Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking employer to cover childcare costs

881 replies

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 05:33

I’ve been asked to go on a business trip for a week, is it unreasonable to ask the company to pay the incremental childcare costs?

OP posts:
Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 10:07

@girlswillbegirls i would expect to compensate everyone who was going on a 10 day trip. But then I don’t work for a shit company, we look after our employees. It’s not up to an employer to decide who does what in our employees’ homes. If sending them on a work trip is going to cause issues, financial or otherwise, then of course I would plan to mitigate that.

Flamme · 02/02/2024 10:06

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 06:53

@MayThe4th i don’t see why my partner should be expected to cover it. Man or woman, in this day and age…if incremental costs are incurred for business purposes why is is so outrageous to ask the organisation to pay?

He's expected to because you signed up for it when you took the job.

girlswillbegirls · 02/02/2024 09:31

@Littlegoth I know you are HR but you are also missing the point. If a company want to compensate EVERYONE on the team for their time away that's fine. Because everyone's time outside working hours is valuable. The issue here is the justification of asking for covering for childcare because the father of the kids can't cope. That's ridiculous, sorry. Why would you make an special allowance because this person can't sort this out at home with a partner. And seing this as progressive is to me frankly stupid. We need men to get the finger out and not employers to subsidise their lack of cop on.

As the last poster said, where do you draw the line?

stichguru · 02/02/2024 09:26

To me it depends on two things: is the travel (even occasional travel) part of the job you signed up for? When you sign up for a 9-5 with children, you don't ask to be paid more than a childless person working those hours, it's your job to factor the childcare in when you decide whether the job pays enough for you to apply. If you apply for a job with travel, then you factor in the overnight care costs when you apply. No need for them to pay you more, you shouldn't have taken the job, if you could afford to get your children cared for while you did it. However, if it is an unknown one off, maybe a sudden conference that you weren't expecting, then I think yes they should pay costs, because you didn't know you would have those costs.

Secondly, is it essential that you go? If it has just been suggested you go, then if you can't or don't want to fund the childcare, work have given you an excellent option of not going! They don't need to fund the childcare because you can take the other option they have given you. If however, there is quite a lot of pressure on you to go, then they need to either make not going a reasonable option, or help remove the barriers to you going.

twnety · 02/02/2024 09:18

Jumpingthruhoops · 01/02/2024 16:59

I can see both sides. Professionally, I don't think asking about childcare costs will go down well. As others have said, it's this sort of thing that could potentially put employers off hiring women of child-bearing age. Yes, it's wrong - but it is what it is.

Financially, though, as you say, a company would naturally pay for flight, hotels, meals etc on the basis that, if you were not in Africa, these are costs you wouldn't incur. So, by that same logic, if you were here and not in Africa, you wouldn't incur the costs involved in having to pay someone else look after your child. So, for that reason, it should be factored in like any other expenses.

All that being said, if I were in this scenario at work, I'd probably want to demonstrate to my employers a willingness to travel and would suck up the cost.

So, by that same logic, if you were here and not in Africa, you wouldn't incur the costs involved in having to pay someone else look after your child. So, for that reason, it should be factored in like any other expenses.

But again, my dog, my cat, my plants, my volunteering - all things that would/could incur costs if I am away, what about the second job I have in the evenings at the local pub, I wont be getting that money either.... and I also make scultures which take 2 nights and I sell each one for £10,000 - so the company needs to pay for 5? of those, £50,000 please (obviously I am being ridiculous with numbers)

Where do we draw a line? Should we pay for childcare - personally I think not. Just because you cannot drop them at a kennel (as a pp said) children is a choice (for the majority of people)

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 08:47

I can’t help but shake my head here. I am evil HR, there for the business (according to mumsnet!) and can’t believe the race to the bottom on this thread. Of course you should ask for work to cover any out of pocket expense. What this thread highlights is that there’s an imbalance here between most posters and their employers, as too many of you are happy to accept working conditions and practices that just aren’t fair or reasonable, and you using equality as a reason for accepting unfair conditions. They are only your employer during working hours. They don’t own you. Be aware of your rights and make sure you get them.

A temporary responsibility payment (as it sounds like OP is getting) is completely reasonable here. 10 days is a very big ask of an employer, whatever is in the contract. They don’t own her. 250 a day barely covers the overtime hours - to cover those hours abroad while not in training- based on a 37k salary at basic rate. It’s not a holiday. Her employer owes her remuneration for her time.

Maray1967 · 02/02/2024 08:46

I’m a univ lecturer and when I worked 0.6 but was asked to take on an additional responsibility for a very short time - one month, I think, I was told there was capacity within my contracted hours so no extra salary or overtime money, but my line manager did say I could have an extra day childcare a week for that month and claim it back as an expense.

jeaux90 · 02/02/2024 08:46

I'm a lone parent. My contract is similar. I have to flexi board my DD14 to accommodate the travel asks.

I have no other choice.

If as a lone parent I asked for them to cover it I guess they would start discriminating against single parents.

Sorry OP it's shit but it's life.

Justmyopinionbut · 02/02/2024 08:45

Afraid so, because that's the choice we make when we decide to become parents and work.

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 08:38

CountingDownTheLongDays · 01/02/2024 23:35

People like OP are the ones who hold back the careers of all women of childbearing age, including the infertile and childfree ones.

By the same token, do you think I can get my dog boarding costs covered? Thought not.

No because it’s an animal, not a child. Dogs are property, not people.

girlswillbegirls · 02/02/2024 08:38

YoBeaches · 02/02/2024 07:29

Yes my company would cover your dog boarding costs in this scenario.

Why are you all so against additional employer support to sustain your personal responsibilities for a work commitment?

Another pp said her husband arranged to wfh if she was away - so it's ok for dh work place to make allowances for him as a man. But not for your employer to make allowances for you as a woman?.That's fucked up part here.

This is about equity for both parents to be successful in the workplace.

I am the poster who said my husband arranged with his company to WFH the afternoons in order to facilitate my work trip and mind his own children. I also said that what I would do exactly the same if he needed to travel for work.

It wouldn't cross my mind to ask for extra money to cover for child care while I am away as I consider my husband and father of our children responsible for that.

I would say that fits the definition of equality.

the7Vabo · 02/02/2024 08:26

To the person who said it was your choice to have kids and you are ruining it for others. I disagree I think that attitude is ruining it for others. 10 days is a long time to be away. If also wonder from what you’ve said whether this trip is at all necessary. My older generation should never have normalised self-sacrifice for corporates. What we should normalise is working hard within standard business hours.

The fact that people are back to business trips post-Covid really pisses me off. Training can be done via video call very effectively. The planet is burning up and people are flying to Africa to train people. It’s utterly insane.

EarringsandLipstick · 02/02/2024 07:57

Maybe read every post in future...

🙄

Maybe you should?

Posters said they would expect to be reimbursed for concert tickets or pet sitting fees - not that they had.

Now off you go to read every post. 🫤

ElaineMBenes · 02/02/2024 07:53

expenses when travelling are generally higher than you’d need to spend on an average day because there’s the understanding that you should be compensated for being away from your family. When my husband travels for work, he’s given a daily budget and he’s not expected to scrimp and save for each meal, he’s given enough money that he can have a reasonable meal somewhere nice to eat. The hotels he stays in tend to also be quite nice (ie not the cheapest budget hotels). When my dad used to fly often with work, he travelled business class as a minimum because his company thought this was a reasonable expense to cover.

Unless you work for a university like I do 😂😂
I have strict limits for meals which I can't go over ( Iceland was fun .... chips and a coke was over budget!) and I have to travel economy and stay in hotels within a specified budget.

Horriblescareydolls · 02/02/2024 07:51

What are you asking them to cover is it nursery costs? I can imagine that you normally take your children to their childcare and by that time I assume your partner is at work? Could they move their hours around at all hen you could only ask and say " I'm going to need x number of hour childcare at x cost, partner has moved their hours around but can't do both ends of the day" I suppose it all depends on your contract.

ElaineMBenes · 02/02/2024 07:51

LeedsMum87 · 02/02/2024 07:37

What are the extra childcare costs for? are you part time and being asked to travel on your non working days? If so, I think it’s reasonable to decline due to childcare.

The thing is, international travel is ALWAYS likely to involve travel/work which falls out of your standard working hours.
If it's part of your job then you have to accept it. Typically you get that time back.
I'm coming to the end of a 10 day trip to China and Hong Kong. I will have been away for two weekends when I get home. I couldn't do a trip like this by sticking purely to my working days /hours.

Reb2014 · 02/02/2024 07:49

Ignore my previous comment 😂

I’m so pleased they agreed to cover it! I really don’t understand the comments about OP damaging women’s progress in the workplace.

expenses when travelling are generally higher than you’d need to spend on an average day because there’s the understanding that you should be compensated for being away from your family. When my husband travels for work, he’s given a daily budget and he’s not expected to scrimp and save for each meal, he’s given enough money that he can have a reasonable meal somewhere nice to eat. The hotels he stays in tend to also be quite nice (ie not the cheapest budget hotels). When my dad used to fly often with work, he travelled business class as a minimum because his company thought this was a reasonable expense to cover.

the only reason this isn’t a normal expense to cover is because traditionally wives didn’t work or worked hours where it wouldn’t be affected by the husband going on a business trip. My dad would regularly travel with work (minimum once a month for a week at a time), and if my mum had been working too it would have made his very well paid job not very well paid if he’d had to pay that amount of childcare.
employees shouldn’t be in a worse financial position because their employer wants them to travel. If employers cover taxis, flights, hotels, food, insurance and in some cases security (again, when my dad travelled there were times he needed a full security team at all times), and there are many company’s that pay for their employee to have more than the bare minimum, then I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect for childcare to be one of those expenses.
It’s not an expense the employee would have if they were not away with work, therefore it should be covered by the company.

ElaineMBenes · 02/02/2024 07:47

Another pp said her husband arranged to wfh if she was away - so it's ok for dh work place to make allowances for him as a man. But not for your employer to make allowances for you as a woman?.That's fucked up part here.

How is it fucked up to expect a child's parent to make changes to their working pattern to facilitate childcare?
Why is it only the OPs responsibility to ensure there is childcare available?

I'm currently on an international trip and my DH has had to make arrangements this last week to ensure he's available for drop offs and pick ups. Why wouldn't that be a reasonable expectation? He is their parent after all and I do the same when he is away.

This is about equity for both parents to be successful in the workplace.

Unfortunately the OPs husband doesn't appear to have got the memo......

LeedsMum87 · 02/02/2024 07:39

Could your partner take some annual leave to cover the gap? That’s what my husband does on the odd occasion that I need to work on days our daughter isn’t at nursery x

LeedsMum87 · 02/02/2024 07:37

What are the extra childcare costs for? are you part time and being asked to travel on your non working days? If so, I think it’s reasonable to decline due to childcare.

YoBeaches · 02/02/2024 07:29

CountingDownTheLongDays · 01/02/2024 23:35

People like OP are the ones who hold back the careers of all women of childbearing age, including the infertile and childfree ones.

By the same token, do you think I can get my dog boarding costs covered? Thought not.

Yes my company would cover your dog boarding costs in this scenario.

Why are you all so against additional employer support to sustain your personal responsibilities for a work commitment?

Another pp said her husband arranged to wfh if she was away - so it's ok for dh work place to make allowances for him as a man. But not for your employer to make allowances for you as a woman?.That's fucked up part here.

This is about equity for both parents to be successful in the workplace.

Reb2014 · 02/02/2024 07:22

Tbh I think there’s a few questions I have.

Does your company have access to any free (external) legal help? One of the benefits of my husbands job is we’re given so many hours of free legal advice a year to ask any questions we like. If you do, is it worth asking them about this? Companies get employees to do all sorts of things that they shouldn’t so might be worth seeing if there’s anything that they suggest.

I don’t think you’re unreasonable in asking, but I would be wary about what their response may be if you ask. Could they suddenly make your job unbearable? Could it affect future promotions? If so, it would probably make me pause and think about whether it was worth asking. I know it shouldn’t happen, but it does, so you’d need to think about it.

ultimately I think it’s fine to ask, you might just need to be prepared for any potential consequences of asking and decide whether you’re ok with those consequences.

ElaineMBenes · 02/02/2024 07:09

girlswillbegirls · 01/02/2024 23:03

Sorry I think people here are missing the point.

Just back from a working trip. I'm female. My husband arranged with his company to WFH afternoons while I was away. And he minded his own children. As I would if he was away.

We are in 2024. And people are saying here well done OP, you got your company to pay for the extra childcare because your partner can't cope.

Is this what we are aiming for as women?

You've summed up my feelings perfectly.
Quite frankly I'd be embarrassed to admit to my employer that my husband couldn't cope with some additional childcare in order to facilitate a work trip.

Ggttl · 02/02/2024 06:59

My work doesn’t expect anyone with young children to do over night travel. They do ask but it is usually only the men who agree to go.

Passingthethyme · 02/02/2024 01:32

CountingDownTheLongDays · 01/02/2024 23:35

People like OP are the ones who hold back the careers of all women of childbearing age, including the infertile and childfree ones.

By the same token, do you think I can get my dog boarding costs covered? Thought not.

Yep agree

Swipe left for the next trending thread