Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking employer to cover childcare costs

881 replies

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 05:33

I’ve been asked to go on a business trip for a week, is it unreasonable to ask the company to pay the incremental childcare costs?

OP posts:
TylaTiga · 01/02/2024 11:12

Hii93 · 01/02/2024 11:11

Except it would be held against her by others when you show that parents get preferential treatment even when they have the same job and contract as others

The not if the company extended the same response to all their staff. If they treat staff differently that’s on them, not on the staff member who is simply asking.

whatkatydid2014 · 01/02/2024 11:12

I think it’s simply a case of either you change travel and it’s a bit inconvenient (which travel generally can be for many people with or without kids) or you say you can’t go due to your circumstances and then they have a choice of doing remotely, sending someone else or offering to find a way to allow you to go.

In general for occasional work travel that’s part of your contract you should be able to figure something out. I generally agreed with my boss I’d work significant extra hours when travelling but used the banked time to do shorter days before going or on return. That way OH could do both drop off and pick up/work less when I was away and we’d swap on my return. It wasn’t entirely about saving money for us but more we were a bit reluctant to extend the kids childcare time when they were already in nursery/school & wraparound 8-6 three days a week. When that didn’t work we paid for extra hours & it is a bit rubbish but it’s pretty standard in big companies that occasional travel can be expected so it is just part of your role.

Times work did cover childcare were when I was working 80% but went on a 3 week trip they paid the kids extra nursery fees & time they asked me to travel when my husband was already committed to work late several days and they covered a nanny. In the first case work said when asking me to go that they could help with any childcare costs. In the second I initially said I couldn’t go as OH was already committed. I feel in both cases it was a reasonable compromise.

The people at work I know who incur the biggest expenses when they have to travel (by miles) are the ones who are single with dogs & have to cover them going in kennels. We had a project where we were travelling 2 weeks out of 8 and it cost my friend a fortune to cover her 2 dogs. When she got them she had family who were able to help but 10 years on one parent was infirm, one had died and her siblings had moved so she was in a position of moving roles for one with less travel or paying.

I think if it’s totally atypical for you to travel and it’s going to be a significant impact to you either financially or from a family pov it’s ok to say you can’t go and to offer alternatives like doing the training online.

arethereanyleftatall · 01/02/2024 11:12

Because @Reugny it results in the childless folk getting the tasks no one else wants to do. And for the company, it results in an expense to them which wouldn't be required for childless people.

TylaTiga · 01/02/2024 11:12

twnety · 01/02/2024 11:01

By trying to claim childcare costs, you are sending a signal that businesses should not employ people (normally women) with younger children.

Would you say the same about paid maternity leave? Because many people fought against that when it was suggested too. And people were pissed off about the childcare hours recently introduced for 2 year olds too.

I have no thoughts about the OPs request except she could explain her situation to her employer and they can decide between them if there is an agreement they can reach. It’s not unreasonable to ask. She could request a pay increase to cover her costs - that IS the sort of thing a man would do and everyone would accept it.

It’s okay to have conversations with your employer about the issues that are raised within your workplace due to working requests. If the OP is normally a hard worker then I don’t see why a manager would suddenly decide never to hire women of child baring age again. They’d be a pretty idiotic manager if they did.

This thread has gotten out of control.

Hii93 · 01/02/2024 11:11

Toomuch2019 · 01/02/2024 06:10

Our organisation would allow expenses for childcare if you were being asked to come in on a contracted non working day and had to pay childcare as a result. But not so much for something like this.

However if you didn't come due to the extra costs we would be understanding. It wouldn't be held against you but we would send someone else

Except it would be held against her by others when you show that parents get preferential treatment even when they have the same job and contract as others

GreyWednesday · 01/02/2024 11:10

Hii93 · 01/02/2024 11:02

How are they decent when people are punished for not reproducing

Oh bloody hell. Punished for not reproducing 🤣
I suppose maternity leave is unfair too as it’s a year off work?

So in the same vein, imagine a couple car share. William doesn’t work on Wednesdays, so Kate takes the car. William is asked to come in on a Wednesday, which will incur him greater costs than if he drove in, and it will also mean they will have to arrange for someone to look after the corgis.

If the company offer to pay the travel difference and the dog walker is that punishing all of employees who have two cars and no pets?

