Then if the housing element doesn't cover all the rent, they have to top it up and it leaves even less.

I can't imagine many people on MN wanting to change from earning £100k a household to having £369 + £315 = £684 a month to pay their bills.
I'd imagine that would barely cover 1/3rd some people's monthly expenditures. (I've seen some people say they spend £200+ on food a week)

Mambo19866 · 02/02/2024 09:31

CakedUpHigh · 02/02/2024 08:29

A couple of things:
NHS dentists are like gold dust so getting free care is almost impossible.
Council Tax benefit no longer covers the whole bill.
Energy companies don't offer cheap gas and electricity to benefit claimants, quite the opposite, they're often put on expensive pre-payment tariffs when they get behind with their bill!
They don't get half price broadband, compared like for like, it's about a 20% discount. If you don't live near a PDSA pet hospital you can't get free treatment for a pet.
Social housing rents are often now set at local housing allowance rates which is the maximum amount you can get in housing benefit for a PRIVATE rental. And the 'benefits' of having social housing set at market rate...? A 2 year tenancy in which you will have to supply your own carpets and large kitchen appliances! But this is irrelevant as social housing isn't available to most people on benefits now anyway.

So even the benefits of being on benefits don't really exist anymore!

Ffs just google it bt offer half price broadband 20 pound a month for those on benefits. Ask ovo about their social tier tariff it exists im still using it ffs.

Simonjt · 02/02/2024 09:21

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:55

Juggling:
Full time job x2. + working in evenings
Social commitments
Appointments
Workmen/quotes - people constantly coming in and out the house.
Child's play dates and weekend activities
Washing
Cleaning
Food shopping
Keeping on top of life admin - friends and relatives birthdays, baby showers, weddings etc.
bedtime routine

I literally don't have time to breathe from 7am until 23.00

Thats just normal life, I did it as a lone paret, breathing was certainly not an issue, neither was downtime.

Muddywalks34 · 02/02/2024 09:19

At some point in the future you will
have a house you own outright, you will be able to retire with good pensions and be living a much better more secure life than your SIL. Suck it up, worth hard and you will one day reap the rewards of that. Building a decent life for your family is of course going to be tough. I did it for years, coming upto 50 now, mortgage free, healthy pensions and early retirement is on the cards. Yes getting here was hard work but I certainly don’t envy any of my peers who took the easy route. I can’t imagine anything worse than retiring on a state pension in a house I don’t own, having nothing to pass down to my children when I go.

CattyMcTat · 02/02/2024 09:19

Comparison is the their of joy OP.

I guess the reality is that it doesn't matter how much money you have OP, you have an unhappy life. It doesn't matter how much more money you throw at it, you need to make actual changes.

Scale back on socialising if you are seeing it as a chore rather than downtime.

Why is everything left to you? Why isn't your husband helping out? If he is lazy get him to help out more or leave him.

Scale back on the play dates and clubs.

You've said you'd be happy living in a social housing property inherited from parents. So presumably you'd be happy living in a dated house decorated by a now deceased person ? So cancel the renovation.

funinthesun19 · 02/02/2024 09:13

Household income of 100k and you still don’t have more disposable income than someone on UC? I thought you were going to say you’re on a low income but earn just over the threshold for claiming UC.

Your post just takes the absolute piss out of low income households because you actually think you’re in the same boat, don’t you?

Trinity65 · 02/02/2024 09:08

Do We?

That's news to Me !!

Wasbedeudetetdas · 02/02/2024 09:08

DiamondsArentFood · 02/02/2024 09:01

How is OP better off than SIL?

As I said up thread, I'm on UC.

I don't use heating - can't afford it.
I don't have holidays - can't afford it.
I only eat once a day - main meal when DD is home.
I use as little electric as possible which often means I sit in one room without a TV or radio etc and use the phone battery - as I'm doing now.
I don't buy new clothes - can't afford them.
I don't have savings - can't afford them.
I don't have a pension - can't afford it.
I dont have a car - can't afford it.

But.. the worst thing about being on UC?
You're at the mercy of the government who may cut, sanction, punish you because they see it as a vote winner.
It appeals to fuckwits who think that people on "Welfare" are scrounging lazy entitled scum.

Mumsnet have a lot of threads bashing UC claimants, welfare claimants, benefit claimants.

How is OP better off than SIL?
They're households has an income that means they're earning more than 90% of the population, they're in the top 8% of earners according to the ONS.

Unless they're complete fools, they should have a VERY good quality of life. If they don't.. well, instead of criticising their SIL choices... They should start looking at their own.

I hope you are getting all the help you are entitled to because that sounds like a lot of of 'normal' things you are going without - if you don't mind me asking, are you having to pay a lot extra on rent where you live? No worries if you think me nosey because I kind of am. I know the COL is hitting everyone, but it seems like you have shaver pretty much every cost right back, but your (limited) income must be going on something? I agree though that some folk have no idea how tight it is to be surviving on a benefit like UC, and to suggest someone on £100K is worse off than someone on UC is absolutely wild!

Freakinfraser · 02/02/2024 09:06

DiamondsArentFood · 02/02/2024 09:01

How is OP better off than SIL?

