Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thinking this is an over-reaction to my thoughtless comment

586 replies

Clemcy · 31/01/2024 23:29

Today at work I spent lunch with some colleagues who have children a similar age to my eldest, 16-18 sort of age. We were talking about uni/fees/tech/accomodation etc.
One colleagues wife passed away when their child was younger, he sold the house, moved away to somewhere much cheaper mortgage free etc. and put the rest of the money from the sale away for his daughter.
He was explaining he's not worried as he has enough to buy her a flat/house when she's in second year, pay her fees and keep some back for wedding/emergencies. He quite causally said "yeah there is about £800,000 waiting for her."
This is insane to me, my house is worth a quarter of that, while I appreciate the circumstances that have allowed them to accumulate that money are awful it is a large sum!!
I thoughtlessly said "oh wow lucky girl" and everyone sort of looked at me, I realised and apologised.
Since I've gotten home 3 separate people have messaged me to let me know said colleague is quite upset at my insensitive comment, and there is nothing lucky about your mum dying - I never said there was!!
I messaged him to apologise but he just replied with "no amount of money will bring her mum back, be careful what you say"

I'm now sat quite upset, I genuinely wasn't thinking, heard the amount and thought wow!
AIBU to think this is an overreaction to a thoughtless comment?

OP posts:
JMSA · 01/02/2024 02:40

Of course she's lucky to have that money waiting for her.
And of course you didn't mean that she was lucky to lose her mum!!
YANBU at all. It's an overreaction on their part.

cauliflowerqueen · 01/02/2024 02:29

You've apologised, and however much the comment might have surprised or hurt him, it seems clear it wasn't meant maliciously. I wouldn't bring it up again unless someone else does, in which case I'd calmly explain that you realise it was a thoughtless comment, however you meant no harm and you've apologised, then leave it. Least said, soonest mended.

I do think it was a bit much for three of them to feel compelled to text you, even assuming they didn't know the others were texting. Quite frankly, his admonishment to be careful what you say would irk me when you've already apologised twice. People usually take a moment, then try to shrug these things off and get on with life, particularly as you'd already apologised in the moment. He's not being very gracious. I'd try to forget about it and carry on as usual. You've done all you can or should, imo.

Muchof · 01/02/2024 02:29

Which bit is an over reaction exactly? You made a truly thoughtless, borderline green eyed monster comment and all he said was think more in future. Quite restrained really and to be honest if you sitting there upset for a few minutes stops you from making more hurtful comments then probably a good thing,

FrozenGhost · 01/02/2024 02:19

I wouldn't say it's an over reaction. He's hardly going on about it - he only send one text and it was in reply to you. It was a pretty calm text just saying that yes, he did get hurt from what you said.

As for the others, again, one text each, and they probably didn't know the others had sent anything.

Passingthethyme · 01/02/2024 02:16

User373433 · 01/02/2024 00:58

I think this too.

I'd be tempted to reply something like 'Actually your DD is lucky that she has a father who loves her, chose to prioritise her future and who was financially savvy enough to enable her to have such a huge sum of money. If course it won't make up for losing her mum. If you genuinely think I am so awful as to have meant she was lucky her mother died, then I can see why you can't accept my apologies, and I'm truly sorry you feel that way.

He sounds like a drama queen tbh. Yes, it's very sad he lost his wife and his daughter lost her mother, but she didn't hear it, it wasn't recent, and it was crass of him to boast about it, even give the figure, why?! What kind of reaction did he want? It's one of those awkward silences that somebody could easily try to fill and say the wrong thing. The fact he won't accept your apology when you have gone out of your way to do it a second time is way OTT.

Gosh this is the worst possible reply, completely insensitive and patronising. Please don't send anything like this

Passingthethyme · 01/02/2024 02:13

I understand that you said this by mistake, but it was thoughtless and it's fair that he's not just brushed it off. I guess put yourself in his shoes. I do wonder that perhaps your apology didn't seem sincere as you seem quite blase, hence the reaction from everyone else. I'd probably go for a other genuine, heartfelt apology and say it was a stupid comment that just came out without thinking and then leave it at that

KimberleyClark · 01/02/2024 02:09

PriOn1 · 31/01/2024 23:52

I messaged him to apologise but he just replied with "no amount of money will bring her mum back, be careful what you say"

He sounds like an arsehole to me. I despise people who still chide you after you’ve genuinely apologized.

And his daughter is fortunate to get that amount of money, regardless of what it was that prompted her father to start saving.

He’s an arsehole for being upset his wife died and his daughter losing her mother?

you sound like an arsehole too.

coxesorangepippin · 01/02/2024 02:08

I'm on your side here,op.

They are overreacting

Of course you didnt mean that!

TheSlantedOwl · 01/02/2024 01:47

Actually he was being totally crass naming the amount of money. He was showing insensitivity towards those he was speaking to, who don’t have that money to support their kids.

And yes the poor kid is deeply painfully unlucky to have lost her mum, but lucky to have a supportive father and a tonne of cash.

He and your colleagues over reacted.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 01/02/2024 01:40

Well, you said it yourself: “I genuinely wasn’t thinking”. I don’t see how that exonerates you in any way.

Whether or not he’s tempered his reaction adequately isn’t for you to decide, and frankly if you’d put as much thought into the comment as you’re putting into the umbrage you’re taking right now, you wouldn’t be here.

Lesson learned.

SurelySmartie · 01/02/2024 01:27

User373433 · 01/02/2024 00:58

I think this too.

I'd be tempted to reply something like 'Actually your DD is lucky that she has a father who loves her, chose to prioritise her future and who was financially savvy enough to enable her to have such a huge sum of money. If course it won't make up for losing her mum. If you genuinely think I am so awful as to have meant she was lucky her mother died, then I can see why you can't accept my apologies, and I'm truly sorry you feel that way.

He sounds like a drama queen tbh. Yes, it's very sad he lost his wife and his daughter lost her mother, but she didn't hear it, it wasn't recent, and it was crass of him to boast about it, even give the figure, why?! What kind of reaction did he want? It's one of those awkward silences that somebody could easily try to fill and say the wrong thing. The fact he won't accept your apology when you have gone out of your way to do it a second time is way OTT.

No don’t reply like that and make it worse. When someone has lost their partner or mum the last thing they need to hear is that they are lucky. Of course they would rather have her back than have the money. The last thing they will feel is lucky.
You’ve apologised and that’s enough. His reaction is his reaction and he’s entitled to that. Hopefully now he can move past the comment and apology.

hattie43 · 01/02/2024 01:25

I wonder why he said the sum involved , he must have known it's a large sum of money and to expect a reaction . It's not normal for a young girl to receive that kind of money .

I think what you said was obviously a spontaneous comment and surely they realise no malice was intended .

I do think they've over reacted tbh .

socialdilemmawhattodo · 01/02/2024 01:20

Yes it's a total overreaction. From the father for all the reasons listed above by pps and the grief vulture colleagues just lapping up the drama. Please don't apologise again.

SeaglassSigil · 01/02/2024 01:15

Oh come on! I'm surprised at the comments here. If I was in that conversation I would have assumed you were complimenting the dad for being able to provide that money. It's the normal reaction to someone saying they have huge sums of money for their child

Yes obviously it is awful that she lost her mother and it's good that you clarified that! But I think it's pretty weird that anyone would think you were saying she was lucky in her life in general, as he just spoke about the money.

I wouldn't blame him for being upset as it's an emotional topic. But everyone bringing it up after you apologised at the time seems pretty odd

Fionaville · 01/02/2024 01:11

I get it was the wrong thing to say. I think he should have graciously accepted your apology though.

Shimmyshimmycocobop · 01/02/2024 01:02

Universalsnail · 31/01/2024 23:35

Yes they are overreacting.

It is incredibly lucky and privileged to have that much money aside for you like that.

That does not mean that the circumstances that it came about are not awful, but tbh many children loose a parent and do not end up with that amount of money. She is lucky.

When my partner's Dad died it meant we suddenly had his inheritance to buy a house with. We could never have otherwise. We're we lucky to inherit that money, yes. We're the circumstances awful. Yes. Would my partner rather have had his Dad alive, absolutely yes. All 3 are true.

Edited

This

User373433 · 01/02/2024 00:58

Teeheehee1579 · 31/01/2024 23:42

Yes I do think they overreacted - you obviously did not mean isn’t she lucky her mum died, you meant she’s lucky to have the money that she will have. And she is lucky to have the money. Obviously not lucky her mum died. Both can be true. You apologised and I think his response should have been far more gracious given the lack of intent to hurt and offend.

I think this too.

I'd be tempted to reply something like 'Actually your DD is lucky that she has a father who loves her, chose to prioritise her future and who was financially savvy enough to enable her to have such a huge sum of money. If course it won't make up for losing her mum. If you genuinely think I am so awful as to have meant she was lucky her mother died, then I can see why you can't accept my apologies, and I'm truly sorry you feel that way.

He sounds like a drama queen tbh. Yes, it's very sad he lost his wife and his daughter lost her mother, but she didn't hear it, it wasn't recent, and it was crass of him to boast about it, even give the figure, why?! What kind of reaction did he want? It's one of those awkward silences that somebody could easily try to fill and say the wrong thing. The fact he won't accept your apology when you have gone out of your way to do it a second time is way OTT.

Lemonyfuckit · 01/02/2024 00:54

Grimchmas · 01/02/2024 00:15

It's all fairly normal and understandable human interaction to me.

You made an only human mistake. It hurt a widower deeply, even though you didn't mean to. People told you that he was hurt. You apologised. He didn't graciously accept the apology, but that shouldn't be a condition of apologising.

If you're seeking grace for being only human and making an insensitive comment, give the man who wishes he had his wife instead of the money the same grace for not having replied as you wish he had. Give the others grace that they didn't know others would also be telling you.

This is very wise. Whilst I don't think you need to continue chiding yourself for what was a genuine foot in mouth moment which we've all done and for which you've apologised, you can also give him grace for not graciously accepting your apology.

TedMullins · 01/02/2024 00:50

friendlycat · 31/01/2024 23:41

I view it two ways. Obviously you just blurted out what you did, but honestly I don’t think he needed to quantify the amount of money available for his daughter. It just seems unnecessary.

Yes it was crass for you to say that, but did he really need to also add those figures into the equation?

I was devastated at my own personal loss of my Mother, and benefited from her estate but would not have welcomed conversation about it casually being bandied around.

Agree with this. He was more insensitive casually bragging about his 800k, and yes, he is overreacting.

Zfactorstar · 01/02/2024 00:46

Can men do anything right for some people? I enjoy this website but the men bashing that goes on can get out of control. He's a widower, who stepped up to the plate for his daughter and was hurt by a thoughtless comment. I'm sure he'll get over it but the person who did the hurting isn't the person who gets to decide when the apology is to be accepted. OP, I actually sympathy because we've all been there. Give him space and time. And if it comes up again apologize again.

Kedece2410 · 01/02/2024 00:35

It was an unfortunate comment but let's face it very few people who lose a parent at a young age get the best part of a million pounds handed to them when they're at uni. So from the perspective that it's down to her Dad prioritising her & investing well, she IS lucky.

Killinginthenimya · 01/02/2024 00:26

I don't think yabu. Having been in this position this comment would not upset me ( though the loss incredibly painful) if this was genuine thoughtless comment i could see where you were coming from.

Grimchmas · 01/02/2024 00:15

It's all fairly normal and understandable human interaction to me.

You made an only human mistake. It hurt a widower deeply, even though you didn't mean to. People told you that he was hurt. You apologised. He didn't graciously accept the apology, but that shouldn't be a condition of apologising.

If you're seeking grace for being only human and making an insensitive comment, give the man who wishes he had his wife instead of the money the same grace for not having replied as you wish he had. Give the others grace that they didn't know others would also be telling you.

Tater05 · 01/02/2024 00:06

They're overreacting. Have they honestly never accidentally said something out of turn like that? I think we all have at some point.

I recently lost my dad at a young-ish age and was able to buy my first house with the inheritance. Obviously I'd rather have my dad than the money and house but I'm also very aware that lots of people lose a parent at a young age and don't even get an inheritance so I'm not going around telling everyone about it.

When I was buying the house and told the estate agent I'm paying cash and my DH said it's from an inheritance the estate agent said something along the lines of 'oh that's lucky'. I knew he was referring to the fact that I was able to buy my first house mortgage free and not that I'd lost someone, because you'd have to be a really horrible person to genuinely think someone's lucky to lose a close family member. So I didn't say anything and we carried on.

You've apologised and he didn't need to come back to you with that comment, please don't think on it any longer.

winterwarmer8274 · 01/02/2024 00:00

I’ve made a very similar comment before that I wished I could take back as soon as I said it. No one made me feel bad about it though because everyone could see it for what it was, a really, really stupid comment.

I think he is overreacting a bit - you meant no harm and it’s clear why you said it in the context.