Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Saying DD has to go to specific school or give up sport

116 replies

Tipisy · 31/01/2024 16:25

DD is 15 in Y11 and plays a sport competitively.
After summer she will move up a team from U16 to U18 and she will move to Sixth form.
The U18 team train two mornings a week 6.30-7.30.
DDs current school is 20 minutes from the centre they train at. We live about 10 minutes from both. There is a school next door to the centre they train at and a college within walking distance. DD has applied to all of them for sixth form.
DD really wants to stay at her current school as most of her friends will be.
But due to us living in a small village this would mean I'd have to drive her there in the morning for 6.30, pick her up at 7.30, drive her home for 7.45 giving her 20 minutes to shower and get dressed for school then get the bus or pick her up later let her shower at the centre and drive her all the way to school.
Alternatively, she can go to the school next door, I'll drop her off at 6.30, she can shower and get ready at the centre, walk over to school and study/meet friends etc. until school starts. Or the same and go to the college.
I have 3 other kids who I need to sort school for too, admittedly they will all be in secondary by then but it would be a lot.

AIBU to say to DD she has to either give up the sport and stay at her current school or pick the school/college near the centre and continue? DH thinks it's mean but I WFH and have other kids to sort and just can't be back and forth all morning!

OP posts:
mitogoshi · 31/01/2024 17:42

The other thing is that depending on the sport, even if she's very good, unless she's elite by 16 then it's just a hobby and as a family we have to decide when enough is enough. I stepped back once mine were at 6th form, hobbies I would fund but sacrifice my sanity for (late nights rather than early mornings for mine)

mitogoshi · 31/01/2024 17:38

Is there no public transport from the sports centre to the school, could she shower there then catch the bus? I'd also suggest checking that she can get a school bus from your house to her existing school post 16, there's no statutory requirement so families have been caught out here - the school bus only takes 11-16 despite the sixth form being on the same site. Post 16 can get the public bus the opposite direction so the council doesn't need to provide

Tipisy · 31/01/2024 17:35

PuttingDownRoots · 31/01/2024 17:34

Where will her team mates go?

None at her school currently, some will go to the school next door, others another school in the same town or the college, some are privately educated.

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 31/01/2024 17:34

Where will her team mates go?

Hankunamatata · 31/01/2024 17:33

With your update its a no brainer she goes to the bigger school next to the training centre

Clarinet1 · 31/01/2024 17:33

At sixth form level would DD definitely have to be in school first thing every morning? At mine you were allowed in late or allowed to leave early if you had a free period. Obviously this might not be clear until September when timetables are known but it could help. Also, given that she’s established and achieving in her sport, would it be worth seeing whether some kind of special arrangement could be made?

itsgettingweird · 31/01/2024 17:31

I get this. Ds is a competitive level for sport and it involves morning training as well as evening.

Ok, his is earlier 5-7am! But when he moved from school to college I told him he needs to consider how he's travelling. (Easier for me as due to a disability he needed me to take him!). But otherwise I meant consider times of college, times I work and the travel required of me.

I think she needs to either

A) get public transport to her current school from the sport or

B) go to a school near her sport.

If she's serious about her sport and wanting to go all the way when faced with realising the independence required and the sacrifices she needs to make to her life as well as the ones the parents make to facilitate it she'll decide herself to carry on or quit and on what school works best

Bythefireside · 31/01/2024 17:31

I recently made her decision that has ended in my teen basically giving up the hobby they loved and were really good at and had dedicated years to. All I can tell you is the guilt is a b*#+# and I would change the decision in a heart beat if i could. Just something to think about.

ChateauMargaux · 31/01/2024 17:29

What about an ebike? Or, as someone else suggested a 50cc moped?

We have sporty kids we are constantly driving around. They do some biking / public transport to ease the load but winters are tricky.

RandomMess · 31/01/2024 17:27

I've had to give DD the deadline that this is the season I will take her to sports training. I'm knackered, she either passes her driving test or changes team or changes club.

Jellyx · 31/01/2024 17:27

My parents had 6kids and took all of to our sports. Why can't you do this hard work for a year or 2?

lifeturnsonadime · 31/01/2024 17:26

If the schools are academically equal then I would expect your DD to compromise on this.

It will be good for her development to meet new friends in 6th form, she can then have 3 sets of friends, school ones, sports ones and 6th form ones.

I can't see any reason for you to have to do unnecessary driving.

Tipisy · 31/01/2024 17:25

MrsAvocet · 31/01/2024 17:21

For me, one key thing would be whether there is any real advantage to her staying at her current school or if it is just a preference. I'd probably feel rather differently if there was a subject at the existing school that she wanted to do that the others don't offer or if the results were significantly better at her current school.
It is a potentially very disruptive schedule for you and the other children so I'd want to be able to see a real advantage to staying in the same school.
Another consideration is your DD's own well being. I know how much pressure there is for a young person combining a serious sport or other activity with A levels as my own children have been there. Being at the school near the sports facilities is potentially quite a bit less stressful and tiring for her as well as you. The time spent in the 6th Form Centre in the mornings could be used a lot more productively than the same time sitting in traffic. Whilst a change of school may seem like a big upheaval for her right now, long term it might make her life a lot easier.

That is the other frustrating thing.
Her dream A-Levels are Maths, Further Maths Economics and German. She can't do that at her current school as economics isn't offered and further maths is dependent on uptake (small school). The other school which is bigger offers all her dream subjects and has consistently better results at A-Level.
We don't send our kids there for GCSE results are effectively the same and we liked the transition from primary to secondary at the other school (plus being smaller made it seem friendlier).
DD already spends more time than most at school (says she's more productive in the library than at home) so I'd imagine either way she will go in early to study etc.

OP posts:
Heronwatcher · 31/01/2024 17:24

I think I would try to make it work, something like DP drops her off at swimming on his way to work, she takes school stuff with her, she gets showered and changed there, and either you pick her up with the other kids in the car later (8ish) and drop her at school, dropping other kids on the way or way back, or she gets a bus if this is possible (I assume she’d have 45 mins plus to get to school afterwards).

It’s a big deal to go to a school without her friends and if she’s happy at school
where she is I don’t think I’d be pushing her to change it, or to ditch the sport.

Obviously if it’s a total nightmare for some reason (and you might want to test run buses or driving this term) or she actively wants to go to the college, that’s different.

PennyNotWise · 31/01/2024 17:23

Even if she does move school will she need a lift anyway? So maybe your DH could take her early morning either way. Then the only prob for you would be working out how to pick her up 2 days if she does stay at current school

Waxdrip · 31/01/2024 17:23

DH should drop off if he has to leave at 7 anyway. Especially if you're dealing with three other kids. I would try to keep her at the school that she likes if possible.

museumum · 31/01/2024 17:23

I think it's reasonable to insist she gets from training to school/college herself. If she wants to stay at her current school she needs to come up with a plan - cycling, bus, lift from a friend?
If not, she needs to change to a more convenient school/college.

MrsAvocet · 31/01/2024 17:21

For me, one key thing would be whether there is any real advantage to her staying at her current school or if it is just a preference. I'd probably feel rather differently if there was a subject at the existing school that she wanted to do that the others don't offer or if the results were significantly better at her current school.
It is a potentially very disruptive schedule for you and the other children so I'd want to be able to see a real advantage to staying in the same school.
Another consideration is your DD's own well being. I know how much pressure there is for a young person combining a serious sport or other activity with A levels as my own children have been there. Being at the school near the sports facilities is potentially quite a bit less stressful and tiring for her as well as you. The time spent in the 6th Form Centre in the mornings could be used a lot more productively than the same time sitting in traffic. Whilst a change of school may seem like a big upheaval for her right now, long term it might make her life a lot easier.

AutumnFroglets · 31/01/2024 17:20

DH thinks it's mean
Then DH needs to step up and think how he can help more in the mornings. Would his work consider a late start twice a week, he could work through his lunch hour instead. Would he even ask? If he can't help provide a proper solution then he needs to shut up.

Also ask DD how she imagines how it will work with the needs of her three siblings and her mother's exhaustion level? She's old enough to start figuring this out, it's called time management and responsibilities, and all six formers/college students need to learn this to function as an adult.

Tipisy · 31/01/2024 17:20

Emptyheadlock · 31/01/2024 17:17

Yanbu

She at least has an option.

Guessing this sport negatively impacted the other 3 over the years. She can suck it up now.

Oh 100% and we would still take her to wherever necessary from competitions which can be up to 3/4 hours one way. We do rotate this with the other parents but it's a big commitment and I do feel DD is at an age now where she has to put some of the effort in to make it work within the family unit.
DD2 is also getting to an age where she will be competing more so it's got to be a balance.

OP posts:
Watercolourpapier · 31/01/2024 17:20

There's not a chance in hell i would be doing all that extra running around when it's simply dd's preference to stay in her current school.

Its not fair on your other children and it's not fair on you for her to take up so much of your resources.

Also, Unless dh wants to be part of the solution, he can shut up.

WhatNoUsername · 31/01/2024 17:19

I can't believe people are saying you should do all that running around. I wouldn't even consider it.

I would consider a few options - are there ways she could transport herself for some of it - buses, cycling, moped, friend's parents?

If not then I would agree with you. She either goes to the more practical school or she drops the activity.

bridgetreilly · 31/01/2024 17:19

She’s old enough to work out her own plan. You tell her precisely the limits of what you can do to help and then let her come back to you with her solution.

Emptyheadlock · 31/01/2024 17:17

Yanbu

She at least has an option.

Guessing this sport negatively impacted the other 3 over the years. She can suck it up now.

Tipisy · 31/01/2024 17:16

PuttingDownRoots · 31/01/2024 17:13

No public transport, even if a bit of a walk or a change?

Not at those times it's rural so the bus service is irregular, the first bus from our village to the centre wouldn't arrive at the centre until 6.40 then it's still a walk. Coming back the way she would miss the bus going back by a few minutes so not something we could rely on.

OP posts: