Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Saying DD has to go to specific school or give up sport

116 replies

Tipisy · 31/01/2024 16:25

DD is 15 in Y11 and plays a sport competitively.
After summer she will move up a team from U16 to U18 and she will move to Sixth form.
The U18 team train two mornings a week 6.30-7.30.
DDs current school is 20 minutes from the centre they train at. We live about 10 minutes from both. There is a school next door to the centre they train at and a college within walking distance. DD has applied to all of them for sixth form.
DD really wants to stay at her current school as most of her friends will be.
But due to us living in a small village this would mean I'd have to drive her there in the morning for 6.30, pick her up at 7.30, drive her home for 7.45 giving her 20 minutes to shower and get dressed for school then get the bus or pick her up later let her shower at the centre and drive her all the way to school.
Alternatively, she can go to the school next door, I'll drop her off at 6.30, she can shower and get ready at the centre, walk over to school and study/meet friends etc. until school starts. Or the same and go to the college.
I have 3 other kids who I need to sort school for too, admittedly they will all be in secondary by then but it would be a lot.

AIBU to say to DD she has to either give up the sport and stay at her current school or pick the school/college near the centre and continue? DH thinks it's mean but I WFH and have other kids to sort and just can't be back and forth all morning!

OP posts:
Purplebunnie · 01/02/2024 18:00

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 01/02/2024 16:42

20 minute drive not walk.

Thought I'd misunderstood, my fault, thank you

Mumof2teens79 · 01/02/2024 17:08

Is there no bus from the centre to her current school?
Do they not currently do morning training? Are both sessions compulsory?
How about others on the team? Maybe in year above? Could anyone lift share?

It does seem more practical to move....but also what's the sixth form timetable like at both?
Most 6th formers here skip the school bus because they rarely have to be in first thing.

ODubhshlaine · 01/02/2024 17:06

My twins moved schools in order to get the subjects they wanted that weren’t offered at their school

They now are both at Uni studying subjects that they love that are directly related to those subjects that they nearly gave up because of their friends. They actually moved to a much better school and (tbh) found really lovely friends.

I also believe you will be doing too much running around and older children benefit from some independence. They will need this when they leave home along with the ability to make new friends.

If it was my family and she wanted to keep up with the sport she either
changes school
finds another team that accommodates her existing school

breezesin · 01/02/2024 17:06

DH needs to step up …

ProfessorInkling · 01/02/2024 17:02

Could DH drop her off as he is leaving for work shortly after anyway - and then she could get showered and changed at the centre, and you pick her up and drive her to school, along with DD2? The older ones get the bus on those days?

Birch101 · 01/02/2024 17:02

Would it be feasible that you or your partner drop her off at 6.30 she showers and changes at the sports centre and she gets a taxi to school the 2 days a week of practice
You could encourage her to get a job at weekends/evenings of possible to help fund this.

I wish I had stayed at my 6th form with friends rather than change (and wonder if i would have had better grades).and had given up all.my sports by her age due to numerous reasons so would try and find other alternatives, that being said she is becoming a young adult and should be involved in the conversation and understand logistics and practicalities.

minipie · 01/02/2024 16:59

Ok I am not a sporty person but for me, unless competing at national level you do not choose a school based on a sport.

Things like A level choices are much more important - also friends are important- but appreciate these two things point to different schools for your DD.

Are there any friends at all going to the bigger, close to sports centre school? Surely some friends must also want a better choice of A Levels?

In your shoes I would be working on her to pick the bigger school for the A level choices alone. The sports training being easier might help with this. She can still keep up with her old friends who stay at the smaller school. Presumably she’d see some of them at sports training. It might be a good thing to have two groups of friends, old school and new school.

If she decides to stay at the old school after all… Are there any other kids/ parents who will be doing the run between training and school? Can you share it so it’s only once a week? And yes agree it would make sense for DH to do the early drop off. Coming home in between is a non starter, there clearly isn’t time, she needs to shower there and go straight to school.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 01/02/2024 16:57

I have to agree that there’s three options.
Move, give up, or dh takes.
I would approach DH and see if the last is a true option before presenting it to dd.

PrawnDumplings · 01/02/2024 16:54

WhatsInANameDearBethany · 31/01/2024 16:50

Is a 50cc moped an option?

Are you serious?!

lanthanum · 01/02/2024 16:54

It sounds as if moving school would be better from the point of view of her A-levels as well as making the sport easier. I'm not sure why you didn't even mention that in the original post, as it's probably more important.

Rather than trying to force her into a decision by using the sport, can you work on the other reasons to move school.

DD went to a sixth form where she knew nobody else. That took some guts (especially as she had been very shy), but it worked really well. She's still friends with her previous crowd, but she's made some new friends, and it's given her a lot more confidence. It means that she's not at all worried about making new friends at university, because she's already done it once. Can you try selling your DD on some of the positives of moving?

Do any of the others on the sports team go to that sixth form? That might help encourage her. Are there any taster days?

DottyLottieLou · 01/02/2024 16:52

You are being perfectly reasonable. She needs to learn to compromise and that sacrifices sometimes need to be made.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 01/02/2024 16:42

Purplebunnie · 01/02/2024 16:35

I don't think I've got this. Why can't she walk the 20 minutes from the training centre to her current school. Surely that is the most logical course of action

20 minute drive not walk.

Bookkeepermum · 01/02/2024 16:39

Why can't your husband take her there and back for that hour while you sort your other children?

Clearinguptheclutter · 01/02/2024 16:39

i think you've hit the nail on the head with
I do feel DD is at an age now where she has to put some of the effort in to make it work within the family unit.
you've obviously taxied her a lot to her sport and continued to do so, but committing to a 6.30 am taxi, and possibly a 7.30 am taxi too, when you have three other children to sort out in the mornings, is a lot TBH.
My son has serious sporting commitments but understands that his commitments impact what his brother (and parents!) can/cannot do and sometimes compromise is needed. And he's only 8.

Purplebunnie · 01/02/2024 16:35

I don't think I've got this. Why can't she walk the 20 minutes from the training centre to her current school. Surely that is the most logical course of action

GreatGardenstuff · 01/02/2024 16:27

Saw your update, if the new school has better courses and results she should be seriously considering going there anyway. The logistics for training should be rubber stamping the deal. 6th form is a great time to move out of the comfort zone of school.

VickyEadieofThigh · 01/02/2024 16:25

Tipisy · 31/01/2024 17:25

That is the other frustrating thing.
Her dream A-Levels are Maths, Further Maths Economics and German. She can't do that at her current school as economics isn't offered and further maths is dependent on uptake (small school). The other school which is bigger offers all her dream subjects and has consistently better results at A-Level.
We don't send our kids there for GCSE results are effectively the same and we liked the transition from primary to secondary at the other school (plus being smaller made it seem friendlier).
DD already spends more time than most at school (says she's more productive in the library than at home) so I'd imagine either way she will go in early to study etc.

Just want to add weight to this A level issue.

My eldest niece (all grade A* and 9 at GCSE in 2017) was planning to move to a more successful school for better A level choice and results, but in the end elected to stay put because of friends. She ended up having to take English Lit instead of her first preference (history) because of a much smaller 6th form at her original school AND - was the only student choosing the subject!

As a result, they only gave her half the lessons other A levels got and being a. lass of one was awful. She got ABB when she should've had at least AAA. The original school went into Inadequate with Ofsted not long after and 6th for. teaching was a major issue.

Try to guide your daughter towards the subjects she really prefers AND emphasise how important a bigger, more successful 6th form would be for her.

celticprincess · 01/02/2024 16:21

Tipisy · 31/01/2024 17:08

It's really not that simple, DH has to leave at 7am for work, youngest will only be 11 when this all starts so definitely not ready to be left to her own devices.
DD1 already takes up more of our free time than the others and I think somewhere there has to be a balance. I think moving school and continuing sport is a fair compromise especially as it's sixth form when loads of pupils move.
DD already goes to school early most days so she's used to studying in library until the day starts and the other school starts the day at 8.30 so it's not a lot of waiting around!