ChipsAreLife · 01/02/2024 11:10

@Hii93 how am I punishing people who are childless because I'm supporting people with children?

I also support an employee who is childless that suffers with depression by given them paid time off when they're not well. Am I punishing those without mental health issues?

I approach life that we are all human and things happen, we need to look at each person individually and decide whether it's worth supporting them or not to keep them around.

You can either work with people or against them. I know which option has helped me grow my company!

Reugny · 01/02/2024 11:08

Hii93 · 01/02/2024 10:53

And that is the thing that causes people to hate working with parents

Why?

The money isn't going in the parents pocket it is going to a registered childcare provider.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/02/2024 11:08

arethereanyleftatall · 01/02/2024 11:04

She probably will. Regardless of whether they do or not. It's quite clear from her responses that the op is always right.

That's true too!

DocOck · 01/02/2024 11:07

Not a chance I am reading 17 pages but YABU asking employer to cover childcare costs, it's not their responsibility. However, when it was compulsory I attended an important meeting outside of work and I said I might struggle due to childcare my manager offered to pay for cover.

Hii93 · 01/02/2024 11:07

PutThatDownNow · 01/02/2024 05:40

I think it is fine to discuss it with them. I used to be able to claim directly related childcare costs if I had to travel when my children were young.

Childcare costs in the usual run of business are your responsibility but additional costs as a result of travel or hours outside of the norm should be discussed.

I always saw it as an equality issue. Not supporting childcare costs in these circumstances is likely to put women off such travel more than men.

But supporting childcare costs while there is another parent around can alienate childfree people

EarringsandLipstick · 01/02/2024 11:07

wubwubwub · 01/02/2024 10:44

It will be hilarious if OP comes back and tells us the employer said yes 🤣

Not at all. Several posters have said this would be possible in their workplace. I'll be very pleased for OP if that's the case.

The point being made was - to expect her childcare costs to be covered is unreasonable. To have a mature, professional discussion with her manager about the challenges of this request, OP's preference, the business' preference and ultimate resolution - that's entirely reasonable.

That's totally different from OP's whinge about 'it's unfair i have to travel and not get my childcare paid for'.

As other posters have said, there may be an adaption e.g. increase in per diem rate, overtime or whatever, that would bridge this gap for OP. And that's great.

It's a big requirement, for her to go away so far and for so long - I'm all for appropriate compensation.

But that's again, different from 'pay my childcare because my child's father just won't or can't adapt his hours to do the pick ups and drop offs needed'. Amazed you and OP can't see this.

arethereanyleftatall · 01/02/2024 11:04

wubwubwub · 01/02/2024 10:44

It will be hilarious if OP comes back and tells us the employer said yes 🤣

She probably will. Regardless of whether they do or not. It's quite clear from her responses that the op is always right.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/02/2024 11:03

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 01/02/2024 10:24

Not sure why you posted in AIBU. You clearly do not think you are being unreasonable and are arguing with people giving views you've invited them to give.

Exactly this.

Hii93 · 01/02/2024 11:02

GreyWednesday · 01/02/2024 11:00

What, @ChipsAreLife being a fair and decent employer makes you hate working with parents?

How are they decent when people are punished for not reproducing

EarringsandLipstick · 01/02/2024 11:01

Totupthenumberspls · 01/02/2024 10:14

@EarringsandLipstick so I should have predicted my life in 8 years but that’s not applicable to you. Ok

What are you talking about?

I said that you should consider the implications of your contractual arrangements when you sign a contract and begin a job. I did this. When at a certain point I couldn't meet those arrangements, I recognise (in my case) I needed to find a new role (someone else may have needed to discuss possible role changes with their employer or whatever - the point being, yes, when you sign a contract you anticipate that there may be changes in the future that will mean you can no longer fulfill the contract in the same way and that you may have to change your approach or you role).

Why is that so hard for you to understand? Or are you wilfully misunderstanding?

twnety · 01/02/2024 11:01

By trying to claim childcare costs, you are sending a signal that businesses should not employ people (normally women) with younger children.

GreyWednesday · 01/02/2024 11:00

Hii93 · 01/02/2024 10:53

And that is the thing that causes people to hate working with parents

What, @ChipsAreLife being a fair and decent employer makes you hate working with parents?

EarringsandLipstick · 01/02/2024 10:58

@wubwubwub

You left a role without even asking if a small accommodation could be made?

Madness!

You really struggle with reading comprehension, don't you?

It wasn't a 'small' adjustment. There was simply no way the role was compatible with looking after 3 small children (one was a baby), with a dramatic change in financial situation, no support from ex, and trying to recover from an abusive situation.

Tbf, there is a wider context that the particular role was possibly not sustainable and may have changed anyway, meaning I may have needed to move roles or completely change the nature of my professional work but the personal situation preceded that.

I'm very glad you have no idea of what happens when you are suddenly in a very difficult situation with no support and dealing with trauma, and doing whatever you can to keep your head above water. 'Madness' is how I'd describe your inability to comprehend such situations.

TylaTiga · 01/02/2024 10:58

Nofilteritwonthelp · 01/02/2024 05:38

Seriously? It was your choice to have children, honestly it's attitudes like yours that ruin it for every other woman

WTF is this response?! Jeez.

Thudercatsrule · 01/02/2024 10:57

My DP spent 3weeks working away in Asia, it wasnt a choice, its part of the job and expected. And while our children arent young, there were lots of additional costs as i dont drive and had to arrange transport for them. Never occurred to either of us to expect his company to pay.

BIWI · 01/02/2024 10:57

So many holes in your argument/logic, @Totupthenumberspls

First you say you've been asked to go for a week, then it becomes 10 days. Which is it?

Next you say you and your partner share childcare 50:50, yet you then say it's you who does all the pick ups/drop offs

... but you also acknowledge that your partner could manage without you

Then you say your company is very 'blaze' (I think you mean 'blasé) about your contract, when very specifically - i.e. not blasé - it says:

unlimited hours, travel as required, location as deemed necessary

And go on to start about them profiting from you going on the trip. Well of course! The whole point of having employees in a business is to help the business make money!

Look. The cost of childcare is a cost to you of going to work. Just like the cost of travel. If you suddenly moved 200 miles away, because you prefer the new area/house, you wouldn't expect your employer to meet the cost of travel, would you?

You're making something out of nothing here. You have admitted that your partner can cope when you're away (for however long). So what is the issue? You're being awkward for the sake of it.

The expenses that would be justifiable to claim are those that are to do with the trip - so out-of-pocket expenses when you're there, like subsistence, client entertainment, travel to/from hotel, etc. And if the trip means you're away for a weekend, which would be the case for a 10 day trip, then you should be able to claim TOIL as well.

But to moan on about needing extra and unnecessary extra childcare is ridiculous.

Reugny · 01/02/2024 10:55

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/02/2024 09:41

I'm sure you're not trying to argue that men do equal childcare as not only would that fly in the face of all statistics but it would give everyone on here a good laugh.

No I just tend to get taken on by companies where many men do hands on parenting. (There is a link there somewhere.) Most of it is due to them having wives/partners who work in the NHS in patient facing roles or who are much higher earning.

Hii93 · 01/02/2024 10:55

Tracker1234 · 01/02/2024 10:53

Please dont ask for your childcare to be paid - it will be a big black mark against women and maybe next time when they are recruiting they will choose the man. I have been in the corporate world for years and never heard of this. There are also two of you and presumably you chose to have children? Both of you?

What next? Pet care, costs for employing someone to look after an elderly parent in the evening when you are not here? I have both of these things and wouldnt dream of asking my employer to pay for these costs if I was asked to travel occasionally. I would of course expect petrol and hotel costs to be covered.

Also if she doesn't go and someone else has to go they will presumably pick a childfree person which will cause her to be hated when people realise that they have to pick up the slack for parents

Tracker1234 · 01/02/2024 10:53

Please dont ask for your childcare to be paid - it will be a big black mark against women and maybe next time when they are recruiting they will choose the man. I have been in the corporate world for years and never heard of this. There are also two of you and presumably you chose to have children? Both of you?

What next? Pet care, costs for employing someone to look after an elderly parent in the evening when you are not here? I have both of these things and wouldnt dream of asking my employer to pay for these costs if I was asked to travel occasionally. I would of course expect petrol and hotel costs to be covered.

Swipe left for the next trending thread