Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be furious at Brexit checks 'price you pay to be sovereign again'

459 replies

NoCloudsAllowed · 31/01/2024 12:09

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/jan/31/uk-minister-andrea-leadsom-brexit-checks-price-you-pay-sovereign-state-again

Andrea Leadsom saying barrier checks are the price of sovereignty.

This is not what they promised, is it? The bare faced lies of it all. They've delayed introducing checks because they knew they couldn't square it with Leave campaign promises. In the end, the issue of NI was only solvable by these checks.

This is supposed to cost £330m a year. It will make food more expensive and supply less reliable. There is zero, absolutely zero, benefit to the country. It's just a direct detriment imposed because they can't accept the whole thing is a fuck up.

They never actually express what this sovereignty is supposed to do for us, or what was problematic about the EU rules. It's all on 'the principle of the thing'. Sovereignty won't feed hungry children, will it?

I think I'm just as piping mad about this as I was in 2016 - they're taking the whole country for fools.

UK minister: Brexit checks ‘price you pay for being a sovereign state again’

Andrea Leadsom says businesses experiencing ‘some friction’ should ‘adapt’ to changes in trade rules

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/jan/31/uk-minister-andrea-leadsom-brexit-checks-price-you-pay-sovereign-state-again

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
Havanananana · 31/01/2024 19:46

@IMustDoMoreExercise "No system is perfect, but FPTP is better than most."

That is why no other country in Europe has FPTP, and why the UK is one of only two countries in Europe that do not use some form of Proportional Representation.

"Do you actually know anyone in France or Germany?"

As it happens, I do - having lived in Germany and in two other EU countries, and as I now live just 40 minutes from the German border and can see the news and follow what is happening there.

I know many Germans - and other Europeans. None can understand that the UK tolerates an electoral system that allows a party that obtained the votes of less than 30% of the electorate to have an absolute majority in Parliament. Few can understand why there are no alternative parties in Parliament, let alone in government Where I live, the government is made up of representatives from several parties, including the Greens. FPTP makes this impossible, giving most of the UK a bland choise between Dumb and Dumber. Even though the majority of UK voters voted for a party other than the Conservatives, they still had a majority and have been able to push through laws that are in no way beneficial to the country at large, all the while falsely claiming to be following "the will of the people."

I don't like the politics of some of the extreme parties - in the UK, Germany or anywhere else - but I see no sense in depriving myself of the option of voting for the party that best matches my views just because I don't like the views of someone else who might vote for a party that I don't approve of.

Dymaxion · 31/01/2024 19:41

Legal immigration is forecast to come down.

Are you sure @Clavinova , I could swear it mentioned the population rising to 74 million due largely in part to legal migration, on the news this morning ?

Clavinova · 31/01/2024 19:37

Dymaxion
Which is hilarious really isn't it? Brexit was about immigration and yet legal immigration figures are at record levels under the Tories and forecast to grow even higher

Legal immigration is forecast to come down.

LlynTegid · 31/01/2024 19:29

I would not blame Brexit for the impasse in Northern Ireland just resolved. The DUP would have found some way to object to a Sinn Fein First Minister and used it to extract something from the UK government, even if there had not been Brexit.

TheThingIsYeah · 31/01/2024 19:24

Dymaxion · 31/01/2024 19:20

Uncontrolled mass immigration is an even more toxic issue now than it was back in 2016.

Which is hilarious really isn't it ? Brexit was about immigration and yet legal immigration figures are at record levels under the Tories and forecast to grow even higher. It's almost like it had nothing to do with the EU ?

And yet according to many people on Mumsnet the Tories are "far right"! Lol.

EasternStandard · 31/01/2024 19:24

Dymaxion · 31/01/2024 19:20

Uncontrolled mass immigration is an even more toxic issue now than it was back in 2016.

Which is hilarious really isn't it ? Brexit was about immigration and yet legal immigration figures are at record levels under the Tories and forecast to grow even higher. It's almost like it had nothing to do with the EU ?

