Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking employer to cover childcare costs

881 replies

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 05:33

I’ve been asked to go on a business trip for a week, is it unreasonable to ask the company to pay the incremental childcare costs?

OP posts:
Tailfeather · 03/02/2024 12:55

@Nofilteritwonthelp totally agree!

brogueish · 03/02/2024 12:51

nopuppiesallowed · 03/02/2024 12:33

If your husband was asked to travel, would he ask for extra money to cover child care? Equality in the workplace has been hard won. If a man wouldn't ask for or expect childcare expenses, why should a woman?

The point is that a father should ask for extra money to cover childcare in this situation, but traditionally it's been expected that "the wife" will sort it. If everyone just assumes that the partner (male or female) will adjust their lives around one of their employers, that's not equitable to single parents, partners with inflexible jobs, etc.

nopuppiesallowed · 03/02/2024 12:33

If your husband was asked to travel, would he ask for extra money to cover child care? Equality in the workplace has been hard won. If a man wouldn't ask for or expect childcare expenses, why should a woman?

wubwubwub · 03/02/2024 11:27

Danni1970 · 03/02/2024 08:37

If you don't need to go, why are you then
Obviously your career means more too you than your child does.

Why are you spending time on MN insulting people instead of being with your child ???? Obviously being on MN means more to you than your child does....

NojudgementGem · 03/02/2024 11:20

Change your mindset on this to see it as if you’ve been lucky you’ve not needed to do it more rather than thinking ‘why should I because I never had to do it before?’
It is part of the contract and therefore your employers would expect you to find a way to make it happen for a one off without them picking up the costs. They obviously think it’s a benefit for the company for you to be there.
I occasionally have to travel for my job, it’s a pain and means husband and other family helping but it’s what we have to do

ElaineMBenes · 03/02/2024 10:06

Danni1970 · 03/02/2024 08:37

If you don't need to go, why are you then
Obviously your career means more too you than your child does.

What a ridiculous comment 🙄

stichguru · 03/02/2024 09:49

"Why are so many people focusing on my DP? This isn’t about him.
Im amazed so many people think it’s ok for my employer to request I go to the back and beyond of somewhere like Chad and pay for the inconvenience for 10 days"

It's 10 days. If it is part of your role, as in an important networking or training or a business deal that YOU need to do and needs to be done in Chad, then it is something you should be able to do. I cannot fathom why you would think this isn't about you DP. It is 100% about your husband, because what you NEED in this situation, depends on what he can provide. When my husband goes away, I generally manage our childcare with the childcare we have in place anyway, plus an extra day of before school and after school with the childminder for £20. When I am away, my husband asks to work at home for a couple of days so he can see our child out to school and be in the house when he arrives back. Assuming your DP is a competent parent, my first thought is you would never need to ask this question because your DP would be fine handling 10 days childcare. Your question about what your employer should cover is IMPOSSIBLE to answer without knowing about you DP. IF you NEED to go on the trip and your DP is doing a utterly non-flexible job (like a doctor say) then you are in a situation where you HAVE to spend lots in childcare to go, and it is ok to ask work to pay. If your DP is competent and has the flexibility to provide the extra childcare, then you can go on the trip without needing funding for something you don't need. If your DP has another reason not to have the kids, maybe he is ill or a bad parent, then that is more complicated.

Danni1970 · 03/02/2024 08:37

If you don't need to go, why are you then
Obviously your career means more too you than your child does.

MumsGoneToIceland · 03/02/2024 08:12

On the odd occasion that DH or I were asked to go away with work, the other had to flex their hours to cover the other’s childcare responsibilities and they would either take some leave or make up the hours in the evening to balance it out.

i don’t believe it’s reasonable for a company to cover your childcare costs, they employed you on the basis you could provide some flexibility when required as per your contract.

YoBeaches · 03/02/2024 07:57

GonnaBeYoniThisChristmas · 02/02/2024 11:03

Employer, can I have flexibility to leave at a certain time each day to do nursery pick up and avoid wrap around charges?

Sure.

Employer, can I have some extra cash to pay for wrap around to cover the fact that my husband’s employer wont offer the same flexibility on finish time that you kindly do?

Jog on…

There are loads of jobs where that level of flexibility isn't feasible from a staffing perspective.

The company wants OP to travel and she shouldn't be financially penalised because of that..

KT1112 · 03/02/2024 03:55

I’m baffled by some of these responses.

i think there’s absolutely no harm in asking at all. I’m a single parent now but when I was married, a 10 day trip would’ve meant my husband had to take annual leave. That would then mean we wouldn’t have enough annual leave between us to cover the school holidays. do there would be a knock on effect.

I think I would approach my
manager and say this trip will cost me £300 in additional childcare fees over and above the norm. Is there any help you could give me so the business trip doesn’t leave me out of pocket, or would it be better for someone else to go. Let them decide which option they’d prefer and go from there! Good luck x

HelenTherese2 · 03/02/2024 00:45

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 05:59

@nohopehere i work in probably one of the most male dominated fields possible. Believe me when I say I stand up for women and equality. Men wouldn’t ask because their wives would be expected to cover ….

This is actually pretty sexist of you to assume this and to assume that a wife would be able to cover. I wouldn’t have been able to as I work full time. We had to manage and get extra cover if he was away.

EmmaInScotland · 02/02/2024 21:54

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 08:43

Why are so many people focusing on my DP? This isn’t about him.
Im amazed so many people think it’s ok for my employer to request I go to the back and beyond of somewhere like Chad and pay for the inconvenience for 10 days

I think it's because (at least in the posts I've read), you've not made it clear why it's so difficult for him to work more flexibly while you're away. If you'd said he works in a care home / milking the cows / ambulance/ etc., then it'd be easier to see that he'd find it more difficult to change -esp if it's something like care, where they're probably seriously understaffed. As others have said, you can but ask. They've asked you to go, it sounds as if they feel no-one else can do it, so ask

Lorralorr · 02/02/2024 21:05

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 06:30

I’m amazed at the negative response on here! Any other expense would be covered, but I guess I’m being unreasonable

Well not really - if you were a keen gardener - you wouldn’t ask your company to mow your lawn while you were away on business would you?

GirlsAndPenguins · 02/02/2024 21:00

Hi,
I think simply due to your contract you cannot expect them to pay. Guess it can’t hurt to ask though!
I can’t help but be confused by your extra expenses. You work 9-5 so surely they already have to go to at least an after school club. You are away 10 days…so this would be over a weekend as well so a maximum of 8 school days. £300 extra on top of the wrap around care you are already paying for 8 days? My wrap around would total £115 for 8 days, obviously you are already paying some due to your working hours. I mean I’m probably missing something I’m sure. Maybe you have quite a lot of children which is fair enough.

Solibear · 02/02/2024 20:52

If your contract allows for this eventuality then yes, you’re being unreasonable. It’s not up to your employer to ensure you have childcare in order for you to do your role - it’s up to you to cover that. You presumably don’t ask them to pay your day-to-day nursery costs, so why should they pay the extra? Especially if your husband can take care of things anyway?

This is coming from someone who was in a very similar situation this time last year. My contract states that my employer can ask me to work anywhere in the UK as required by the business, for an indefinite period, and anywhere outside of the UK for up to a month. I’ve worked there for more than a decade and never had to travel anywhere outside of my base London office or working from home. March last year, with a 4yo at home, I was asked to go to Paris for 3 nights. I’d never had a single night away from her before, never mind 3, but I sucked it up because it’s there in black and white in my contract. Just because it hasn’t happened in the decade before, doesn’t mean it never will. My husband managed just fine. I’m sure yours will too. I appreciate 10 nights is more than 3 nights, but the principle is still the same, so if it’s not something you will be able to manage again in the future either, then perhaps you need to either look for a new job or renegotiate the terms of your current contract

Cyb3rg4l · 02/02/2024 20:07

And start looking for a new job

Mumof2n · 02/02/2024 19:25

Horrified by some of the comments here. For a 10 day trip away, a lot of employers I know would offer to pay for additional childcare to wrap around the other childcare that already exists. Nothing to do if man or woman or husband or wife travelling, being away from home for an extended period and having every pick up and drop off and evening and x2 weekends with no other professional or personal commitments is frankly asking a hellava lot. My o/h’s work offered the wrap around as an expense while he was on a 10 day trip. I needed to expense x2 evening babysitting to go to my university lectures to pass my own exams. Everyone who travels gets offered that at that employer. We didn’t take the piss, just used what extra we needed and gave receipts. We don’t have family nearby and our friends all have kids of their own to be doing the juggle with. Imagine if your other half was a shift worker or also had long commutes etc. Or you were a single parent. It’s a juggle at the best of times with 2 working parents so for a very fair question OP and many companies do and should have this in their travel policy.

Julimia · 02/02/2024 18:53

Try it and see a or some sort of compromise msy be a possibility

upthehills1 · 02/02/2024 18:37

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 18:30

If you are incurring costs as a result of an unusual 10 day work trip, then no matter what it’s for you should ask for remuneration. That’s what OP has done.

And if you can’t go because you can’t arrange xyz then you can’t go - some things will be covered under the equality act giving a measure of protection, but really it’s not good practice to send an employee on an extended work trip if they don’t want to go.

Then all staff going should receive remuneration or overtime pay. The OP said she works in the office 9-5 so it’s really not clear what the extra childcare is for. Actually just sounded like she didn’t want to go

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 18:30

upthehills1 · 02/02/2024 18:02

Just leave the dog home alone then? In both cases the result is additional expense it’s nothing to do with the child’s wellbeing

Edited

If you are incurring costs as a result of an unusual 10 day work trip, then no matter what it’s for you should ask for remuneration. That’s what OP has done.

And if you can’t go because you can’t arrange xyz then you can’t go - some things will be covered under the equality act giving a measure of protection, but really it’s not good practice to send an employee on an extended work trip if they don’t want to go.

alanet · 02/02/2024 18:09

Were they really planning on paying you no extra for all the extra hours you would essentially be at work for?

upthehills1 · 02/02/2024 18:05

girlswillbegirls · 02/02/2024 12:07

This exactly summarised my thoughts.

Can people not see women have to start feeling equal to be equal? Make him make the arrangements with his workplace to look after his own children in this scenario (as any female would do).
I still have to see the first man going to HR to ask to cover for wraparound care because his female partner and mother of the kids cannot cope with 10 days of doing this.

There is a poster taking about the gender gap: how can you compare the OP's ridiculous request to negotiate a pay rise, conditions or a job title when you feel is the moment to do so? We all should be going for those, men and women. But not ridiculous requests I am 100 per cent sure no men would make.

This is what actually maintains the gender gap.

Edited

Agreed. The OP doesn’t want to go on this trip at all by the sounds of things. But if next time is a career boosting, exciting trip she might miss out when they offer it to the men first

upthehills1 · 02/02/2024 18:02

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 08:38

No because it’s an animal, not a child. Dogs are property, not people.

Just leave the dog home alone then? In both cases the result is additional expense it’s nothing to do with the child’s wellbeing

Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 17:47

Hii93 · 02/02/2024 17:33

Actually they could be covered by indirect discrimination

On what grounds?

Swipe left for the next trending thread