Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thinking this is an over-reaction to my thoughtless comment

586 replies

Clemcy · 31/01/2024 23:29

Today at work I spent lunch with some colleagues who have children a similar age to my eldest, 16-18 sort of age. We were talking about uni/fees/tech/accomodation etc.
One colleagues wife passed away when their child was younger, he sold the house, moved away to somewhere much cheaper mortgage free etc. and put the rest of the money from the sale away for his daughter.
He was explaining he's not worried as he has enough to buy her a flat/house when she's in second year, pay her fees and keep some back for wedding/emergencies. He quite causally said "yeah there is about £800,000 waiting for her."
This is insane to me, my house is worth a quarter of that, while I appreciate the circumstances that have allowed them to accumulate that money are awful it is a large sum!!
I thoughtlessly said "oh wow lucky girl" and everyone sort of looked at me, I realised and apologised.
Since I've gotten home 3 separate people have messaged me to let me know said colleague is quite upset at my insensitive comment, and there is nothing lucky about your mum dying - I never said there was!!
I messaged him to apologise but he just replied with "no amount of money will bring her mum back, be careful what you say"

I'm now sat quite upset, I genuinely wasn't thinking, heard the amount and thought wow!
AIBU to think this is an overreaction to a thoughtless comment?

OP posts:
fatphalange · 01/02/2024 12:48

I think it's clear your comment was directed at the financial privilege and security his DD has. What a silly stick to beat you with.

DeeLusional · 01/02/2024 12:45

I think it was very insensitive and in extremely bad taste for the colleague to announce that he was providing his DD with £800000 when he may well have been in the room with people suffering severe financial hardship.

aarghnotmeagain · 01/02/2024 12:45

Angelsrose · 01/02/2024 12:44

I don't think there was any ill intent behind what you said. There isn't anyone out there who hasn't made a faux pas they wish they could take back. I think the reprimand in response to your apology is unnecessary and trying to make you feel worse than the situation really calls for. You have apologised sincerely and that's really all you can do.

I agree with this.

Angelsrose · 01/02/2024 12:44

I don't think there was any ill intent behind what you said. There isn't anyone out there who hasn't made a faux pas they wish they could take back. I think the reprimand in response to your apology is unnecessary and trying to make you feel worse than the situation really calls for. You have apologised sincerely and that's really all you can do.

RoseJam · 01/02/2024 12:44

OP - you felt awful about the comment and apologised. What is the point of asking whether or not he over-reacted? Are you going to pull him over it, and retract your apology? Not apologise in a similar circumstance? Regret the apologies you have made? What are you hoping to gain?

What has happened has passed. You apologised and that was the right thing to do. Now is the time to let it go.

aarghnotmeagain · 01/02/2024 12:40

Only read your OP. It was a thoughtless comment ( literally, you clearly were not thinking of the reason why she has this money when you said this ) but you have acknowledged this and apologised twice. Assuming your apologies were genuine (not 'I'm sorry but.'.. type justifications) he should accept this with grace and move on. He last email to you was unnecessarily putting the boot in.

It was also perhaps a bit thoughtless of him to raise his daughter's easy financial state in a conversation where others are presumably worrying over supporting their kids financially. I'm not surprised you blurted out what you did in that context.

phoenixrosehere · 01/02/2024 12:37

Bumblebeestiltskin · 01/02/2024 12:24

YABU, definitely not an overreaction. But all you can do is apologise and move on, you obviously didn't mean to be thoughtless.

She’s apologised twice. Immediately after she said it and again through a text.

If he chooses not to accept it, obviously his choice, but how many times does OP have to apologise over a bad choice of words?

bogoffeternal · 01/02/2024 12:37

Sorry, that is a ridiculous reaction from your colleagues and they should (and I suspect totally do) know what you meant.

Garlickit · 01/02/2024 12:36

Not really the point of the story, but the bloke seems to have been saying DD's got all this money because he chose to downsize - not that it was his wife's life insurance. Presumably could have downsized with his wife, had she lived.

He can't have it both ways, can he? He wants all the cookies for being a prudent parent, and also wants DD's financial good fortune linked to her mother's death 🤔

Shefliesonherownwings · 01/02/2024 12:36

It was a stupid comment, not just throughtless albeit not malicious, and I don’t think they, particularly the colleague concerned was overreacting. However given you apologised then and hopefully after your colleague messaged you, I’d expect everyone to move on now. If they keep going on about it then they’re being unreasonable.

roarrfeckingroar · 01/02/2024 12:34

Very thoughtless of you. Nothing you can do about it now.

Xmasbaby11 · 01/02/2024 12:32

YANBU. Of course it was a tragedy she lost her mother, but a person can be lucky and unlucky. It sounds a bit strange everyone going on about it - you apologised!

Maybe he was sensitive because he'd had a lot of comments and he was starting to say something.

InAMess2023 · 01/02/2024 12:32

I totally sympathise with you as it's definitely the kind of thing that I would come out with! I think just an apology will do and explain you meant no harm. I don't think it's anything that needs to be dwelled on from either side.

On the flip side I lost my dad aged 13 and can see why it caused upset. (Although if I'd been left £800k from it rather than £0k it might have made my formative years a little bit easier!)

AutumnColour89 · 01/02/2024 12:31

True, but a lot of people's 'privilege' (or perceived privilege) doesn't stem from what they've chosen?

Wealthy parents? Private education? Race? Lucky lottery win?

So much of privilege is not what we have chosen.

AutumnColour89 · 01/02/2024 12:27

OP didn't 'point it out'- that suggests she was directly saying 'ah so what if she lost her mother, she's got nearly £1 mill!'

£800k is a staggering amount and OP was clearly saying the girl is lucky to have that. That is not saying she's 'lucky' to have lost her mother!

Spinet · 01/02/2024 12:27

I mean if he can't move past it he can't, but you've done your bit by apologising. You could email back and say 'you're absolutely right.' but otherwise just try to forget about it because any amount of your apologies and rending of clothese is not going to bring his daughter's mum back is it. If anyone mentions it just say 'yes, I've apologised and feel terrible. Let's drop it now please.'

PrawnDumplings · 01/02/2024 12:26

I don't think anyone sounds very mature in this whole scenario tbh.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 01/02/2024 12:25

AutumnColour89 · 01/02/2024 12:15

OP I've never understood reactions like your colleagues. I appreciate the comment was a little insensitive and poorly worded, but I think they're really overracting.

The two are mutually exclusive; losing a parent young is truly devasting, in that sense of course she isn't 'lucky'.

But having £800k 'sat there waiting for her' is a privilege that will afford her a life of very little financial concern throughout her life (if any) and she is at an incredible advantage compared to her peers. That's a headstart beyong comprehension. So in that sense she's very lucky.

There are plenty of teens out there who have lost parents yet have nothing like that level of financial windfall, maybe not any. There are also plenty of teens out there who have sadly suffered abuse or unhappy childhoods who have no such boost to help them overcome a hard start.

Its presumably not a 'privilege' she wanted though. She'd prefer to have her mum.

I found it insensitive when my grandmother made a similar comment to me about a friend being lucky that she could buy a house outright - I pointed out that it was only because of the money from the sale of her mum's house after she died, which my grandmother was aware of.

(She also didn't understand why I was upset when my rabbit died on the grounds that we had another rabbit, so she had form for being insensitive.)

Bumblebeestiltskin · 01/02/2024 12:24

YABU, definitely not an overreaction. But all you can do is apologise and move on, you obviously didn't mean to be thoughtless.

Blu23 · 01/02/2024 12:23

I understand why you said the girl was lucky, you said it based on the money she will be getting, not because her mum passed away. Not every child gets that amount of money when one of their parent passes away. I don't think you did it intentionally. You have apologised so it should be done and dusted by both the parties.

AutumnColour89 · 01/02/2024 12:23

I know someone who sadly lost their mother as a young teen. They received a fraction of £800k yet the head start that a lump sum gave them is glaringly obvious 20 years later.

No concern over uni fees; being able to live wherever they want, study where they want- expensive city for dream job, affluent area near family and friends; now mortgage free after being able to put a sizeable deposit on a house age 21 and never having to throw money to private landlords.

Not lucky for losing their mother, at all.

Lucky for living their full adult life shielded from the harsh financial comprimises and sacrifices that most of us have to make- yes.

notlucreziaborgia · 01/02/2024 12:23

AutumnColour89 · 01/02/2024 12:15

OP I've never understood reactions like your colleagues. I appreciate the comment was a little insensitive and poorly worded, but I think they're really overracting.

The two are mutually exclusive; losing a parent young is truly devasting, in that sense of course she isn't 'lucky'.

But having £800k 'sat there waiting for her' is a privilege that will afford her a life of very little financial concern throughout her life (if any) and she is at an incredible advantage compared to her peers. That's a headstart beyong comprehension. So in that sense she's very lucky.

There are plenty of teens out there who have lost parents yet have nothing like that level of financial windfall, maybe not any. There are also plenty of teens out there who have sadly suffered abuse or unhappy childhoods who have no such boost to help them overcome a hard start.

Does that require pointing out though?

Op’s level of butthurt over finding out his daughter has £800k as a result of personal tragedy hardly requires being treated with more sensitivity than someone who yes, may be in a financially advantageous position, but is in said position because his wife died.

betterangels · 01/02/2024 12:23

PrawnDumplings · 01/02/2024 09:33

Yep

Oh and he was really rude to not accept your genuine apology. "Careful what you wish for" He sounds like a right knob. You apologised (needlessly imo) What the hell else does he want?

No one is entitled to have their apology accepted.

Mynewnameis · 01/02/2024 12:21

Total over reaction. Dh inherited 100k from his mother. He feels grateful to have it.

MCOut · 01/02/2024 12:20

When you apologised, though, I hope you didn’t focus on yourself. If you did, and they thought it was insincere that might be the problem. I genuinely think to a certain degree people are punished for being accountable so not a lot of people know how to apologise properly.

There’s a difference between an apology that focuses on your intention, your character, your feelings etc and one which is accountable, acknowledges his feelings and shows that you understand why your comment was hurtful.

If you did the latter, he’s still upset and your colleagues still messaged you then it’s an overreaction.

Swipe left for the next trending thread