Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thinking this is an over-reaction to my thoughtless comment

586 replies

Clemcy · 31/01/2024 23:29

Today at work I spent lunch with some colleagues who have children a similar age to my eldest, 16-18 sort of age. We were talking about uni/fees/tech/accomodation etc.
One colleagues wife passed away when their child was younger, he sold the house, moved away to somewhere much cheaper mortgage free etc. and put the rest of the money from the sale away for his daughter.
He was explaining he's not worried as he has enough to buy her a flat/house when she's in second year, pay her fees and keep some back for wedding/emergencies. He quite causally said "yeah there is about £800,000 waiting for her."
This is insane to me, my house is worth a quarter of that, while I appreciate the circumstances that have allowed them to accumulate that money are awful it is a large sum!!
I thoughtlessly said "oh wow lucky girl" and everyone sort of looked at me, I realised and apologised.
Since I've gotten home 3 separate people have messaged me to let me know said colleague is quite upset at my insensitive comment, and there is nothing lucky about your mum dying - I never said there was!!
I messaged him to apologise but he just replied with "no amount of money will bring her mum back, be careful what you say"

I'm now sat quite upset, I genuinely wasn't thinking, heard the amount and thought wow!
AIBU to think this is an overreaction to a thoughtless comment?

OP posts:
Jk8 · 02/02/2024 19:59

Teajenny7 · 02/02/2024 17:24

Your comment came across as jealous and insensitive.
I don't think it is an over reaction.
What am amazing Father to think ahead and provide for his daughter.

Are you having a laugh ? The man was volunteering private infomation that would put his daughter in the top 100 (if not 10) wealthiest teens in the UK (as opposed to teens with wealthy parents) along side day to day providing

It's obviously a way hes coped with the loss of his wife, to always ensure his daughter is provided for, & therefore heavily tied to her mother's death but really he wasnt having a conversation about her mother's death he was having it about his daughters future & his decision to sell his house & transfer the bulk of it to her along side savings.

The 'lucky girl' comment was about having her entire life housing/university/wedding pre financed NOT a question of wether she would prefer to have her mother back & hes clearly overreacted & others have piled on to defend him as he lost his wife.

coldcallerbaiter · 02/02/2024 18:13

It was not life insurance according to OP. The father downsized and released money. Unless I am missing some extra info.

If it was life insurance then maybe it would be in poor taste, as it is money that is a direct result of the death and could not have been received otherwise.

Even if the mother was alive the couple could have still downsized.

Yes it is a lot of money but it is odd to give an exact figure out like that. It would not bother me, but they say that English people think it is vulgar.

I have around the same amount put aside in total for my teens, there have been no deaths, they can each buy outright a flat in the SE with it. I would not tell anyone other than close friends and only if they asked me directly, because it is not the norm and can make people feel envious

Timetocheersme · 02/02/2024 18:03

Not an overreaction initially, as it's an Argyll thing to have lost his partner and mother of his child. However after you apologised it would have been nice if he accepted your apology. Makes me think they'll go on about your comment for ages. Tbh I think that he was also in the wrong. No need to mention the &800k, he sounds like he was bragging.

Dangerousthings · 02/02/2024 17:36

Sorry op, I don’t think it’s an over reaction. My colleague made a similar comment about me being lucky to be mortgage free, after my partner died leaving me with 4 small children. I just replied that I wouldn’t call it lucky and that was the end of it. It’s very tough when kids lose a parent early and my kids don’t have that amount of money put aside but even if they did, they would in no way be lucky.
However, you have apologised so there is not much more you can do.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 02/02/2024 17:31

I agree that @Clemcy didn’t mean to cause any offence or hurt, @CruCru - but I don’t think the man’s response to her apology text was dreadful either. It sounds as if he was hurt by what she said, and the advice to think before you speak in the future isn’t bad advice, especially if the OP has a tendency to have foot-in-mouth moments (which I know we don’t know).

Hopefully now she has apologised twice, he and their colleagues will draw a line under it and move on - I really hope they don’t turn on her, because that would absolutely be unreasonable of them. I hope that they can all be grown up and reasonable about it.

Teajenny7 · 02/02/2024 17:24

Your comment came across as jealous and insensitive.
I don't think it is an over reaction.
What am amazing Father to think ahead and provide for his daughter.

CruCru · 02/02/2024 17:17

It isn’t as though the OP was intending to be cruel - that is obvious. She has apologised twice and that is enough. The father was ungracious in his response.

Realistically, what the OP will have learned is that this man (and his friends) will quickly turn on her. She won’t relax around them and will avoid getting into conversations with them.

Some of the responses on here are quite strange. I very much hope that I live long enough to see my children’s middle age but, if I don’t, I hope that they go on to have happy live regardless. I’d hate the thought that people would be expected to tiptoe around them forevermore. My own mother’s parents died when she was young (her mum when she was nine, her dad when she was 13). She is very matter of fact about death and that it is part of life.

NutsForMutts · 02/02/2024 14:49

It was a throwaway comment and your colleagues and the dad are totally overreacting. No one was saying it's lucky mum died, just that it's lucky daughter now has financial security. Lucky may not be the right word but it's a word people use to express that someone is in a good position, so was appropriate enough really.

OneTC · 02/02/2024 13:32

But they're separate things aren't they. They have 800k owing to the astute fathers reaction to the tragedy.

People saying that those who can see why it's lucky are materialistic I offer the flip side. I have a friend, both parents alive but separated, he idolises them and they are the most palpably awful fucking people I know, despite never having to worry for much in his life, he is one of the unluckiest people I know because his emotional, moral and every other aspect of his development was ignored or failed by his parents. This is not his view btw, just mine.

The dad might be a complete arsehole who also totally ignores his daughters development and thinks that 800k is gonna solve all her problems and in this respect she would be unlucky. The lucky and unlucky portions of our lives are outside of our control by definition

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 02/02/2024 13:13

You seriously think money makes losing your mum less painful, @Getonnow?

It might make things around the bereavement easier - I am sure it can do - but it can’t change or diminish the pain of losing someone.

Getonnow · 02/02/2024 13:05

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 02/02/2024 12:30

Do you think that not having to worry about rent or bills makes it any less painful to lose your mum at a young age, @pootlin?

Of course it does, financial security makes it easier to handle anything and everything. Losing DH young was awful, but it was definitely easier because we were well provided for.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 02/02/2024 12:30

pootlin · 01/02/2024 15:23

She is lucky, a lot of people lose their parents and don’t get a penny.

Let’s not pretend that money isn’t a cushion that lets you grieve instead of worrying about rent and bills and food, it’s so disingenuous 🙄

Edited

Do you think that not having to worry about rent or bills makes it any less painful to lose your mum at a young age, @pootlin?

BardRelic · 02/02/2024 12:23

ttcat37 · 02/02/2024 11:25

I think it’s probably a matter of an opinion based on how materialistic you are. No amount of money would soften the blow of a loved one to me. And for a child losing their parent it pales into insignificance. You may think it’s a minor misstep but imo it makes the person totally transparent and reveals them as someone I would not want to have any sort of friendship with

Edited

I don't think it's about being materialistic, it's just pragmatic. Grief is horrendous. Grief whilst worrying about paying the bills is worse, because whilst you're grieving, you've also got to process a lot of other stress. It really isn't about somehow implying the money in some way makes up for the loss. It's just acknowledging that everything is worse when you have no money and you're worried about that as well.

OneTC · 02/02/2024 12:22

ttcat37 · 02/02/2024 11:25

I think it’s probably a matter of an opinion based on how materialistic you are. No amount of money would soften the blow of a loved one to me. And for a child losing their parent it pales into insignificance. You may think it’s a minor misstep but imo it makes the person totally transparent and reveals them as someone I would not want to have any sort of friendship with

Edited

This isn't an option. You can have the money or not have the money but you definitely can't have your parent back.

There is nothing materialistic in recognising that having a significant amount of money is going to facilitate many normally difficult aspects of someone's life.

I lost my dad at a young age and I asked my mum about this yesterday and she said of course I was lucky to have had the start I had in life, whilst also being unlucky I didn't get to know him more, but his work and success left me far more privileged than most other people. Children didn't get anything in inheritance but my dad achieved what he wanted as a parent which was security for his family but his illness and death was obviously a very horrible blow. Not recognising the fortune undermines the achievements of both parents in this and I reckon that's something that at some point, if not the father, then the daughter, will realise

The pp who said earlier that we don't get to choose our luck has it right

Angelsrose · 02/02/2024 11:55

ttcat37 · 02/02/2024 11:25

I think it’s probably a matter of an opinion based on how materialistic you are. No amount of money would soften the blow of a loved one to me. And for a child losing their parent it pales into insignificance. You may think it’s a minor misstep but imo it makes the person totally transparent and reveals them as someone I would not want to have any sort of friendship with

Edited

That is your right to behave in any way you choose but I think the issues are being conflated. Of course the op does NOT think the girl is lucky that her Mum passed away. How on earth could anyone even begin to think that? It's not untrue or unfair to say she is lucky to have a nest egg whilst also recognising that of course she would much prefer her mother present as we all would. I think that life is very difficult if one takes everything as a mortal wound.

GasPanic · 02/02/2024 11:47

If you have a reputation for making thoughtless comments then maybe they are somewhat justified. But otherwise I think they are being over the top.

Yes your comment was thoughtless, but you apologised. That would be the end of it for me.

"be careful what you say" sounds a bit ominous to me. "Please think more about what you say in future" is probably more appropriate.

My guess is there is something else going on here as to why your colleague is being so unforgiving.

ttcat37 · 02/02/2024 11:25

Angelsrose · 02/02/2024 09:15

I'm sure the op and every normal person reading this thread is very very sorry that this gentleman's wife died and he raised his daughter alone. I think the op is wondering if it is an overreaction because what are you really supposed to say when someone reveals a nearly £1 million pound nest egg? It is certainly extraordinary information. The op was surprised, (as was I to read it) had a momentary lapse and blurted out something and apologised. The matter should have closed there and then, not dragged on with ongoing berating. Minor missteps like this should be forgiven and forgotten especially when major and life changing events are happening around us all the time.

I think it’s probably a matter of an opinion based on how materialistic you are. No amount of money would soften the blow of a loved one to me. And for a child losing their parent it pales into insignificance. You may think it’s a minor misstep but imo it makes the person totally transparent and reveals them as someone I would not want to have any sort of friendship with

Goldbar · 02/02/2024 10:14

Angelsrose · 02/02/2024 09:15

I'm sure the op and every normal person reading this thread is very very sorry that this gentleman's wife died and he raised his daughter alone. I think the op is wondering if it is an overreaction because what are you really supposed to say when someone reveals a nearly £1 million pound nest egg? It is certainly extraordinary information. The op was surprised, (as was I to read it) had a momentary lapse and blurted out something and apologised. The matter should have closed there and then, not dragged on with ongoing berating. Minor missteps like this should be forgiven and forgotten especially when major and life changing events are happening around us all the time.

Voice of reason.

For goodness sake, we all suffer from foot in mouth occasionally and stretching someone out on the rack due to a tactless lapse, harmlessly meant, isn't really on.

Angelsrose · 02/02/2024 09:15

ttcat37 · 01/02/2024 23:24

Nobody’s saying she intended malice. The fact that she’s posted saying the bloke overreacted shows that she’s not very remorseful and still doesn’t acknowledge how hurtful what she said was.

I'm sure the op and every normal person reading this thread is very very sorry that this gentleman's wife died and he raised his daughter alone. I think the op is wondering if it is an overreaction because what are you really supposed to say when someone reveals a nearly £1 million pound nest egg? It is certainly extraordinary information. The op was surprised, (as was I to read it) had a momentary lapse and blurted out something and apologised. The matter should have closed there and then, not dragged on with ongoing berating. Minor missteps like this should be forgiven and forgotten especially when major and life changing events are happening around us all the time.

Mumto2kids86 · 02/02/2024 08:10

You misspoke, nothing more than a bit careless. Maybe just apologise, but yes they are overreacting. Also quite insensitive and vulgar for them to brag about how much they have in the bank! Who does that!

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 02/02/2024 02:03

user1471462634 · 01/02/2024 22:33

Pull this thread Mumsnet, OP does not need anymore kicking. No doubt she feels even more terrible after posting. I hope she's read the supportive posts but it's enough now.....21 pages, jeez!

Don't think the widower either will be particularly thrilled to read this in the Daily Mail

T1Dmama · 02/02/2024 00:51

I think it’s obvious to anyone with 2 brain cells that you meant she was lucky having all expenses covered…. And obvious you didn’t mean ‘oh she’s lucky her mum died!!’….
my friends husband died and unfortunately he didn’t have life insurance….. now if someone said who DID have insurance said ‘oh luckily we had life insurance’ it doesn’t mean they consider themselves ‘lucky’ that their partner died…. But lucky they’d covered themselves!!
his daughter is very unfortunate that she lost her mum…. But yes I’d consider her lucky that her parents had taken out insurances to enable her to have a financially secure life herself !!

I’d probably have responded and just say.. ‘I can only apologise and assure you I didn’t mean it the way it came across, it was very thoughtless and clumsy’ or words to that effect!!

SurelySmartie · 02/02/2024 00:49

For goodness sake this thread is mad.

No one is saying OP meant any malice. Or that she meant they were lucky for losing their mum/ partner. Yes it’s clear she meant lucky to have the money.

But can you imagine losing your partner and someone telling you that you or your child was lucky to have the money? Imagine being that bereaved and someone using the word lucky? It would feel awful.

andthat · 02/02/2024 00:36

Rosscameasdoody · 01/02/2024 18:45

The reason it’s such an issue is that OP recognised what she’d done immediately and apologised in person at the time. That should have been the end of it. How many apologies are enough ?

Yes it should have been.

Only OP messaged him after the initial apology, therefore inviting a response. Which he gave. 🤷‍♀️

Gloryloroliesjo · 02/02/2024 00:29

Op has disappeared since last night.Probably not worth commenting on!