Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed that those on UC have more disposable income

461 replies

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:07

Myself and DH both work full time and have one child in nursery that we are paying for. We have a household income of just under £100k. After taxes, mortgage, student loan, NI, pension deductions and bills we are not actually left with a huge amount of disposable income. We are in the south east.

Brother in law and his partner have just had their first baby and announced that SIL will not be returning to work for at least 3 years. BIL earns roughly £30k and they live in social housing (lucky them). They will get around £900 a month in UC + no childcare bill.

So whilst we are running around like headless chickens trying to keep on top of things and juggle professional jobs, house renovations and parenting. My SIL will have the pleasure of sitting at home with no stress enjoying her baby. (SIL is known to be very lazy and also took the whole of her pregnancy off sick due to anxiety.)

At this point I just feel so deflated, and am wondering what the point is of working hard and being self sufficient. Funny thing is in laws think we are the lucky ones, when I don't actually think we are here. The system needs to change as there is no incentive to work.

OP posts:
StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 02/02/2024 06:53

@Mambo19866 Do you know how to have a conversation without being rude?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/02/2024 06:53

Would you be happier if they were really struggling, OP?

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 02/02/2024 06:52

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:49

'Anxiety can be serious enough to stop someone working. I'd hate to be in that position, wouldn't you? '

It's convenient that it meant taking her entire pregnancy off.

I've been unable to work most of my adult life due to anxiety. Pregnancy can exacerbate anxiety.

29andLost · 02/02/2024 06:52

I get uc as me and DP earn about 24K combined. I would rather be in your position any day OP and the sad truth is, I probably never will be

Simonjt · 02/02/2024 06:52

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:49

'Anxiety can be serious enough to stop someone working. I'd hate to be in that position, wouldn't you? '

It's convenient that it meant taking her entire pregnancy off.

You think suffering ill health, ill health which could have a negative impact on their baby is convenient? So if you became too unwell to work would you also find that convenient?

SunshineAndRainbowsToday · 02/02/2024 06:51

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:49

'Anxiety can be serious enough to stop someone working. I'd hate to be in that position, wouldn't you? '

It's convenient that it meant taking her entire pregnancy off.

You clearly don't understand mental illness. Yes, it definitely can be enough to stop someone working an entire pregnancy. Years even.

nowthelighthasgone · 02/02/2024 06:51

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:49

'Anxiety can be serious enough to stop someone working. I'd hate to be in that position, wouldn't you? '

It's convenient that it meant taking her entire pregnancy off.

Just admit you don't like her I kind of hope she does see this because the way you're writing about her is horrible

Weedoormatnomore · 02/02/2024 06:50

It is hard at times when you know people who are on UC are out nearly every single weekend or going away as plenty of disposable income.
However at same time I know one mum who got stuck had plenty always out then when her child left school most of her benefits stopped and was struggling for money.

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 02/02/2024 06:50

@Mambo19866 Nope, it's all changed now. We get a reduction but we still have to pay council tax. As I said, I cannot get an NHS dentist so I pay the same prices as you do. I don't use BT and am contracted with another company. You made it sound like you automatically get a discount no matter what provider you are with. As far as I am aware, my LA won't pay towards a mortgage, only if renting.

It's not all peoples nature, just jealous and bitter people who should perhaps be grateful for what they have got

ChaosAndCrumbs · 02/02/2024 06:49

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:46

The funny thing is they live in a very expensive area that we could not afford to buy in.

Well, then, you’ll have to live with being jealous because I’m afraid it’s sounds like they’re the exception to a rule.

Simonjt · 02/02/2024 06:49

I had a similar household income to you as a lone parent, so I had less take home pay due to the personal allowance etc. I was living in zone 1 with one child in nursery. How much juggling can there possibly be to collect and drop off one child from nursery?

How are you hard up? I don’t know anyone who doesn’t have spare money who can afford to fund renovations on their home.

Mambo19866 · 02/02/2024 06:49

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 02/02/2024 06:38

@Mambo19866 I am on full benefits and do not work and I can confidently say that I do not get all that you have listed.

  • I still have to pay council tax, albeit a reduced amount.
  • There are no NHS dentists so I have to pay private fees.
  • I do not get any discount on gas and electric and pay the same price as everyone else.
  • There is no half price broadband, I pay full price for my package.
  • Housing benefit will not pay towards a mortgage.
  • Anyone who 'resents' me for how I live my life will simply be removed from my life. I wouldn't surround myself with such judgmental and arrogant people.

In reply to the OP, having anxiety is extremely stressful and I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. I would have absolutely LOVED to have what you have but it's not possible. Think yourself lucky and fortunate to be where you are.

Man this information is even just on googles front page lol google “can I claim mortgage on universal credit” google “is there social electricity tariff for benefits” and finally “is there cheaper broadband for those on benefits” like do you even check what you say or just pull it out to ur arse.

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:49

'Anxiety can be serious enough to stop someone working. I'd hate to be in that position, wouldn't you? '

It's convenient that it meant taking her entire pregnancy off.

OP posts:
quisensoucie · 02/02/2024 06:48

"Tarquin, one of the peasants appears to have more carrots than we. Get the secretary to write to our MP, the DM and the Telegraph. How dare an uneducated, low-waged person have more than us?"

SunshineAndRainbowsToday · 02/02/2024 06:46

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:26

But we have stress trying the juggle everything. I would be a lot less stressed if I could be at home all day.

Do it then.

I find your post judgey. Anxiety can be serious enough to stop someone working. I'd hate to be in that position, wouldn't you?

If she parents well she won't be sitting on her backside at home all day either.

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:46

ChaosAndCrumbs · 02/02/2024 06:43

Yes, you’re being unreasonable. I also think you’re possibly not managing your money well? £100K is a lot more than many. You’ve chosen to buy a house that needed renovations and you’re choosing to spend money on that. You had control over where to live and which house to pick and can move if your neighbours are crap. They can’t. We chose not to live in an expensive area of the country, that came with negatives and positives like every decision.

Technically, you could sell the house, squander the money and be given UC and social housing, but you haven’t - so there’s some incentive to work. You could choose to be a SAHM, but you’d have to make different decisions like potentially downsizing and not renovating.

Clearly there are some issues between you and your SIL. If she genuinely had anxiety in pregnancy, then I’m sorry for her and hope this doesn’t get worse after her baby is born.

Yes, it’s ridiculous that the cost of living is so high generally, but that’s a very different conversation. I don’t know anyone of UC who’s genuinely happy and comfortable and has heaps of disposable income. I do know plenty of people on large salaries who could manage their money a bit differently, but through the choices they’ve made are under pressure.

The funny thing is they live in a very expensive area that we could not afford to buy in.

OP posts:
Mambo19866 · 02/02/2024 06:44

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 02/02/2024 06:38

@Mambo19866 I am on full benefits and do not work and I can confidently say that I do not get all that you have listed.

  • I still have to pay council tax, albeit a reduced amount.
  • There are no NHS dentists so I have to pay private fees.
  • I do not get any discount on gas and electric and pay the same price as everyone else.
  • There is no half price broadband, I pay full price for my package.
  • Housing benefit will not pay towards a mortgage.
  • Anyone who 'resents' me for how I live my life will simply be removed from my life. I wouldn't surround myself with such judgmental and arrogant people.

In reply to the OP, having anxiety is extremely stressful and I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. I would have absolutely LOVED to have what you have but it's not possible. Think yourself lucky and fortunate to be where you are.

Actually your wrong you do get full council tax subsidation at least I did, yes there are nhs dentists where I am, ask ovo for their “social tariff” I can link it. Yes there is half price broadband speak to BT and ask for it it’s 20 a month for 72mb. Housing benefit does pay towards a mortgage check the website ffs and finally yes people will resent you if anyone thinks your getting something for free they are not they will resent you it’s peoples nature.

nowthelighthasgone · 02/02/2024 06:43

Another disgusting thread criticising a benefits system that's already driving more into poverty and some posters here appear to want to reduce benefits even further. I think it's sickening

ChaosAndCrumbs · 02/02/2024 06:43

Yes, you’re being unreasonable. I also think you’re possibly not managing your money well? £100K is a lot more than many. You’ve chosen to buy a house that needed renovations and you’re choosing to spend money on that. You had control over where to live and which house to pick and can move if your neighbours are crap. They can’t. We chose not to live in an expensive area of the country, that came with negatives and positives like every decision.

Technically, you could sell the house, squander the money and be given UC and social housing, but you haven’t - so there’s some incentive to work. You could choose to be a SAHM, but you’d have to make different decisions like potentially downsizing and not renovating.

Clearly there are some issues between you and your SIL. If she genuinely had anxiety in pregnancy, then I’m sorry for her and hope this doesn’t get worse after her baby is born.

Yes, it’s ridiculous that the cost of living is so high generally, but that’s a very different conversation. I don’t know anyone of UC who’s genuinely happy and comfortable and has heaps of disposable income. I do know plenty of people on large salaries who could manage their money a bit differently, but through the choices they’ve made are under pressure.

SkankingWombat · 02/02/2024 06:43

PickledPurplePickle · 02/02/2024 06:09

You have your own house, you have pensions, you have security - your SIL doesn't have any of this

Until you have to use it all to pay for your care in old age...
If you have a council house, you have it for life, so no less secure.

I agree it isn't fair and that there isn't enough of an incentive to work hard and save currently. I think the solution lies around making the decision to work and save pay more, rather than running down benefits further, however. In our street, you can broadly tell which house is which as (and I hate to revert to stereotypes, but it's definitely true in our street) the 100k households mostly have older mid-range cars and the council residents mostly have new high-end ones. It does make you wonder 'what's the point?' as ultimately we both live in the same house, and whilst our house may well need to be sold to pay for care home fees, theirs will be passed on to their DC(s) automatically if they've continued to live there, as many do.

Jifmicroliquid · 02/02/2024 06:43

I would normally agree with you, if say your combined income was low because your and your husband both worked full time in low paid jobs. Thats when it’s tough to see others doing nothing and receiving similar, if not more, money.

But you have a combined income of £100k. I can’t understand why you have little disposable income. If your rent/mortgage is ridiculously high, then downsize or move.

I beg you to try working 6 days full time and earning 18k. I am self employed. I can only just cover my bills.

PinkyFlamingo · 02/02/2024 06:42

Your BIL does work though doesn't he so why say there should be more incentive to work

Queijo · 02/02/2024 06:42

Also there’s no way they’re getting £900 a month with no childcare bill. It will likely be around £400 depending on their LHA rate.

PinkFrogss · 02/02/2024 06:42

Princessandthepea0 · 02/02/2024 06:36

Many people on MN are educationally and economically challenged. They don’t understand quite how much tax you will be paying. By the way - don’t go over 100k. In your situation your marginal tax rate would be over 100%.

The problem is - many people, do feel like you. Is it worth it? Which is why net contributors are now decreasing and net takers are the majority. The problem is - what you feel is what many are feeling. The people who are paying for it all are changing economic behaviour and working less. They need to start looking at other ways of tax as opposed to the same small group of people actually working.

How do you know OP is a net contributor?

Plus we’d be pretty screwed if everyone in low paid jobs and not net contributors just sacked it all in for better paid jobs or something. Carers, shop and factory workers, many NHS staff, etc. Where would we be without them?

No idea what you mean by the tax comment, I can only assume you don’t know much about tax Confused

Nofilteritwonthelp · 02/02/2024 06:41

TedMullins · 02/02/2024 06:36

Quit your job and stay home then, or drop your hours, or failing that be grateful for what you’ve got. Perhaps if the basics in life - secure housing being one - were genuinely affordable they wouldn’t need to claim UC. Hate the game not the player. That said, if you’ve got no disposable income on 100k you need to look at your spending.

Do this OP, you're seriously clueless if you think she'll just be sitting at home doing nothing for 3 years. Also you don't sound like you're barely making ends meet if you don't have a huge mortgage and are doing renovations. I initially thought YANBU, but you just sound bitter

Swipe left for the next trending thread