Do you think enough people would vote for FOM though if given the option?

EffieeBriest · 31/01/2024 19:21

@couiza We weren’t checking anything up until this week. So much for protecting our borders. The government has kicked it down the road something like 5 times, finally decided to implement it because ….? Who knows, may be there was a time limit.

Dymaxion · 31/01/2024 19:20

Uncontrolled mass immigration is an even more toxic issue now than it was back in 2016.

Which is hilarious really isn't it ? Brexit was about immigration and yet legal immigration figures are at record levels under the Tories and forecast to grow even higher. It's almost like it had nothing to do with the EU ?

couiza · 31/01/2024 19:18

Forgive my ignorance but what does Britain actually have to "Check"?

Is it imports from EU? if so I'm puzzled as to why checks would be needed, as surely EU imports have met all criteria for safety, food safety, animal welfare etc.

Is it checks on the way out (exports), can't see why the recipient country wouldn't undertake that.

Is it part of a mutual agreement, UK import export trade agreement with EU.

I know, I know - I should look it up myself. Still curious, so please don't bite my head off and call me an idiot, many are baffled by all this bureaucracy that we were told would be long gone on our exit.

BarelyLiterate · 31/01/2024 19:13

Moaning about Brexit is a completely pointless waste of time. We all know it has been a disaster for Britain, but it won’t be reversed in the foreseeable future because rejoining is politically impossible. Starmer knows this perfectly well.

Uncontrolled mass immigration is an even more toxic issue now than it was back in 2016. Rejoining would inevitably mean accepting freedom of movement. Anyone who thinks England outside the M25 would vote for that in a referendum is deluded.

megletthesecond · 31/01/2024 19:08

"..guess my point is that I think everyone should be furious about this - Brexit voters as much as anyone".

Tbh most of the people I know who voted for Brexit (colleagues, school parents, gym) aren't they type to watch the news. They won't know this is happening.

EasternStandard · 31/01/2024 19:06

Sourisblanche · 31/01/2024 18:40

I think there will be a slow creep back. Like rejoining Horizon, which as someone who works in STEM, I was very pleased to see.

I welcome this kind of thing for sure

I’m not sure if something as big as FOM ie SM would happen without a vote at GE at least

Clavinova · 31/01/2024 19:04

TheNoonBell
Just be thankful we aren't part of an increasingly authoritarian union that is going out of it's way to destroy the economy of a member state who disagrees with the endless support for a foreign war

Ah yes, the famous 'veto' - Hungary exercises its veto and the EU plots to destabalise Hungary's economy in return.

NB -
I recognise several posters on this thread who recently claimed that EU member states could block every EU law with a veto. However, if you look on the EU's website it quite clearly states that around 80% of all EU legislation is adopted by qualified majority voting;

https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/council-eu/voting-system/qualified-majority/

Unanimity voting is limited to specific policy areas;

https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/council-eu/voting-system/unanimity/

TooBigForMyBoots · 31/01/2024 18:56

PictureFrameWindow · 31/01/2024 17:33

It's batshit isn't it. As if the cost of food isn't high enough already.

Plus the £3pm bung to the DUP to restart Stormont.

Brexit has cost billions and for what?

So Boris could get his name in the history books. I eagerly await the publication of Boris: The Bloke Who Ballsed Up Britain and Beyond.

BouncingJAS · 31/01/2024 18:51

@Clavinova

The City at the Senior Manager level is a fairly small circle of people. Her reputation there is one of comfortable incompetence (there were people like this around who got in based on personal references and not how much value they could add to the bottom line. They dont last all that long and cap out career-wise by being managed out into a role they cannot do much damage in). Nobody speaks highly of her in terms of how productive she was at her job.

Rachel reeves basically got caught plagiarising her book.

Personally, I would have fired her.

But I suspect Starmer doesn't really have anybody that can remotely replace her.

This is the problem with UK politics.

Absolutely nobody competent would ever go into politics. Not in a million years. They stay in the private sector.

Crispedia · 31/01/2024 18:46

TheThingIsYeah · 31/01/2024 18:36

Ok. But people need to stop going on about that fucking bus and the £350m being nonsense. The NHS chomps through nearly £200bn a year; what figure do the Tories need to spend of your money to convince people it's enough? £500bn? £1trn?

Need to fund it equivalent to other EU countries who spend more on healthcare. Tories underfunded it hugely between 2010-2018 and recent increases are not enough to make up for it.

To be furious at Brexit checks 'price you pay to be sovereign again'
Roussette · 31/01/2024 18:45

Meadowfinch · 31/01/2024 18:43

@Roussette No, I meant, for environmental reasons, I buy food with as few miles on them as possible, which means I buy British food for my family wherever possible. I buy seasonal produce and so any extra charges will have less impact on my bill.

Hopefully others will do the same.

I always buy British when I can but honestly some just cannot afford to. I live rurally, my local Co-op has fruit and veg locally grown, it's about 3 times the price. Ditto meat from local farmers.

Crispedia · 31/01/2024 18:44

Sourisblanche · 31/01/2024 18:40

I think there will be a slow creep back. Like rejoining Horizon, which as someone who works in STEM, I was very pleased to see.

I agree and v much hope this will happen.

Meadowfinch · 31/01/2024 18:43

@Roussette No, I meant, for environmental reasons, I buy food with as few miles on them as possible, which means I buy British food for my family wherever possible. I buy seasonal produce and so any extra charges will have less impact on my bill.

Hopefully others will do the same.

Crispedia · 31/01/2024 18:41

TheNoonBell · 31/01/2024 18:00

Just be thankful we aren't part of an increasingly authoritarian union that is going out of it's way to destroy the economy of a member state who disagrees with the endless support for a foreign war.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2024/01/30/inside-eu-plan-strangle-hungary-economy-ukraine-funding/

A state who's leader has been elected more times than any other european leader yet somehow is called "undemocratic" by unelected EU commision officials.

Also read up about Putin. He is the one who has decided the west is his enemy, has invaded Ukraine and hugely hints he wishes to invade neighbouring European countries. Europe don’t want war but Putin’s actions and words suggest he may want it. Orban supports Putin.

EffieeBriest · 31/01/2024 18:40

Listened to a brexit supporter on LBC this evening. He quite seriously said that trade with the EU hadn’t changed and was ‘98%’ the same as before. Tom Swarbrick was gobsmacked. This is what we are fighting, the deliberate distortion of facts quite clearly designed to influence the more gullible.

Sourisblanche · 31/01/2024 18:40

I think there will be a slow creep back. Like rejoining Horizon, which as someone who works in STEM, I was very pleased to see.

Clavinova · 31/01/2024 18:39

BouncingJAS
She was a failure at her job

How would you know? Your first post implied she was a career politician.

All of us in the City pretty much all fell off our chair laughing when she claimed to have worked as an investment banker

Leadsom never claimed to have personally been a fund manager, and Bob Yerbury, former Chief Investment Officer at Invesco Perpetual and Leadsom's former manager, dismissed the controversy about how she described her time there and described her as "totally honest"

And what do you think about Rachel Reeves' CV? There's a great deal of hype about her having worked for the Bank of England - as far as I can see she stopped working for the Bank of England when she was aged 27.

Roussette · 31/01/2024 18:39

I loathe Leadsom, I really do. She typifies everything I dislike about the Tory Party

Crispedia · 31/01/2024 18:38

EasternStandard · 31/01/2024 18:26

It doesn’t seem to come up much in policies

Do you think all of them Labour included have just decided we can’t go there

I think Starmer and co rightly don’t want this election to be about Brexit or rejoining as it’s a bit too soon but I think the coming years there will be more MPs openly discussing the benefits of being part of the single market and customs union.