Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you can't handle the children you've got you should stop having kids?

318 replies

Absolutelybloomingflabbergasted · 01/02/2024 18:10

I know this is subjective but, I wanted 3 kids and knew after 1 I wouldn't be able to handle a younger child and balance life effectively.

I'm sat on the train, and, this isn't the first occurrence.

A mother with 4 children, shouting at her baby, telling her she's naughty because she's upset and being a normal baby.

Yes, we all get stressed but she's blatantly lying to her, saying she needs to shut up as the train guards coming and doesn't want to hear her racket, threatening to throw her dummy in the bin for being bad. Saying she never should of taken them out, 'especially her' 'she's too bad to take out and always does this, she never learns and neither do I, next time she's staying home'

I understand parenthood is stressful, but now all the other kids are shouting at this poor child, who is still in a pram and looks no older than 1.5

I found toddlerhood the most stressful.

I understand pregnancy and children come unexpectedly but, I see this very frequently in my area, which is very poverty striken and there is not a great deal of support.

I feel so upset for this child.

I'm sick of seeing people having more children then they are phyiscally able to and then pretty much abusing them.

I came from a household that did similar and refuse to do this to not only myself but my children.

I know this will likely be conflicting but, I believe behaviour is echoed from the role model or parent, in general but especially in this case.

It makes me so sad.

OP posts:
VanLife33 · 01/02/2024 21:51

@Unexpectedlysinglemum I would never speak to my kids like that either ...
Doesn't mean I have to agree with the op"s judgements or comments she has made on this thread

Mariposistaaa · 01/02/2024 21:50

@Absolutelybloomingflabbergasted you and I could be friends.
This woman has no right being a mother. How dare she threaten to lamp her own innocent infant? I would have taken to my phone and pretended to make a call to the police asking them to meet the train as there is a woman threatening to harm a tiny baby on board and watched her shit herself.
If it were a man threatening and shouting at an infant, he would no be 'supported' - he would be pillaged. She has chosen to reproduce 4 times, I doubt she was forced!

Absolutelybloomingflabbergasted · 01/02/2024 21:49

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/02/2024 21:27

Um what? Do you think only one person could disagree with you? The arrogance!

I dont think that at all, its just quite ironic that you portray your words almost identically.

It's been an interesting evening!

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 01/02/2024 21:49

OP, she sounds really unpleasant.

You're not coming across well here, because you've made it all about you and your issues. Writing how it must be about the number of children and pointing out that you've stopped at one, as though that makes your judgement better.

It's not really about the number of children. She shouldn't be threatening to hit her baby. First baby, fourth baby. And I don't think you can demonstrate that she was doing it because she has too many kids.

I don't think using the threat of the train guard is abusive with older kids btw, but it's really odd to use it with a child too young to understand.

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/02/2024 21:46

PodgePie · 01/02/2024 21:42

Absolutely baffled by the posters condoning this vile behaviour and suggested OP should have offered support.

There are many people for whom large families aren’t the right path but this doesn’t stop it happening - whether that’s down to a lack of education, naivety or stupidity doesn’t really matter - the only people really suffering are those poor children who OP saw today.

We all have bad days, we all struggle with parenting at times but if you’re able to talk to your toddler like that on a public train, chances are you’re treating them even more alarmingly in private.

Has anyone condoned the behaviour?

I think some of us are just a bit repelled by OP’s need to start a thread about how rubbish a random parent is, and then her follow-up accusations that anyone not willing to join in roundly slagging off mums ‘like that’ (it was clear she had a whole group in mind) are secret abusers.

It all just stinks.

brunettemic · 01/02/2024 21:45

Ignoring the example given as I think it’s likely unfair, yes I do tend to agree. I have friends who have 4 kids and a lot of the time they complain about never having money because of the kids, how tiring they are etc…and I internally roll my eyes.

Absolutelybloomingflabbergasted · 01/02/2024 21:44

IncompleteSenten · 01/02/2024 21:36

Ideally everyone would make logical choices based on their circumstances, wider societal circumstances and based on a good insight into their strengths and weaknesses.

Nobody would get into a bad situation, stay in one, do things that weren't right for them, know their limits etc etc.

But that's not how humans are. We don't operate like that. Most of us don't even have the ability to look critically at ourselves and be truly honest and objective about what we can and cannot achieve.

Certainly agree with you!

OP posts:
Absolutelybloomingflabbergasted · 01/02/2024 21:43

Boomboom22 · 01/02/2024 21:32

I don't believe @Canthave2manycats does work in safeguarding. As if any teacher, social worker etc seeing this would call the police. She didn't actually do anything illegal nasty as she was, noone is going to act on that report. And those in safeguarding/ teaching / sw know this.

Also weird comments about not judging. This lefty identity it's good to be the underclass stuff isn't actually non judgement. It's damming children to dreadful life's because in your middle class bubble you think its just a different value set or way of life.
But op knows the damage, she is literally from this type of family, or actually sounds a fair bit worse, herself so perhaps give over on the 'I'm such a good person I wouldn't judge but I would try to have her arrested' bs.

It's coming from somewhere, I'm unsure where or why it's so direct at me!

But thank you, I just assume they aren't actually reading my replies, as they just can't seem to grasp that? Or maybe I have just come across totally wrong!!

OP posts:
LifeIsHardAlways · 01/02/2024 21:42

Completely agree with you OP, guarantee she’ll be far worse in private.

People like that shouldn’t keep banging out children they can’t manage.

PodgePie · 01/02/2024 21:42

Absolutely baffled by the posters condoning this vile behaviour and suggested OP should have offered support.

There are many people for whom large families aren’t the right path but this doesn’t stop it happening - whether that’s down to a lack of education, naivety or stupidity doesn’t really matter - the only people really suffering are those poor children who OP saw today.

We all have bad days, we all struggle with parenting at times but if you’re able to talk to your toddler like that on a public train, chances are you’re treating them even more alarmingly in private.

Absolutelybloomingflabbergasted · 01/02/2024 21:41

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/02/2024 21:40

There’s a difference between recognising that a behaviour is poor or damaging and just prattling on about how awful a woman on a train is.

Isn’t there a saying about not looking down in someone unless you’re helping them up? OP would do well to think on that.

Can you actually note the last time I mentioned the parent on the train? My frustration since has been direct at society or those defending such behaviour or accusing me of being at fault?

OP posts:
GreenAppleCrumble · 01/02/2024 21:40

Boomboom22 · 01/02/2024 21:32

I don't believe @Canthave2manycats does work in safeguarding. As if any teacher, social worker etc seeing this would call the police. She didn't actually do anything illegal nasty as she was, noone is going to act on that report. And those in safeguarding/ teaching / sw know this.

Also weird comments about not judging. This lefty identity it's good to be the underclass stuff isn't actually non judgement. It's damming children to dreadful life's because in your middle class bubble you think its just a different value set or way of life.
But op knows the damage, she is literally from this type of family, or actually sounds a fair bit worse, herself so perhaps give over on the 'I'm such a good person I wouldn't judge but I would try to have her arrested' bs.

There’s a difference between recognising that a behaviour is poor or damaging and just prattling on about how awful a woman on a train is.

Isn’t there a saying about not looking down in someone unless you’re helping them up? OP would do well to think on that.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 01/02/2024 21:39

VanLife33 · 01/02/2024 18:16

You've seen a tiny snippet of this woman's day ....

You have no idea how she parents 24/7

I think you're being quite judgmental seeing as this train ride is all you have to go on ..

I'm team OP here I would NEVER talk to my child like that. The train mum clearly doesn't have capacity for empathy or understanding of what is developmentally appropriate expectation of a baby and needs help and support from government agencies

IncompleteSenten · 01/02/2024 21:36

Ideally everyone would make logical choices based on their circumstances, wider societal circumstances and based on a good insight into their strengths and weaknesses.

Nobody would get into a bad situation, stay in one, do things that weren't right for them, know their limits etc etc.

But that's not how humans are. We don't operate like that. Most of us don't even have the ability to look critically at ourselves and be truly honest and objective about what we can and cannot achieve.

Boomboom22 · 01/02/2024 21:32

I don't believe @Canthave2manycats does work in safeguarding. As if any teacher, social worker etc seeing this would call the police. She didn't actually do anything illegal nasty as she was, noone is going to act on that report. And those in safeguarding/ teaching / sw know this.

Also weird comments about not judging. This lefty identity it's good to be the underclass stuff isn't actually non judgement. It's damming children to dreadful life's because in your middle class bubble you think its just a different value set or way of life.
But op knows the damage, she is literally from this type of family, or actually sounds a fair bit worse, herself so perhaps give over on the 'I'm such a good person I wouldn't judge but I would try to have her arrested' bs.

LodiDodi · 01/02/2024 21:28

This is similar to a woman I saw on the bus thr other day who had 3 but it sounded more like 10. She was doing her best bless her but the shrieking, dear God the shrieking. I think I would have gauged my own eardrums out

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/02/2024 21:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Um what? Do you think only one person could disagree with you? The arrogance!

Hereforthebunfights · 01/02/2024 21:21

You sound paranoid and in need of therapy.

Pickles2023 · 01/02/2024 21:16

She says the baby has embaressed her for being fussy...id be more embaressed that i spoke like that in public to a baby that cant communicate 😭😭

I can't relate i guess though (only have one, i find that hard enough 😅) , but i generally feel embaressement more so at my own reactions then others..as my reactions are the only ones i can control.

Absolutelybloomingflabbergasted · 01/02/2024 21:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ghentsummer · 01/02/2024 21:13

VanLife33 · 01/02/2024 20:53

How would you have felt as a child if an outsider came over and showed you some support?
Or had a word with your mother, about her behaviour towards you
You'd never forget them

She probably would never have forgotten the abuse her mum gave her when they got behind closed doors either.

If a parent is willing to be abusive in public then they will be the same or worse at home. And they don't suddenly realise the error of their ways because someone spoke to them about it, they just label that person as an interfering cow who should keep her nose out.

Absolutelybloomingflabbergasted · 01/02/2024 21:13

MeMySonAnd1 · 01/02/2024 20:44

I don’t give a hoot at what happened to her or her day. She is verbally abusing a toddler and she is
the grown up here.

If she behaves like that in front of other people, go figure what she does behind doors.

Thank you!

OP posts:
GreenAppleCrumble · 01/02/2024 21:12

This thread is pure poison.

Just an excuse to judge, judge and judge some more. I don’t believe for a second OP was genuinely worried for the children. The bit about the potential smack was a shameless (made-up) drip-feed.

OP’s early comments accusing people of secretly being abusers were beyond the pale.

If anyone dares to suggest that this was just a snapshot (true) or that the family might be having a really bad day (possible), they’re accused by a snide OP of being a shit parent who probably hits their kids.

Reminds me of nothing so much as The Crucible tbh. As long as you’re the one pointing the finger, you’re ok.

Absolutelybloomingflabbergasted · 01/02/2024 21:11

bakewellbride · 01/02/2024 20:53

The trouble is op where do u draw the line? Do we have to be perfect all the time?

I - not very often but very occasionally- snap at my kids. I'm human. So I suppose if you saw me at a glance in that situation you'd think I shouldve stopped at 1 and why did I have 2 etc. Your logic is a bit of a slippery slope.

Certainly not, but as the train journey escalated, the more wept out. I think there's a vast difference between being 'perfect' and verbally abusing/threatning a child?

The other children joined in?

As though it is the babies fault?

Obviously my view is of a snippet, I'm not stating its not, my comment wasn't directly to her but an overall view of why the situations continue and how to provide actual support.

OP posts:
Absolutelybloomingflabbergasted · 01/02/2024 21:08

VanLife33 · 01/02/2024 20:57

In hindsight ..
Do you feel good about the decision you made today ?

Yes, I don't believe I've done anything wrong apart from vent my frustrations.

I believe most can understand and provide respectful responses back, a select few, yourself included, are providing quite personal and bordering/insulting comments to myself.

You're either not reading or just simply not understanding what I'm trying to say.

OP posts: