Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Detention for asking period question

211 replies

Hoiz · 01/02/2024 13:47

A female relative of mine (year 5). Recently had a lesson on puberty, specifically periods.

After school my relative and a few friends were getting ready to go to an after school club, they were still discussing last lesson on puberty, when relative asked friend if her sister (goes to same school) had started her period. The friend took massive offence and cried. Relative apologised straight away.

A teacher was found and a detention has been issued.

My relative is a nice, sweet girl.

Aibu to think this was harsh?

OP posts:
Madamum18 · 02/02/2024 18:39

I think this is a ridiculous and pretty appalling response to a group of Year 6 children talking about such an important issue.

  1. They haven't taken any notice of the fact that this was clearly a non malicious question, as explained by the 3rd child present
  1. The opportunity to discuss appropriate boundaries regarding questions and curiosity about other people's bodies has been missed
  1. The opportunity to discuss how to manage a situation where one feels offended or upset with the other child has been missed
  1. An opportunity to model appropriate behaviours to resolve issues has been lost
  1. Children are left with a potential fear and wariness about talking about and asking questions about an important aspect of growing up and their bodies

I think it is really poor practice

BooBooDoodle · 02/02/2024 18:29

Shameful really. It shouldn’t be taboo at all and this was an ideal opportunity for a teacher to set the record straight for all included and have a chat. When I was younger we would all ask each other about periods and had we started ours yet. It was a natural curiosity and something we all knew would happen.
The girl who started crying though? I’d be more concerned from a safeguarding point of view as to whether she’s experienced trauma of some type given her response to a genuine and innocent question.

itsgettingweird · 02/02/2024 18:10

Sounds like a massive overreaction on all parts. Well done- not your dds tbf.

The girls could have said that's not her information to give and the teacher should have explained to the girl she had a right to protect her sisters privacy but your dd was just asking a question.

They've made out asking if someone has started their periods as punishable and therefore making them something shameful. This is the 21st century.

Ps I've not read full thread so not sure if updates just stating my opinion.

Viviennemary · 02/02/2024 18:10

Doesn't sound like this is the full story. So you say there isn't any more to it. But I agree with appropriate boundaries. You don't ask personal questions especially not in front of other folk. Did this happen outside school. It all sounds a bit odd.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 02/02/2024 18:06

TheNanny24 · 01/02/2024 13:52

Doubt you're getting the whole story from the child who was told off.

I agree. There will be a lot more to this.

lieselotte · 02/02/2024 18:02

did people note the posts from a couple of teachers where pupils are explicitly told not to talk about the PSHE subjects outside the class

That is stupid - how can you develop your ideas about something if you aren't allowed to discuss it? PHSE isn't just about sex and periods, it covers loads of topics like environmental issues for example.

lieselotte · 02/02/2024 18:00

You can't go snivelling off to the teacher to get someone else into trouble every time you fancy it

Seems to be the way in schools now. Even ds's state comprehensive was a bit like Stasi-era East Germany at times.

lieselotte · 02/02/2024 17:59

It’s very odd to me that so many people here don’t understand shame vs. privacy, considering most of the posters here are mothers, and part of being a mother is teaching young children we do and don’t ask other people/say in public

Oh we're back to the "I'm a perfect mother and I have taught my children everything and they never ever put a foot wrong"

Meanwhile in the real world, kids don't always do what their parents tell them, and sometimes they make mistakes. The issue here is whether the sanction was over the top and I'd say the majority here think it was.

I remember someone saying to me I was obviously on my period when I was 14. I was muddy, we'd been doing PE. She was deliberately trying to embarrass me, that's a completely different issue - and we were 14, not 10. Not that I told the teacher because back then they wouldn't have done anything.

Maireas · 02/02/2024 16:55

Bewler · 01/02/2024 21:43

How this wasn’t simply resolved by a gentle conversation between teacher and pupil along the lines of “periods are private” is beyond me. Surely if they are teaching about periods, they are teaching that (as with all aspects of puberty) some children may feel shy about it. So ask a teacher or your parents if you have questions but don’t make personal comments.
Detention? Fuck no! What kind of weird school is this?
#theremustbemoretoit

One of those all age girls' independent schools.

Mariposistaaa · 02/02/2024 09:37

SheilaFentiman · 02/02/2024 09:05

Please don’t call a 10 year old a poor snowflake for getting upset by an unexpected personal question. It makes you sound nasty.

read what @YoureALizardHarry11 wrote - if she didn't like the question (and that is her prerogative) THAT is the way she should have reacted to it. The little girl would then have stopped asking (and if she hadn't, then YES she would have been in the wrong), and that would have been that. You can't go snivelling off to the teacher to get someone else into trouble every time you fancy it.

SheilaFentiman · 02/02/2024 09:24
  1. are people getting that this is a lunchtime detention? Quite possibly it was used to talk to the niece about boundaries
  2. did people note the posts from a couple of teachers where pupils are explicitly told not to talk about the PSHE subjects outside the class? If that speech was done here, then it is probably the reason for the punishment
ToddlerIs2 · 02/02/2024 09:22

Def ott

I'd be more interested, as the teacher, in the other child's tears. What have they learnt at home that's made the .ere qn induce tears?

The whole "she shouldn't have asked about the sister" is this really where we are? Discussion on periods, you'll probably start in a year or so. Oh bestie has your year older sister had her yet. Omg how DARE you, you shall be PUNISHED!!

What's next?
So had your sister really got a bf? Right, a month's detention.
Did you sister have a nice birthday? Detention!!
Does your sister want to come bowling with us? How dare you ask one person what another person might think or want to do, you're expelled!!

Thebookdragon · 02/02/2024 09:08

Hoiz · 01/02/2024 13:54

Yes, the teacher has given the exact scenario in the write up.

A third girl was present who said to the offended girl she was sure my relative did not mean to cause offence.

Then I would refuse to do the detention saying asking questions about periods should be the norm. Apologise for the timing and the person has the right to say no. But asking who has started is normal. Check direct with the school that an innocuous question was all it was and there was nothing else

SheilaFentiman · 02/02/2024 09:06

Separately, it is possible her sister does not get periods because of an eating disorder, or that the girl’s parents do take a biblical view of periods and the upset child finds the question hard for that reason.

SheilaFentiman · 02/02/2024 09:05

Mariposistaaa · 02/02/2024 08:31

@YoureALizardHarry11 can you imagine when the poor little snowflake starts having periods herself? She won’t cope!

Please don’t call a 10 year old a poor snowflake for getting upset by an unexpected personal question. It makes you sound nasty.

JustwantacupfT · 02/02/2024 08:51

Really poorly handled by school. This girl will have a hang up now about certain conversations because she has been shamed for her naivety in this situation. Instead as pp has said teacher could have explained that not everyone wants to share things like that and that everyone is different. What a shame.

Mariposistaaa · 02/02/2024 08:31

YoureALizardHarry11 · 02/02/2024 08:00

Oh, come on, that’s way over kill. Crying? Ridiculous. I know it’s technically a ‘’personal question’’ but 1. It wasn’t about the girl so it’s even odder that she cried, and 2. It was totally innocuous, really. If someone asked me at that age I would have honestly thought nothing of it. Yes/No/Not sure. In any case, there was absolutely no need for a detention. A simple, ‘’Excuse me, we don’t need to ask personal questions about other people, please’’ End of story. Some people are utterly ridiculous.

Edited

@YoureALizardHarry11 can you imagine when the poor little snowflake starts having periods herself? She won’t cope!

ThanksItHasPockets · 02/02/2024 08:26

nevertrustanyoneagain · 01/02/2024 21:44

Sounds like a Plymouth brethren school, conservative Christians, combined school, private minibuses etc

If you are right then this is a highly relevant bit of context.

YoureALizardHarry11 · 02/02/2024 08:00

Oh, come on, that’s way over kill. Crying? Ridiculous. I know it’s technically a ‘’personal question’’ but 1. It wasn’t about the girl so it’s even odder that she cried, and 2. It was totally innocuous, really. If someone asked me at that age I would have honestly thought nothing of it. Yes/No/Not sure. In any case, there was absolutely no need for a detention. A simple, ‘’Excuse me, we don’t need to ask personal questions about other people, please’’ End of story. Some people are utterly ridiculous.

Testina · 02/02/2024 07:45

nevertrustanyoneagain · 01/02/2024 21:44

Sounds like a Plymouth brethren school, conservative Christians, combined school, private minibuses etc

I think you’ve nailed it. If you’re right, the parents are just as much at fault as the school, if they’ve chosen to send your daughter somewhere that treats women like that.

Maireas · 02/02/2024 07:37

Mariposistaaa · 01/02/2024 21:55

Exactly.

Dear Mrs/Miss XXX
I understand that my daughter XXX has got herself into a spot of bother by asking curious questions about puberty/female development to another member of the class. I shall be speaking to her and making sure that if she has any doubts or needs anything clarifying, that she speaks to myself, an female family member or friend or one of her teachers so as not to generate any playground gossip or twisted versions of reality.
I understand that she has apologised to the girl in question, and assures me that she will not be asking any more questions. I therefore consider the matter closed. XXX will not be attending detention on Friday afternoon. We have a prior engagement that evening.
Very best wishes

XXXX's mother.

It's not an after school detention.
It's break time.
Plus, remember that this is not a regular state primary school. It's an independent girls' school, so different rules apply.

CJsGoldfish · 01/02/2024 23:15

Garlickit · 01/02/2024 16:37

There is nothing in the Bible to say periods are filthy 🤔

Leviticus 15:19 When a woman has a discharge, and the discharge in her body is blood, she shall be in her menstrual impurity for seven days, and whoever touches her shall be unclean until the evening.

Leviticus 15:20 And everything on which she lies during her menstrual impurity shall be unclean. Everything also on which she sits shall be unclean.

Leviticus 20:18 If a man lies with a woman during her menstrual period and uncovers her nakedness, he has made naked her fountain, and she has uncovered the fountain of her blood. Both of them shall be cut off from among their people.

Leviticus 15:28-30 But if she is cleansed of her discharge, she shall count for herself seven days, and after that she shall be clean. And on the eighth day she shall take two turtledoves or two pigeons and bring them to the priest, to the entrance of the tent of meeting.

Ezekiel 36:17 When the house of Israel lived in their own land, they defiled it by their ways and their deeds. Their ways before me were like the uncleanness of a woman in her menstrual impurity.

  • There's a lot more, as you should know. It all boils down to re-statements of Leviticus, who makes it very clear that a menstruating woman is so revolting for seven days that nobody can touch her or anything she sits/lies on. Then she stays unclean for another seven days, after which she has to go for a special bath and make sacrifices (orthodox Jewish women still do this!)
(Biblical thread diversion over.)

Awkward 😝

Think we're going to just pretend that didn't happen 🤣

Mariposistaaa · 01/02/2024 21:55

ReadingSoManyThreads · 01/02/2024 19:11

This is ridiculous. Her mother should absolutely be challenging the school over this. They teach them about periods then shame them by punishment for asking an innocent question, as she was yet to learn about boundaries regarding puberty.

If I were the mother, I'd be refusing consent for the detention.

How dare they try to shame the girl for asking an innocent question about what they had just been taught. Shocking behaviour from the teacher.

Exactly.

Dear Mrs/Miss XXX
I understand that my daughter XXX has got herself into a spot of bother by asking curious questions about puberty/female development to another member of the class. I shall be speaking to her and making sure that if she has any doubts or needs anything clarifying, that she speaks to myself, an female family member or friend or one of her teachers so as not to generate any playground gossip or twisted versions of reality.
I understand that she has apologised to the girl in question, and assures me that she will not be asking any more questions. I therefore consider the matter closed. XXX will not be attending detention on Friday afternoon. We have a prior engagement that evening.
Very best wishes

XXXX's mother.

Bewler · 01/02/2024 21:52

nevertrustanyoneagain · 01/02/2024 21:44

Sounds like a Plymouth brethren school, conservative Christians, combined school, private minibuses etc

If so, that would make this whole thread make a bit more sense….

ToWhitToWhoo · 01/02/2024 21:45

Now that I've RTFT, this (private school) does seem to be the case

Your relative may have been a little tactless, but in a completely innocent way. A detention seems way OTT.