Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Detention for asking period question

211 replies

Hoiz · 01/02/2024 13:47

A female relative of mine (year 5). Recently had a lesson on puberty, specifically periods.

After school my relative and a few friends were getting ready to go to an after school club, they were still discussing last lesson on puberty, when relative asked friend if her sister (goes to same school) had started her period. The friend took massive offence and cried. Relative apologised straight away.

A teacher was found and a detention has been issued.

My relative is a nice, sweet girl.

Aibu to think this was harsh?

OP posts:
nevertrustanyoneagain · 01/02/2024 21:44

Sounds like a Plymouth brethren school, conservative Christians, combined school, private minibuses etc

Bewler · 01/02/2024 21:43

How this wasn’t simply resolved by a gentle conversation between teacher and pupil along the lines of “periods are private” is beyond me. Surely if they are teaching about periods, they are teaching that (as with all aspects of puberty) some children may feel shy about it. So ask a teacher or your parents if you have questions but don’t make personal comments.
Detention? Fuck no! What kind of weird school is this?
#theremustbemoretoit

ToWhitToWhoo · 01/02/2024 21:41

ConflictedCheetah · 01/02/2024 14:06

I was about to say this. What primary schools give detentions at all? Let alone for something like this.

From the description, it sounds as though it may be the junior department of an all-age private school. I may be wrong on this; but, if this is indeed the case, it's less surprising that they might have detentions.

CynthiaRothrock · 01/02/2024 21:15

@Mumof2teens79 Unusual maybe, but not unheard of. I've worked in a school, one family had 5children. 1 in Yr 6, 1 in Yr 5 one in Yr 3 one in Yr 1 and a baby. 10 months between the first 2. 11 months between the second and third.....

ReallyAgainReally · 01/02/2024 21:01

how old is year 5? stop saying relative as it makes it like it's an adult.

teacher was right. does your relative watch eastenders/coronation street where they are all screaming and shouting at each others, or gossiping about friends? 'relative' must LEARN to not discuss people who are not present.

sunnyday81 · 01/02/2024 20:54

I’m not saying at all your relative is lying but teachers don’t hand out detentions for nothing and is a bit odd the other child was so upset. Perhaps there’s a bit more to it - had the girls been specifically told not to ask each other personal questions so girls who had / hadn’t started their period didn’t feel embarrassed when asked, perhaps it was her tone or what might have been said between them e earlier in the day and this was the last straw for the teacher. I teach year 5 and the sweetest, loveliest girls can have friendship fallouts with friends and in the heat of the moment say something daft. Their version of events often don’t quite tally with what really happened, small details left out or added in. It’s all part of growing up and navigating friendships.

Frangipanyoul8r · 01/02/2024 20:50

What exactly is the lesson to be learnt from this detention? That no one should ask a personal question through fear of offending? Is that really what girls schools are teaching nowadays? Bonkers.

MountainBarbie · 01/02/2024 20:47

Your poor relative, this is so not okay Op. Sorry for the assumptions being made on here I've read the thread and it's very clear what you've said has happened. Please complain to the school - how was the teacher to know that your relative hadn't indeed started her period herself at that age and was trying to confide in another student in a clumsy way because of her age? Absolutely appaling, the teacher needs to explain their reasoning ASAP.

ThanksItHasPockets · 01/02/2024 20:43

BoohooWoohoo · 01/02/2024 19:58

They use “staying in at playtime” for things like bad behaviour like violence or not finishing work because of messing around during lesson time.

Sure, but they don’t call this ‘detention’ or send home a written slip. I see OP has clarified that it is an independent school.

CecilyP · 01/02/2024 20:26

Happyhippy99 · 01/02/2024 18:24

The OP said that the girl given the detention was asking another girl if her sister had started her periods.
The girl given the detention needs to understand that asking private medical questions is rude and unacceptable. The school are teaching her basic manners by giving her a detention. Imagine if the same girl asked a relative with cancer, when are you going to die ? Or asked a male relative about his testes or ED.

Except periods are not a medical matter. They can be, but mostly they are not as they happen to all healthy females between certain ages. It is not remotely like asking a relative about cancer.

CecilyP · 01/02/2024 20:19

Periods are nothing to be ashamed of. But someone's personal experience of their own periods is a private subject, to be discussed only on their terms. The girl needed to learn that asking such intrusive questions – especially about someone else not present – is inappropriate.

It’s not really intrusive. She didn’t ask for any detailed information of the sisters experience of periods, simply if she’d started or not.

CecilyP · 01/02/2024 20:08

Happyhippy99 · 01/02/2024 17:58

YABVVU
Ok girls need to understand that periods are natural and nothing to be ashamed of. But for gods sake, this girl was asking VERY personal questions about her sister. I’m glad the school gave her a detention to teach her some respect for others and manners.
Do you expect all adult females to answer personal questions about their gynaecological history to anyone who asks ?

No. So why expect a child to answer such questions about her sister.

How is it a VERY personal question when just about EVERY female within a certain age range spanning about 40 years has periods?

It really isn’t like gynaecological history which can vary significantly between women and could indeed be very personal.

BoohooWoohoo · 01/02/2024 19:58

ThanksItHasPockets · 01/02/2024 17:53

Something doesn’t add up here. State schools
in the UK do not, as a rule, use detentions.

They use “staying in at playtime” for things like bad behaviour like violence or not finishing work because of messing around during lesson time.

Cattymonster · 01/02/2024 19:50

@ExpressCheckout

The enthusiasm that inadequate and less intelligent teachers have in imposing arbitrary sanctions on children is a safeguarding concern, in my opinion.

Absolutely right! It's bizarre.

Testina · 01/02/2024 19:43

@Hoiz “This is literally her first encounter with the subject (think they drew a penis and vagina last yr), so the boundaries are unknown and need to be learned -ideally in a non punitive manner.”

Then you should tell her parents that they’re failing. One of my girls started her periods in summer term of Y6. This is way too late for this to be her first encounter “with the subject” - they are letting her down.

Cattymonster · 01/02/2024 19:38

This is absolutely nuts! If I were the parents of the child who asked the question I would not be allowing her to go to the detention. I'd also be writing to the governors to explain what has happened, to express my concern and to request an explanation.

Normally I'd be in favour of supporting schools, but when they go bananas then parents do need to intervene.

TheDdistinguishedScarlett · 01/02/2024 19:38

Simple solution OP

ASK the teacher in question as I'm quiet certain there may be more to it than meets the eye

momonpurpose · 01/02/2024 19:30

Hoiz · 01/02/2024 14:04

Can people stop derailing with saying there is more to the story. There isn’t.

The detention slip and conversations centre around inappropriate boundaries. My relative’s mum has spoken to the teacher who was involved and there has been zero mention of nasty behaviour.

I hope the detention hasn't happened and will be fought. I have no problem with a warranted detention. This is not at all deserved.

momonpurpose · 01/02/2024 19:25

Patchworksack · 01/02/2024 13:50

Way to go to teach them periods are something shameful! It sounds very harsh unless there is more to it. Surely being told some people aren’t comfortable sharing that information and consider it private was all that was needed?

This. What an over reaction from the other dc and school. Shocking in 2024 these type of reactions.

CupOfCoffeeandaPineappleChunk · 01/02/2024 19:18

Presumably this indicates school taught the subject initially really well, that periods etc are matter of fact straightforward every day life that are simple and unremarkable, in the way, say, people in France speak French or in Spain speak Spanish. The ten year old was engaged and listened and was interested she had presumably absorbed the age she was told periods start and and was simply curious as to whether the older girl had started hers yet. She had no received no indication presumably that people might find the topic to personal or taboo.
A detention is wholly inappropriate. The school have undone the excellent work the started and ate now spreading the message that there is something shameful about periods and they are something that should never be mentioned. This really needs to be brought up with school and the message they are conveying made clear. It is inappropriate , they need to make clear their stance as an organisation in the approach they have to personal issues such as periods and sexual health. Not having to discuss something is once thing, but asking a question out of simple innocent curiosity is entirely another. Neither should be a punishable offence. School need to make a sincere apology and fully explain their reasoning. As a parent I would be furious and be asking the head and govenors for an explanation as to why punishment was given instead of an explanation that some pepole just aren't happy to discuss personal and/ or body issues and it can be rude to ask. If you don't know, you just don't know.

DelphineFox · 01/02/2024 19:16

relative asked friend if her sister (goes to same school) had started her period. The friend took massive offence and cried.
Hard to believe

YankSplaining · 01/02/2024 19:14

falafelover · 01/02/2024 18:19

The usual Mumsnet confusion around shame vs privacy. (Some of you really need to understand the difference.)

Periods are nothing to be ashamed of. But someone's personal experience of their own periods is a private subject, to be discussed only on their terms. The girl needed to learn that asking such intrusive questions – especially about someone else not present – is inappropriate.

Detention is a bit much but I'm not surprised the other girl reacted badly. I'm sure there's more to this. It may well be that the girl is known to be socially clumsy, and her peers will be rather brutal about it (as kids are).

Edited

It’s very odd to me that so many people here don’t understand shame vs. privacy, considering most of the posters here are mothers, and part of being a mother is teaching young children we do and don’t ask other people/say in public.

DelphineFox · 01/02/2024 19:13

I don't believe the story is exactly as you've said. It may be what you've been told but that doesn't mean it's exactly what happened. You weren't there

ReadingSoManyThreads · 01/02/2024 19:11

This is ridiculous. Her mother should absolutely be challenging the school over this. They teach them about periods then shame them by punishment for asking an innocent question, as she was yet to learn about boundaries regarding puberty.

If I were the mother, I'd be refusing consent for the detention.

How dare they try to shame the girl for asking an innocent question about what they had just been taught. Shocking behaviour from the teacher.

Josette77 · 01/02/2024 19:09

Hoiz · 01/02/2024 18:43

I was curious if we were all in the wrong for thinking it was a bit heavy handed (consensus on WhatsApp group).

The girl apologised immediately. Think that counts for something.

This is literally her first encounter with the subject (think they drew a penis and vagina last yr), so the boundaries are unknown and need to be learned -ideally in a non punitive manner.

This school sounds weird ASF.

I wouldn't want my 9 yo drawing penises and vulvas in school.