Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed that those on UC have more disposable income

461 replies

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:07

Myself and DH both work full time and have one child in nursery that we are paying for. We have a household income of just under £100k. After taxes, mortgage, student loan, NI, pension deductions and bills we are not actually left with a huge amount of disposable income. We are in the south east.

Brother in law and his partner have just had their first baby and announced that SIL will not be returning to work for at least 3 years. BIL earns roughly £30k and they live in social housing (lucky them). They will get around £900 a month in UC + no childcare bill.

So whilst we are running around like headless chickens trying to keep on top of things and juggle professional jobs, house renovations and parenting. My SIL will have the pleasure of sitting at home with no stress enjoying her baby. (SIL is known to be very lazy and also took the whole of her pregnancy off sick due to anxiety.)

At this point I just feel so deflated, and am wondering what the point is of working hard and being self sufficient. Funny thing is in laws think we are the lucky ones, when I don't actually think we are here. The system needs to change as there is no incentive to work.

OP posts:
Gillypie23 · 02/02/2024 07:39

People on uc don't have lots of disposable income. You sound bitter and uneducated.

viridiano · 02/02/2024 07:39

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:14

It's a bit late now after we have a mortgage, even if we sold we wouldn't be eligible to claim would we.

Right - so therefore you are much better off than someone on benefits, who doesn't have a mortgage or equity in a house.

Honestly, your complaint is ridiculous.

Sell your house, give all the money to charity, and then go on benefits - then you would be equal.

kikilaw · 02/02/2024 07:38

Princessandthepea0 · 02/02/2024 06:36

Many people on MN are educationally and economically challenged. They don’t understand quite how much tax you will be paying. By the way - don’t go over 100k. In your situation your marginal tax rate would be over 100%.

The problem is - many people, do feel like you. Is it worth it? Which is why net contributors are now decreasing and net takers are the majority. The problem is - what you feel is what many are feeling. The people who are paying for it all are changing economic behaviour and working less. They need to start looking at other ways of tax as opposed to the same small group of people actually working.

This.

Katemax82 · 02/02/2024 07:38

VanilleA · 02/02/2024 06:16

£30K isn't low income

30k is low if its the sole income. Especially in the South east

UndertheCedartree · 02/02/2024 07:36

nappyvalley2024 · 02/02/2024 06:14

It's a bit late now after we have a mortgage, even if we sold we wouldn't be eligible to claim would we.

It's never too late! People with mortgages find themselves having to claim benefits - I'm one of them. Go on, give up your jobs. Think of all that extra money you'll have flowing in! You could get even more renovations done!

Sususudio · 02/02/2024 07:36

Work also gives me the ability not to depend on man.

This-in itself- is priceless, when so many people are out of work.

SoSBeingAMumIsHard · 02/02/2024 07:35

This pic literally represents you
They are just making Lemonade out of lemons. You're looking at the wrong thing. It's you who is unhappy, and you're unhappy that they are happy with the little that they have and you have so much and are still unhappy. That's actually the sad part here.

My god how can anyone begrudge someone in social housing. All calculations of what people get on UC are available so this wild idea that its so much disposable income is incredibly ignorant.

You own your own property which means your children have inheritance.

You have a larger pension.

You have control over where you live, which nursery and schools your children go to.

AITA ....Yes you 1000% are.

To feel annoyed that those on UC have more disposable income
Fetchthevet · 02/02/2024 07:35

Genuine questions - why is choosing to look after your own pre-school age children always seen as such a negative thing on Mumsnet? Why isn't caring for babies and infants seen as of any value to society at all, especially on here?

forcedfun · 02/02/2024 07:35

Your SIL is putting herself in a very precarious position.

I wouldn't ever want to claim benefits unless I had no other choice. You are vulnerable to the whims (and budget) of the government. And I say that as someone sufficiently disabled that I probably could justify giving up work and claiming benefits.

Work also gives me the ability not to depend on man, and career progression which means I won't be stuck with the same budget forever.

Sususudio · 02/02/2024 07:32

Reading your list, I wonder if you would benefit from reducing a few activities until your renovations are over, or DC is older. Children don't need that many play dates. You don't need to attend every social event; many people are scaling back after the pandemic. Try to scale back for a bit.

It's quite usual to feel completely overwhelmed at the stage you are in, but it will get better and then you will glad you have your career, pension and your own house.

anothernamitynamenamechange · 02/02/2024 07:32

Social commitments are 100% something you chose to do. Not saying you shouldn't - socialising is nice. But the money and time you spend on that IS discretionary.

anothernamitynamenamechange · 02/02/2024 07:31

The thing is, the mortgage repayments are a huge burden but in a sense they will come back to you as you will fully own your own house once its all paid. It is buying you an asset not wasted money. I work full time and had to rent for years watching all my money disappear and knowing my landlord could raise the rent any time he wanted. Your relatives in a council house are really luck in the sense that they are more protected from rent increases but the rent they are paying isn't creating an asset for them like your mortgage. Ideally more people that couldn't buy would be in their position (rather than the private rent trap).

If I was feeling sorry for anyone I would feel sorry for me not you because I finally managed to save enough to buy a tiny run down flat. But in doing so I can't afford to spend money on days out/play dates in interesting places/friends weddings, even small things like coffees etc (I have had to skip things I really wanted to go to. It sucks). Some of the stuff you list as necessary expenditure... isn't. My mortgage is still huge but at least its paying back something I will own rather than going straight to my landlords ski holidays. But lots of people are in a much worse position.

I don't think further decimating social housing will help. We do need to build more houses.

Vettrianofan · 02/02/2024 07:29

Nonewclothes2024 · 02/02/2024 06:29

How are they getting that much UC ?

We get roughly this. I am a part time student and DH works full time. It sounds about right.

TedMullins · 02/02/2024 07:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Bloom15 · 02/02/2024 07:27

Icedlatteplease · 02/02/2024 06:13

How on £100k do you not have disposable income?

I can help thinking you did not bear in mind your disposable income when you bought your house. If so that is a choice you made.

A choice.

You need to recognise how lucky you are to have that choice.

Your SIL did not choose to have anxiety and its about time we value those that take care of others.

Agree with this.

Me and DH have 1 DC - we are in the north west but have a joint income of around £50,000. We have a mortgage.

We have enough disposable income to be able to afford a holiday abroad this year and can afford days out, meals etc. we also have good pensions. I am currently off sick on full pay after an operation.

I wouldn't begrudge your in-laws or anyone else on UC - they are on the whim of the government.

If you think their life is so great perhaps you should model your life on theirs?!

lemmein · 02/02/2024 07:26

Aren't you more fucked off about the Michelle Mone's of this world OP?

You might think your SIL is having an amazing time parenting full time with anxiety, but she isn't lounging on a fucking yacht paid for by the taxpayers is she?

There's something really quite distasteful about wanting benefits to be stripped even further so others can feel superior. Don't you think it's great that we live in a country which supports a mum with MH issues?

UndertheCedartree · 02/02/2024 07:25

But you have so much! Your own house, professional jobs, pensions, a large income and you can afford house renovations so you must have pretty decent disposable income - more than those on UC have. Your relatives have a much lower income, rent and your SIL has mental health problems.

I'm on UC and get PIP and DLA for my DC. I have a serious mental illness that stops me working and also mobility issues, my DC both have ASD. Would you like to swap if being on benefits is so great? I'd swap with you in a heartbeat!

arethereanyleftatall · 02/02/2024 07:25

This is temporary op, hang in there.

You're probably right, at the moment, your in laws will have

Pros - more disposable income than you

But you have...

Pros - money in to pensions, security, choice, career progression.

Those things are far more valuable long term.

Dweetfidilove · 02/02/2024 07:23

Mambo19866 · 02/02/2024 07:09

I thought that was who we were talking about people disabled on benefits.

The OP said he’s SIL suffers anxiety, but hasn’t said if the UC includes any disability benefits. This is usually the problem with these threads. There’s usually pertinent information missing.

Even so, because her husband is working, her household would be considered ‘disabled working’ , so they don’t get full support. In fact, they’d get no support as income over £430 (from work and UC) get nil. Much has changed as councils try to balance the books.

Itsbritneybitch22 · 02/02/2024 07:22

@nappyvalley2024

You to fo List sounds like normal life are you sure you don’t have anxiety if you’re finding it stressful?

Also apart working working x2 because your SIL list would be the same apart from working x1 she won’t be having renovation stress, she will have full time childcare which is mainly on her due to being alone with child all day. I’m sure she doesn’t clock off at 5 to relax and be lazy, anxiety or not.

Anywherebuthere · 02/02/2024 07:20

This post has to be a wind up OP!

I would love for you to swap places with your BIL and SIL and then come back and tell us how much you still envy them.

You really do need to sit down and evaluate why you don't have much left of 100k. And figure out what you could change.

Also be grateful you will most likely be ok in the future with your pensions and your mortgaged house. 'Lucky' SIL and BIL have a high chance of being stuck in social housing

Sususudio · 02/02/2024 07:20

Try being an immigrant, high tax payer and net contributor, and having to read all the current Tory rhetoric about immigrants draining the country and burdening the NHS.

I have no envy however. Self-sufficiency is a reward in itself, and I have zero desire to sit at home with "no stress". And I don't think life on benefits is as much fun as you do. I am definitely one of the lucky ones.

Vettrianofan · 02/02/2024 07:19

Lougle · 02/02/2024 07:15

We have UC. We're trapped, really. We can't afford to buy (although have the right to buy our council house) and can't save the deposit, even over a period of years, to do so because we would no longer be eligible for UC. Ironically, once we put a deposit down on the house, we would be eligible again. But we can't afford to be without UC between saving £16,000 and the amount we would need to buy.

UC is a trap I agree. No one is allowed to better themselves to be free of reliance on the state because of the rules. Not allowed to save. Government are just shooting themselves in the foot with this rule.

Vettrianofan · 02/02/2024 07:16

Jollyoldfruit · 02/02/2024 06:19

Her in laws have social housing.
Thats like Willy Wonka’s golden ticket!
My elderly dm has her own home, it’s a millstone round her neck. You don’t need equity when the state take care of you.

It makes sense to depend on the state if you think about it just for the reason alone that you have your housing catered for, no fretting about paying off a mortgage for years to come. No need to worry about equity 🤷🏻

NoSquirrels · 02/02/2024 07:16

Lougle · 02/02/2024 07:12

The UC award is about right
Couples allowance (if both over 25) £578.82
Child 1 £269.58
Rent (if all falls under LHA rate) £1000
Total £1848.40

Wages £2035-work allowance £379= £1656
55% deduction = £910.80

Final award £847.40

Their total income is £2945.80

Your income, even assuming a 5% pension contribution is £5300 per month. Are you saying that the £2300 extra per month you get, along with the future security of owning your own house and pensions, doesn't feel enough to justify working?

Excellent post. The OP will ignore it.