Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Desk and office given away

337 replies

Proseccoprincess33 · 01/02/2024 13:53

I am due to return to work following maternity leave next month. I am anxious about going back but this has been further intensified by the fact my office has been given away during my time off. This has been my office for 5 years. Not only has it been given away permanently but I have not been allocated another office or even a desk. I only became aware of this because some colleagues alerted me to it and I then contacted my manager to discuss it.

She is off site and very hands off so we rarely see her if at all. In fact I have never met her. So had I not been given this heads up by my colleagues I would have been coming into work to see my office and desk occupied and no place for me to sit on my first day back.

I am part of a multidisciplinary team and I manage one of the departments. Therefore having my own desk and office is so important to supervise staff and the nature of our work is very sensitive so privacy is a vital. But at this stage I'd settle for a desk of my own.

I am having a meeting with my manager about this very soon and have found out she has invited 2 very senior managers along also which is intimidating and not helpful to the anxiety I am experiencing. I think she fears I will be very unhappy and so has her reinforcements ready to tell me tough sh1t.

Her solution so far has been that they'll slot me into a desk somewhere when other staff are off....ie hot desking.

AIBU that I am so upset about this and want to fight for a resolution? Any advice from anyone who has been in a similar situation would be much appreciated.

Thank you 😊

OP posts:
Margot2017 · 03/02/2024 13:49

You’re only looking for messages of support, but this one is spot on even if it’s not what you want to hear. You should at this point be thinking about going back, doing the best possible work and reintegrating. The fact that you job share means you’re already being heavily accommodated. I wouldn’t want an employee who is so focused on perceived slights and her “rights” - even if you are not an entitled moaner, it certainly comes across that way. You’d be much better off focusing on doing your job and managing your life (which is always more difficult after returning from mat leave)…best of luck with these aspects of it.

Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 13:40

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 12:00

@Wouldyouguess my role is to advise the senior management team how to get the highest performance as competitively as possible and within the prevailing law. We have a portfolio of benefits and wellbeing initiatives alongside and the bells and Whistles are trumpeted.

Behind the scenes there has been significant suppprt for vulnerable staff which I won't go into because it's potentially outing. The staff concerned know. Ultimately, however, HR work to deliver organisational strategy.

What I have said, frankly, here I would never say in real life. I've given a reality check.

FWIW I am regularly tapped up by NHS Trusts via Head Hunters for Chief of People roles which is what they are now called. I always say no. I would never work for the NHS because I would not suppport the hierarchical and bullying culture. I also wouldn't want to manage an NHS HR team. Occasionally we have hired a Business Partner or Adviser from the NHS. They have either been managed out during probation or been on formal performance management within a year of scraping through probation.

'I would not suppport the hierarchical and bullying culture'

Yet you have advised I am clearly entitled and difficult to manage because I want a space to work at? And are basically advising I need to submit to the decisions within the hierarchy and not question it.

Marginalising peoples legitimate concerns/worries and making them feel like a problem for voicing these issues is fairly bullying behaviour. Making these people feel like they are the problem....gaslighting anyone?

I am glad I work for the NHS despite the many issues. I love that my work is about helping people in times of crisis and my whole remit is not lining the pockets of the big boss at the expense of others.

OP posts:
TeenLifeMum · 03/02/2024 13:38

@Proseccoprincess33 I generally just work where I want now, usually in my preferred office or at home. I’m a senior manager but the directors were trying to “get control”. I think they’ve realised that really wasn’t working and they hadn’t budgeted for travel expenses (which is bloody obvious imo). Sigh… I still have a couple of bums on seats type colleagues so I make sure my teams background is off sometimes so they can see I’m in an office (this seems to make them happy).

Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 13:33

TeenLifeMum · 03/02/2024 11:43

I think organisations are totally confused what to do post covid. My nhs team has gone from wanting teams in (including moving my office so I had to be half a week in my original office and half a week an hour away). They then realised that because I claim mileage for the hour away location, it’s expensive and maybe they don’t need me there so much (I literally sit on teams calls all day because colleagues are at different sites). The main office has an area for my team that has 15 desks for a team of 20.

i don’t have an answer but post covid office life is so messed up. They don’t want you to wfh but there’s also not enough desks and this is our problem. My manager approaches it by ignoring the issue and saying oh it’ll sort itself.

Edited

@TeenLifeMum sorry to hear of your messed up office situ too. Yes managers do a love a bit of bury your head on the sand sadly.

I hope that your current situ is working to your advantage though 😊

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 13:31

Wouldyouguess · 03/02/2024 11:50

You are doing the worst kind of HR it seems. I'd hate to have sometime like you as a manager.
The fact place A is shit for employees does not mean all places have to be equally crap. I hate the "things are bad everywhere so just pipe down" attitude, we should strive to be better rather than force people to accept the worst and grind their teeth. Maybe your company could have done better and you came up with wrong solutions, or maybe your solutions would not work in ops situation.
The fact you don't understand how people may feel coming back after a long absence indicats maybe you're in the wrong job or need retraining. Or just developing minimum empathy.

@Wouldyouguess well said 👏👏👏

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 13:30

Wherearewe2001 · 03/02/2024 11:45

Honestly I’m shocked at the amount of employer bum-licking that is happening on this site at the moment. There have been several threads lately where someone has had a (valid) issue with work and they are piled onto and called entitled, workshy, and all manner of other things.

The attitude prevailing in MN that employees should put up and shut up, are silly little women who should do what the big boss man tells them to and not complain, is honestly disgusting.

@Wherearewe2001 that gave me a giggle. You are so right! I have been quite shocked at some responses. But thankfully the majority of people have resorted my faith in common sense and humanity.

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 13:28

Mersey76 · 03/02/2024 11:27

A similar situation happened to me when I went back after 6 months maternity leave (so quite a few years ago). I was the manager in the office but found they had replaced me with a friend of one of the directors who had lost his job. Apparently it had been decided that this man would stay as the manager. I wasn’t informed what my role would be or where I would work. My first day back I had nowhere to work and no role. My staff were appalled. I was asked if I’d rather be part time and be the new manager’s deputy. I was advised by a solicitor friend that this could be considered constructive dismissal.
I think the advice to contact your union rep and ask their advice is the most helpful comment anyone on this site has made. Hopefully the union will have come across this kind of situation before and be able to advise the best way for you to proceed. The assumptions some commentators have made about your situation are not just unhelpful but cruel. I wish you all the best and hope your return to work is not as fraught as you fear.

I'm sorry to hear of your awful situation 😔 that is a heartbreaking read. And thank you for saying that some comments are cruel, I thought so too.

I hope you were able to get some resolution for your situation ❤️

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 13:26

Boomboom22 · 03/02/2024 11:32

Do kick up a fuss, where is all your stuff?
Also why on earth would you lose access to your email when on mat leave? That's not normal at all, very strange.

Thanks for this. I don't have a lap top while on leave and in the absence of this the emails can only be accessed when you are on a trust building which I wouldn't be in whilst on leave 😊

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 13:24

Chaotica · 03/02/2024 12:55

Just want to add my support @Proseccoprincess33 and say that the abuse you're getting is thoroughly unfair. I have no advice to add, but I hope this gets resolved in your favour. Having a desk to work at is really not so much to ask, in particular for the kind of work which you do.

@Chaotica thanks for taking the time do say that. I appreciate it 😊

OP posts:
Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 13:22

martinisforeveryone · 03/02/2024 11:44

I have come across incorrectly. I don't want my own special princess desk. Just a desk. I'm happy for it to be used by others when I'm not there as obviously that's reasonable and a good use of resources. But to have no idea of there will be somewhere for me to sit when I go in, esp when WFH is being actively discouraged is not acceptable.

@Proseccoprincess33

Well I'm not in HR, let alone a senior, and understood perfectly what you've been saying.

Don't be upset by cutting remarks from people who either can't comprehend, or have wilfully misconstrued, they're clearly cut from the same cloth as your (absent) manager. If she had better understanding of your team and your role within it, she could have handled the whole maternity leave and return to work for two of you in a manner that would have ensured a smooth continuation of your service with minimum disruption to working hours.

I wouldn't normally call Union at this stage, but think it would be wise given you'll face a manager who is inexperienced and remote from your workload and two seniors, who will have been briefed beforehand. I think it fair and wise to have someone at your side for support and to ensure you have an independent to witness what's said at your meeting.

@martinisforeveryone thank you for this. I think you are right 👍

OP posts:
ememem84 · 03/02/2024 13:13

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 03/02/2024 09:16

Your hands are thumbs up, little fingers down, whilst you type.

Ah thanks. Looks a bit strange and I imagine it takes a bit of getting used to but probably great for people with wrist problems.

I might look into it….

Chaotica · 03/02/2024 12:55

Just want to add my support @Proseccoprincess33 and say that the abuse you're getting is thoroughly unfair. I have no advice to add, but I hope this gets resolved in your favour. Having a desk to work at is really not so much to ask, in particular for the kind of work which you do.

DollyMcDollerson · 03/02/2024 12:50

I'm going to come in and say I believe that @RosesAndHellebores is in incorrect in some of her points. I am not "senior" in HR but I do have quite a bit of experience in this area around the application of equality legislation.

A few things jump out at me:

  1. If only you are being asked to hot desk - and it is only you so eg. if you have to shoehorn yourself around the other staff rather than everyone collectively managing who gets desks on what days - then there is a 'disparity of treatment' there. Given you are returning from mat leave it is reasonable to assume this is a factor or that you have been inadequately considered in the application of the policy.
  2. If a second member of staff is also returning and being expected to hotdesk under similar circumstances - this does not lessen your argument, it actually strengthens it as you have a common protected characteristic.
  3. You must ask for a return to work DSE assessment - if the hotdesking scenario is finalised they must be able to outline how they will comply with that under those circumstances.
  4. Are you still breastfeeding or expressing? If so, can they provide a private room that you would be able to do that? Would it have been 'your' office under other circumstances?
  5. There is a limited time window in which to raise grievances (Maternity Action can provide more information) so you need to challenge this sooner rather than later.
  6. Take a Union rep with you
  7. The NHS should have a Womens Network of some sort - contact them for advice - they may have someone with specific expertise on this sort of issue who could help or support you.
  8. You might not be able to avoid hot desking - no one is entitled to a desk anymore - but you should not be the only one forced to do it.
  9. As others have said be cautious about the prevailing wind on this - it sounds like they aren't investing in your service. If, and I hope it doesn't, come to a redundancy point - make sure your period of maternity leave doesn't work against you.
  10. Also check your pay - if there have been pay rises recently make sure you've had any pay adjustments done correctly while you have been off.
Parker231 · 03/02/2024 12:12

Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 11:02

This attitude of 'busy workers who are not off on maternity leave' says it all.

I have come across incorrectly. I don't want my own special princess desk. Just a desk. I'm happy for it to be used by others when I'm not there as obviously that's reasonable and a good use of resources. But to have no idea of there will be somewhere for me to sit when I go in, esp when WFH is being actively discouraged is not acceptable.

Can you not hot desk - it’s the norm where I work and at our clients. No one has a specific desk or individual office regardless of their seniority. There are small hubs which can be used for confidential calls or meetings.

ChangingPhoto · 03/02/2024 12:07

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 11:50

@Wherearewe2001 the big boss man pays the salary. Therefore employees are required to render their contractual obligations in return.

Employment is about to get sticky. Jobs are likely to become more scarce and unemoyment will rise. It will not be helpful to be regarded as a high maintenance employee. Those who are at the top of their game and bring in hundreds of thousands might get away with it. The foot soldiers not so much.

Life is about to get very very hard for many.

Regardless of organisation, redundancies, job security or hierarchies, good communication and respect are crucial. I am at the ‘top’ of my career and ensure that I speak to everybody with respect and if I make a mistake, I apologise. (Including patients and relatives) I try and accommodate requests and listen and if I have to say no, I offer decent explanations.

Nobody gets to treat other people poorly just because they should be grateful they have a job. if your organisation works on that principle, then it is not a healthy work environment.

Hotdesking has taken over the NHS. At least where I work they allow wfh. It must be distressing to find out from colleagues that your desk and office have gone when on maternity leave, and no manger has communicated that with the employee. It is disrespectful and poor management.

There is a different between not being a doormat, and being ‘high-maintenance’

Jobsworth HR staff add little value to any organisation. They are also replaceable.

Wherearewe2001 · 03/02/2024 12:01

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 11:50

@Wherearewe2001 the big boss man pays the salary. Therefore employees are required to render their contractual obligations in return.

Employment is about to get sticky. Jobs are likely to become more scarce and unemoyment will rise. It will not be helpful to be regarded as a high maintenance employee. Those who are at the top of their game and bring in hundreds of thousands might get away with it. The foot soldiers not so much.

Life is about to get very very hard for many.

Luckily employees are protected by laws regarding constructive dismissal and discrimination, amongst other things, which even Mr Big Important Boss Man has to follow or risk being sued.

TheBeef · 03/02/2024 12:01

The behaviour of your manager/workplace is unacceptable.

I can understand empty office space being used during your absence. The nature of your job requires that you have it back. It sounds like the current occupants manage events can sit anywhere.

Old fashioned public sector rules gave guidelines for grades and their expected office accomodation. Now, the idea is that everyone except the CEO hotdesks.

Are their expectations for someone of your grade and role to have their own office space? You should be back in your office or WFH. If you can work from anywhere, why not from home? 2 days WFH and one in the office with dedicated space for calls and meetings of a confidential nature seems like the least they can do.

I would never treat anyone I manage on maternity leave this way. It is wholly unacceptable for your manager to not communicate with you. Not sure why you don't have access to your work account. In any case they should be sending information to your personal account as per your request. It sounds like your workplace does not value your work, at all.

There seems to be a lot of race to the bottom buttercups here. Ignore them.

DoILookThrilled · 03/02/2024 12:00

Proseccoprincess33 · 03/02/2024 11:02

This attitude of 'busy workers who are not off on maternity leave' says it all.

I have come across incorrectly. I don't want my own special princess desk. Just a desk. I'm happy for it to be used by others when I'm not there as obviously that's reasonable and a good use of resources. But to have no idea of there will be somewhere for me to sit when I go in, esp when WFH is being actively discouraged is not acceptable.

You know what l mean 🙄. People are either at work or they are not. My maternity leave was busy but l wasn’t at work

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 12:00

@Wouldyouguess my role is to advise the senior management team how to get the highest performance as competitively as possible and within the prevailing law. We have a portfolio of benefits and wellbeing initiatives alongside and the bells and Whistles are trumpeted.

Behind the scenes there has been significant suppprt for vulnerable staff which I won't go into because it's potentially outing. The staff concerned know. Ultimately, however, HR work to deliver organisational strategy.

What I have said, frankly, here I would never say in real life. I've given a reality check.

FWIW I am regularly tapped up by NHS Trusts via Head Hunters for Chief of People roles which is what they are now called. I always say no. I would never work for the NHS because I would not suppport the hierarchical and bullying culture. I also wouldn't want to manage an NHS HR team. Occasionally we have hired a Business Partner or Adviser from the NHS. They have either been managed out during probation or been on formal performance management within a year of scraping through probation.

DiamanteFan · 03/02/2024 11:53

yanbu for being uncomfortable with the prospect of hotdesking. Hope the meeting goes reasonably OK.

Wrongsideofpennines · 03/02/2024 11:52

Boomboom22 · 03/02/2024 11:32

Do kick up a fuss, where is all your stuff?
Also why on earth would you lose access to your email when on mat leave? That's not normal at all, very strange.

How would she access her work emails? Majority of NHS staff don't have laptops or remote connections. So unless she goes in, finds a free desk/computer to sit at, she can't access them. Never mind the fact that likely her log in details have expired and it will take IT a week to reset them.

Wouldyouguess · 03/02/2024 11:52

Jetstream · 03/02/2024 11:37

You are not being unreasonable OP. Ignore the bitchy, petty comments here. Take a union rep with you to the meeting. Take minutes at the meeting. I think if you know what you are dealing with, you will be better able to do it. Good luck.

This!
So many people here either are bitter because they have shit jobs or are armchair experts in HR seeing it in a tv show once.
It's not unreasonable to want to have decent working conditions!

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 11:50

@Wherearewe2001 the big boss man pays the salary. Therefore employees are required to render their contractual obligations in return.

Employment is about to get sticky. Jobs are likely to become more scarce and unemoyment will rise. It will not be helpful to be regarded as a high maintenance employee. Those who are at the top of their game and bring in hundreds of thousands might get away with it. The foot soldiers not so much.

Life is about to get very very hard for many.

Wouldyouguess · 03/02/2024 11:50

RosesAndHellebores · 03/02/2024 10:13

I am sorry if that was your interpretation but thank you for clarifying that 4 people, at least two part-time will be sharing two desks in one office. I am afraid this is quite normal, particularly if there is some hybrid working continuing.

You and colleagues will need to manage when you need desk space. My department now has 14 desks for 20 staff post covid and with the introduction of hybrid working. Everyone now has a laptop instead of a desktop and there are rotas which ensure the service is covered 5 days a week as everyone wants to wfh on Mondays and/or Fridays and they can't.

Staff voted for the above because the alternative was to say we were entirely user facing and they all had to be back in every day which would have suited the SLT. The staff wanted to retain hybrid - two departme ts have been combined allowing for a floor to be repurposed and to deliver an operational saving.

We live in tough times. A quarter of our workforce was made redundant two years ago. That is not something NHS staff are likely to face.

Our staff are managed and supported well and I made it clear to you that the meeting had been convened badly. However, I also tried to make it clear what may be going on behind the scenes to ensure your eyes were open.

I am sorry you feel frail about returning to work but have to and it is not your preferred choice. That is not your Employer's issue I'm afraid.

You are doing the worst kind of HR it seems. I'd hate to have sometime like you as a manager.
The fact place A is shit for employees does not mean all places have to be equally crap. I hate the "things are bad everywhere so just pipe down" attitude, we should strive to be better rather than force people to accept the worst and grind their teeth. Maybe your company could have done better and you came up with wrong solutions, or maybe your solutions would not work in ops situation.
The fact you don't understand how people may feel coming back after a long absence indicats maybe you're in the wrong job or need retraining. Or just developing minimum empathy.

Wherearewe2001 · 03/02/2024 11:45

Honestly I’m shocked at the amount of employer bum-licking that is happening on this site at the moment. There have been several threads lately where someone has had a (valid) issue with work and they are piled onto and called entitled, workshy, and all manner of other things.

The attitude prevailing in MN that employees should put up and shut up, are silly little women who should do what the big boss man tells them to and not complain, is honestly disgusting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread