Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Desk and office given away

337 replies

Proseccoprincess33 · 01/02/2024 13:53

I am due to return to work following maternity leave next month. I am anxious about going back but this has been further intensified by the fact my office has been given away during my time off. This has been my office for 5 years. Not only has it been given away permanently but I have not been allocated another office or even a desk. I only became aware of this because some colleagues alerted me to it and I then contacted my manager to discuss it.

She is off site and very hands off so we rarely see her if at all. In fact I have never met her. So had I not been given this heads up by my colleagues I would have been coming into work to see my office and desk occupied and no place for me to sit on my first day back.

I am part of a multidisciplinary team and I manage one of the departments. Therefore having my own desk and office is so important to supervise staff and the nature of our work is very sensitive so privacy is a vital. But at this stage I'd settle for a desk of my own.

I am having a meeting with my manager about this very soon and have found out she has invited 2 very senior managers along also which is intimidating and not helpful to the anxiety I am experiencing. I think she fears I will be very unhappy and so has her reinforcements ready to tell me tough sh1t.

Her solution so far has been that they'll slot me into a desk somewhere when other staff are off....ie hot desking.

AIBU that I am so upset about this and want to fight for a resolution? Any advice from anyone who has been in a similar situation would be much appreciated.

Thank you 😊

OP posts:
Spirallingdownwards · 03/02/2024 08:40

Proseccoprincess33 · 01/02/2024 16:50

I get that hot desking works in most offices and that is fab but I am having confidential conversations every hour of every day. I'd be trying to book rooms on the hour every hour. Also it is not the done thing in our work. I'd be the only one hot desking with every single other person having their own desk.

And if I hadn't gone on mat leave that desk would still be mine, as it has been for the past 5 years. If I was on sick leave it would never have happened so I don't see why mat leave is any different. Or even if they'd had a solution for my return I wouldn't mind. I'm not attached to the desk, I just need space to work. Also they aren't even sure if there will be any desks for me to use one of the days.

I am afraid I have to disagree that if you hadn't gone on maternity leave the desk would still be yours. You say that the office and desk has been given to an entirely different department. It was adjudged that they needed that space.

Further part of your complaint is that you weren't informed. Perhaps they were working up to a solution for your return before your colleagues decided for some reason to come to you to tell you.

Perhaps the reason they have asked other managers to be there is so that there are witnesses to whatever conversation there is.

It seems to me they haven't even had the chance to put forward what the new working method and desk situation will be before you have gone steaming in. You simply don't know yet that you won't have your own desk yet or space because you aren't back and perhaps it will be one of your other colleagues giving up space. I would question the motives of the colleague who tipped you off. Perhaps they were worried their space was going to go to you so are stirring so that it is you that kicks off?

You have over a month until you go back so this may not have been something they had thought lf or addressee until you were about to return.. However now your colleague has wound you up and you have gone in full pelt they are probably expecting you to cry discrimination before they even had thought to find a solution. No wonder others are being brought to the meeting.

dammit88 · 03/02/2024 08:27

It's also quite unusual to have a job share that you work the same day as? Does that mean one day a week there is no manager? I wonder if that is an issue for the senior team too that they might want to discuss?

dammit88 · 03/02/2024 08:26

If one of the other team members is on maternity leave too, I wonder if they are aware she is wanting to return part time and thinking you can share a space?

Space is a massive premium in hospitals these days... I honestly wouldn't jump the gun. I often find managers are bit last minute as there are so many acute competing priorities in the NHS and it is likely they would sort this for you but it wouldn't happen until just before your return.

ememem84 · 03/02/2024 08:20

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 03/02/2024 01:32

So how do you hotdesk with a trackball or a vertical keyboard or a specialist chair?

Hotdesking is inherently discriminatory against disabled people and the sooner employers stop this nonsense, the better.

Edited

not the point but how does the verticals keyboard work?

@Proseccoprincess33 id be asking why you’re the only one expected to hit desk and whether you’ll have a desk assessment at whoever’s desk you’re sat at. You’d need to know who was in and out so you can make sure you’ve actually got somewhere to work. What if all staff are in on the same day -

dhs work recently moved into a new office. With desk capacity for 60% of staff. Over 80% of stuff were in the other day. Caused absolute chaos.

TheLiloAndTheSlowCooker · 03/02/2024 08:09

If you are the only one hot desking and everyone else has a set desk then this does sound like discrimination, although I am no expert. I've been in a situation where I was one of a handful of people expected to hot desk when all others had a fixed desk - it had an unexpectedly significant impact on my well-being, and although it was a decade ago I still remember the frustration and feeling of not belonging properly to the team. When everyone is hot desking it's a completely different feeling.

Zonder · 03/02/2024 08:08

So glad you're in a union. Too often in cases like this people suddenly realise they need support.

converseandjeans · 03/02/2024 08:03

@Proseccoprincess33

I would hate having to hotdesk. Can you speak to the manager of the person who is in your office? Sorry but if it's been your work space for 5 years then it's reasonable to expect it to stay that way for you, your job share & your team.

I would be suspicious about the fact that there was nobody taken on to cover your maternity & now you have no office & no desk. Where are they expecting you to sit?

If there is a bookabie space then just book it every time you're in so that you have a place to work.

MeMySonAnd1 · 03/02/2024 07:56

Floopani · 01/02/2024 14:43

Having no desk where there is not a formal hotdesking for all solution is an absolute nightmare. You'll spend a significant amount of time either trying to find somewhere to work or somewhere private for meetings. This is definitely one to push back on. It happened to me in a new job and had a significant impact on my wellbeing.

This. If the place and computers are set for hot desking no problem, but if you have to set up the desk and computer every morning depending on who is off, your mental health will suffer with the every morning frustration of sorting up the computer, make space in the desk and feeling like invading other person’s space. Your productivity will plummet.

Hope the meeting is ok but I would be considering getting legal advice as you may being penalised for going in maternity leave and that is discrimination.

Crazycrazylady · 03/02/2024 07:54

Honestly op. Clearly desks and offices are at a premium , it was never likely that your desk would sit there idly waiting for your return .
I think raising concerns is fine but I don't think you have a leg to stand out demanding a specific desk and office as no one is any organisation is entitled to that that.

Inefficient · 03/02/2024 07:47

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 07:15

May I summarise:

You are about to return from mat leave

You were p/t before mat leave (3 days) and now a formal job share partner has been appointed (2 days)

You work in a team, comprising 4 full-time equivalent posts and 5 people.

It's an NHS Trust and your team is responsible for patients receiving a particular type of care (not sure if any of you are patient facing or how much team members are at their desks)

You manage the other team members.

Your role was not covered when you were on maternity.

The four/five staff have previously been split between two offices and now have only one.

Things I am not clear about:

How many of you also work hybrid?

Whether there is bookable space?

If you all deal with patients why you need to work confidentially and why there isn't a culture of respecting confidentiality?

You talk of managing the team, are you on a higher grade and who managed them when you were away?

On the basis of the information I think has been provided, there is no obligation to provide you with a dedicated desk, office, etc, unless it is written into your contract. Your colleagues have also moved office and are participating in this arrangement so it is not discriminatory - when you are all back and there are 2 desks between 4/5 you will all be hot decking.

You are not returning on different terms and conditions therefore there is no sex discrimination.

More broadly:
If your work could be covered without replacing you when you were on mat leave it is an indication your unit/service is overstaffed. Rather shocking if all we hear about lack of resources and workloads in the NHS is true. If this is so, then it is reasonable there should be a business case to review the service.

Overall @Proseccoprincess33 you sound entitled and inflexible and possibly difficult to manage. I think you should go with the flow, be collaborative, and be mindful that at work it is not your desk or your office, it is the organisation's and they can allocate as they see fit.

If there is a business case in the offing, and it sounds as though there should be, you are doing yourself no favours. A business case is likely to be implemented in accordance with a management of change procedure and any risks will be dotted off.

I presume you are a nurse? If so, there will always be work for you and always an income so it is difficult to entirely see why there would be a problem if there had to be a redeployment.

If there is redeployment the management of change procedure may indicate selection criteria: attendance, performance, appraisal record, etc. Only you know those details.

I'd be open minded and exercise some flexibility if I were you.

I would support you over the meeting however but would like to know who requested it. If it is a formal meeting you should have been given the reason for it and given the opportunity to be accompanied. It is more likely to be informal as were it formal, HR should have advised. It sounds as though your manager feels they need support at the meeting and there could be a myriad reasons why.

Reading between the lines I suspect you may not be the easiest employee to manage. It sounds like your manager has not sought advice from HR but then again NHS HR is a unique beast.

Senior HR by the way.

‘If your work could be covered without replacing you when you were on mat leave it is an indication your unit/service is overstaffed. Rather shocking if all we hear about lack of resources and workloads in the NHS is true’

Ha, this made me laugh. I know from plenty of your other posts that you despise the NHS. But when people go on maternity leave there is often no cover because they simply cannot find people to do the cover as has happened to one of our posts recently. It is often impossible to recruit suitable staff. And sometimes they also use the opportunity to save money for any weeks they can. Don’t assume that it is overstaffed! The cover may have been minimal.

Magicmonster · 03/02/2024 07:46

Pretty sure this is unlawful discrimination under the equality act

Kittylala · 03/02/2024 07:43

And write everything down on paper so you're calm and confident- all the points you made here and ask her to address them especially why she's been emailing your personal account. Use the meeting in your favour.

Kittylala · 03/02/2024 07:39

How stupid she will look when you explain that privacy is vital.

Nutellatea · 03/02/2024 07:23

Hi OP. This exact thing happend to me, so I know exactly how you feel. On the face of it I felt like it wasn't a 'big deal' and I felt awkward making a fuss, but it's what it represents. Zero respect or consideration. Especially when you're the only person expected to adapt.

Sadly in the end I moved to a similar job in another area and the difference has been night and day. It just reflects what your team and manager think of you imo. Hope you have better luck resolving it than me!

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 07:15

May I summarise:

You are about to return from mat leave

You were p/t before mat leave (3 days) and now a formal job share partner has been appointed (2 days)

You work in a team, comprising 4 full-time equivalent posts and 5 people.

It's an NHS Trust and your team is responsible for patients receiving a particular type of care (not sure if any of you are patient facing or how much team members are at their desks)

You manage the other team members.

Your role was not covered when you were on maternity.

The four/five staff have previously been split between two offices and now have only one.

Things I am not clear about:

How many of you also work hybrid?

Whether there is bookable space?

If you all deal with patients why you need to work confidentially and why there isn't a culture of respecting confidentiality?

You talk of managing the team, are you on a higher grade and who managed them when you were away?

On the basis of the information I think has been provided, there is no obligation to provide you with a dedicated desk, office, etc, unless it is written into your contract. Your colleagues have also moved office and are participating in this arrangement so it is not discriminatory - when you are all back and there are 2 desks between 4/5 you will all be hot decking.

You are not returning on different terms and conditions therefore there is no sex discrimination.

More broadly:
If your work could be covered without replacing you when you were on mat leave it is an indication your unit/service is overstaffed. Rather shocking if all we hear about lack of resources and workloads in the NHS is true. If this is so, then it is reasonable there should be a business case to review the service.

Overall @Proseccoprincess33 you sound entitled and inflexible and possibly difficult to manage. I think you should go with the flow, be collaborative, and be mindful that at work it is not your desk or your office, it is the organisation's and they can allocate as they see fit.

If there is a business case in the offing, and it sounds as though there should be, you are doing yourself no favours. A business case is likely to be implemented in accordance with a management of change procedure and any risks will be dotted off.

I presume you are a nurse? If so, there will always be work for you and always an income so it is difficult to entirely see why there would be a problem if there had to be a redeployment.

If there is redeployment the management of change procedure may indicate selection criteria: attendance, performance, appraisal record, etc. Only you know those details.

I'd be open minded and exercise some flexibility if I were you.

I would support you over the meeting however but would like to know who requested it. If it is a formal meeting you should have been given the reason for it and given the opportunity to be accompanied. It is more likely to be informal as were it formal, HR should have advised. It sounds as though your manager feels they need support at the meeting and there could be a myriad reasons why.

Reading between the lines I suspect you may not be the easiest employee to manage. It sounds like your manager has not sought advice from HR but then again NHS HR is a unique beast.

Senior HR by the way.

Skodacool · 03/02/2024 07:05

SecondUsername4me · 01/02/2024 14:47

Contact Pregnant Then Screwed for a chat.

And ACAS

Fitandfree · 03/02/2024 06:46

To those who can't get their head around OP's requirements for her clinical and managerial role - don't be suprised in the future, when you, your family, or friends, find there is no palliative care for you/them. Support for the dying, their family, the staff who support them, and the students being trained to join these teams in the future, don't matter it seems. It is essential you have a union representative OP. Also, WFH isn't possible, when you have student with you all day - they can't come home with you. My blood is boiling.

Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 06:25

TBOM · 02/02/2024 22:57

No problem, MN isn’t always the most user friendly interface. Have you asked your manager what HR advice is on this? Innocuous question but suspect she hasn’t thought about anything beyond her own convenience.

That's a good idea. Thank you 😊

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 06:24

AutumnLeavesOften · 02/02/2024 23:35

This happened to me.

They said I could sit with the Admin Team, I am of course female and so were the Admin Team, but I was a Manager, with staff and people responsibilities

My position was very shortly after made redundant.

I however was in a Union, and not only had they given my office away when i
I was on Maternity Leave, but they had also given my job to TWO men while I was away.

It went to mediation, and they were told they had to find me a new job, within the company, I managed to do that at another site.

I was recompensed.

I should have asked for more really.

But join a union, they were very helpful for me.

@AutumnLeavesOften that is just awful. I'm so sorry you went through this but so glad you got some justice from it all ❤️

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 06:21

Christmasnutcracker · 02/02/2024 23:55

This happened to me. I was on annual leave for a week during pregnancy. When I returned to my desk, somebody else was sitting on my chair!
Nobody had told me. Hot desking wasn't a thing then.

I remember feeling very humiliated. The people I had previously sat with didn't know where to look when I arrived in. The person at my desk looked confused and embarrassed.
Manager at the time asked me to just sit wherever there was a free desk.
Shortly afterwards I was asked to move departments so they had actually given my job away with the argument that I would be leaving for a year in a few months anyway.....

A few months later, the manager at the time, chatted to me and embarrassedly said that it was handled badly at the time. No shit! I think they didn't want me on their team because they expected people to stay late, until 7pm, frequently and I never stayed later than 6pm.

It was embarrassing and humiliating for me. I had taken such pride in my work before then.

Awww @Christmasnutcracker that is so awful. I am so so sorry to hear that. That must have been so so difficult. I too would have been so embarrassed going in and realising my desk had been given away so I am glad my colleagues told me. They were embarrassed about it too, I could tell. It really leaves you feeling under valued as a staff member and person.

I hope your move has proved to be a positive one ❤️

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 06:17

PurpleFlower1983 · 03/02/2024 06:11

Not covering your MAT leave and removing your office is a definitely indicator that they are reducing numbers in this area I would say. Def take a Union rep as this could be a precursor to redundancy talks.

Thank you. I appreciate this and will Def contact union. I have a permanent contract with the trust so would not be made jobless but it is definitely worth considering how they are moving forward with the team and the changes that may be planned.

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 06:15

Hankunamatata · 03/02/2024 00:31

Is the job share a new thing or on place before maternity leave? If so where your job share partner been working and the two other members of staff you mention if the office you all use has been taken away?
(Sorry if u have said and I missed it)

No worries. There were two offices. Both had two desks. The job share is a new thing but I was part time before I went off. It's just the other part of me was not in post yet. So one office housed the other team members and the plan was for the job share to move into the office with me. The office that's now gone. So currently job share and one member of team are in the other office and the other team member is on mat leave and hopefully we will have some resolution before her return which is very soon.

OP posts:
PurpleFlower1983 · 03/02/2024 06:11

Not covering your MAT leave and removing your office is a definitely indicator that they are reducing numbers in this area I would say. Def take a Union rep as this could be a precursor to redundancy talks.

Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 06:11

Mumma1822 · 03/02/2024 00:46

I agree, I would not attend the meeting unless you have union representation in the call with you. I’m so sorry that your MAT leave has had added stress I really hope you get everything sorted out. ❤

Thank you for this. I will definitely contact the union. 😊

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 06:10

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 03/02/2024 00:32

My biggest concern is that the lack of an office/work space is not the main issue here, and the OP is missing the signs that something else may be afoot. Setting up a meeting which includes 2 more senior managers, as well as not needing maternity cover for over a year may well mean that the OPs role no longer really exists.
Make sure you take along union representation and ask for an agenda and ask what is the main purpose of the meeting.

Thanks for this. I have considered this. But the non cover of mat leave is not new. It's happened a few times before over the years. And means stat support functions have not been adhered to. This is the first it has happened to me and I did manage to get another manager to try and link in with the team to offer support in my absence but that is less than ideal.

I will ask for agenda and contact union. Thank you 😊

OP posts: