Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed that those on UC have more disposable income

461 replies

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:07

Myself and DH both work full time and have one child in nursery that we are paying for. We have a household income of just under £100k. After taxes, mortgage, student loan, NI, pension deductions and bills we are not actually left with a huge amount of disposable income. We are in the south east.

Brother in law and his partner have just had their first baby and announced that SIL will not be returning to work for at least 3 years. BIL earns roughly £30k and they live in social housing (lucky them). They will get around £900 a month in UC + no childcare bill.

So whilst we are running around like headless chickens trying to keep on top of things and juggle professional jobs, house renovations and parenting. My SIL will have the pleasure of sitting at home with no stress enjoying her baby. (SIL is known to be very lazy and also took the whole of her pregnancy off sick due to anxiety.)

At this point I just feel so deflated, and am wondering what the point is of working hard and being self sufficient. Funny thing is in laws think we are the lucky ones, when I don't actually think we are here. The system needs to change as there is no incentive to work.

OP posts:
shellyleppard · 02/02/2024 06:41

Op the grass is NOT always greener on the other side. Your sil may be claiming UC but they will have to pay housing costs from that. Which can be very expensive. Its not easy being on UC....so please don't assume it is

MiddleParking · 02/02/2024 06:39

Princessandthepea0 · 02/02/2024 06:36

Many people on MN are educationally and economically challenged. They don’t understand quite how much tax you will be paying. By the way - don’t go over 100k. In your situation your marginal tax rate would be over 100%.

The problem is - many people, do feel like you. Is it worth it? Which is why net contributors are now decreasing and net takers are the majority. The problem is - what you feel is what many are feeling. The people who are paying for it all are changing economic behaviour and working less. They need to start looking at other ways of tax as opposed to the same small group of people actually working.

You’ve either failed to read the post properly, or you’ve read it but failed to understand it. Quite funny really.

ruby1957 · 02/02/2024 06:39

Princessandthepea0 · 02/02/2024 06:36

Many people on MN are educationally and economically challenged. They don’t understand quite how much tax you will be paying. By the way - don’t go over 100k. In your situation your marginal tax rate would be over 100%.

The problem is - many people, do feel like you. Is it worth it? Which is why net contributors are now decreasing and net takers are the majority. The problem is - what you feel is what many are feeling. The people who are paying for it all are changing economic behaviour and working less. They need to start looking at other ways of tax as opposed to the same small group of people actually working.

What a patronising attitude to have.

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 02/02/2024 06:38

@Mambo19866 I am on full benefits and do not work and I can confidently say that I do not get all that you have listed.

  • I still have to pay council tax, albeit a reduced amount.
  • There are no NHS dentists so I have to pay private fees.
  • I do not get any discount on gas and electric and pay the same price as everyone else.
  • There is no half price broadband, I pay full price for my package.
  • Housing benefit will not pay towards a mortgage.
  • Anyone who 'resents' me for how I live my life will simply be removed from my life. I wouldn't surround myself with such judgmental and arrogant people.

In reply to the OP, having anxiety is extremely stressful and I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. I would have absolutely LOVED to have what you have but it's not possible. Think yourself lucky and fortunate to be where you are.

Kosenrufugirl · 02/02/2024 06:38

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:14

It's a bit late now after we have a mortgage, even if we sold we wouldn't be eligible to claim would we.

You can sell, stuff the money into your pension (backdate it for a few years), rent, resign from your jobs, go to the Council and ask to be housed. They will house you as above is all perfectly legal. So you do have choices. My family had to crawl our way back after a doomed business venture. I know where I would rather be

ruby1957 · 02/02/2024 06:36

MiddleParking · 02/02/2024 06:16

How and why are you doing house renovations if you haven’t got much disposable income?

My thoughts exactly - renovations (unless water is pouring in through the roof etc) are a luxury many of us manage without. The OP has a good pension, assets, the satisfaction of providing for her family. Stop whinging OP

TedMullins · 02/02/2024 06:36

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:17

We don't have a huge mortgage actually.

Quit your job and stay home then, or drop your hours, or failing that be grateful for what you’ve got. Perhaps if the basics in life - secure housing being one - were genuinely affordable they wouldn’t need to claim UC. Hate the game not the player. That said, if you’ve got no disposable income on 100k you need to look at your spending.

PinkFrogss · 02/02/2024 06:36

Plus you presumably took a years maternity leave? So you’re only looking at potentially a 2 year difference in that case.

Seasaltsquall · 02/02/2024 06:36

PickledPurplePickle · 02/02/2024 06:09

You have your own house, you have pensions, you have security - your SIL doesn't have any of this

This.

11NigelTufnel · 02/02/2024 06:36

You seem to be getting hung up on how much they are getting on benefits without looking at how much better off you really are. Your child is in nursery now, but that is a short, if eye-wateringly expensive, time. You will have the asset of a house once the mortgage is paid off, career progression and a private pension. Look forward to when you retire comfortably and they have to live in insecure accommodation on the state pension. They will never be able to have savings, when you will be able to redirect some of the nursery money when your child starts school.

Thing is their option is open to you. If you want to go on benefits instead, quit your job, go bankrupt and start claiming. It's certainly not a prospect that appeals to me!

Princessandthepea0 · 02/02/2024 06:36

Many people on MN are educationally and economically challenged. They don’t understand quite how much tax you will be paying. By the way - don’t go over 100k. In your situation your marginal tax rate would be over 100%.

The problem is - many people, do feel like you. Is it worth it? Which is why net contributors are now decreasing and net takers are the majority. The problem is - what you feel is what many are feeling. The people who are paying for it all are changing economic behaviour and working less. They need to start looking at other ways of tax as opposed to the same small group of people actually working.

ArtG · 02/02/2024 06:35

“Why is someone getting something I don’t get? It must stop immediately.” Seems to me to be the attitude at the root of much of the misery in this country.

RowanMayfair · 02/02/2024 06:34

Those figures don't sound right at all if they don't have a childcare bill. They may be getting something towards rent but I really don't think it's possible they could be getting £900 on UC.

PinkFrogss · 02/02/2024 06:33

How are you doing renovations if you have low disposable income? That feels like either bad planning (buying a noise you can’t afford the renovations on) or poor choices.

Are they really that lucky to live in social housing? There must be additional factors for them to have gotten a house so, especially as in most areas the best they would have been offered is a flat. Or they live in a not very desirable area. Pros and cons.

Why don’t you or your DH quit and one of you stay at home? You could always move to a cheaper area, get a cheaper mortgage etc. Cut your cloth to suit one singe high income. There’s a money matters forum if you’d like help budgeting different possibilities.

Queijo · 02/02/2024 06:33

So you have 100k coming in, not a large mortgage and you’re skint? Sounds to me like you’re living outside of your means.

I am a single income household on much less than you, small mortgage and no UC and I have plenty of disposable income left each month.

You could always quit your job and live on UC and see how easy it is then!

PPTorPDF · 02/02/2024 06:32

VanilleA · 02/02/2024 06:16

£30K isn't low income

£30k is low income especially to support a family on.

Mambo19866 · 02/02/2024 06:31

Your allowed to own a house on universal credit so don’t know why people are saying your lucky to own a house lots of people have a house and claim full benefits. If you actually do the math she isn’t entirely wrong once once you add up every single benefit you get for being on benefits it adds up to a lot more than you think. To name a few council tax exemption, totally free dental on nhs, social tariffs on electricity and gas, half price broadband, pdsa for free vet treatment for 1 pet, social housing not hedged on inflation so extremely cheap for example as we are still in the housing is 390 a month for a 1 bed flat or if you have a mortgage paid towards that, cost of living payments worked out to 1200 a year, tax free finance for new car, I know there’s more I’m forgetting. When I was starting work I had to math it out works out you need about 40000 ish a year before you are better off in work. Btw this isn’t including the work allowance of 400ish a month before benefits are effected. So in total it’s like 45000. The downsides though are you are only allowed 6000 in savings so you are perpetually in a precarious position, stale progression in life as you won’t have a career and if/when your claim ends you are screwed, your peers will grow to resent you and eventually be oatracised. On balance it seems you are being taken for a mug but trust me your better off in your position when it’s all said and done though. Maybe you can go part time or just rely on your partners income so you can stay at home. All the best :)

Shoppingfiend · 02/02/2024 06:30

I see what your saying but home all day with a 1, then 2, then 3year old. Not as easy as it sounds.

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:30

Nonewclothes2024 · 02/02/2024 06:29

How are they getting that much UC ?

Do an entitled to you calculation, it's all there if you know someone's postcode, income and housing situation.

OP posts:
MrsMurphyIWish · 02/02/2024 06:30

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:26

But we have stress trying the juggle everything. I would be a lot less stressed if I could be at home all day.

You’re trying to apply your life onto a life on benefits, it won’t work. You won’t have the stress of being a working mum - you’ll have the stress of surviving. I know, I was the child. It’s not an exaggeration when I say the only meal I had was my free school meal. That’s a life on benefits.

MiddleParking · 02/02/2024 06:30

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:26

But we have stress trying the juggle everything. I would be a lot less stressed if I could be at home all day.

Have you tried not renovating your house? How stressful can having one kid that’s in full time nursery really be?

Nonewclothes2024 · 02/02/2024 06:29

How are they getting that much UC ?

Justfinking · 02/02/2024 06:28

BTW being a SAHM is hard work, so she won't be sitting around and if she's lazy she's in for a big surprise!

FUBAR77 · 02/02/2024 06:27

I think people in this country stop seeing ‘being on benefits’ as an actual choice, and being bitter about those that need them. OP you both work and can support your family, why are you jealous of your ILs for not having done as well as you in life, it’s so odd. Even if she went back to work I imagine they need a top up and you’d be jealous about that too!

The real problem is people don’t get paid enough and we live in a very expensive country with massive government mismanagement, you’re angry at that wrong people Im afraid!

Justfinking · 02/02/2024 06:27

Obviously. Who wouldn't be pissed off with this. But think long term, you'll be better off, have assets, be good role models and they'll probably still be dependent on the government (and highly likely their kids will turn out like that too)

Swipe left for the next trending thread