Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed that those on UC have more disposable income

461 replies

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:07

Myself and DH both work full time and have one child in nursery that we are paying for. We have a household income of just under £100k. After taxes, mortgage, student loan, NI, pension deductions and bills we are not actually left with a huge amount of disposable income. We are in the south east.

Brother in law and his partner have just had their first baby and announced that SIL will not be returning to work for at least 3 years. BIL earns roughly £30k and they live in social housing (lucky them). They will get around £900 a month in UC + no childcare bill.

So whilst we are running around like headless chickens trying to keep on top of things and juggle professional jobs, house renovations and parenting. My SIL will have the pleasure of sitting at home with no stress enjoying her baby. (SIL is known to be very lazy and also took the whole of her pregnancy off sick due to anxiety.)

At this point I just feel so deflated, and am wondering what the point is of working hard and being self sufficient. Funny thing is in laws think we are the lucky ones, when I don't actually think we are here. The system needs to change as there is no incentive to work.

OP posts:
StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 02/02/2024 11:31

peakygold · 02/02/2024 11:24

How on earth can someone envy a low-income family in social housing?

I agree with your view of the OP but on a side note, what is wrong with social housing?

GasPanic · 02/02/2024 11:30

You will probably benefit more later in life.

As you get older your earnings will increase more rapidly than your BIL., and when your kids grow up and leave you will have a lot more disposable income.

Plus you will have all the equity you have built up in your house over that period (of course your BIL may gain equity with right to buy).

Anyway, you have Labour to look forward to. If they get in (looks likely) they are going to transfer more wealth from you to your BIL.

peakygold · 02/02/2024 11:24

How on earth can someone envy a low-income family in social housing?

SpeedyDrama · 02/02/2024 11:16

Moreorlessmentallystable · 02/02/2024 10:56

Your son is severely autistic so you need the benefit. Why do hate these threads?, do you not understand that the more people that do not need the benefits rip off the system, the less is there for you and those who really need it? For the particular case of the OP's SIL and BIL, why should they chose to have a low paid job and only one income AND live in an expensive area of London?. Frankly the benefits system is like an enabler to many, while the ones that really need it get the bare minimum and still feel guilty about it....

Who do you believe is ‘ripping off’ the system? In the OP’s sil case, her going to work before the child is 3 would only put the family in deeper financial woes. We are still living in a social/finacial system that is based on conservative family ideals (that it is better for one parent to be home during the early years) but with the modern expectation of both parents working. Of course families will chose the option that gives them better security overall.

And I can completely understand the place the poster you’re quoting is coming from, it’s all very well saying ‘oh but we don’t mean you’ when talking about limited financial/working situations, but most people on benefits are in this situation. Either genuinely unable to work (or more than a few hours), claim UC despite having FT work as top up or have realised their short term situation means that one wage and one stay at home parent is the only way not to sink finances.

And not everyone who needs the benefits system gets ‘the bare minimum’. Many (too many) do, but it’s not always the case. Of course, this isn’t a good thing - people like myself are 10x more screwed in the future than someone like the op who’s actually moaning about having a well set up life…

nothingcomestonothing · 02/02/2024 11:07

Moreorlessmentallystable · 02/02/2024 10:56

Your son is severely autistic so you need the benefit. Why do hate these threads?, do you not understand that the more people that do not need the benefits rip off the system, the less is there for you and those who really need it? For the particular case of the OP's SIL and BIL, why should they chose to have a low paid job and only one income AND live in an expensive area of London?. Frankly the benefits system is like an enabler to many, while the ones that really need it get the bare minimum and still feel guilty about it....

It's not for you (or the OP) to judge who is the deserving or undeserving poor. All you're judging this family on is what the (clearly biassed) OP has posted about their circumstances. The OPs SIL has mental health problems so severe she couldn't work. They have inherited a social housing tenancy, so presumably lost their parent(s). I doubt their life is enviable.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 02/02/2024 11:06

shewasrooting · 02/02/2024 08:03

oh man… you have actually dig around to find out this Op!!! you have way too much time on your hands

To be fair, I do this as part of my job and it takes about 3 minutes

Moreorlessmentallystable · 02/02/2024 10:56

Lwrenn · 02/02/2024 08:11

My partner is on NMW and I get £76 a week as a carer for our severely autistic son. Two of my 4 children are autistic.
We have a low mortgage because I bought my first property at 20 with a 100% mortgage before the crash and by the time I'd sold house prices in that area had rocketed. So I get no housing element to our UC.
We don't get a massive amount of UC but it has dramatically helped us. I dont get more in UC than I would returning to work and I also had a NMW job, but I'm incredibly grateful I'm able to be my sons carer. In all honesty his needs are so extreme that I'm often up and down the school, unlike mainstream school where they barely send a child home, sen schools have you collect regularly, especially for your child being distressed.

