Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be furious at Brexit checks 'price you pay to be sovereign again'

459 replies

NoCloudsAllowed · 31/01/2024 12:09

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/jan/31/uk-minister-andrea-leadsom-brexit-checks-price-you-pay-sovereign-state-again

Andrea Leadsom saying barrier checks are the price of sovereignty.

This is not what they promised, is it? The bare faced lies of it all. They've delayed introducing checks because they knew they couldn't square it with Leave campaign promises. In the end, the issue of NI was only solvable by these checks.

This is supposed to cost £330m a year. It will make food more expensive and supply less reliable. There is zero, absolutely zero, benefit to the country. It's just a direct detriment imposed because they can't accept the whole thing is a fuck up.

They never actually express what this sovereignty is supposed to do for us, or what was problematic about the EU rules. It's all on 'the principle of the thing'. Sovereignty won't feed hungry children, will it?

I think I'm just as piping mad about this as I was in 2016 - they're taking the whole country for fools.

UK minister: Brexit checks ‘price you pay for being a sovereign state again’

Andrea Leadsom says businesses experiencing ‘some friction’ should ‘adapt’ to changes in trade rules

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/jan/31/uk-minister-andrea-leadsom-brexit-checks-price-you-pay-sovereign-state-again

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
Precipice · 31/01/2024 15:12

IMustDoMoreExercise · 31/01/2024 14:15

Be careful what you wish for.

FPTP means you do not get the extreme right and extreme left that you have another countries.

Do really want the national front or BNP to have seats parliament?

If they're able to run as a party (are not a proscribed organisation) and get enough votes to get into parliament, then that's democracy. FPTP favours a two-party model, which is bad for democracy. Even highly objectionable people/those you disagree with have the right to an equal voice in political representation.

Unfortunately, this means that we have to accept that sometimes people like Grzegorz Braun (an MP in Poland) get elected, because they get people voting for them.

WestwardHo1 · 31/01/2024 15:08

EssexMan55 · 31/01/2024 14:44

What are you expecting them to do? We left the EU, the SM and CU. This is the consequence - we have to implement it. There isn't any option of just not doing it.

Honestly explain to people the motivation behind people like Johnson's Brexit stance? Have them admit their duplicity and that it was a fucking massive mistake?

Obviously it won't happen, but imagine it did.

Johnson taking some Veritaserum and appearing on TV and saying the whole lot was absolute lies.

Hereyoume · 31/01/2024 15:07

But . . .

We have Blue Passports, they're printed in the EU because it's cheaper, but they are BLUE.

We have absolute control of our borders and can deport any people who sneak into our country 🤔😬

We no longer have to abide by the verdicts of the EU courts 🙄😬

We can forge trade deals with the USA, leveraging that "special relationship"😬

We can still travel easily to the EU 🙄

We can still live in our French Chateaus and retire to our Spanish villas 😂

We can still import cheap food from the EU 😬

We can . . . let me think . . . we can . . .

OK we can't do any of that, but we do get lovely BLUE covers on our EU printed, now mostly useless, passports.

EssexMan55 · 31/01/2024 14:44

NoCloudsAllowed · 31/01/2024 12:50

The problem with a 'what's done is done' view is that this isn't done. They're about to impose checks.

The harm hasn't been done yet, but they're about to do it, there's no rational justification of why it benefits the country, but we're supposed to just shrug about it.

Brexiters mostly want to look the other way, remainers are dismissed as not being over it - who is holding them to account for planning to do actual, unnecessary harm to the country?

If they came out and announced 'we have a new policy that will make trade harder and food more expensive' they'd get flak - but this is supposed to just be waved through?

What are you expecting them to do? We left the EU, the SM and CU. This is the consequence - we have to implement it. There isn't any option of just not doing it.

StandardLFinegan · 31/01/2024 14:41

Daphnis156 · 31/01/2024 13:26

Some people just can't let go, and will be doomed to endlessly fight lost battles.
Divert the energy to more positive things.

And that’s a classic diversionary tactic as described below. Criticise those who highlight the issues rather than accept responsibility for the problems and address the matter in question.

Cyclebabble · 31/01/2024 14:32

If you think it is bad now just wait until they start the requirement for individual checks at channel ports and other points of crossing into the UK. This will cause chaos at the ferry ports, particularly in August holidays.

Cornettoninja · 31/01/2024 14:26

It's not all benefits

The audacity of this string of words that insinuates there are any benefits.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 31/01/2024 14:21

CranfordScones · 31/01/2024 12:55

Why should goods flow unchecked across borders?

Have you been following the news from France in the past week? That's the benefit of not being controlled by the EU.

And the farmers in Germany and Netherlands.

Why are all these farmers revolting if the EU is so great?

IMustDoMoreExercise · 31/01/2024 14:15

BouncingJAS · 31/01/2024 12:39

@NoCloudsAllowed

This is very, very unlikely.

The people that voted as a block in high numbers to leave the EU were the over 60s.

And those folks are largely disconnected from the real economy, as they are heavily subsidised via their triple lock pensions, healthcare, free transport etc.

They will keep saying "its all worth it" until the pass on to the great beyond because they will largely be insulated from the negative economic effects.

Its hypocrisy of the highest order of course but that is the reality in the UK.

The people that will really get economicalmy hammered are the lower earners and JAMS (middle class) who will get much poorer in real terms as their standard of living will get worse as prices rise due to Brexit effects.

I personally do not see a way out for the country given the politics and FPTP electoral structure so the optimal choice for someone who is not old is to emigrate abroad. I know this might not be an easy option for some (only UK passport), but you should definitely explore it to see if you can go to commonwealth countries (a bit easier for UK folks).

Be careful what you wish for.

FPTP means you do not get the extreme right and extreme left that you have another countries.

Do really want the national front or BNP to have seats parliament?

EasternStandard · 31/01/2024 14:09

TheDogsMother · 31/01/2024 14:06

But we did get this so everything is great

I didn’t vote for it but I think it has gone up by more

GasPanic · 31/01/2024 14:08

beguilingeyes · 31/01/2024 13:47

"I think there is going to be some pain in the short term. It's not all benefits. But in the long term it will be much better for us to be more independent and have multiple sources for products rather than be overly reliant on just one partner. That's what opening up competition does."

The trouble with this scenario is that the EU is just over there...it makes much more sense to trade with our nearest neighbour than Papua New Guinea, or wherever. Dover is infinitely preferably to flying everything in from the other side of the planet. Remember air miles?

Dover isn't "infinitely preferable" to any alternative.

It's great when it works and awful when it doesn't. If we want to continue to rely on it, fine. The problem is when it all goes wrong, the people who want to continue that reliance disappear into the woodwork with the profits they managed to extract and it's "no one could have possibly foreseen this was going to happen". Who does that remind you of ?

A bit like the GFC which was supposed to be a six sigma event but ended up hitting us out of nowhere.

Strategic bottlenecks and inbalances are bad news and should not be allowed to develop. However our EU membership has allowed lots of them to happen. The sooner they are unwound IMO the better. That's going to cause some short term pain.

Government these days is mostly about short term benefits rather than long term ones. Kick the can down the road, take the profits now, run up debt and hope imbalances that develop are someone elses (our childrens) problem. I'm one for thinking a bit more long term than that, and accept there are going to be some undesirable short term consequences as a result.

TheDogsMother · 31/01/2024 14:06

But we did get this so everything is great

To be furious at Brexit checks 'price you pay to be sovereign again'
WestwardHo1 · 31/01/2024 13:57

Elisj · 31/01/2024 13:44

Let’s be clear: Theresa May agreed a Brexit deal with the EU which would have meant no border checks on goods.

Boris Johnson sabotaged that deal and used the drama that created to force her out of office. Not because there was anything wrong with May’s deal, but because he saw a path to power.

The border checks aren’t the price we pay for sovereignty, they’re the price we pay for Boris Johnson getting to play at being Prime Minister.

Yes. All cheered on by a) the people who saw a disaster capitalism opportunity and b) the people they manipulated (mainly the people who were already the ones in areas most adversely affected by decades of Tory rule).

No wonder she turned up to his no confidence vote wearing a ballgown. She should have brought party poppers.

EasternStandard · 31/01/2024 13:52

PriOn1 · 31/01/2024 13:39

I think, in an ideal world, Brexit might allow and encourage the UK become a bit more self sufficient, which would be a good thing. It’ll be a long haul though.

I also worry that Labour will get in and be voted straight back out after five years. It’s so obviously going to take a while to stabilize and they will be blamed for not fixing it, even though nobody could manage it in that time scale.

It would take a politician with incredible communication skills and the ability to persuade people to trust that it’s a long haul to give them a proper chance. I don’t believe Starmer has those skills. It would take someone with Tony Blair’s charisma (at the start of his stint as Labour Party leader/PM) to pull it off and I don’t see anyone in the Labour Party who even approaches it.

Edited

Yes there was another thread that was interesting on rejoin, not the usual Brexit tirade usually found

I always wonder given the strength of feeling apparently that no votes on this in the offing. But it would take a good salesperson like that. Starmer is side stepping the too hard and wants Brexit voters anyway

To add - I don’t think many want rejoin but maybe SM / CU. Not sure though without a vote

Haffiana · 31/01/2024 13:52

Andrea Leadsom needs to get back in her box and for a proper grown-up to padlock it properly this time.

Thank FUCK they have already super-glued Jacob Rees-Mogg's box shut or he would be extolling the patriotic virtues of eating our sovereign swedes, turnips & mangold wurzels instead of French cheese, wine & pate, and Dutch butter & salads.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 31/01/2024 13:51

Just wait until the free trade deals are signed with India and others. If people voted for brexit to reduce immigration they are going to be in for a shock.
Again utterly predictable and discussed before the referendum but waved away as "project fear" by Brexit activists.
The next few years are going to be messy.

WinkyTinky · 31/01/2024 13:48

ginasevern · 31/01/2024 12:37

Well I didn't vote for this shit fest. It was the white working class uneducated that mostly fell for the lies. They loved Boris because he was "a good laugh" and Farage because he was photographed holding a pint of beer. Makes me fucking sick.

This is exactly what my stbxh did. And he still stands by it. Hence the stbxh (amongst many other things.)

soupfiend · 31/01/2024 13:48

beguilingeyes · 31/01/2024 13:47

"I think there is going to be some pain in the short term. It's not all benefits. But in the long term it will be much better for us to be more independent and have multiple sources for products rather than be overly reliant on just one partner. That's what opening up competition does."

The trouble with this scenario is that the EU is just over there...it makes much more sense to trade with our nearest neighbour than Papua New Guinea, or wherever. Dover is infinitely preferably to flying everything in from the other side of the planet. Remember air miles?

Remember also 'food standards'

beguilingeyes · 31/01/2024 13:47

"I think there is going to be some pain in the short term. It's not all benefits. But in the long term it will be much better for us to be more independent and have multiple sources for products rather than be overly reliant on just one partner. That's what opening up competition does."

The trouble with this scenario is that the EU is just over there...it makes much more sense to trade with our nearest neighbour than Papua New Guinea, or wherever. Dover is infinitely preferably to flying everything in from the other side of the planet. Remember air miles?

Elisj · 31/01/2024 13:44

Let’s be clear: Theresa May agreed a Brexit deal with the EU which would have meant no border checks on goods.

Boris Johnson sabotaged that deal and used the drama that created to force her out of office. Not because there was anything wrong with May’s deal, but because he saw a path to power.

The border checks aren’t the price we pay for sovereignty, they’re the price we pay for Boris Johnson getting to play at being Prime Minister.

WestwardHo1 · 31/01/2024 13:41

GasPanic · 31/01/2024 13:12

It's good news for us to take a more global outlook on trade. Trade with the EU built up to be a significant choke point, especially around Dover, where industrial action always leads to massive queues (I'm hazarding a guess that when the half term skiing comes around the French farmers will probably take it on themselves to blockade again and no doubt it will "all be the fault of Brexit").

As we rebalance the trade with the ROW, Dover becomes less of a choke point and we should get better pricing. Food pricing is already cheaper in the UK than Europe in general.

I think there is going to be some pain in the short term. It's not all benefits. But in the long term it will be much better for us to be more independent and have multiple sources for products rather than be overly reliant on just one partner. That's what opening up competition does.

How long will these sunlit uplands take to materialise? And in the meantime...?

PriOn1 · 31/01/2024 13:39

GasPanic · 31/01/2024 13:12

It's good news for us to take a more global outlook on trade. Trade with the EU built up to be a significant choke point, especially around Dover, where industrial action always leads to massive queues (I'm hazarding a guess that when the half term skiing comes around the French farmers will probably take it on themselves to blockade again and no doubt it will "all be the fault of Brexit").

As we rebalance the trade with the ROW, Dover becomes less of a choke point and we should get better pricing. Food pricing is already cheaper in the UK than Europe in general.

I think there is going to be some pain in the short term. It's not all benefits. But in the long term it will be much better for us to be more independent and have multiple sources for products rather than be overly reliant on just one partner. That's what opening up competition does.

I think, in an ideal world, Brexit might allow and encourage the UK become a bit more self sufficient, which would be a good thing. It’ll be a long haul though.

I also worry that Labour will get in and be voted straight back out after five years. It’s so obviously going to take a while to stabilize and they will be blamed for not fixing it, even though nobody could manage it in that time scale.

It would take a politician with incredible communication skills and the ability to persuade people to trust that it’s a long haul to give them a proper chance. I don’t believe Starmer has those skills. It would take someone with Tony Blair’s charisma (at the start of his stint as Labour Party leader/PM) to pull it off and I don’t see anyone in the Labour Party who even approaches it.

Lorac23 · 31/01/2024 13:39

Those who think it's a grand thing to have markets to deal with for food products aren't factoring in climate collapse, environmental impact, or the fact that we don't grow/produce enough domestically to feed the population. And if you think the food situation is grand, just wait until you see what's coming with medication supply lines.... hope you and your family don't rely on any common drugs produced in Germany, say.

But hey, project fear, eh.

NoCloudsAllowed · 31/01/2024 13:38

CranfordScones · 31/01/2024 12:55

Why should goods flow unchecked across borders?

Have you been following the news from France in the past week? That's the benefit of not being controlled by the EU.

Hm @CranfordScones

I'm not sure it's that clear cut. As I understand it, the farmers are angry about pressures from energy and fuel costs going up, cost of living etc that cuts everywhere, and at a specifically EU scheme to reform CAP to improve sustainability.

Governments everywhere are looking at sustainability measures. Farmers in the UK are pissed off about the same things, even if they're not protesting in the same way. So I don't really think it's an EU issue.

It is quite a good example of where we're not 'controlled by the EU' but need to do basically the same things as the EU in order to meet a global goal - reducing carbon, improving biodiversity etc. Lots of the things the EU regulated might have caused challenges but they were necessary things to effect progress. Like GDPR etc. The need is still there, the rules will still be a pain, they just won't be EU rules.

There isn't a cloud cuckoo land where just because we're in the EU we can ignore outside pressures and problems.

And as to why goods should flow unchecked across borders - because removing barriers to trade is progressive? Because checks take time, cause bureaucracy, haven't been necessary for a long time, cause food waste and delay etc? Because checks also require exporters to bother with our red tape and a lot of them won't be bothered? Because a large part of brexit was supposed to be about reducing red tape but this imposes a lot more of it?

OP posts:
NoCloudsAllowed · 31/01/2024 13:33

Daphnis156 · 31/01/2024 13:26

Some people just can't let go, and will be doomed to endlessly fight lost battles.
Divert the energy to more positive things.

It's a lost battle in the sense that we've left, we'd never get back in on the same terms, that damage has been done.

But they're planning to enforce controls they said would never be needed, that will cause harm. That's happening now, not in the past.

I don't spend my whole life gnashing my teeth about it but when I see an article flagging up just how utterly without principle or honour the brexit lot are, yes my teeth get a bit gnashy!

OP posts: