Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Desk and office given away

337 replies

Proseccoprincess33 · 01/02/2024 13:53

I am due to return to work following maternity leave next month. I am anxious about going back but this has been further intensified by the fact my office has been given away during my time off. This has been my office for 5 years. Not only has it been given away permanently but I have not been allocated another office or even a desk. I only became aware of this because some colleagues alerted me to it and I then contacted my manager to discuss it.

She is off site and very hands off so we rarely see her if at all. In fact I have never met her. So had I not been given this heads up by my colleagues I would have been coming into work to see my office and desk occupied and no place for me to sit on my first day back.

I am part of a multidisciplinary team and I manage one of the departments. Therefore having my own desk and office is so important to supervise staff and the nature of our work is very sensitive so privacy is a vital. But at this stage I'd settle for a desk of my own.

I am having a meeting with my manager about this very soon and have found out she has invited 2 very senior managers along also which is intimidating and not helpful to the anxiety I am experiencing. I think she fears I will be very unhappy and so has her reinforcements ready to tell me tough sh1t.

Her solution so far has been that they'll slot me into a desk somewhere when other staff are off....ie hot desking.

AIBU that I am so upset about this and want to fight for a resolution? Any advice from anyone who has been in a similar situation would be much appreciated.

Thank you 😊

OP posts:
wronginalltherightways · 03/02/2024 10:11

Bookworm39 · 02/02/2024 20:52

Definitely get your union rep along - I did this in a reshuffle (NHS) as I have a disabled child I need to support so was working part time and flexibly. I did not warn them in advance I was doing so (as per union advice) and the manager's face when I walked in with the union rep was a picture I have remembered for a long time! The union rep was excellent and knew their stuff and helped on my behalf. They also advised me to draw up a list of issues in writing. I think the management were expecting me to roll over and instead I ended up with an addendum added to my contract to support flexible work patterns. After that I always asked for union rep support - they know their stuff and managers suddenly realise they can't get away with all the s**t they were going to pull.

Great story.

Definitely bring your union rep, OP. It's why you have them!

Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 10:08

ExpressCheckout · 03/02/2024 10:01

I don't want to be seen as being difficult. I just want a desk and a space to call my own.

Sorry OP but this is now normal.

I used to have an office to myself, but now we're all in a large open plan office. I do have 'my own' desk, but we have to clear them at the end of the day due to GDPR etc., and although we don't officially hot desk, people on occasion do use 'my' desk. And, yes, all of the meetings I have are confidential.

It was new at the time, and a bit annoying, but you will adapt.

Even a desk that I know is available every day I'm in is enough. But I'm not even getting that. I'm happy as long as I have somewhere to work.

OP posts:
DoILookThrilled · 03/02/2024 10:07

Fitandfree · 03/02/2024 09:46

She hasn't asked for a shrine - she's asking to be provided with the resources she needs to do her job, now that she is returning to work. She doesn't work on a ward - unless the departments you are talking about, do exactly her role, you can't compare. Also, it's not a race to the bottom.

I never said she worked on a ward and l know she doesn’t work on a ward, l said l used to work on a ward. It was the mentality about things being “mine” by the patients on the ward that reminded me of the OP. When they don’t actually belong to them. I totally agree she should have the resources to work as that’s reasonable, it’s the there being no changes and lm special / different etc that isn’t. I think l can compare health teams trying to assist and support patients with limited space and resources. It’s not a race to the bottom but it’s important to be realistic that the NHS is buckling at the seams. It’s not a wealthy company with the real estate and money to dole out offices to everyone who wants them. Like l said some people have no office space at all, not even a meeting room. These are active busy workers who are not off on maternity leave

Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 10:05

@Fitandfree thank you so much, I really appreciate your understanding. I actually cannot believe how much abuse I have gotten because I want a desk to just put my head down and get on with my job. Is that really what the world has come to that people think a desk to do your work is entitled and that you should basically put up and shut up.

As someone who feels vulnerable and upset on my return to work some of the absolutely horrible messages on here and lack of any kind of compassion make me sad about the world my kids will grow up in.

I don't mind people giving their thoughts but the personal attacks from the keyboard warriors is something else. I too hope your loved ones never find themselves in a situation that the patients I work with do and as a result of hot desking or inappropriate accomodation the staff member is unable to support you to the fullest when you are at one of the lowest points in your life.

OP posts:
Fitandfree · 03/02/2024 10:02

It's not hot desking if everyone else has a desk, except you.

ExpressCheckout · 03/02/2024 10:01

I don't want to be seen as being difficult. I just want a desk and a space to call my own.

Sorry OP but this is now normal.

I used to have an office to myself, but now we're all in a large open plan office. I do have 'my own' desk, but we have to clear them at the end of the day due to GDPR etc., and although we don't officially hot desk, people on occasion do use 'my' desk. And, yes, all of the meetings I have are confidential.

It was new at the time, and a bit annoying, but you will adapt.

Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 09:59

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 07:15

May I summarise:

You are about to return from mat leave

You were p/t before mat leave (3 days) and now a formal job share partner has been appointed (2 days)

You work in a team, comprising 4 full-time equivalent posts and 5 people.

It's an NHS Trust and your team is responsible for patients receiving a particular type of care (not sure if any of you are patient facing or how much team members are at their desks)

You manage the other team members.

Your role was not covered when you were on maternity.

The four/five staff have previously been split between two offices and now have only one.

Things I am not clear about:

How many of you also work hybrid?

Whether there is bookable space?

If you all deal with patients why you need to work confidentially and why there isn't a culture of respecting confidentiality?

You talk of managing the team, are you on a higher grade and who managed them when you were away?

On the basis of the information I think has been provided, there is no obligation to provide you with a dedicated desk, office, etc, unless it is written into your contract. Your colleagues have also moved office and are participating in this arrangement so it is not discriminatory - when you are all back and there are 2 desks between 4/5 you will all be hot decking.

You are not returning on different terms and conditions therefore there is no sex discrimination.

More broadly:
If your work could be covered without replacing you when you were on mat leave it is an indication your unit/service is overstaffed. Rather shocking if all we hear about lack of resources and workloads in the NHS is true. If this is so, then it is reasonable there should be a business case to review the service.

Overall @Proseccoprincess33 you sound entitled and inflexible and possibly difficult to manage. I think you should go with the flow, be collaborative, and be mindful that at work it is not your desk or your office, it is the organisation's and they can allocate as they see fit.

If there is a business case in the offing, and it sounds as though there should be, you are doing yourself no favours. A business case is likely to be implemented in accordance with a management of change procedure and any risks will be dotted off.

I presume you are a nurse? If so, there will always be work for you and always an income so it is difficult to entirely see why there would be a problem if there had to be a redeployment.

If there is redeployment the management of change procedure may indicate selection criteria: attendance, performance, appraisal record, etc. Only you know those details.

I'd be open minded and exercise some flexibility if I were you.

I would support you over the meeting however but would like to know who requested it. If it is a formal meeting you should have been given the reason for it and given the opportunity to be accompanied. It is more likely to be informal as were it formal, HR should have advised. It sounds as though your manager feels they need support at the meeting and there could be a myriad reasons why.

Reading between the lines I suspect you may not be the easiest employee to manage. It sounds like your manager has not sought advice from HR but then again NHS HR is a unique beast.

Senior HR by the way.

This message was brutal and unnecessary. I have never once complained to management about anything in all my years in my post. Having a space to work is a basic requirement and I'm not surprised you're in HR....hr have always been useless when anyone needs support! I am one if the most supportive managers and I expect a little support from my immune in return.

As for your overview it is incorrect. There are 4 staff overall. So 2 of us will eventually be in this situ. The 2 that went on mat leave and no other department is expected to do this. Only the social work department ...not nursing!

To call me entitled because I am asking for the basics to do my job is a joke and I would expect you are quite bullying in your role and very unsupportive.

As an employee who is feeling emotional about returning to work and vulnerable your response is horrid and I feel so sorry for anyone you supposedly support.

OP posts:
Fitandfree · 03/02/2024 09:49

Crazycrazylady · 03/02/2024 07:54

Honestly op. Clearly desks and offices are at a premium , it was never likely that your desk would sit there idly waiting for your return .
I think raising concerns is fine but I don't think you have a leg to stand out demanding a specific desk and office as no one is any organisation is entitled to that that.

She's not demanding a specific desk or office - just the resources she needs to effectively carry out her role

Fitandfree · 03/02/2024 09:46

DoILookThrilled · 03/02/2024 09:34

This makes me think of when l used to work on wards and patients would argue about which chair on the ward belonged to them. Ward manager said people were obviously allowed to reserve space on the chairs they had brought with them at the point of admission. No one had brought a chair with them so their weren’t “theirs”. The chair, desk and office belong to the trust. At the trust l work at space is at such a premium some entire teams have no office space at all. So why should an office be left as a shrine to one person who might take 12-18 months or even more off? Most people would love their own but it’s just not realistic.

She hasn't asked for a shrine - she's asking to be provided with the resources she needs to do her job, now that she is returning to work. She doesn't work on a ward - unless the departments you are talking about, do exactly her role, you can't compare. Also, it's not a race to the bottom.

Figgygal · 03/02/2024 09:45

The workplace is changing, offices are downsizing and people who previously had their own offices are having to adjust to working differently. My entire very sensitive function across the country works in open plan, some locations together in a group of desks others right on the floor plate previously with offices or fixed desks. We protested, argued it wouldn't work but it does with some planning occasionally.
The communication is poor yes but you've no idea of their plans ahead of your return and it sounds like due to other internal moves this isn't even linked to mat leave it was operationally necessary and could have happened if you were there anyway.
I'd certainly establish some more facts before yelling discrimination

DoILookThrilled · 03/02/2024 09:34

This makes me think of when l used to work on wards and patients would argue about which chair on the ward belonged to them. Ward manager said people were obviously allowed to reserve space on the chairs they had brought with them at the point of admission. No one had brought a chair with them so their weren’t “theirs”. The chair, desk and office belong to the trust. At the trust l work at space is at such a premium some entire teams have no office space at all. So why should an office be left as a shrine to one person who might take 12-18 months or even more off? Most people would love their own but it’s just not realistic.

GRex · 03/02/2024 09:33

I'd lay money on the plan being to tuck an extra desk into the remaining office, so you can all share; smaller desks might be needed. Your job share partner and you will simply need to share a desk, and that's a completely normal work requirement. If you are both in for a meeting then presumably you are IN the meeting, so not at the desk.

I do wish women would get out of the habit of calling professional colleagues "girl" though, it's so patronising. Find to use it for your mates at the pub if you want, but in the wirkplace grown adults are known as "women" if you know them, possibly stretching to "lady" if you don't.

averythinline · 03/02/2024 09:28

I would ask what their solutions were for the work? Have you been covered whilst on mat leave.. what's been happening whilst you've been off? With these patients/families..

You may have valid points but its coming across as you stropping about loosing your desk/office...
And not wanting to change...

I would suggest you have a list of the issues from an confidentiality/patient point of view ..to explore the options with ... Going in all guns blazing type approach is not going to get you anywhere. .

However many organisations nhs/LA are shrinking space to save money so it maybe a done deal .. so work out what you think would work for you....
Re lack of info/discussion whilst you've been off is poor and sees odd no kit days/conversations... Would raise that with manager/union/hr.. as that should be on record

ClumsyNinja · 03/02/2024 09:22

@Trez1510

Return to work events were often difficult even although KIT days were regular and informative. Even when people had been provided with up-to-date/ accurate information regarding changes in their absence, they would strop when presented with the reality of those changes.

Thanks for your insight.🤦🏻‍♀️

It’s a shame you either couldn’t be bothered to read all the OP’s posts or deliberately chose to ignore the fact that none of your anecdotal stories fit these circumstances.

In this case, no maternity cover was arranged to cover OP’s role to manage the existing team so they were left to cope as best they could. From your perspective, staff supporting people who are dying don’t ‘add value’ to the NHS so let’s just ignore them.

Important information was sent via an email address that the OP has no access to during her maternity leave but other more generic information was emailed to the OP’s home email. Why do you think the manager chose to do this?

Reading some of these unpleasant and arrogant replies to the OP effectively telling her to pipe down and accept whatever management decides, reminds me of the high handed way the PO treated their staff and handled the Horizon disaster. We all know how well that turned out…!

Bouledeneige · 03/02/2024 09:19

I'm a CEO and I hot desk ( as well as working at home a lot). I have a lot of politically sensitive conversations. I think it's reasonable for circumstances to change whilst someone is on mat leave - rather than leaving an office empty for a year or however long.

They just need to discuss the new desk arrangements and find a suitable new location mindful of the confidential needs of the role. But in a previous organisation I ran we had an information and advice team having confidential conversations in an open plan office as when we analysed it confidential data was not discernible from one side of a conversation. So they just need to find a reasonable solution.

I would advise against going in all guns blazing - the desks and offices we use do not belong to us. They belong to the organisation and it's up to them to make best use of the organisations resources at any given time. They just need to support your return to work appropriately and ensure the whole team can work effectively,

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 03/02/2024 09:16

ememem84 · 03/02/2024 08:20

not the point but how does the verticals keyboard work?

@Proseccoprincess33 id be asking why you’re the only one expected to hit desk and whether you’ll have a desk assessment at whoever’s desk you’re sat at. You’d need to know who was in and out so you can make sure you’ve actually got somewhere to work. What if all staff are in on the same day -

dhs work recently moved into a new office. With desk capacity for 60% of staff. Over 80% of stuff were in the other day. Caused absolute chaos.

Your hands are thumbs up, little fingers down, whilst you type.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 03/02/2024 09:15

gillefc82 · 02/02/2024 14:23

In my experience, most workplaces are moving away from personal offices with seniors instead sharing space with their teams (possible exception being Exec level). This is designed to foster a closer relationship as a team and make the manager / leader more approachable/connected.

Can you ask about feasibility of blocking out /book a meeting room as a project room for your team to use for any sensitive conversations?

Regarding a desk, absolutely a provision should be made for you to have a space to work from. In the move to hot-desking, sometimes businesses don’t make allowances for all hands meetings where full teams will be on site and needing somewhere to sit and log on.

May sound a daft question, but what type of desk is it? Perhaps time to suggest a move to a project collab desk set up similar to this, where you don’t have workstations in the usual way, but just network cables and power sockets and you can get a good number of people in the space that 4 normal workstations would occupy?

Christ almighty…the ergonomics of hot decking is bad enough and this photo shows workstations that would be suitable for just an hour at the very most

This is the issue being overlooked by most posters, and a major issue with hot desking. Many people need good ergonomic chairs for desk working, and ideally height adjustable desks. A good ergonomic chair has around 5 to 6 settings and to change all of those each time you get to your desk is a complete waste of time and frustrating . It can work, of people are given it as a time allowance and management ram on about taking time to ensure you are seated ergonomically. Otherwise, hot desking is a recipe for severe ergonomic issues in the future.
im retired. Even with excellent ergo chairs I’ve persistent back issues from year and years of mainly arse based working, much at it during the years before we got ergo chairs and sit /stand desks. Those initiative came too late for my back- the initiative helped me get through more days of sitting on my arse mostly, but damage had been done by then which I’m still seeing physios for on regular basis

collab desks are for a single meeting. Those chairs are crap. I’d struggle to even sit in them for 45 mins without being in pain when I stand agian.

notsuchafrugalkitty · 03/02/2024 09:09

I think you're right to question it OP, I went back after my first maternity leave years ago to find my classroom had been given away and was told there was no room in the school for me to have a desk. I was head of two departments (no office) so had no classroom or space to work. Wasn't even allowed a desk in the shared planning room as it wouldn't be fair to other staff, ie the ones who had their own offices and classrooms already. In the end the SENCO took pity on me and made space in their room for me to have a base.

Do keep us updated, I'd love to know the outcome.

Wrongsideofpennines · 03/02/2024 09:08

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 07:15

May I summarise:

You are about to return from mat leave

You were p/t before mat leave (3 days) and now a formal job share partner has been appointed (2 days)

You work in a team, comprising 4 full-time equivalent posts and 5 people.

It's an NHS Trust and your team is responsible for patients receiving a particular type of care (not sure if any of you are patient facing or how much team members are at their desks)

You manage the other team members.

Your role was not covered when you were on maternity.

The four/five staff have previously been split between two offices and now have only one.

Things I am not clear about:

How many of you also work hybrid?

Whether there is bookable space?

If you all deal with patients why you need to work confidentially and why there isn't a culture of respecting confidentiality?

You talk of managing the team, are you on a higher grade and who managed them when you were away?

On the basis of the information I think has been provided, there is no obligation to provide you with a dedicated desk, office, etc, unless it is written into your contract. Your colleagues have also moved office and are participating in this arrangement so it is not discriminatory - when you are all back and there are 2 desks between 4/5 you will all be hot decking.

You are not returning on different terms and conditions therefore there is no sex discrimination.

More broadly:
If your work could be covered without replacing you when you were on mat leave it is an indication your unit/service is overstaffed. Rather shocking if all we hear about lack of resources and workloads in the NHS is true. If this is so, then it is reasonable there should be a business case to review the service.

Overall @Proseccoprincess33 you sound entitled and inflexible and possibly difficult to manage. I think you should go with the flow, be collaborative, and be mindful that at work it is not your desk or your office, it is the organisation's and they can allocate as they see fit.

If there is a business case in the offing, and it sounds as though there should be, you are doing yourself no favours. A business case is likely to be implemented in accordance with a management of change procedure and any risks will be dotted off.

I presume you are a nurse? If so, there will always be work for you and always an income so it is difficult to entirely see why there would be a problem if there had to be a redeployment.

If there is redeployment the management of change procedure may indicate selection criteria: attendance, performance, appraisal record, etc. Only you know those details.

I'd be open minded and exercise some flexibility if I were you.

I would support you over the meeting however but would like to know who requested it. If it is a formal meeting you should have been given the reason for it and given the opportunity to be accompanied. It is more likely to be informal as were it formal, HR should have advised. It sounds as though your manager feels they need support at the meeting and there could be a myriad reasons why.

Reading between the lines I suspect you may not be the easiest employee to manage. It sounds like your manager has not sought advice from HR but then again NHS HR is a unique beast.

Senior HR by the way.

Maternity leave cover is often not provided in the NHS. I have worked in 3 different trusts and in multiple teams and seen probably dozens of people go on maternity leave. I have only ever known cover to be arranged once. The cover was locum staff, unfortunately the agency failed to find anyone appropriately qualified so there was no cover. What the OP says has been happening here is that things haven't been done in her absence. The team is not overstaffed, more likely that training has had to slip, supervision hasn't been completed, patients are waiting longer for treatment, admission criteria has been tightened etc etc. Unfortunately it's attitudes like yours that mean services are cut because they're seen as not necessary and then someone decides that people will die anyway with or without Palliative care so why bother providing it at all.

The OPs situation is not unusual and this could not sound more like the NHS if it tried. The confidentiality thing is accepted for patients but for staff it's not appropriate for them to be having to share their own struggles and support needs in front of colleagues. And if it's anything like my office building there are no free breakout spaces/meeting rooms. Our team has to pay to book any meeting rooms in our own building. This often needs to be booked in advance via admin who are the only people who can view availability. Room occupancy is monitored using movement sensors in the room so they know if we haven't paid for it. And we have a finite budget so we don't book rooms. We have confidential conversations in the corridor and the kitchen and its crap for staff morale. So they leave. And then the rest of the team have to struggle on with an increased workload while people make unhelpful comments about how the team must have been overstaffed before.

Crochetablanket · 03/02/2024 09:07

I’m just shocked that you have a line manager you have never even met - for five years! Is this the norm in the nhs ?

Littlemisscapable · 03/02/2024 08:52

Yes this happened to me too..except I actually turned up after maternity leave to find someone who had joined a month ago sitting at my desk. And all my work during maternity still sitting there ! The stress. This is the reality of the NHS for those who don't work in it. I really understand how anxious this can make you. Could your job share colleague come to this meeting?. Or someone from your team ? I think I would avoid talking about 'my desk' but rather argue for a protected space to be able to deliver your role as a team. As for the time back as well..or do you want any KIT days. Would these help the transition back to work? Also maximise any opportunity to wfh. Good luck.

LlynTegid · 03/02/2024 08:52

No new advice but I hope you get the outcome you need, which is a perfectly reasonable one.

Trez1510 · 03/02/2024 08:48

This is where my thinking goes. It's based on a previous work-role as a manager of a large group (40+) people in three teams line-managed by first line managers.

I found returns from any sort of leave were often difficult. Mostly because people on leave tend to believe the world should stop until they are ready to climb aboard once again.

Return to work events were often difficult even although KIT days were regular and informative. Even when people had been provided with up-to-date/ accurate information regarding changes in their absence, they would strop when presented with the reality of those changes.

Here, I'm stealing a phrase I picked up from an article linked on another thread about employment law where the claimant lost - people tend to look at their value / importance to an organisation through 'a very linear lens of your (their) own perspective.'

I believe that is what is happening here with OP. Particularly in regards to the constant references to 'my' - my desk, my room, my team, my importance (as a p/t) manager of two staff, my importance in providing this uber-confidential service within an already confidential service etc. etc.

I believe posters egging her on with support for claims of discrimination etc. are doing her a disservice.

Like other wiser heads, I'd suggest she go along and find out what the actual situation is for her rather than basing it entirely off rumour and innuendo from colleagues.

LilMsLurker · 03/02/2024 08:46

Hot-desking in a shared job role would be normal, but it would be you and the other person in your role sharing the desk (you're on it your three days a week, they use it the rest). The desk therefore pertains to the job, and not the person, and it keeps things consistent. You can have a calendar of thing relevant to the role on the desk to be accessible to both without needing to synchronise your Google calendar, anything that needs to be handed in to your department goes in an in-tray on that desk for whichever of you to read, ect.

It doesn't sound like they really planned for you coming back. They could haveplayed musical desks if you were present/ on sick leave if there was a need (I.e an office was uninhabitable due to a burst pipe so people shuffled around depending on how much that impacted their work) but it just seems like your company manager doesn't have much forward planning or ability to see consequences.

Also, I'm curious how much paid leave your company gets if they seem to think you will always be able to jump on a free desk when you arrive at work. Is there never a time when all employees (with desks) are in the office at the same time? That seems highly unlikely.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 03/02/2024 08:41

@RosesAndHellebores glad you’re in HR-maybe you should read the OPs posts as she answered most of your questions there.
I hope you and your family never need the care of the OP and her team who do such a difficult job supporting people and their families as they are dying. This is the NHS-I can assure you they are not overstaffed-patients just won’t be getting the service they need and OPs staff weren’t supported whilst she was off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread