Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking employer to cover childcare costs

881 replies

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 05:33

I’ve been asked to go on a business trip for a week, is it unreasonable to ask the company to pay the incremental childcare costs?

OP posts:
Magicmama92 · 02/02/2024 12:28

I would just go and speak to your boss and say I have kids I cant just go off for a week. That you've never been sent out and worked at your desk for years. That you have no need to go away as you can do the job the same from your desk.
It may be time to consider a move to a job they can't just decide you are traveling away for. It seems unfair for jobs to randomly expect people to be able to travel or go to team building. I always just say no I just want to to my job role and no more and they accept that.
People on here saying that she chose to have kids and you should think of the future I hope you realise birth control fails. You cannot see in to every possible future occurrence. I don't think it's feasible that your job should cover all childcare expenses but I would maybe say I either can't go or il need some help with covering child care. If they need you to go that badly they may give some towards it or they will say it's fine for you to stay.
Maybe ask if you can have the travel thing removed since you say you don't actually need to travel anyway.

Jumpingthruhoops · 02/02/2024 12:21

twnety · 02/02/2024 09:18

So, by that same logic, if you were here and not in Africa, you wouldn't incur the costs involved in having to pay someone else look after your child. So, for that reason, it should be factored in like any other expenses.

But again, my dog, my cat, my plants, my volunteering - all things that would/could incur costs if I am away, what about the second job I have in the evenings at the local pub, I wont be getting that money either.... and I also make scultures which take 2 nights and I sell each one for £10,000 - so the company needs to pay for 5? of those, £50,000 please (obviously I am being ridiculous with numbers)

Where do we draw a line? Should we pay for childcare - personally I think not. Just because you cannot drop them at a kennel (as a pp said) children is a choice (for the majority of people)

Where do we draw the line? Definitely before dog, cats, plants and sculptures... 🤷‍♀️

Respectfully, what you outline is a bit of a strawman argument...

girlswillbegirls · 02/02/2024 12:07

boomingaround · 02/02/2024 10:50

This may be true as a general position but it's not true in this specific case. The OP is asking if she can ask her employer to pay for wrap around care whilst she is away with work because another available parent can't be bothered to do it. In the alternative scenario if her partner was away he would not ask for the same support from his employer because he would have the OP doing this for him. The end result is that OP is the one taking the hit on her career and a VERY IMPORTANT MAN is left to pursue his entirely unfettered from childcare responsibilities because his partner does it when she is here and her workplace covers it when she is not. What would actually progress women's rights in this scenario is for OP to tell her husband she's off on a work trip so he needs to cover the drop off and pick up for ten days and for him to tell his own workplace that is what he is doing for ten days whilst his partner is away. End result in this scenario is the OP nurtures her career, her partner gets off his arse and becomes an equal partner in childcare and his employer sees that men are also capable of childcare and that men also need concessions for childcare rather than it just being the sole responsibility of the woman and, by extension, her workplace.

This exactly summarised my thoughts.

Can people not see women have to start feeling equal to be equal? Make him make the arrangements with his workplace to look after his own children in this scenario (as any female would do).
I still have to see the first man going to HR to ask to cover for wraparound care because his female partner and mother of the kids cannot cope with 10 days of doing this.

There is a poster taking about the gender gap: how can you compare the OP's ridiculous request to negotiate a pay rise, conditions or a job title when you feel is the moment to do so? We all should be going for those, men and women. But not ridiculous requests I am 100 per cent sure no men would make.

This is what actually maintains the gender gap.

comeagainx · 02/02/2024 11:11

By the same token, do you think I can get my dog boarding costs covered? Thought not

This is good example and I think the answer to it is the same as I would give to OP - it's worth asking if it's an exceptional cost that you would not other wise have because of an exceptional request by the employer. They may agree they may not agree but then its up to you whether you can or can't do the work that requires this exceptional outlay.

It would be different if your job routinely involves the same work that causes the outlay - so say international travel. If that's always been part of your job from the start, then you are expected to organise yourself in a way that suits you and to not take the job if you can't afford it. That's different from OPs situation which is exceptional travel to a remote location for 10 days.

I think in that situation it's not unreasonable to ask for extra financial assistance if you are suffering a loss yourself.

crumblingschools · 02/02/2024 11:09

When I was a school governor (so an unpaid role) they would cover childcare costs up to a limit.

I asked for childcare costs when I was asked to come in to work on a day I didn't normally work. My son was in nursery at the time and nursery wouldn't swap a day. It took effort and there was much huffing from the employer but they did pay in the end.

Instead of people saying it is ruining it for other women, shouldn't we be saying why aren't men asking this question?

boomingaround · 02/02/2024 11:05

@Segway16 most womens jobs are not flexible either. They simply have to make them flexible to work round their children. Women are routinely leaving the office at 5pm to pick up their children and logging back on at 7pm when they are in bed. Women are routinely dipping out of meetings or having to have awkward conversations with their bosses about managing their jobs around their work.

Here is the simple truth: until men have to make the same concessions and have the same conversations, nothing will change. So simply saying her partners job "isn't flexible" and expecting that to be the end of it, is not good enough. He needs to be picking up the slack for these 10 days or paying for the childcare that he gladly expects OP to do for the rest of the time to allow him to simply hold the "my job isn't flexible" card and enjoy all the perks that come with that.

GonnaBeYoniThisChristmas · 02/02/2024 11:03

Employer, can I have flexibility to leave at a certain time each day to do nursery pick up and avoid wrap around charges?

Sure.

Employer, can I have some extra cash to pay for wrap around to cover the fact that my husband’s employer wont offer the same flexibility on finish time that you kindly do?

Jog on…

Segway16 · 02/02/2024 11:01

Dothefandangos · 02/02/2024 10:55

Get a grip. Just don’t go and say you can’t for personal reasons.
Employers arent going to start coughing up for costs related to kids, pets, hobbies, elderly parents etc.

But they did pay for costs related to kids.

The attitude towards parents and children is vile. Children are not remotely akin to pets or hobbies.

Segway16 · 02/02/2024 10:59

boomingaround · 02/02/2024 10:50

This may be true as a general position but it's not true in this specific case. The OP is asking if she can ask her employer to pay for wrap around care whilst she is away with work because another available parent can't be bothered to do it. In the alternative scenario if her partner was away he would not ask for the same support from his employer because he would have the OP doing this for him. The end result is that OP is the one taking the hit on her career and a VERY IMPORTANT MAN is left to pursue his entirely unfettered from childcare responsibilities because his partner does it when she is here and her workplace covers it when she is not. What would actually progress women's rights in this scenario is for OP to tell her husband she's off on a work trip so he needs to cover the drop off and pick up for ten days and for him to tell his own workplace that is what he is doing for ten days whilst his partner is away. End result in this scenario is the OP nurtures her career, her partner gets off his arse and becomes an equal partner in childcare and his employer sees that men are also capable of childcare and that men also need concessions for childcare rather than it just being the sole responsibility of the woman and, by extension, her workplace.

OP explained several times that her partner can’t do it as they already split the drop offs and pick ups 50/50 but her husband’s job isn’t flexible. She did not say her partner couldn’t be bothered.

When both parents have a job, sometimes that is simply the way of things.

Missamyp · 02/02/2024 10:58

boomingaround · 02/02/2024 10:50

This may be true as a general position but it's not true in this specific case. The OP is asking if she can ask her employer to pay for wrap around care whilst she is away with work because another available parent can't be bothered to do it. In the alternative scenario if her partner was away he would not ask for the same support from his employer because he would have the OP doing this for him. The end result is that OP is the one taking the hit on her career and a VERY IMPORTANT MAN is left to pursue his entirely unfettered from childcare responsibilities because his partner does it when she is here and her workplace covers it when she is not. What would actually progress women's rights in this scenario is for OP to tell her husband she's off on a work trip so he needs to cover the drop off and pick up for ten days and for him to tell his own workplace that is what he is doing for ten days whilst his partner is away. End result in this scenario is the OP nurtures her career, her partner gets off his arse and becomes an equal partner in childcare and his employer sees that men are also capable of childcare and that men also need concessions for childcare rather than it just being the sole responsibility of the woman and, by extension, her workplace.

Still missing the point that a business can be flexible in giving employees perks via personal one-to-one negotiations.
I'm not buying the patriarchal shoehorning in this example.
Sorry.

ElaineMBenes · 02/02/2024 10:57

Is your workplace unionised?

Yes. I work at a university.

I should point out that I think my terms and conditions are pretty good - just not negotiable in the way some people seem to be assuming.

I can't simply negotiate a pay rise for example. I'm on a specific pay scale with annual increments. Any movement from that requires me to be able to prove my job role has evolved into something that should be on a higher pay scale.

Dothefandangos · 02/02/2024 10:55

Get a grip. Just don’t go and say you can’t for personal reasons.
Employers arent going to start coughing up for costs related to kids, pets, hobbies, elderly parents etc.

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 10:54

Reugny · 02/02/2024 10:53

Dogs, cats, plants, second jobs, voluntary and sporting activities aren't covered by the Equality Act. That's where the line is currently drawn.

Posters are really struggling to understand this

Reugny · 02/02/2024 10:53

twnety · 02/02/2024 09:18

So, by that same logic, if you were here and not in Africa, you wouldn't incur the costs involved in having to pay someone else look after your child. So, for that reason, it should be factored in like any other expenses.

But again, my dog, my cat, my plants, my volunteering - all things that would/could incur costs if I am away, what about the second job I have in the evenings at the local pub, I wont be getting that money either.... and I also make scultures which take 2 nights and I sell each one for £10,000 - so the company needs to pay for 5? of those, £50,000 please (obviously I am being ridiculous with numbers)

Where do we draw a line? Should we pay for childcare - personally I think not. Just because you cannot drop them at a kennel (as a pp said) children is a choice (for the majority of people)

Dogs, cats, plants, second jobs, voluntary and sporting activities aren't covered by the Equality Act. That's where the line is currently drawn.

Reugny · 02/02/2024 10:51

ElaineMBenes · 02/02/2024 10:41

You aren't taking into account different types of organisations.
I can assure that there is NO negotiation in relation to my contract, pay or conditions.
Policies around travel and expenses are set centrally and are non negotiable.
They are applied equally across all grades and staff.

I'm willing to put up with these terms and conditions for a whole range of reasons. I'm well paid, I have very generous annual leave and flexibility. I also happen to really enjoy my job.
That doesn't mean I don't know my own value or that I'm a 'reason the gender pay gap exists'.
It means I work in a sector where terms and conditions are fixed.

Is your workplace unionised?

One of my brothers' recognises a union so they do all negotiations. Many people like him were very sceptical until the union actually saved all their jobs plus some of their colleagues outside the UK, as they were all going to be moved to a cheaper location abroad.

boomingaround · 02/02/2024 10:50

Missamyp · 02/02/2024 10:32

This thread provides an example of why the gender pay gap persists. Women often hesitate to negotiate their salaries-perks and sometimes even react negatively when their colleagues do. However, contracts are not set in stone and can be negotiated with flexibility. Men, on the other hand, tend to ask for what they want without the same internal hesitations that women experience.

I hope that none of the individuals who are opposing our ideas hold management positions. Their advice appears to be motivated by spite and is quite unhelpful.

This may be true as a general position but it's not true in this specific case. The OP is asking if she can ask her employer to pay for wrap around care whilst she is away with work because another available parent can't be bothered to do it. In the alternative scenario if her partner was away he would not ask for the same support from his employer because he would have the OP doing this for him. The end result is that OP is the one taking the hit on her career and a VERY IMPORTANT MAN is left to pursue his entirely unfettered from childcare responsibilities because his partner does it when she is here and her workplace covers it when she is not. What would actually progress women's rights in this scenario is for OP to tell her husband she's off on a work trip so he needs to cover the drop off and pick up for ten days and for him to tell his own workplace that is what he is doing for ten days whilst his partner is away. End result in this scenario is the OP nurtures her career, her partner gets off his arse and becomes an equal partner in childcare and his employer sees that men are also capable of childcare and that men also need concessions for childcare rather than it just being the sole responsibility of the woman and, by extension, her workplace.

noodlebugz · 02/02/2024 10:50

OP I’m really glad that you got the expenses and then some paid. My husband had to go on a work trip which clashed with the normality scan for our eldest. When we tried to rebook it, it clashed with the flight home which was worse as he was in the air - facepalm. His company paid for a private scan so he didn’t miss out.
Companies that get the best out of their people and keep the best people value them as PEOPLE not just numbers.
Enjoy the work trip.

Missamyp · 02/02/2024 10:48

ElaineMBenes · 02/02/2024 10:41

You aren't taking into account different types of organisations.
I can assure that there is NO negotiation in relation to my contract, pay or conditions.
Policies around travel and expenses are set centrally and are non negotiable.
They are applied equally across all grades and staff.

I'm willing to put up with these terms and conditions for a whole range of reasons. I'm well paid, I have very generous annual leave and flexibility. I also happen to really enjoy my job.
That doesn't mean I don't know my own value or that I'm a 'reason the gender pay gap exists'.
It means I work in a sector where terms and conditions are fixed.

This is a broad discussion not company specific.
The OP quite rightly asked and was given what she wanted. Both parties benefitted. This is now a precedent, she can in the future perhaps look forward to travelling without being penalised personally.

Segway16 · 02/02/2024 10:46

Nofilteritwonthelp · 01/02/2024 05:38

Seriously? It was your choice to have children, honestly it's attitudes like yours that ruin it for every other woman

No, attitudes like yours ruin it for other women.

Mel2023 · 02/02/2024 10:45

You can ask. I don’t think they would though. If it’s in your contract that occasional travel is required then they have every right to ask you to go on a trip. That being said, I would say to them you can totally make the trip but you can’t sort childcare on this occasion so unless they can help with the cost of wraparound care then you can’t go. And they can’t expect you to if that’s your reasoning. If they push explain that you can’t afford the extra £. You may then be surprised and they could cover it if they really need you to go.

I have to travel occasionally for my job as do many others in my team. My DH works shifts so he’s not home on evenings to look after DS. I have never ever considered getting childcare for those evenings when I’m away as we absolutely couldn’t afford to pay it. So if family can’t help out I have to say I can’t do the trip. There’s been several times we’ve all travelled to meet for away days and team meetings etc which are usually a night or two away from home, and there’s always one or two who haven’t been able to make it because of childcare. It’s just accepted.

Reugny · 02/02/2024 10:44

EarthaKittsVoice · 01/02/2024 17:40

Yes - rights within the workplace. An employee can put forward a flexible working request - what that details is down to the individual ie location/hours etc.

The OP has been requested to work abroad for 10 days in what seems to be the 1st time in 8 years. It is within their rights to request reimbursement for additional costs.

We all have rights in the workplace - parent or not.

But I do think we are still quite behind Europe RE womens rights in the workplace. From this thread I see why and it's mostly due to mindset/beliefs.

I wonder what people on this thread would think if their employer started a Creche at their place of work. It's a thing in Europe....

Actually in the UK before the Tories came to power in the coalition there were a lot of workplace nurseries.

I actually remember working at 2 organisations and bumping into parents dropping off their kids at the workplace nursery.

My own DP's employer had a workplace nursery until about 2010. They then worked out it was cheaper to run the voucher scheme and then pay for some emergency childcare if an employee needed it.

ElaineMBenes · 02/02/2024 10:41

Missamyp · 02/02/2024 10:32

This thread provides an example of why the gender pay gap persists. Women often hesitate to negotiate their salaries-perks and sometimes even react negatively when their colleagues do. However, contracts are not set in stone and can be negotiated with flexibility. Men, on the other hand, tend to ask for what they want without the same internal hesitations that women experience.

I hope that none of the individuals who are opposing our ideas hold management positions. Their advice appears to be motivated by spite and is quite unhelpful.

You aren't taking into account different types of organisations.
I can assure that there is NO negotiation in relation to my contract, pay or conditions.
Policies around travel and expenses are set centrally and are non negotiable.
They are applied equally across all grades and staff.

I'm willing to put up with these terms and conditions for a whole range of reasons. I'm well paid, I have very generous annual leave and flexibility. I also happen to really enjoy my job.
That doesn't mean I don't know my own value or that I'm a 'reason the gender pay gap exists'.
It means I work in a sector where terms and conditions are fixed.

boomingaround · 02/02/2024 10:39

girlswillbegirls · 02/02/2024 09:31

@Littlegoth I know you are HR but you are also missing the point. If a company want to compensate EVERYONE on the team for their time away that's fine. Because everyone's time outside working hours is valuable. The issue here is the justification of asking for covering for childcare because the father of the kids can't cope. That's ridiculous, sorry. Why would you make an special allowance because this person can't sort this out at home with a partner. And seing this as progressive is to me frankly stupid. We need men to get the finger out and not employers to subsidise their lack of cop on.

As the last poster said, where do you draw the line?

I agree with this.

It's the most anti-feminist nonsense I've heard that this woman's employer is going to be asked to cover the cost of her partner not being able to cope. OPs partner sounds like a real catch. To avoid being inconvenienced for ten days because he can't do something the OP does literally every day, she is jeopardising her career further by either not going or by asking her employer for money to cover her partner's entitlement.

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 10:36

Missamyp · 02/02/2024 10:32

This thread provides an example of why the gender pay gap persists. Women often hesitate to negotiate their salaries-perks and sometimes even react negatively when their colleagues do. However, contracts are not set in stone and can be negotiated with flexibility. Men, on the other hand, tend to ask for what they want without the same internal hesitations that women experience.

I hope that none of the individuals who are opposing our ideas hold management positions. Their advice appears to be motivated by spite and is quite unhelpful.

I agree. I just put the scenario to my partner - his contract requires ‘some’ travel, and he’s had the odd 3/4 night trip. If he was going to be sent abroad for 10 days what additional expenses would we incur as a result and would he ask his employer to cover it - he didn’t even hesitate, of course he would!

I find it at work too. Men are more likely to ask for an increase on salary offer, or pay rise, or challenge appraisal rating. Men are more likely to ask for job title to be amended (Yes really! exchanging ‘senior’ to ‘lead’ for example). Sabbaticals. Compressed hours (women more likely to ask for part time - usually due to childcare whether we like to face up to that or not!), pay rises, responsibility allowances.

Missamyp · 02/02/2024 10:32

This thread provides an example of why the gender pay gap persists. Women often hesitate to negotiate their salaries-perks and sometimes even react negatively when their colleagues do. However, contracts are not set in stone and can be negotiated with flexibility. Men, on the other hand, tend to ask for what they want without the same internal hesitations that women experience.

I hope that none of the individuals who are opposing our ideas hold management positions. Their advice appears to be motivated by spite and is quite unhelpful.