Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

…or is my childminder?

286 replies

Childminderwoes · 01/02/2024 10:25

DS is 10 months and started with a childminder 6 weeks ago. 2 days a week so I can get various things done before my maternity leave ends in March, and full time hours when I go back.

He has a drop off/pick up time as you would expect but she’s very very very rigid about this. And will message to complain if you’re not there at the exact minute because she has other drops offs 5 minutes either side of his slot. To the extent where she’s messaged to complain about him being dropped off 2 or 3 minutes before or after his set time.

She wants me to text 2 minutes before arrival every time he’s dropped off, so she can come outside to collect him, and is very firm about this, and will again text if I forget to remind me for next time.

She wants him to be in the buggy at every drop off to minimise his distress at being ‘handed over’ which I understood for the first few weeks but it’s become a real pain getting the buggy out of the car, setting it up and strapping him in just to wheel him down her driveway.

She’s really lovely but after 5 weeks all of it is getting a bit much. I thought by now I would be able to just hand him over, as you would expect mornings are a bit mad as I also have a 4 year old to get to school. All these extra caveats are starting to grate on me a little.

To add to this I’m not too sure about his meals. He has lunch at hers, but never what I would call a proper lunch - the diary entry says things like bread sticks, toast, pouches, fruit. I suppose I expected he would have something a bit healthier and hot.

Is this normal for a childminder?

OP posts:
HedgehogPrincess · 02/02/2024 01:45

It’s a red flag. Perhaps trying to conceal how many other children they mind, arriving at different times. Would make me wonder how long they are leaving kids in buggies. Just pull out, or check asap with other parent clients about their experience.

Lazylaptoping · 01/02/2024 23:07

Its very weird. I would be tempted to be early and loiter late for a day or two, see the others being dropped off and try to figure out why she is doing it. Pretend you are on a call so can't drive away.
And yes I would ditch her for it, I couldn't stand that inflexible attitude. It wouldn't have fitted with my relaxed parenting style. If she that strict with you, I'd worry how strict she is with the kids? How does she deal with the kids messing her around, taking their time, making a mess? Can you imagine her attitude to potty training?
Everyone has a parenting style and you do meet people whose attitudes are just alien to you. Its best to walk away. I had a friend who encouraged her child to hit back. You can imagine how that ended.

MrsCarson · 01/02/2024 22:35

Sounds weird to me. She doesn't want you picking up 5 or 10 minutes early either?
She's very rigid. It would put me right off.

SeenYourArse · 01/02/2024 22:30

Sounds like she’s leaving baby strapped in the pushchair for her own convenience whilst doing other hand overs!

prescribingmum · 01/02/2024 20:34

Universalsnail · 01/02/2024 13:03

Ex childminder here.

Her rules about timings are reasonable. If you are late you throw the morning routine off massively which is a problem if you have drop offs to do and your arrival time is close to needing to leave drop offs. I was always quite relaxed about people being early but tbh that can also be a problem because if someone is too early I might not ready. Personally If I was you I would be 5 mins early and wait in the car.
Does she use his buggy to take him out with or her own. Tbh if she doesn't use the buggy to take him out with I think she's being rediculous needing him to be in the buggy and you should be able to hand him over by hand.

Edited

Her rules about timings are utterly ridiculous! If a cm needs to do a school run (as our one used to), she tells parents the times she will not be available for drop off ie come before 8.15 or after 9. Requesting parents do not turn up early is also entirely reasonable as she maybe sorting her own family.

Requesting parents arrive within a 2 minute window is ludicrous! Schools and nurseries all have a window to account to traffic/other children/other eventualities. Requesting a text message at a specific time (which can only be sent whilst driving to achieve the request) is also crazy! And unless she is about to take the child on the school run/walk by foot the moment they arrive, there is no rational reason they need to be put in a buggy before being taken to the front door.

This all just makes a busy parents life harder. I would certainly be looking elsewhere

cansu · 01/02/2024 19:02

Sounds rigid and ridiculous. Of course you should be on time but a few minutes early or late is not something anyone should be stressed about. Putting him in the buggy again sounds stupid. Find someone else.

Oranesandlemons · 01/02/2024 18:24

I’ve been using a childminder for nearly 3 years for my two children now and a huge part of the appeal to me is how flexible she is! I can drop my children off early (by agreement), if I’m running late and she’s doing the school run, I just meet her at the school or wait until she’s home. If I’m held up, I message her to ask if I can pick up a bit later. She says no when it doesn’t work for her, but when it does work for her she’s happy to be flexible. I obviously pay the extra if I’m dropping off early or picking up late.

My youngest is not quite 2 and she gives her a hug when she walks in and holds her hand etc. I would absolutely hate doing a buggy handover and so would my daughter!

I think the main thing is that if it isn’t working for you, or it’s not a good match, it’s better to find someone new, especially when your child is so little. I definitely don’t think your expectations are unreasonable at all.

BrieAndChilli · 01/02/2024 16:23

I'd be worried if she is waiting outside the house for each drop off then the other children are inside unattended (unless that is why she wants them in a buggy so she can just keep them in the buggy? Which I wouldn't be happy with)

Meals - did she provide an example menu? what sort of things were on that?

Traffic can be so variable - I drop the kids to school, its 2 mile and some days we get there in 7 minutes and others can be 30min! I agree being early or later than your paid time is not on but I think a longer time slot would be acceptable as long as it doesnt interfere with school runs that she has to do.

Littlemisscapable · 01/02/2024 16:19

No I wouldn't be happy with this at all..of course you would never want to be dropping off before she started or picking up after she finished but otherwise there should be some flexibility. She's obviously on a school run and wants your child not to disrupt her routine in any way. She should be engaging with your 10 month old not wanting them strapped in buggy..if its hard to accommodate you then she should just say so now as a full time place I would want my dc to be really happy there..

AhBiscuits · 01/02/2024 16:13

I wouldn't be interested in continuing with her. Ridiculous.

Anjea · 01/02/2024 16:08

Nah she's nuts

Jelouscat · 01/02/2024 16:00

No she sounds bonkers and far too rigid for me. I can drop my child off whenever really. If I’m going to be significantly later than usual I’ll message her and she’ll tell me if they are planning to be out and suggest I drop DD off there. I pick her up at any time before 5pm (but I know they’ll be off on the school run between certain times) and I just turn up. If I’m running late she never charges me (because it’s rare and I’m flexible with her when she’s running late in the mornings etc). We have a quick chat at drop off and pick up while wresting the children in and out. I just plonk DD on her doorstep and she runs in happily. So do the other children who may or may not arrive at the same time. She’s a brilliant childminder and I’ve used her for both my kids for the last 5 years. She’s (understandably) strict about no early drop offs unless pre-arranged. Lunch is usually cold and in the form of ham or cheese wraps with veg. Sometimes pasta. It’s doesn’t bother me that it’s not hot. Saves me checking what they had for lunch to make sure it doesn’t clash with dinner.

ellie09 · 01/02/2024 15:43

No not normal.

What happens if there is traffic or delays etc?

Mine wants dropped off in the morning anytime from 7:30-8:30 and can pick up anytime from 4:00-7:00pm. She just asks for an estimate on the time we will be coming.

Ours doesnt provide meals so we send lunch etc although there has been days she has given him some dinner which I have been grateful for - just nuggets, waffles etc.

I had a previous childminder that was exactly the same only she provided meals, and the meals provided were always "hot meals" e.g. stew, mini roast, pasta etc.

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 01/02/2024 15:39

I think the "childminders" saying they think this is reasonable have never worked in a proper childcare setting outside their own house/bubble. Because all nurseries and schools manage to cope with kids getting dropped off. Usually parents queue outside.

Thank God when we moved from a nursery to a childminder she was very experienced as a nursery manager and can handle a few parents lining up outside her door for drop off and cope with feeding the children nutritious meals and giving them engaging activities. I've never seen children fastened into high chairs/buggies at her house, either.

OP your whole childminder's set up sounds awful. Just goes to show you can get all the qualifications/legal requirements in the world but there's no substitute for actually working in childcare before striking out alone.

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 01/02/2024 15:31

Bonkers, find something else.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 01/02/2024 15:03

It’s the complete lack of flex and that put me off a childminder. If she’s sick or goes on holiday - that’s your problem. Your one sounds incredibly high maintenance

nursery - drop off when you like and collect when you like ( before closing) hot food, staff sick? THEIR problem!

momonpurpose · 01/02/2024 14:50

Bladwdoda · 01/02/2024 10:29

Doesn’t sound normal to me.
Fair enough making sure people are on time for drop off, but expecting people to text 2 mins before drop off every day is extreme and the buggy thing sounds silly too.

I also wouldn’t be happy with that food situation. That’s not an actual lunch it is, it’s snacks.

with childminders I think you have to follow your gut. You’re not happy with her and I think it’s good to listen to that.

I agree with this. None of this is normal and I'd look to find someone else. You do not need this drama when you go back to work

Beautiful3 · 01/02/2024 14:47

That sounds far too strict and controlling. I'd change child minder.

tralalalalalalalal · 01/02/2024 14:43

Not normal and I'd swap now so he has time to settle in somewhere else! She sounds mad

Toooldforthis36 · 01/02/2024 14:06

Crappy lunch, I’d complain about that.

HAF1119 · 01/02/2024 14:05

I have also used a nursery - you can be late dropping off but not early, they kept door shut (1 or 2 mins ok to ring the bell but not before) and again you can be early as you like to pickup, but don't be late :)

HAF1119 · 01/02/2024 14:04

Not normal at all! And I'd find it a bit odd she only wants to meet you outside. I've used 3 childminders and know a few, none need a message before dropping off, all just open the front door and whatever children are there are playing in the background and that's lovely, chaotic, and totally normal. The buggy thing is madness too when you're coming by car.

I do text when I'm going to pickup but that's so they can get him in coat and shoes without me there at the door while he runs about saying 'I don't wanna go yet I'm playing' etc, so more for me than them as I can't be doing with the fact that he likes it there more than at mine and having him ready for me to do a quick handover and go is better for me!

anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled · 01/02/2024 13:58

Universalsnail · 01/02/2024 13:03

Ex childminder here.

Her rules about timings are reasonable. If you are late you throw the morning routine off massively which is a problem if you have drop offs to do and your arrival time is close to needing to leave drop offs. I was always quite relaxed about people being early but tbh that can also be a problem because if someone is too early I might not ready. Personally If I was you I would be 5 mins early and wait in the car.
Does she use his buggy to take him out with or her own. Tbh if she doesn't use the buggy to take him out with I think she's being rediculous needing him to be in the buggy and you should be able to hand him over by hand.

Edited

What a total PITA I think claiming"unsettling routine" is laughable if you can't manage to allow parents more than a 5 minute a lot in which to drop off their child and insist on a buggy from the car to the door

OP it's not normal at all and there is no way I'd put up with this

WimpoleHat · 01/02/2024 13:56

For me, a childminder has to be flexible. They work with babies and toddlers FGS!

With the caveat that I have never used a childminder - this is what jumped out at me! Small kids can’t be managed to the minute. Is she as rigid about rules with the children she minds?

WavingCatsandDogs · 01/02/2024 13:46

I'd never drop off before time but after, if it's a few minutes is weird.

The buggy thing is also weird. It's up to her to manage the drop off. Tell her you're not doing it anymore,

She must know with babies you can't always guarantee how they will be.
Tell her you do your best and to stop texting. You will only text if 10 mins late.