Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

…or is my childminder?

286 replies

Childminderwoes · 01/02/2024 10:25

DS is 10 months and started with a childminder 6 weeks ago. 2 days a week so I can get various things done before my maternity leave ends in March, and full time hours when I go back.

He has a drop off/pick up time as you would expect but she’s very very very rigid about this. And will message to complain if you’re not there at the exact minute because she has other drops offs 5 minutes either side of his slot. To the extent where she’s messaged to complain about him being dropped off 2 or 3 minutes before or after his set time.

She wants me to text 2 minutes before arrival every time he’s dropped off, so she can come outside to collect him, and is very firm about this, and will again text if I forget to remind me for next time.

She wants him to be in the buggy at every drop off to minimise his distress at being ‘handed over’ which I understood for the first few weeks but it’s become a real pain getting the buggy out of the car, setting it up and strapping him in just to wheel him down her driveway.

She’s really lovely but after 5 weeks all of it is getting a bit much. I thought by now I would be able to just hand him over, as you would expect mornings are a bit mad as I also have a 4 year old to get to school. All these extra caveats are starting to grate on me a little.

To add to this I’m not too sure about his meals. He has lunch at hers, but never what I would call a proper lunch - the diary entry says things like bread sticks, toast, pouches, fruit. I suppose I expected he would have something a bit healthier and hot.

Is this normal for a childminder?

OP posts:
VinegarTrio · 03/02/2024 13:10

thunder234 · 03/02/2024 11:48

Couldnt agree more. Nurseries are a much better option

I don’t necessarily agree with this as a blanket statement.

Nurseries are a much better option for some families and children. Childminders are a much better option for others.

Quality varies across settings whatever type of early years provision you use.

I use a nursery for DS3 (and did for DS2). It works well for us. A childminder turned out to suit DS1 far better when he was little, and worked for my circumstances too. DS1 had a terrible time at nursery as a baby and it was so much better for him when I switched to a childminder.

theduchessofspork · 03/02/2024 13:06

Find someone else

VinegarTrio · 03/02/2024 13:06

Universalsnail · 03/02/2024 12:43

No of course not. Childminder clearly expects parents to arrive and then text from outside not while driving. Don't be so rediculous

Are you the childminder this OP is talking about?

I can think of no other reason why you’d be defending a policy of allocating 5 minute drop off/pick up windows and expecting parents to arrive two minutes early and text from the car so the childminder can come out and get the child.

It’s such a weird, undesirable and obviously not going to work in reality policy to have.

VinegarTrio · 03/02/2024 13:04

Universalsnail · 03/02/2024 12:49

It is not really that difficult to arrive somewhere early then get out of the car and arrive on the door step by the time you are meant to be there. I do think the childminder is being rediculous with the text 2 minute thing but it's not unreasonable to ask for people to be on time not early or late.

I agree with you about saying the child needs to be dropped off earlier. I had some situations where parents didn't want to pay for earlier and wanted to drop off when they needed it. I was a soft touch tbh and often would let people drop off earlier and I'd not charge the extra but without knowing why the parent has arranged that this the drop off time it's hard to comment on.

Setting 5 minute windows is just ridiculous. Even more so doing them back to back and getting annoyed that the parents aren’t hitting their 5 min window perfectly.

Even my local primary school manages a 10 minute window for children to come
into school. And schools are hardly known for their flexibility!

I would never pick a childminder who is monitoring things by minutes like this. When I did use a childminder, she basically charged in half day increments with opening and closing times for the sessions (like nurseries usually do), and school run windows where everyone knew she’s be out doing the school run. I’d let her know if I was going to be earlier or later than I usually was within those hours (so she could make sure she was ready etc) but there’s no way I’d have been interested in someone counting down minutes to calculate charges.

Having to keep track of and bill for attendance on a to the minute basis just creates masses of extra paperwork for everyone involved - so I don’t see how a childminder even benefits from this kind of policy.

Scottishgirl85 · 03/02/2024 12:50

We have used a childminder for 5 years. She's wonderful and feels part of our extended family. It would be no problem to drop a bit late, but picking up late is definitely a no-no.The buggy thing is beyond weird. Do you leave her with your buggy?

Universalsnail · 03/02/2024 12:49

prescribingmum · 01/02/2024 20:34

Her rules about timings are utterly ridiculous! If a cm needs to do a school run (as our one used to), she tells parents the times she will not be available for drop off ie come before 8.15 or after 9. Requesting parents do not turn up early is also entirely reasonable as she maybe sorting her own family.

Requesting parents arrive within a 2 minute window is ludicrous! Schools and nurseries all have a window to account to traffic/other children/other eventualities. Requesting a text message at a specific time (which can only be sent whilst driving to achieve the request) is also crazy! And unless she is about to take the child on the school run/walk by foot the moment they arrive, there is no rational reason they need to be put in a buggy before being taken to the front door.

This all just makes a busy parents life harder. I would certainly be looking elsewhere

It is not really that difficult to arrive somewhere early then get out of the car and arrive on the door step by the time you are meant to be there. I do think the childminder is being rediculous with the text 2 minute thing but it's not unreasonable to ask for people to be on time not early or late.

I agree with you about saying the child needs to be dropped off earlier. I had some situations where parents didn't want to pay for earlier and wanted to drop off when they needed it. I was a soft touch tbh and often would let people drop off earlier and I'd not charge the extra but without knowing why the parent has arranged that this the drop off time it's hard to comment on.

Universalsnail · 03/02/2024 12:45

anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled · 01/02/2024 13:58

What a total PITA I think claiming"unsettling routine" is laughable if you can't manage to allow parents more than a 5 minute a lot in which to drop off their child and insist on a buggy from the car to the door

OP it's not normal at all and there is no way I'd put up with this

I feel like clearly people can't read because I said I thought the buggy was unnecessary.

But yes I think it's completely reasonable to expect parents to not be late if you have to leave to take children on the school run etc. really the childminder should arrange for the child to turn up earlier so it isn't so rushed but parent might not want to pay for an earlier drop off.

Universalsnail · 03/02/2024 12:43

Reugny · 01/02/2024 13:34

So you expect someone to text while driving?

Oh and if you need to leave at a particular time to do a school drop off tell the parents that you do a school drop off at x time so you need to be there x minutes before.

No of course not. Childminder clearly expects parents to arrive and then text from outside not while driving. Don't be so rediculous

Universalsnail · 03/02/2024 12:42

OVienna · 01/02/2024 13:31

To the MINUTE, as opposed to a window, plus the malarky around texting EVERY MORNING two minutes before the official drop off time. Did you read that part?

Yeah I think the texting is weird.

But I think to the minute is fine. Just be early and wait in your car.

user1492757084 · 03/02/2024 12:03

Now that your child is used to her, ask to drop him off not in the push chair. It is unreasonable that you have to deliver him that way now that he probably won't cling to you.
It is dangerous to text and drive. Can't she agree to you texting that you have left home and will most likely arrive XXX minutes later?
But try to be diligent about drop off time.
You might not be suited to one another.

thunder234 · 03/02/2024 11:48

LondonLass91 · 03/02/2024 09:40

She sounds like a nightmare. Can you imagine what she's like when your little precious baby accidentally touches something he isn't supposed to? He can hardly tell you that she shouted or smacked him. I would never leave my child with someone like this. You seem scared of her? Run for the hills. Can't you put your child in nursery. At least you'll know there is more than one person there so hopefully be safer.

Couldnt agree more. Nurseries are a much better option

Awaywiththeferries123 · 03/02/2024 11:29

God no! Our childminder enhances our lives, she’s doesn’t add to our stresses.

You need to find another one I’m afraid.

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 03/02/2024 11:27

She's far too rigid with timings. I wonder if the child being in the buggy and wheeled into the house means she doesn't have to watch them until all the other children have arrived - a sort of restraint which isn't on.
Also, giving you all specific times to drop off and pick up is actively making sure you don't meet other parents. Why? That seems odd.
And lunch. I would have expected the children to have a nice healthy meal at a table to help with social and motor skills development in this area. All the things you describe are like snacks rather than an actual meal. Cheaper and easier to prepare.
If you're in England, check out her Ofsted report.
Honestly though, I'd be looking for different childcare for my wee one. There are too many things concerning you to keep your child there.

Fundays12 · 03/02/2024 11:13

Definitely not normal. Sometimes no matter how hard you try you will be 5 minutes late with traffic etc and the getting the buggy out is total madness and sets alarm bells of to me.

I used a childminder for years for my younger DC. Drop of times were set but if I was a minute or two late there was no issue. I wasn't ever late for pick up out of respect. I provided packed lunches as that was the normal though I think she did offer hot meal lunches at an additional charge. There was the odd occasion she would meet me on her drive and pop DC in her buggy as she was walking to the park or something.

Q13 · 03/02/2024 11:05

That's insane, no way I would leave my child in that sort of set up, how can anyone arrive on an exact minute with traffic and maybe a dirty nappy as you go out the door.. pulling over to find a doddee.. etc etc. And he should be getting some proper food!

Grimbelina · 03/02/2024 11:05

This sounds incredibly controlling and I would also worry if he was being left in the buggy for periods. I would definitely be looking for a new CM.

fleurneige · 03/02/2024 10:57

You need to go right back to interview time. Did you explain clearly what YOUR expectations are, what you expect her to cook for lunchtime, etc.

It is difficult to find good child carers, and it seems some people just pick anyone who seems 'nice'- and perhaps 'cheap' (comparatively) - and not interview properly with clear expectations. The of course, things get complicated. Is she qualified, has she got experience, does she receive a proper salary and is legally registered, etc, etc.? So many questions here.

AhBiscuits · 03/02/2024 10:42

For drop off at nursery I would walk my child in, settle them with a toy, give them a cuddle and a kiss goodbye. I wouldn't leave my child somewhere if I couldn't see the environment.

Nets281 · 03/02/2024 10:37

agree - something doesn’t sit right here. I wonder how many other children she minds and if their parents have to work by the same rules

Minutepapillon · 03/02/2024 10:32

I'm a childminder. If she is on a tight schedule for school run or activities, then it could make children late for school, etc if drop off times noted in the contract aren't respected. I would expect a text if running very late, otherwise no, but all parents know my schedule before they sign the contract. If I have an appointment, or another change to usual schedule or the parents do, it's agreed with as needs be (and if possible). A small minority of parents take the piss and turn up noticeably early or late. Maybe this is why she is rigid over times? I'd ask why.

For the lunches, no way. Proper cooked food, as little processed as possible.

And I provide pushchair/car seat for our days and only want pushchair if someone else is collecting child. I can't safely store 2 extra pushchairs! A hug and 'have a nice day' from the parent are so important before leaving the child. All parents take their children into the house and we do a proper handover, I ask if child had a good night and tell parent what we'll be doing (and eating). It's so much nicer for us all. And the same in reverse in the evening.

NextPrimeMinister · 03/02/2024 10:25

How does pick up work?

If you have to text your arrival and DC is wheeled out to you, I'd be very concerned and imagine, like previous posters have said, he's in that chair throughout the day.

I'd move him and report to ofstead.

AuntMarch · 03/02/2024 10:19

My childminder provided snacks, not lunch. I preferred it as I could plan his lunch around what we'd be having for dinner and I knew I was in control of keeping the balance. I wouldn't necessarily expect a hot meal, if she has different ages (stages of weaning), dietary requirements etc that could add considerable time to her working day.. you wouldn't want her doing it when caring for your child after all.

The rest though... she wouldn't have been for me. Mine only asked that children were there before 9.30 as they went out most days!

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 03/02/2024 10:10

That would not be a match for me!

wronginalltherightways · 03/02/2024 10:00

An exact minute is ridiculous. A window, and never arriving before your drop off window or after your pick up window is definitely more sensible and customary. Insisting on a buggy handover is also unreasonable.

You should also expect a proper meal at some point during the day for your child, not just snack bits.

Every single thing seems to be about her convenience, not yours, and you're paying her for the privilege. I would be looking elsewhere.