As I said up thread, I'm on UC.

I don't use heating - can't afford it.
I don't have holidays - can't afford it.
I only eat once a day - main meal when DD is home.
I use as little electric as possible which often means I sit in one room without a TV or radio etc and use the phone battery - as I'm doing now.
I don't buy new clothes - can't afford them.
I don't have savings - can't afford them.
I don't have a pension - can't afford it.
I dont have a car - can't afford it.

But.. the worst thing about being on UC?
You're at the mercy of the government who may cut, sanction, punish you because they see it as a vote winner.
It appeals to fuckwits who think that people on "Welfare" are scrounging lazy entitled scum.

Mumsnet have a lot of threads bashing UC claimants, welfare claimants, benefit claimants.

How is OP better off than SIL?
They're households has an income that means they're earning more than 90% of the population, they're in the top 8% of earners according to the ONS.

Unless they're complete fools, they should have a VERY good quality of life. If they don't.. well, instead of criticising their SIL choices... They should start looking at their own.

Well said. I’m rather dismayed by the “life on benefits is golden” posters. “Way better than earning a hundred grand a year and working, owning your own home, having a private pension ” such nonsense.

I grew up in a council house on benefits and it’s shit. We were skint. No way round it, and now with the rule changes, a person who can work, choosing a life on benefits will be nearly impossible. And relying on state pension is no walk in the park either.

CakedUpHigh · 02/02/2024 09:03

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 02/02/2024 07:01

@Mambo19866 Fair enough, it's just not something I've ever heard of but then again, I've never owned a house so not had to look into it. Maybe it's changed over the years.

You can get a loan to help cover mortgage costs, they do not just pay them although they used to. Until fairly recently they used to cover the interest after 3 months of unemployment.

Freakinfraser · 02/02/2024 09:02

Hhhh80 · 02/02/2024 09:01

@nappyvalley2024 she won't be able to have 3 years off. They'll be changing the rules so parents have to look for work from the baby being 9 months because they're rolling out free childcare from 9 months. So they'll be on her case from the baby being less than a year old.

That’s true, the rules changed. And they will force her into community work if she doesn’t get a job or stop her benefits

DiamondsArentFood · 02/02/2024 09:01

How is OP better off than SIL?

As I said up thread, I'm on UC.

I don't use heating - can't afford it.
I don't have holidays - can't afford it.
I only eat once a day - main meal when DD is home.
I use as little electric as possible which often means I sit in one room without a TV or radio etc and use the phone battery - as I'm doing now.
I don't buy new clothes - can't afford them.
I don't have savings - can't afford them.
I don't have a pension - can't afford it.
I dont have a car - can't afford it.

But.. the worst thing about being on UC?
You're at the mercy of the government who may cut, sanction, punish you because they see it as a vote winner.
It appeals to fuckwits who think that people on "Welfare" are scrounging lazy entitled scum.

Mumsnet have a lot of threads bashing UC claimants, welfare claimants, benefit claimants.

How is OP better off than SIL?
They're households has an income that means they're earning more than 90% of the population, they're in the top 8% of earners according to the ONS.

Unless they're complete fools, they should have a VERY good quality of life. If they don't.. well, instead of criticising their SIL choices... They should start looking at their own.

Hhhh80 · 02/02/2024 09:01

@nappyvalley2024 she won't be able to have 3 years off. They'll be changing the rules so parents have to look for work from the baby being 9 months because they're rolling out free childcare from 9 months. So they'll be on her case from the baby being less than a year old.

forcedfun · 02/02/2024 09:00

suspiriana · 02/02/2024 08:54

She won't it will be paid by UC or housing benefit and she will get pension credit if she doesn't have enough credits for a pension.

I think it's complacent to make any assumptions about how state pensions will look in 20 plus years time, with an aging population

DonnaBanana · 02/02/2024 08:59

It sounds like the real problem is the other woman doesn’t have to work and OP does. If it’s that annoying to you, become a SAHM and get your man to step up!

Rosieposy89 · 02/02/2024 08:58

How do you not have disposable income? Our household income is about half yours and we have money left over. You have probably made choices that are above your means.

Beezknees · 02/02/2024 08:57

suspiriana · 02/02/2024 08:54

She won't it will be paid by UC or housing benefit and she will get pension credit if she doesn't have enough credits for a pension.

And a state pension is less than £200 a week. Yes, sounds great.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 02/02/2024 08:57

quisensoucie · 02/02/2024 08:50

I literally don't have time to breathe from 7am until 23.00

Oh my goodness @nappyvalley2024 - how awful for you; how does that work for cell respiration and all the other little things our bodies need oxygen for? how do you get rid of the carbon dioxide accumulation?

Excellent response.
I love when people use literally in completely the wrong way.
Some of the MN responses do suggest lack of oxygen to the brain though.

Freakinfraser · 02/02/2024 08:56

suspiriana · 02/02/2024 08:54

She won't it will be paid by UC or housing benefit and she will get pension credit if she doesn't have enough credits for a pension.

I feel really sad for you, you genuinely seem to think a life on benefits is something aspirational and cannot see how the ops costs will reduce over time and the benefit it will bring to their lives