Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two dog walkers chatting while their 10 dogs were off lead, and running around

83 replies

Upsetmother12 · 01/02/2024 20:02

Today I was walking my two small reactive spaniels on playing fields near my house. I always put them on a lead around other dogs. Normally, I walk my cockers in woodland away from other dogs and people. In part, because urban parks tend to be full of big dogs - like Huskies or Rottweilers. Today, my dogs were galloping around the fields when I saw two, I assume dog walkers, with ten dogs, including two huge mastiff like dogs and a Rottweiler, all off lead. These dogs were a literal dog pack and I knew that they posed a potential danger to me, my dogs and, worse, any toddlers that were on those fields. The women were weakly calling for them to ‘come back’. The dogs ignored them and the two women concerned were pretty nonchalant, and engrossed in conversation. I am angry. I am angry on so many different levels: 10 dogs running loose and together form a pack; the women were chatting away and completely oblivious to fouling and, finally, the fields are a public facility used by parents and children, in addition to dog owners. Am I right to be angry? I am so tired of dodging dog walker dog packs … argh. I feel that my small, elderly spaniel would have reacted defensively towards the pack and they, literally, could have eviscerated her. My spaniels only react nervously to other dogs, one of them having been mauled in the past by a husky and a Red Setter. It is not just XL Bullies who should be banned. Dog walkers should are ‘advised’ to restrict themselves to up to six dogs. They should be required to have a much smaller maximum. Is it because each dog is worth £25 and this means that 1-2 hrs work becomes more lucrative? Also, why do so many dog walkers walk their dogs in public shared spaces? Why not hire a field for 2 hrs (£40) and let the dogs charge around? Grrrr …. Btw, I am not attacking dog walking as a profession. I even thought about being one. However, I would never allow so many dogs off lead - especially if they were not mine. I am assuming that these two ladies were dog walkers.

OP posts:
Upsetmother12 · 02/02/2024 23:51

PennysLane · 02/02/2024 09:42

Complete waste of time and resources. dog workers aren’t doing anything illegal.

If I saw the original posters reactive Dog off lead and out of control that might warrant phone calls to police as she’s already stipulated the dog is reactive and off lead.

Good grief. They were not ‘out of control’. Just two small spaniels catching their rubber balls, in an unoccupied corner of the field. The dogs are only reactive if approached by other dogs who are over friendly or aggressive. Even then they do not bite. One of them cries and the other gives a growl to say, ‘Leave me alone’. She was attacked by a husky and red setter who ended up bouncing her on their backs. The point is a total of ten dogs, all together, several of them mastiff like, is unnerving. Forget my dogs, you are missing the point. Even if I did not have my dogs with me, I would still be uneasy. It is potentially dangerous, if not lethal.

OP posts:
Fizbosshoes · 02/02/2024 20:24

I was out running and I am a bit of a wuss about dogs I don't know. One came bounding up to me with the owner some way behind. She yelled "don't worry he's fine ". I stopped anyway and then the dog looked quite threatened and started crouching and growling, then started jumping at me. It didn't hurt me, but as I say I'm quite wary and it made me nervous. The owner eventually caught up and then reprimanded the dog and did give me as much of a backwards glance!

This isn't indicative of most dog owners I meet though, I would say majority are amenable and in control of their dog and its easy to share the space

eduwot · 02/02/2024 20:07

I am a dog walker and think large groups like this should not be in public locations. I don't take more than four and I would never meet up with another walker.
You are unreasonable in thinking 1 dog is worth £25 for an hr. I don't know where you are, but that would be very high for an hours walk. Also, think about the time it takes to drive to each dog, collect them, drive to walking location and home. Think about the fuel and the insurance. I don't think anyone walking dogs is 'quids in'. This is probably why you get silly situations with large groups, because dog walkers are struggling financially and it probably is the only way of making decent money. I wouldn't do it though. I think it is totally irresponsible.

IlsSortLaPlupartAuNuitMostly · 02/02/2024 19:53

Do you not have rules about dog walkers in your local area then? Lambeth has licensing for use of parks. No idea whether it's enforced properly - I'm rarely in parks in the middle of a weekday. Note how the licence for 6 dogs is much higher than the licence for 4.

Two dog walkers chatting while their 10 dogs were off lead, and running around
Spacecowboys · 02/02/2024 19:35

I think it depends really. If there are dogs off in the distance playing around together, with zero interest in approaching us then that’s fine. If they are close or approaching I always put my dog back on his lead and find it incredibly rude when other dog owners don’t do the same.

BigDogEnergy · 02/02/2024 19:23

PennysLane · 02/02/2024 06:59

This woman in question was mauled to death by her own dog. It was an XL bully.

She was attacked by several of the dogs, a number of which were large or giant breeds. It was only 2 Dachschunds that were initially not siezed by police.

https://www.leicestermercury.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/mauled-dog-walker-seen-struggling-8044618

Mauled dog walker seen 'struggling to control' pets days earlier

Eight dogs have been seized after the 28-year-old woman was mauled to death

https://www.leicestermercury.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/mauled-dog-walker-seen-struggling-8044618

PennysLane · 02/02/2024 09:48

It’s honestly breaks my heart to read comments about how awful people take professionals dog walkers are.

I honestly wish I could publish my business page, my website on here so that you guys can all see what a proper one does and what customers think of a proper one a good one one that cares about welfare over profit.

I wish you could see the number of telephone calls and emails I’ve had to local Council trying to put an end to other dog walkers that do walk substantial amounts of dogs and where occur and piss off the general public. And not to mention the daycares all over the U.K. that fill them with totally oversubscribed numbers of dogs, but no one sees it no one bats in eyelid because it’s behind closed doors. At least professional dog walkers are out there in the public. You can see what’s going on and see there’s no animals. You can see if the dogs are out of control or not.

okay, so much to show you guys what I do and how I do it. You’re barking up the wrong tree and don’t tar us all with the same brush

I have clients who are vets or veterinary nurses teachers rescue owners. Other Dog professionals famous actors, even they can all see what a valuable resource this is.

spanishviola · 02/02/2024 09:45

Fleeceflop · 01/02/2024 20:07

I really do think dog walkers shouldn’t be allowed to use public parks. They totally
Dominate a park near us and have turned into a no-go area for everyone else. Members of the public ought to be able to use parks without being hassled by dogs.

Agreed.

NotAnotherPylon · 02/02/2024 09:45

i rest my case.

OK😆

PennysLane · 02/02/2024 09:42

determinedtomakethiswork · 02/02/2024 09:35

I would've taken photos of the dog walkers and called the police to be honest. That is so dangerous.

Complete waste of time and resources. dog workers aren’t doing anything illegal.

If I saw the original posters reactive Dog off lead and out of control that might warrant phone calls to police as she’s already stipulated the dog is reactive and off lead.

PuddlesPityParty · 02/02/2024 09:42

@NotAnotherPylon how do you know they were using pack instincts, though? I’m not sure you quite know what it is and are just acting like a group of dogs = pack. Sorry that happened to you though, sounds scary.

PennysLane · 02/02/2024 09:41

NotAnotherPylon · 02/02/2024 09:18

But I’m 99% sure there is more to this than meets the eye.

Like what @PennysLane?

I'm not saying it isn't somewhat unusual, but we were chased by dogs acting as a pack, which came out of nowhere. This was many years ago when people let their pet dogs roam the streets. We were still talking about the absolute terror of it right into adulthood. I am just questioning the assertion that dogs no longer have a pack instinct. It's anecdotal, granted, but it was something that happened to me. I don't even care why or how to be honest.

Just like that, there was automatically something more to it. It was years ago when people let the dogs run on the street. i rest my case.

Potentialmadcatlady · 02/02/2024 09:36

Devilshands · 01/02/2024 20:48

Never met a ‘dog walker’ (i.e. one who claims to be a professional or is one) who wasn’t a twat.

Ultimately, if they’re not walking 10 dogs at once or they don’t have six dogs booked into a one hour slot and give them all 10 minutes each and leave them in the van for the rest of the time (which some near me regularly do) they’re not making money. They don’t hire fields as it eats into their profits.

Dog walkers don’t care about the dogs they walk. They care about the profit. You’d need your head read to use one IMO

Edited

I’m not a twat 😁 and I only take on one dog at a time ( two at the absolute most if I know them well and they have met before)
Some of us are decent and not in it for the profits but just to make enough to live off and the joy of it.
I would never send my own dogs to walk in a big pack or to ‘doggie daycare’.. no matter how good they are they let them run around almost feral. I totally disagree with the six dog limit- it would take a v strong person to handle six dogs if they got out of control.

Swizzlersandtwizzlers · 02/02/2024 09:36

lieselotte · 01/02/2024 20:26

During covid, when parkrun was suspended, I stopped going to the park to run because of exactly this. You'd get 4 dogwalkers meeting up with 4 dogs each. You couldn't go anywhere near.

Personally if I was paying someone to walk my dog I'd want them to walk my dog and not a whole pack. Nice work if you can get it!

That’s ridiculous. It’s so important for people to have access to green spaces and to be able to exercise outside if that’s what they want. It’s awful that people like you are being deterred from going to parks.

I think we need dog parks AND dog-free parks especially in urban areas where there is limited green spaces. Parks are being turned into toilets for dogs and a dangerous place for joggers and toddlers.

Dangerous dogs legislation states you must be in control of your dogs. If you have 5 dogs - and many of them are not yours - how can you claim you’re in control ?

determinedtomakethiswork · 02/02/2024 09:35

I would've taken photos of the dog walkers and called the police to be honest. That is so dangerous.

KreedKafer · 02/02/2024 09:28

So if five people were each walking two off-lead dogs each at the same time - which would be very normal in a lot of popular parks - do you think those dogs would form a pack?

Dogs that don’t live together don’t form ‘a pack’. Ten stray dogs would form a pack. Ten dogs who live together in a home might, although having people around them all the time tends to stop that dynamic.

Ten individual dogs being taken out for a walk by two people do not form a pack.

Ultimately, if your dogs are reactive, they are the ones who need to kept under close control, not the ten non-reactive dogs that are happily playing together and have no interest in yours. If your dogs bark and snap and react when they see non-aggressive dogs approach them in a normal way, your dogs are the aggressors and that is your problem to manage.

Also your own anger and tension and fear at seeing other dogs running free, even when they aren’t approaching yours, is something your own dogs will definitely pick up on.

NotAnotherPylon · 02/02/2024 09:18

But I’m 99% sure there is more to this than meets the eye.

Like what @PennysLane?

I'm not saying it isn't somewhat unusual, but we were chased by dogs acting as a pack, which came out of nowhere. This was many years ago when people let their pet dogs roam the streets. We were still talking about the absolute terror of it right into adulthood. I am just questioning the assertion that dogs no longer have a pack instinct. It's anecdotal, granted, but it was something that happened to me. I don't even care why or how to be honest.

PennysLane · 02/02/2024 08:02

And if you do post on social media this only serves to attempt to destroy someone’s reputation, business and income. They’ll be insured, with legal cover and hopefully will sue you if you do.

ad much as you don’t like it or approve, they’re doing absolutely nothing wrong or illegal.

PennysLane · 02/02/2024 08:00

EveryDayIsASchoolDayOnMN · 02/02/2024 07:11

Why don't you post on your local fb? It's a good way of getting idiots to realise people are not impressed with their behaviour.

