Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be at the end of my tether with school?

232 replies

Pillowchase · 01/02/2024 06:25

DS is in reception, he turned 5 last week.

Thankfully he settled into school the first term and was really enjoying it, I was aware this could change anytime but I find the circumstances upsetting and frustrating and not sure what to do.

Since the start of this term school have phoned 5 times because he's been pushed over, had things thrown at him causing bruising and he was bitten; 1 of which required a medical check up. Its the same child, at the end of the day they're 4, they probably have something else going on (which isn't my business) and I appreciate the teacher has a hard job managing an entire class.

Its reached the point though I'm now furious and really upset about it. Everytime I speak to school I very much angle it as well what are you going to implement to keep my child safe- they always promise this and that but I've had enough. He's been told to always stay away from this child, the teacher says he does do this but what he doesn't always do is immediately move away when the child approaches. So everytime he's playing at a station or whatever he's supposed to drop everything immediately even if he's enjoying himself and with friends if this child decides they want to be go there; ridiculous in hindsight but there we go. Yesterday I had another call saying DS was playing at the water table and because he didn't move away straight away when this child approached it was unfortunate but he was pushed over and basically ended up with his face in the water and his stomach catching the side of the tub. He was told off for not moving away which I was furious about.

Anyway, DS has been up most of the night crying and saying he doesn't want to go back to school. I can't blame him, but what do I do? I've enquired at other local schools and no spaces to transfer, homeschooling isn't an option and for his sake I don't want to keep him off regularly in case he's physically assaulted at school.

I've been understanding until now, probably too much so and haven't advocated for DS as much as I should as I've tried to see the whole picture and feel for the child who evidently isn't getting the support they need; but I've had enough. I've spoken to the teachers and said if the issue is he's being mean/antagonising the child or triggering them somehow let me know and I'll reinforce at home not to do this etc, but they say no he's always just playing with others or minding his own business.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
clarehhh · 05/02/2024 13:23

No one has mentioned if he was pushed in the water enough to hurt his stomach he could have drowned. It only takes a tablespoon of water. Stay very calm at the meeting, note all all incidents and agree a safeguarding scheme for him. I feel for the poor teacher.

ClumsyNinja · 05/02/2024 10:05

Naptrappedmummy · 05/02/2024 09:51

I've said don't simply walk away from an activity as that's not fair, but to speak to an adult in the room (which the school have agreed to manage) if they don't notice first and intervene.

Even I don’t really understand what this means or what it looks like, so God knows how a 5 year old does.

Really, that’s a shame that you don’t understand what that means, but luckily the OP’s 5yr old is able to both understand the advice and act on it.

Hankunamatata · 05/02/2024 10:00

I think you have handled this with style and grace op. You have advocated for your dc without all guns blazing or making the other child out to be a monster.

SparkleGranny · 05/02/2024 09:54

As a former teacher, I wish all parents were as sensible as you. Your update shows that you are helping your child to learn to manage interacting with people in the real world in a way that respects everyone. You supported them by listening to your child, and going to talk to staff at school. You've given your child specific practical strategies for what to do in those situations at school (very important) so that their rights are not compromised and they are kept safe. You've taken steps to build relationships with the school staff, showing your concern and desire to find a positive way forward and you've even had a useful general chat with the other child's mum. You've arranged for the child's dad to be involved when he's back. All this means that everyone can move forward together and you're not setting up imagined and unhelpful battle lines with you and your child on one side and the school/other kid on the other. That's a great role model for your kid. Well done.

Naptrappedmummy · 05/02/2024 09:51

I've said don't simply walk away from an activity as that's not fair, but to speak to an adult in the room (which the school have agreed to manage) if they don't notice first and intervene.

Even I don’t really understand what this means or what it looks like, so God knows how a 5 year old does.

Pillowchase · 05/02/2024 09:49

Naptrappedmummy · 05/02/2024 09:37

Because a reception age child won’t understand about special needs, when the lines are crossed, why there are different standards of behaviour for different children and so on.

At 5, all he needs to be told is that somebody attacking him is never ok, and he must tell the teacher every time it happens. With you and the school sorting this out behind the scenes.

The rather confused message he will now take away is that it’s ok for children to attack him if he does something to provoke them (and he won’t even be clear on what that ‘something’ is). He likely won’t report further attacks as he will blame himself and worry he will be punished for causing them.

It’s not his, or your, job to ‘support’ this other child. It’s your job to protect your son, not rush to sound inclusive at the cost of his safety.

If somebody attacked you in the local shop just think how shaken up you would be. That’s what he is facing every day. With his own mum telling him to ‘respect’ and ‘support’.

Anyway I’ll finish there.

I've not said that to him at any point though, you're massively projecting. I've said don't simply walk away from an activity as that's not fair, but to speak to an adult in the room (which the school have agreed to manage) if they don't notice first and intervene. The school apologised for suggesting he should be the one to simply walk away following me speaking to them and advocating for my DS. It was made very clear to him that being attacked is never okay, and that it wasnt his fault.

Personally I think it's fine to tell a child that x needs space and to honour that (again, not when it directly affects what DS is doing but in general) whilst not ostracising and being nasty to them. An important part of learning at that age should be social stuff- to be considerate of others whilst not losing out yourself. He will be be with children with additional needs throughout school and out in the 'real world', I'd rather he understand that it's not his fault and never acceptable to hit but that some children find some environments more challenging and it doesn't make them mean or nasty as he said at the start. You can teach both.

I've literally never said he should just accept it and never report, I did however suggest it would be nice to also acknowledge their kind behaviour- not that it mitigates the rest. Is that the part you have an issue with?

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 05/02/2024 09:37

Because a reception age child won’t understand about special needs, when the lines are crossed, why there are different standards of behaviour for different children and so on.

At 5, all he needs to be told is that somebody attacking him is never ok, and he must tell the teacher every time it happens. With you and the school sorting this out behind the scenes.

The rather confused message he will now take away is that it’s ok for children to attack him if he does something to provoke them (and he won’t even be clear on what that ‘something’ is). He likely won’t report further attacks as he will blame himself and worry he will be punished for causing them.

It’s not his, or your, job to ‘support’ this other child. It’s your job to protect your son, not rush to sound inclusive at the cost of his safety.

If somebody attacked you in the local shop just think how shaken up you would be. That’s what he is facing every day. With his own mum telling him to ‘respect’ and ‘support’.

Anyway I’ll finish there.

Pillowchase · 05/02/2024 09:23

Naptrappedmummy · 05/02/2024 09:10

I think you’re giving very mixed messages to your very little son, and he deserves for you to be more on his side than that. Sorry.

In what way?

OP posts:
SalmonWellington · 05/02/2024 09:20

I think you're handling it perfectly.

Naptrappedmummy · 05/02/2024 09:10

I think you’re giving very mixed messages to your very little son, and he deserves for you to be more on his side than that. Sorry.

Pillowchase · 05/02/2024 09:08

Sorry haven't been on in a few days!

Have a meeting with DH as well on Wednesday. DS came home on Friday and said x was really kind to me today, he checked I was okay when I fell over in the playground. I did say to him be nice to let the TA know as I feel for this child its a big thing to do that. We had some chats around respecting the need to give space to x whilst also not being mean/nasty (not that DS would I don't think but don't want him to think giving space means no one should play with them and should be ostracised). Teacher agreed the advice to fully stay away and move when playing and they approached was unfair- have said to DS that they can go speak to them if they're in the middle of playing and they'll help manage it (not sure how but at least they now acknowledge it was wrong to say this).

I'm going to remain firm in that DS needs to be kept safe and not made to feel that he needs to drop what he's doing all of the time; but also with DS to try and explain in an age appropriate way that some children struggle more in certain situations and its good to respect that and support whilst not disadvanataging ourselves everytime.

I actually saw his mum in Asda of all places, I sort of knew her by sight but she came up and said are you ys mum- was a bit worried to be honest as you never know how it'll go. We just had a general chat to be honest, it was nice to break the ice as it were and whilst still not going to use it to talk about school stuff, I feel like it's a weight lifted.

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 05/02/2024 08:50

I’m very uncomfortable with the viewpoint that if a child has triggers, then every other child should tiptoe around them to avoid getting hurt. What kind of message does that send out?

MrsSymon · 05/02/2024 07:54

It's not just safeguarding for your son but also the sen child too ! If the child is like this everyday the school/parents needs to assess his needs and why he is like it and look at 1-1 funding

MrsSymon · 05/02/2024 07:51

This is a safeguarding issue you can Google the process of complaining it starts with the teacher then the headteacher then the board of governors I did this with my son as soon as I contact the board I had very quick responses from the head after being ignored for ages , good luck ! Oh and mention safegaurding as soon as you mention that they normally start flapping !

tinytim2016 · 05/02/2024 07:26

I feel for you honestly. First have the meeting and put a formal complaint in about the person telling your child off for not moving. Kids need to learn to share. I'm guessing teacher is probably scared of other child's parents or the confrontation. Your child has the right to be safe. I had same problem with my son every week. Write everything down and send emails to the school saying your concerns then you have proof if needed later on.

HFJ · 05/02/2024 06:56

Regardless of the needs and level of understanding of children with SEN, it is possible to learn.

I’d be asking school leaders about what rules, routines and habits are being TAUGHT, practised and praised. Children love getting simple things right if they know what to do because the adults have made it clear.

If the reply indicates there is none of this, and instead perhaps a more reactive-only ‘wait till they’re ready/offer choices/get more adults in/reduce expectations’, then I’d be taking this to the chair of governors.

MikeBrns · 05/02/2024 06:44

It's always the case these days that schools never deal with the troubled child, they actually move the kids being bullied. Schools have a legal right to protect your child when you leave them in their custom. Ask the school to arrange a meeting with the other child parents and have a one on one. If it still continues, ask to have a meeting with the head of education, also ask the school for a copy of their anti bullying policy, every school must carry a copy. Sorry to hear about your child hope it's sorted soon.

stichguru · 04/02/2024 17:20

If you have told the whole story, this would be a straight if there are more incidents you will be sued for failure in keeping my son safe. Occasional incidents are understandable accidents, but repeated incidents are not.

inappropriateportioncontrol · 03/02/2024 08:38

@Pillowchase you sound so thoughtful and considerate.I'm glad your little boy was happier yesterday .
Just going to repeat this
Ideally take someone with you to take notes, or else record the meeting - it's perfectly legal and you don't have to ask permission. Produce your own minutes of the meeting and send them to the head and class teacher afterwards.
as i think note taking by a third party and then feeding back to school is such excellent advice .

IsadoraSpoon · 03/02/2024 07:50

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 02/02/2024 21:46

You're making an awful lot of assumptions here. Autism/the bullying isn't on purpose/they don't know what they're doing. It is bullying; there may be reasons why they're acting the way they are but it still boils down to bullying another child, regardless of the intent behind it.

I'm stopping here because I can't believe I've been dragged into an argument about whether a child who almost certainly has SEND is a bully. My assumptions are based on two decades in the classroom and being a SENCO. I've encountered a few 'naughty' children aged four; I've encountered far more children with unmet and at that stage undiagnosed SEND. I suspect many posters on this thread havent actually experienced working with children.

AuntMarch · 03/02/2024 01:38

Jelouscat · 02/02/2024 03:56

Sorry your DS is going through this IOP. If the child in question has diagnosed SEN they could be offered an EHCP which would give one-to-one support. Perhaps you could enquire with the school whether or not they are supporting the family for this to happen.

Not a quick process, unfortunately. My friends daughter has one now but it was a long time in the making. By the time she finally got it, it immediately needed updating because the information it was bases on was so out of date!

Boomboom22 · 02/02/2024 22:27

It is possible for children who are autistic to be naughty. They do have personalities. They are people, not just a label.

Plus autism is a catch all umbrella term for everything from non verbal non continence with developmental delay to academically brilliant. It is a completely unhelpful label in terms of telling teachers what support an individual needs.

Really each child should be taught to their own needs with a relationship with the teacher, who gets them. The teachers professional judgement about suitable provision should have a lot more weight than the parents.

And all children should be safe. Ultimately I do think the needs of the majority must drive education. With provision then in place, yes inclusive but within reason.

Fraaahnces · 02/02/2024 21:53

Whoops.. trying to type one-handed.
or any other SEND. It is not a catch-all for all behavioural problems. SOME kids are naughty.

Fraaahnces · 02/02/2024 21:52

Also, nobody knows whether THIS specific kid has ASD or any

Worriedmotheroftwo · 02/02/2024 21:50

I find the lack of understanding of autism on this thread absolutely sickening.