Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking employer to cover childcare costs

881 replies

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 05:33

I’ve been asked to go on a business trip for a week, is it unreasonable to ask the company to pay the incremental childcare costs?

OP posts:
Hii93 · 02/02/2024 17:33

Reugny · 02/02/2024 10:53

Dogs, cats, plants, second jobs, voluntary and sporting activities aren't covered by the Equality Act. That's where the line is currently drawn.

Actually they could be covered by indirect discrimination

Hii93 · 02/02/2024 17:22

arethereanyleftatall · 01/02/2024 11:12

Because @Reugny it results in the childless folk getting the tasks no one else wants to do. And for the company, it results in an expense to them which wouldn't be required for childless people.

Exactly parents don't realise how much extra work is done by childfree people and how they don't get anything for it

LittleBearPad · 02/02/2024 16:29

wronginalltherightways · 02/02/2024 16:09

Can't cope? What if her husband is in the military? Or a teacher? Or works for the NHS?

Not every adult can just rearrange their jobs to facilitate their partner's job.

Well he’s not because whilst it ‘won’t be easy’ it’s not impossible. And if he were a bit of wraparound care wouldn’t cut it.

wronginalltherightways · 02/02/2024 16:09

girlswillbegirls · 01/02/2024 23:03

Sorry I think people here are missing the point.

Just back from a working trip. I'm female. My husband arranged with his company to WFH afternoons while I was away. And he minded his own children. As I would if he was away.

We are in 2024. And people are saying here well done OP, you got your company to pay for the extra childcare because your partner can't cope.

Is this what we are aiming for as women?

Can't cope? What if her husband is in the military? Or a teacher? Or works for the NHS?

Not every adult can just rearrange their jobs to facilitate their partner's job.

PopandFizz · 02/02/2024 16:06

Wow so many negative responses. OP I think you're victim to a lot of people who have never worked in a male dominated workplace.
Why on earth would DP suddenly be able to leave work early for 8 days (I assume OP usually does pick up and DP works later). Many work places don't simply allow for time in lieu because your DP has work commitments to leave an hour or so early. He would likely have to book a half day for 8 working days which is a ridiculous expectation.

£300 is a big incremental, I think my thought would be, are you being paid for the overtime out there? Because surely you should be subject to additional pay for having to be away from home for 10 days. I don't just mean a per diem of £30 or something rubbish like that.
You should be being paid for the inconvenience of being away from home for so long which should cover the additional cost of childcare AND your expenses. If not, I'd approach your manager about this and just be honest. You're happy to do the trip and DP is fine with pulling the solo parenting for a long length of time but he cant leave work early and the extra expense is going to mean the trip costs you money and you feel you should be reimbursed for these costs. A reasonable employer would consider this I feel.

DixiePeach · 02/02/2024 15:22

Yes we have a child care fund where staff can claim childcare costs when attending conferences. It’s worth asking if your employer has such a thing.

April489 · 02/02/2024 15:16

girlswillbegirls · 02/02/2024 13:08

@April489 the point is that policies should be the same for everyone travelling for work, kids or not, women or men.

The point is its always women accommodating childcare, refusing work trips to accommodate husband's big important job.
Women and men should be equally working, travelling, caring for others and having their time off respected.

I think it's very straight forward. That's the gender pay gap for you in a nutshell.

PS. My husband is in a very senior role. He asks his company to wfh when I'm travelling as I do when he does. I would not want a partner who doesn't want to allow any flexibility in his work. When men say my work does not allow me to do that is bollocks. Most importantly I want my two girls and boy to normalise that mummy and daddy have equal important jobs and responsibilities. I want for them to be treated the same in the future by their partners.

Edited

The policy is the same for everyone, single, partnered, married, divorced, any identity, with or without children, or pets.

The point is that to combat a partner needing to accommodate the care then more policies like the above are needed, not fewer.

Aprilx · 02/02/2024 14:43

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 08:16

@Whinge this is just bullshit. My partner will manage if needs too. But why are you putting blame on him rather than a massive corporation?!?

Are you seriously asking why your children’s father has more responsibility for his children’s care than your employer?

I think it is a blow for equality that an employer has to pick up the slack on childcare because some useless father won’t. Letting men off the hook as usual. Why didn’t you go to your partner and read him the riot act rather than your employer.

twnety · 02/02/2024 14:33

Mememe9898 · 01/02/2024 19:56

This is a made up post 😅 who is going to pay you an extra £2.5k for 10 days just for doing your job. They wouldn’t even pay that in expenses let alone as extra income. Someone is pulling a fast one.

oh no, its so totally true... Hmm

twnety · 02/02/2024 14:24

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 18:17

@EarringsandLipstick well that sense of entitlement you hate so much has just earnt me an additional 2.5k

they're paying you an EXTRA £250 a DAY???

EDIT oh - you're going for a week? working week? an extra £500 a DAY???

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 14:19

Missamyp · 02/02/2024 14:16

Colleagues complaining about a perceived injustice is indeed a management issue. However, employees need to make a stake in their own value rather than looking at others. There is absolutely nothing wrong with negotiating with your employer.
It's an empirical observation that the ones complaining the most are often adding the least value to a company.

I completely agree. Employers don’t have to listen to their employees, or treat them fairly (legislation aside) or take on board feedback, but they might find that the best workers will piss off pretty sharpish to an organisation that does. By the same token - if you don’t ask, you don’t get.

Missamyp · 02/02/2024 14:16

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 14:03

@fitzwilliamdarcy I would have issue with any form of discrimination in the workplace. I think what you are saying is that childless women are treated unfavourably. This is itself could be covered by the equality act, depending on the reason for the woman being childless.

I have been the woman asked to go somewhere in a colleague’s place because they didn’t have childcare - I’d had 3 miscarriages over 2 years at the time and would have been on maternity leave had things gone to plan, but life happened. It wasn’t unfair treatment, or discrimination - just my employer asking if I was able to go in the place of someone who was unable to.

Yes there needs to be a balance to make things fair, and yes I can see that people may perceive they are picking up the slack, but that’s a management issue, not a legal one.

Edited

Colleagues complaining about a perceived injustice is indeed a management issue. However, employees need to make a stake in their own value rather than looking at others. There is absolutely nothing wrong with negotiating with your employer.
It's an empirical observation that the ones complaining the most are often adding the least value to a company.

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 14:12

Wotsitoverthere · 02/02/2024 14:08

If your contract says you might sometimes have to travel, I think this is your problem.
I've just been sent away for a course and had to pay for extra visits from my dog sitter, but that's my issue for having dogs.
You either say "I can't do it" and they remember how helpful you were next time bonuses, promotions etc are coming round, or you suck it up for the benefit it gives you and the company.

And if they state that she has got a smaller bonus or didn’t get a promotion because she refused to travel due to childcare, it will be the easiest sex discrimination tribunal ever. (Scroll up and read my post regarding the Dobson tribunal). Hopefully you aren’t a manager using this sort of reasoning, as it’s discrimination.

Wotsitoverthere · 02/02/2024 14:08

If your contract says you might sometimes have to travel, I think this is your problem.
I've just been sent away for a course and had to pay for extra visits from my dog sitter, but that's my issue for having dogs.
You either say "I can't do it" and they remember how helpful you were next time bonuses, promotions etc are coming round, or you suck it up for the benefit it gives you and the company.

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 14:03

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/02/2024 13:54

@Littlegoth It’s not that I “don’t like” that working parents have legal protection, it’s more that I think that some employers are so fearful of exposing working mums to any kind of possible detriment that they inadvertently end up subjecting other women to unequal treatment.

You may have no issue with that - most mums don’t in my experience.

@fitzwilliamdarcy I would have issue with any form of discrimination in the workplace. I think what you are saying is that childless women are treated unfavourably. This is itself could be covered by the equality act, depending on the reason for the woman being childless.

I have been the woman asked to go somewhere in a colleague’s place because they didn’t have childcare - I’d had 3 miscarriages over 2 years at the time and would have been on maternity leave had things gone to plan, but life happened. It wasn’t unfair treatment, or discrimination - just my employer asking if I was able to go in the place of someone who was unable to.

Yes there needs to be a balance to make things fair, and yes I can see that people may perceive they are picking up the slack, but that’s a management issue, not a legal one.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/02/2024 13:54

@Littlegoth It’s not that I “don’t like” that working parents have legal protection, it’s more that I think that some employers are so fearful of exposing working mums to any kind of possible detriment that they inadvertently end up subjecting other women to unequal treatment.

You may have no issue with that - most mums don’t in my experience.

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 13:39

^ too late to add edit: Dobson was dismissed when a change in working pattern made childcare too difficult, she couldn’t work the set pattern and so her employer fired her. A judge ruled this was discrimination. This ruling means that the childcare burden on working mothers has to be considered by employers. Working mothers have protection in law. You might not like it, but it’s there.

Yes we all know that it’s unfair that the burden does still heavily fall to women. Change takes time though. Even 1 generation ago (for me anyway!) men did very little childcare. In my Grandparents’ generation men did none, it was women’s work. Society is evolving but it’s not immediate. That’s why things like the Gender pay gap are important, and why protecting working mothers from indirect sex discrimination is important. Society will catch up.

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 13:29

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/02/2024 12:59

Neither are children or one’s parental status - only pregnancy and maternity.

Sex and marriage are both in there, which would cover working parents as it could fall under indirect discrimination.

Don’t just take my word for it though - there have been rulings at tribunal setting a precedent for this.

Dobson v North Cumbria integrated care NHS Foundation Trust makes it clear that all future cases can take it as fact that women are more likely to suffer a disadvantage as a result of childcare responsibilities than men.

girlswillbegirls · 02/02/2024 13:08

@April489 the point is that policies should be the same for everyone travelling for work, kids or not, women or men.

The point is its always women accommodating childcare, refusing work trips to accommodate husband's big important job.
Women and men should be equally working, travelling, caring for others and having their time off respected.

I think it's very straight forward. That's the gender pay gap for you in a nutshell.

PS. My husband is in a very senior role. He asks his company to wfh when I'm travelling as I do when he does. I would not want a partner who doesn't want to allow any flexibility in his work. When men say my work does not allow me to do that is bollocks. Most importantly I want my two girls and boy to normalise that mummy and daddy have equal important jobs and responsibilities. I want for them to be treated the same in the future by their partners.

April489 · 02/02/2024 13:00

It's a shame so many people feel it is wrong to receive fair expenses. I'm glad the OP was willing to ask and had a positive outcome. Done politely, what is the harm in asking?

FWIW for the non believers, it is written in the policy document that my employer will pay for childcare and pet care which is expensed as a result of being necessary due to company travel.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/02/2024 12:59

Reugny · 02/02/2024 10:53

Dogs, cats, plants, second jobs, voluntary and sporting activities aren't covered by the Equality Act. That's where the line is currently drawn.

Neither are children or one’s parental status - only pregnancy and maternity.

brogueish · 02/02/2024 12:49

Some of these posts are frankly bonkers.

OP is not setting back the sisterhood and her OH does not sound rubbish.

The problem is not that she has asked for childcare to be remunerated, it’s that most people - including men - don’t. All parents should be asking the question if they’re asked to do something out of the ordinary by their employer that necessitates additional childcare. The employer’s needs should not be facilitated by the wife, husband, mother, or neighbour of the employee. Why would they?

Those saying that she or her husband should suck it up to accommodate an expense incurred by her (or his) work are spectacularly missing the point.

ldnmama2 · 02/02/2024 12:48

@jeaux90 same thing happened to me. Life can be shit

upthehills1 · 02/02/2024 12:36

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 05:38

My contract is very blaze….unlimited hours, travel as required, location as deemed necessary…….however I work from the office 9-5 and have done for the past 8 years

I don’t fully understand when you need the additional childcare if you’re in the office all day 5 days anyway. Who is doing childcare now outside of nursery? Can’t your husband speak with his work for some flexibility to help that week?

Sorry I really don’t get this, your employer shouldn’t cover your childcare costs imo. And your contract does say ‘travel’, you’re lucky it’s a one off and not every month

upthehills1 · 02/02/2024 12:32

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 06:22

@Spangler son is in nursery full time, im asking for the incremental cover as I won’t be able to do drop off and pick up

So is your employer currently flexible with you to allow you to drop off/pick up and look after the children while working? I think that is the benefit you have which sounds like you take for granted a bit tbh. They could have you in the office 9-5 and you’d need to lay wraparound care every day