Plus the people that are paying for this service would get to know what they are paying for, numbskulls who think 10 dogs off the leash is acceptable

Their customers already know. The customers recognise how valuable a professional dog walkers service is. It allows their dog to use the toilet, get exercised and socialised whilst they are at work or unable to do so themselves.

HavfrueDenizKisi · 02/02/2024 07:23

I'd have to agree OP. I avoid all parks, woodlands and rec areas now with my ddog as she is slightly nervous and I'm tired of off lead dogs who have owners who haven't trained them. See also people nattering while their dogs take massive dumps out of their eye line thus they don't clear the poo up.

EveryDayIsASchoolDayOnMN · 02/02/2024 07:11

Why don't you post on your local fb? It's a good way of getting idiots to realise people are not impressed with their behaviour.

Plus the people that are paying for this service would get to know what they are paying for, numbskulls who think 10 dogs off the leash is acceptable

PennysLane · 02/02/2024 07:09

somekittenmittens · 02/02/2024 03:39

Dogs do form packs, they bounce off each other's energy and will get more het up in a group larger than three. Maybe you've been lucky in the dogs you've walked but when dogs run or walk together they absolutely do form a pack and follow each other's actions. You can see it in street and feral dogs, they will naturally form roaming packs when together and that's when they will attack other dogs or other animals. They also have a dominance structure to said packs, you can watch anyone who does alot of work with stray dogs to see this behaviour, like Dev Naz's earlier videos on youtube.

There’s two separate arguments here. One about groups or more than three dogs. And one about street dogs.

  1. Has nothing to do with number of dogs. One, or even two dogs can be come over aroused and over stimulated. This can happen at the play park WITHOUT a professional dog walker and with regular pet owners. When people don’t understand dog body language- such as signs of stress/over arousal then dogs play wild, then can become ‘self employed.’ There’s growling. There’s whinging. There’s chasing. All very normal behaviour in dog play and learning but can appear scary to an average person. A good owner or professional dog walker will recognised these dings and stop or redirect play WELL before the animals become over aroused. During over arousal (if left to get to this stage) adverse behaviour is learned and engrained. THIS IS NOT A PACK
  2. street dogs- completely different. these are dogs who have been born and raised by other dogs/themselves with absolutely NO human interaction. They will form relationships with each other. But will not form packs. They are not wolves.

Anyone interested further in this topic should read the latest scientific information available. It’s fascinating. Even a simple google search will help.

PennysLane · 02/02/2024 07:00

NotAnotherPylon · 01/02/2024 23:04

Dogs in groups play, they interact but they do not form packs.

Ah right, so the 'group' of 7 or 8 dogs that chased me, my sister and our friend when we were kids, were playing. They charged at us, full force, and we honestly thought we were going to get mauled to death. We were close to home and managed to shut the gate, then the front door on them. Maybe ... they were wolves🤔

This post is so vague. Would be hard to tell. But I’m 99% sure there is more to this than meets the eye.

PennysLane · 02/02/2024 06:59

BigDogEnergy · 02/02/2024 04:05

Makes me think of the young woman (who I believe was a dog walker of some sort, potentially not officially in terms of an actual business, insured etc from memory) who was killed by the large group of dogs she was walking, including her own.

We've had some bad dog walker experiences but our current one is amazing. She will occasionally pair up compatible dogs if its of benefit to them (mine is a solo dog and he loves it) but usually it's one household at a time. She's worth her weight in gold!

This woman in question was mauled to death by her own dog. It was an XL bully.

Manyandyoucanwalkover · 02/02/2024 04:09

lightinthebox · 01/02/2024 20:29

Perhaps the dog walkers know how the dogs they regularly take care of react and behave, so weren’t concerned about them attacking or being dangerous.

Dogs running around and playing aren’t automatically dangerous and I’m fed up of this assumption. Mine runs around with her doggy pals, they aren’t a pack of bloodthirsty dogs intent on mauling everything in their path.

This ^ 💯.

Nothing bad has actually happened here.