My 11 is left to her own devices 2 days a week for school now. I leave at 7:15am for work on 2 days. North DD11&DD13 have to be up when I leave and then they get themselves to school. They leave at different times as the youngest is an early bird and meets friends. Eldest is also autistic but has been doing it since she was 11. Both secondary 11 though as August birthdays . Bit we did start walking to and from school alone from y6, just with me seeing them out the door. Work days was wrap around I had to pay for on primary.

GreatGardenstuff · 01/02/2024 16:17

DH seems on board with her plan. How about he facilitates it by taking her there each morning? Halves the load for you and gives you time to concentrate on the younger ones .

WhatWouldTheDoctorDo · 31/01/2024 20:37

I'd be encouraging her to change schools because it's a better option for her A levels. Being next to the training centre is an added bonus. And if DH leaves at 7, then surely he could do the 6.30 drop offs twice a week, leaving you to sort the other DC for school.

ThaQuilomum · 31/01/2024 19:21

ColdAsConcrete · 31/01/2024 17:03

And what about the other DC she has at home?
Her DH can sort them!

FloatlikeaFeather2, they're teenagers, aren't they? Or all in secondary. Will they be asleep in bed still? With their dad? She would still have to be up and out and drop her daughter to training at that time even if she does move school.

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 31/01/2024 19:06

Put it on her. How does she see it work and what is her solution. She is old enough to understand compromises need to be made and she needs to find a solution. Being ferried around like that is completely unreasonable.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 31/01/2024 19:02

Sounds like the options are-

  1. she goes to the bigger school, or
  2. she gives up the sport, or
  3. your husband takes her and does this morning jaunt around two venues or at the very least does the 6.30 bit

1 and 3 both sounds like preferable options to 2, but not my decision to make. If your DH thinks it’s “mean” he should definitely make it work and there doesn’t seem to be any reason why he can’t.

Barbarbarann · 31/01/2024 17:59

I think you answered your own question - by saying the other school ( I assume the one near the sport) has better A level results and offers the subjects she wants. Literally the only thing that matters at sixth form is A level results (if she plans to go to university). So it is a no brainer. Those A levels have a LOT of homework. Also, you don't want a school that only sometimes teaches further maths - you need proven teachers ( I am talking from experience there!). Sounds like regardless of the hobby, it seems like a better sixth form.

We also had a difficult decision like this with DD, who was a swimmer with the reverse issue of school. Her sixth form was in the opposite direction of the swimming pool and no buses where we are. We agreed that since she didn't plan to be a professional swimmer , she should give it up to focus on her A-Levels. She wanted to study medicine and that had to take precedence. She was upset for a few weeks but then found herself enjoying the sleep in and she took up waterpolo - as she still loved the water.

MrsAvocet · 31/01/2024 17:45

So it sounds like the school close to the training facility is actually more suitable for her anyway then OP?
It's quite understandable that she is nervous at the prospect of changing schools but it does sound like it makes sense on a number of levels.
If your area is anything like ours she won't be alone as lots of kids change schools for 6th forms, to do specific subjects, go somewhere with better facilities or just because they fancy a change. Quite a lot of children come to my DC's school from elsewhere for 6th form and they seem to settle in within weeks. My DS is in year 13 and has a mix of friends he has been with since year 7 and those who only joined in year 12. Of course it's a big change, but it's not like being one new pupil in an established year group, there will almost certainly be plenty of new arrivals. Does your DD have any friends from her sport who already go there or who would be making the same change? Or any pupils from her old school who are moving for other reasons. That might make the transition easier for her. It's a stressful year and she is probably anxious about making a big change but it sounds like it would benefit her.