I hate these threads, I'd give my universal credit to the devil himself to rid my son of a condition that makes him navigating his life, independence and whole life so fucking tough for him. I'd work in a fucking Victorian workhouse 16 hours a day to have a child who's life wasn't going to be him struggling each day to just cope with the most basic of things.

But sorry I sometimes have a spare 100 quid at the end of the month to treat my children to a nice day or something.

Your son is severely autistic so you need the benefit. Why do hate these threads?, do you not understand that the more people that do not need the benefits rip off the system, the less is there for you and those who really need it? For the particular case of the OP's SIL and BIL, why should they chose to have a low paid job and only one income AND live in an expensive area of London?. Frankly the benefits system is like an enabler to many, while the ones that really need it get the bare minimum and still feel guilty about it....

Moreorlessmentallystable · 02/02/2024 10:44

29andLost · 02/02/2024 06:52

I get uc as me and DP earn about 24K combined. I would rather be in your position any day OP and the sad truth is, I probably never will be

But the real question is , you hat are you doing to be in that position one day?

whatkatydid2014 · 02/02/2024 10:42

we have a gross household income a little under £100k after pensions (split 50/50). There are a few other things deducted from our pay (health insurance, charity donations through a work scheme, professional fee & some training cost for a new qualification my OH is self funding). With that we get just shy of £6k a month. I assume you must have a similar income (possibly a bit less if you still have student loans/pension taken out &/or your income split is uneven but similar)

Their net income even with things like cost of living payments is going to be about £3k so you have something around £3k more than them available to you. It may also be there are some services they can access at reduced cost/free but there also may not. It’s not automatic that those on UC can all access everything regardless of what much of the press would have us believe. Right now that £3k could mainly be going on nursery fees. However it’s temporary and in a few years you’ll get most of it available to you again. Also you may well get some career advancement with pay increases and that will all make a big difference.

You may well end up no better off for a year or two but in the long run you’ll have a lot more disposable income and you’ll have more choices than someone depending on UC.

The general set up where you end up worse off by working more at various points (coming off UC, tax bands etc) is a fairly stupid system and I genuinely think there has to be a better way of managing it. You can’t get upset with individuals though. For all the self righteousness that’s regularly on display on mumsnet about benefit claimants or high earners dodging tax almost everyone will only want to work more if it benefits them. If you tapered off UC much more gradually and didn’t cliff edge various associated benefits I’d imagine a lot less people would be inclined to try and stick to working the minimum hours vs increasing them and being worse off overall. A sensible approach would surely be to taper UC off gradually enough that when you earn more your get a significant portion of the additional earnings as incremental net income. The way they do it currently effectively creates a ludicrous marginal tax rate on a slice of income and it’s a real barrier to getting people to work more

DiamondsArentFood · 02/02/2024 10:33

Freakinfraser · 02/02/2024 10:19

To be fair there are plenty of unskilled low income min wage jobs available more than people looking for work, and if you don’t work then you will have work given to you or your benefits stopped.

and more nurseries and child minders will open up to meet demand.

If more nurseries and such opened to meet demand... Why is there a waiting list at pretty much every nursery right now?

Just a summary glance around MN shows that there's limited places.

nothingcomestonothing · 02/02/2024 10:32

Freakinfraser · 02/02/2024 10:19

To be fair there are plenty of unskilled low income min wage jobs available more than people looking for work, and if you don’t work then you will have work given to you or your benefits stopped.

and more nurseries and child minders will open up to meet demand.

Plenty of unskilled low income jobs which fit in school hours and offer 12 weeks a year annual leave to cover school holidays? Can you link to three?

Nurseries and child minders are closing as the rate government pay for funded hours don't cover the costs of the childcare place.

It's not that simple.

Ελλe · 02/02/2024 10:25

I get where you are coming from and sometimes feel a bit like this myself - DH and I work really hard and have a teeny tiny house (we live in a stupid expensive area) while BIL and his girlfriend had five kids in quick succession, she’s never worked and they get a massive council house in a central location. A house we could only dream of the likes. It’s annoying but I would rather carry on knowing I was honest and hard working and my kids got those qualities.

I do however think describing someone with clearly terrible anxiety as lazy is a disgusting attitude and you perhaps need to educate yourself.

focus on yourselves - it’s not worth the energy

CakedUpHigh · 02/02/2024 10:20

Mambo19866 · 02/02/2024 09:31

Ffs just google it bt offer half price broadband 20 pound a month for those on benefits. Ask ovo about their social tier tariff it exists im still using it ffs.

Ffs if you can get broadband for £25 on the open market, £20 is a 20% discount, not half price. Who pays £40 for broadband?
I will admit I'm not with Ovo so I don't really know what they offer, but each company has their own scheme and they're often only available to those who are already behind with their bills. Many energy companies are still forcing expensive pre-payment meters on vulnerable customers, it's been extensively covered by the press ffs.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 02/02/2024 10:20

shewasrooting · 02/02/2024 06:10

your SIL would be screwed if it all went tits up

and i suspect they don’t have a penny between them in the pensions or savings

Yeah but they will get their care paid for when they are old and I would t put it past me they will make estate pensions means tested int he future and benefits all their life as they are "poor", kids uniforms, energy payments/grants, cost of living payment, help with rent, the OP is "rich" on paper with a high income so will get zero help.

Freakinfraser · 02/02/2024 10:19

DiamondsArentFood · 02/02/2024 10:04

I do hope that if funded hours kick off and work without a system collapse that parents of 1yr + lose entitlement to certain benefits as they should be able to work part time.

Let's think that through:
The government announced that in April 2025, certain benefits will cease for parents of children over 1 as those children should be in funded hours and the parent should be working.

Suddenly 1000s upon 1000s of children need funded places. Where are those places coming from?

Suddenly 1000s of parents are expected to find work, part time hours at least.
Where are those jobs coming from?

All those parents that are now forced into part time labour are paid NMW and need UC to top up their wages which puts them on a path to having their SIL start jealousy driven threads about them on MN.
Where are all those SILs coming from?

I don't think you thought that through... Just spewed bile..

To be fair there are plenty of unskilled low income min wage jobs available more than people looking for work, and if you don’t work then you will have work given to you or your benefits stopped.

and more nurseries and child minders will open up to meet demand.

GettingStuffed · 02/02/2024 10:17

Remember UC doesn't usually cover the entire rent.

arethereanyleftatall · 02/02/2024 10:15

I was you 20 years ago op. (Just making a guess!)
Now I'm nearly 50, my beautiful house, chosen by me in my favourite area, is nearly paid off.
I reckon got two more years of full time work, and then my house will be 'free'. I can then go part time. And I, hopefully but I know maybe not, have a fabulous asset for my children.
Compared to my friend who has always rented. In two years time, she will still have to pay the £2000 a month she pays in rent.
The government will look after her in retirement I hope.
But the pay back for working hard like you are early doors, will hopefully manifest in your fifties.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 02/02/2024 10:04

@DiamondsArentFood yes, I am aware of how it's calculated and what it is supposed to go on, I just feel that it must be hard to be struggling with so much. I hope things improve for you. I know that ridiculous rent payments can be a real issue for many folk on UC, even those in part time or full time work.

DiamondsArentFood · 02/02/2024 10:04

I do hope that if funded hours kick off and work without a system collapse that parents of 1yr + lose entitlement to certain benefits as they should be able to work part time.

Let's think that through:
The government announced that in April 2025, certain benefits will cease for parents of children over 1 as those children should be in funded hours and the parent should be working.

Suddenly 1000s upon 1000s of children need funded places. Where are those places coming from?

Suddenly 1000s of parents are expected to find work, part time hours at least.
Where are those jobs coming from?

All those parents that are now forced into part time labour are paid NMW and need UC to top up their wages which puts them on a path to having their SIL start jealousy driven threads about them on MN.
Where are all those SILs coming from?

I don't think you thought that through... Just spewed bile..

C8H10N4O2 · 02/02/2024 10:03

Mambo19866 · 02/02/2024 09:31

Ffs just google it bt offer half price broadband 20 pound a month for those on benefits. Ask ovo about their social tier tariff it exists im still using it ffs.

Can't comment on the ovo tariff but the BT broadband deal is not half price. The service included is only the most basic service so for a claimant doing some work its discount of about a fiver before VAT

If there is no income at all there is a £15 deal but the hypothetical DB wouldn't qualify as he is in work.

Dweetfidilove · 02/02/2024 10:03

suspiriana · 02/02/2024 08:43

How is OP better off than SIL?

She might eventually have an "asset" but she will have paid huge amounts of money for it (from post-taxed income), will have to pay for her own housing renovations, maintenance etc. If she falls on hard times she will have to sell up and downsize (and pay £££ stamp duty again). If she loses her job and can't pay the mortgage she will have to sell up and downsize (and pay stamp duty). Benefits won't pay her mortgage, only possibly some mortgage interest so she would have to pay off the capital. She has no security of tenure (see points above). She doesn't get to live in central London and probably has a much smaller home than SIL in comparison to what she is paying in mortgage costs (which are really high since interest rates have increased).

In contrast, SIL has;

Massively subsidised housing in prime central London, a secure tenancy which means she doesn't have to worry about being evicted or not being able to pay the mortgage as if husband loses his job UC will continue to pay the rent and being evicted is as likely as being struck by lightning in social housing, all renovations done for free by the council (brand new kitchen every xx number of years), no care home fees in later life, no inheritance tax if house is worth over a certain amount as they don't own it, can pass on the tenancy as an inheritance with no inheritance tax to pay. They basically have the equivalent of a million pound home that is theirs for life with all the benefits of home ownership and none of the burdens.

The husband can also take a lower paid job as they don't have a mortgage to cover and still get topped up handsomely in benefits.

Seems to me that actually OP is completely correct and there is absolutely no incentive to better oneself. Sounds like SIL and BIL are actually the rich ones.

Sounds like SIL and BIL are actually the rich ones.

Shortsighted view.

—OP is going renovations to improve value her property- something in-laws likely cannot afford to do.

  • OP already has disposable income (renovations are not free) and will have more post childcare / pay increases etc. Again, something her in-laws will likely not enjoy unless the husbands wakes up a high-flyer…
  • At some point their UC entitlement will decrease - when the children are no longer dependents. At that time as well, UC will also take a deduction for the now non-dependent children. By this point (health and opportunities permitting), the OP and her husband will be earning amounts unimaginable for the in-laws.
  • Old age -OP now owns her home outright and has choice over relocating/downsizing/care options etc, plus a healthy private pension and state pension. In-laws have fewer choices around all those areas and tiny private pension / state pension. Benefits are now means tested based on said pensions. Care options limited (council care homes are apparently going bankrupt everywhere).
  • We could go on all day and still find the in-laws are not the rich ones 🙄.
WithACatLikeTread · 02/02/2024 10:01

Your SIL won't be entitled to funded childcare or the 85% UC will pay because she doesn't work.

ChallahPlaiter · 02/02/2024 09:58

Birch101 · 02/02/2024 09:54

Honestly I see where you are coming from.

My only advice is that you will receive some funded childcare at some point so will save a little money, invest any savings wisely and perhaps in the long term adjust your outgoing as it seems as household you earn a decent amount.

One would hope your decisions to work hard will provide you children and yourselves with more experiences and opportunities in the long run.

I do hope that if funded hours kick off and work without a system collapse that parents of 1yr + lose entitlement to certain benefits as they should be able to work part time.

You hope that people with tiny children have their lives made more difficult?

What a horrible thing to say.

WithACatLikeTread · 02/02/2024 09:56

Birch101 · 02/02/2024 09:54

Honestly I see where you are coming from.

My only advice is that you will receive some funded childcare at some point so will save a little money, invest any savings wisely and perhaps in the long term adjust your outgoing as it seems as household you earn a decent amount.

One would hope your decisions to work hard will provide you children and yourselves with more experiences and opportunities in the long run.

I do hope that if funded hours kick off and work without a system collapse that parents of 1yr + lose entitlement to certain benefits as they should be able to work part time.

Are you aware of the lack of childcare places at the moment?

Birch101 · 02/02/2024 09:54

Honestly I see where you are coming from.

My only advice is that you will receive some funded childcare at some point so will save a little money, invest any savings wisely and perhaps in the long term adjust your outgoing as it seems as household you earn a decent amount.

One would hope your decisions to work hard will provide you children and yourselves with more experiences and opportunities in the long run.

I do hope that if funded hours kick off and work without a system collapse that parents of 1yr + lose entitlement to certain benefits as they should be able to work part time.