Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thinking this is an over-reaction to my thoughtless comment

586 replies

Clemcy · 31/01/2024 23:29

Today at work I spent lunch with some colleagues who have children a similar age to my eldest, 16-18 sort of age. We were talking about uni/fees/tech/accomodation etc.
One colleagues wife passed away when their child was younger, he sold the house, moved away to somewhere much cheaper mortgage free etc. and put the rest of the money from the sale away for his daughter.
He was explaining he's not worried as he has enough to buy her a flat/house when she's in second year, pay her fees and keep some back for wedding/emergencies. He quite causally said "yeah there is about £800,000 waiting for her."
This is insane to me, my house is worth a quarter of that, while I appreciate the circumstances that have allowed them to accumulate that money are awful it is a large sum!!
I thoughtlessly said "oh wow lucky girl" and everyone sort of looked at me, I realised and apologised.
Since I've gotten home 3 separate people have messaged me to let me know said colleague is quite upset at my insensitive comment, and there is nothing lucky about your mum dying - I never said there was!!
I messaged him to apologise but he just replied with "no amount of money will bring her mum back, be careful what you say"

I'm now sat quite upset, I genuinely wasn't thinking, heard the amount and thought wow!
AIBU to think this is an overreaction to a thoughtless comment?

OP posts:
Garlickit · 01/02/2024 05:58

PriOn1 · 31/01/2024 23:52

I messaged him to apologise but he just replied with "no amount of money will bring her mum back, be careful what you say"

He sounds like an arsehole to me. I despise people who still chide you after you’ve genuinely apologized.

And his daughter is fortunate to get that amount of money, regardless of what it was that prompted her father to start saving.

Team overreact here, too, for the same reasons. His own manners could do with an overhaul.

pootlin · 01/02/2024 05:57

Topseyt123 · 01/02/2024 03:35

It was a stupid, thoughtless comment from you, and one that he cannot unhear.

If course you didn't mean that she was lucky her mum died, but your mouth ran away on wheels. However, I think he was also wrong to divulge private information like the figures involved. He could have said just about everything he did without doing that, and he probably will keep quiet about it in the future because it invited your unfortunate remark.

You've apologised. You'll probably need to apologise again and show that you are properly contrite. It will always be an extremely sensitive issue for them, so don't dismiss it as an overreaction. Accept it.

No she doesn’t need to apologise again and she has nothing to be contrite for, he’s a manbaby loving the drama.

pootlin · 01/02/2024 05:56

YANBU. He’s one of those dullards who says ‘I’d give anything back for just one day with x but I can’t’. People grieving don’t talk about money.

He knows most people, let alone young people, can’t dream of having £800k handed over to them and he’s rubbing it in your face.

Don’t apologise again and avoid him in future.

Noicant · 01/02/2024 05:53

I think it was an overreaction, if I had been him it would have caught me short but then I would have given myself a nudge and realised that you didn’t mean it that way. Also 800k is an amazing amount of money, most people would be floored by it and would think anyone with it would be “lucky”.

You can lose a parent and end up living in poverty or lose a parent and live comfortably. Pretending that money doesn’t make a difference is just not true.

Northernsouloldies · 01/02/2024 05:52

Why would anyone go into that sort of financial detail surely you just keep that to yourself. A misplaced comment yes but I feel the person was bragging about what daughter was in for money wise. Why would you tell people that?.

renthead · 01/02/2024 05:49

This is a crazy overreaction on all of their parts. Of course it's terrible that her mum died, but to have nearly a million pounds available? That is lucky! I can't even quite work out how the mum dying is connected to the money, as it doesn't sound like it's an inheritance.

It also seems really distasteful to discuss that amount of money at work. It's obviously going to attract comments, so it's sort of on him.

stcrispinsday · 01/02/2024 05:49

Given you apologised immediately, the people messaging you need to wind their necks in. You're not a child who needs admonishing. You mis spoke. Everyone does it from time to time. I actually think the widowed friend was being quite rude to tell you to be "careful" rather than just gracefully accepting your apology. Still, nothing you can do except chalk it up to experience and move on.

Bestyearever2024 · 01/02/2024 05:48

Thoughtless if you to say that.

Is the Dad overreacting?

No

Possiblynotever · 01/02/2024 05:47

Well, I know people who lost their mum and did not get £800K.
Very sad for her to lose her mum, but very lucky to have a dad who has thought about her financial necessities.

RantyAnty · 01/02/2024 05:42

SoYoung · 31/01/2024 23:48

Comments like that come from people who are a bit stupid or a bit horrible. I don't think so many people would have messaged you if they thought you were a bit dim and it was a harmless comment, so it must have come across pretty badly. Was your apology sincere? Because you calling the reaction an overreaction says a lot.

I was thinking maybe she has form for blurting out rude things.

RowanMayfair · 01/02/2024 05:28

Most people wouldn't have that kind of money waiting for them because of the death of a parent. They must have had a fair bit of money to start with. So from a financial point of view she's lucky, because her parents were able to provide a lot of money for her (which she would have benefitted from whether her mum had lived or not). That aspect is clearly not being acknowledged by the father, as everyone is focusing on the insensitive comment. So yeah it was a foot in mouth moment but she's also lucky, from a purely financial point of view.

TeddyToes · 01/02/2024 05:18

From what you've said I think it would have been clear to the people there that you meant no malice. Obviously you were commenting on the amount of money and not the fact that the girl lost her mother ... why on earth would anyone say that was lucky?
I think his response to you is over the top, considering you apologised. And frankly he had no need to be mentioning the specifics of the amount in the first place!
You misspoke, you had the good grace to say sorry and you don't need to beat yourself up about it.

Zanatdy · 01/02/2024 04:47

It was thoughtless but exactly that, no malice intended. I think he was in his rights to say what he did about being careful what you say. All you can do is apologise, and you have so try and put it behind you.

betterangels · 01/02/2024 04:44

I thought he seemed pretty restrained in his reply, honestly. You should think before you speak.

Tink2345 · 01/02/2024 04:24

I think the fact that OP has posted here shows this is playing on her mind as she genuinely didn’t mean to upset this person.

Many children lose parents and are left with nothing, and I personally think in the context of this conversation I would automatically think the OP was saying the girl was lucky for the amount of money and that her dad thought to act the way he had to provide it for her. Of course it doesn’t replace her mum, but it’s a legacy many children don’t get so why shouldn’t she count herself lucky?

Topseyt123 · 01/02/2024 03:35

It was a stupid, thoughtless comment from you, and one that he cannot unhear.

If course you didn't mean that she was lucky her mum died, but your mouth ran away on wheels. However, I think he was also wrong to divulge private information like the figures involved. He could have said just about everything he did without doing that, and he probably will keep quiet about it in the future because it invited your unfortunate remark.

You've apologised. You'll probably need to apologise again and show that you are properly contrite. It will always be an extremely sensitive issue for them, so don't dismiss it as an overreaction. Accept it.

junebirthdaygirl · 01/02/2024 03:30

Teeheehee1579 · 31/01/2024 23:42

Yes I do think they overreacted - you obviously did not mean isn’t she lucky her mum died, you meant she’s lucky to have the money that she will have. And she is lucky to have the money. Obviously not lucky her mum died. Both can be true. You apologised and I think his response should have been far more gracious given the lack of intent to hurt and offend.

Even if l got a stab to the heart if someone said that l would leave it off as it makes everything a bit awkward now. He is being a bit crass discussing his private money business like that especially mentioning amounts. It was lovely you apologised and that should have been that.

BestBadger · 01/02/2024 03:18

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 31/01/2024 23:33

As i was reading your post i was thinking 'please don't say something about being lucky'. I don't think it was an overreaction to be upset by the comment. You know it was the wrong thing to say. Not much you can do about it now though. You've apologied and hopefully your colleague will be able to move past it.

3 people messaged though, to point out what the OP already acknowledged. Sounds more like they're milking the opportunity to have a dig at OP to me.

BitchImLoco · 01/02/2024 03:14

Yes he overreacted. And he was showing off about the money he’d saved when you were all talking about how worried you were. Bit of a hypocrite, and very undignified talking about you being your back and not accepting the apology.

Justfinking · 01/02/2024 03:10

Trez1510 · 01/02/2024 03:07

If you're generally a kind, generous of spirit sort of person then the four individuals acting independently are definitely over-reacting.

If you generally react in a 'jealous' way, or have a history of making sarky/envious comments, then they are not over-reacting.

For me, I think the fact you've referenced how little your own home is worth in comparison to the young lady's imminent wealth says quite a bit really.

It's probably all down to your 'tone', and potentially your previous reactions to people mentioning things you don't have/can't afford.

Agree with this too, if you're generally a nice person I think you would have been given more leeway. The fact four other people have said something gives you your answer

Trez1510 · 01/02/2024 03:07

If you're generally a kind, generous of spirit sort of person then the four individuals acting independently are definitely over-reacting.

If you generally react in a 'jealous' way, or have a history of making sarky/envious comments, then they are not over-reacting.

For me, I think the fact you've referenced how little your own home is worth in comparison to the young lady's imminent wealth says quite a bit really.

It's probably all down to your 'tone', and potentially your previous reactions to people mentioning things you don't have/can't afford.

user1473878824 · 01/02/2024 03:06

Some people have money some people don’t. There’s no excuse for being an arsehole though.

Justfinking · 01/02/2024 03:02

RaptorTruck · 01/02/2024 02:54

I don’t think they’re over reacting. You were thoughtless about some thing that is extremely sensitive. If you can’t engage your brain during conversations about such topics, try to say nothing.

I think if you were truly sorry, you wouldn’t post it here even, trying to get people on your side. You may not have meant it how it came out but that doesn’t take away the shock and hurt it would cause to hear it, so just put yourself in your colleagues shoes.

You fucked up, you have apologised, now you should just let it go.

I agree with this. If you were sorry you'd feel bad about it, not post on here trying to get people to justify your opinion. Pull your head in. Also he just said to think, which was right. I'm assuming you wanted him to say no worries, and it's ok?

RaptorTruck · 01/02/2024 02:54

I don’t think they’re over reacting. You were thoughtless about some thing that is extremely sensitive. If you can’t engage your brain during conversations about such topics, try to say nothing.

I think if you were truly sorry, you wouldn’t post it here even, trying to get people on your side. You may not have meant it how it came out but that doesn’t take away the shock and hurt it would cause to hear it, so just put yourself in your colleagues shoes.

You fucked up, you have apologised, now you should just let it go.

pikkumyy77 · 01/02/2024 02:49

Zfactorstar · 01/02/2024 00:46

Can men do anything right for some people? I enjoy this website but the men bashing that goes on can get out of control. He's a widower, who stepped up to the plate for his daughter and was hurt by a thoughtless comment. I'm sure he'll get over it but the person who did the hurting isn't the person who gets to decide when the apology is to be accepted. OP, I actually sympathy because we've all been there. Give him space and time. And if it comes up again apologize again.

He “stepped up to the plate for his daughter?” He didn’t do more than any parent of whatever sex is supposed to do.