Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A school absence v holiday one!

57 replies

Bartlebum · 31/01/2024 08:42

Last year both my children's grandparents died. As they were from a different country, my husband wanted to scatter their ashes there.

We went out of the way to coordinate this in school holidays but the only way we could make it work (as there are not daily flights to this small country) would mean we missed two days of school. While we were in the country we arranged to meet family members and introduce the children to their uncles, aunts and cousins. Some of these people are 80+ so it felt so important to my husband to give them the chance to meet them, especially as his parents had not reached this age.

We wrote a letter to the school to explain the importance of this trip and why - including that it was to scatter their ashes. Their immediate response was that they don't approve holidays and refused to discuss further.

It was very upsetting especially as we take school so seriously and had never taken them out before except for the funerals. It made me wonder if they considered it just a holiday if someone went to a burial or scatter of ashes of a grandparent in this country.

Next month it will be a landmark birthday for my own grandmother and she has arranged for the family to stay in a nice location in the UK for three nights. As the kids have school I said we will have to miss the Monday and we will arrive late on the Friday. But as it gets closer I am appreciating how lucky we are to still have her and how this could easily be the last chance to do something like this as a family, something my children never got to experience with their other grandparents. I don't want to be the only ones leaving early when we could be spending quality time with a family that never see each other like this.

My AIBU is, as I won't get permission, is it better to mark them as sick that day? What would the repercussions be for lying? I know it will affect the trust if they found out, but after the way they handled it last year I don't have much trust in them already.

YABU - Don't miss time off school, leave the gathering!
YANBU - Mark them as sick and stop worrying about it!

Thanks for your honest feedback. I will take it on board.

OP posts:
drivinmecrazy · 31/01/2024 12:41

Testina · 31/01/2024 12:00

“Whatever happened to 'at the Heads discretion'?”

Possibly a huge increase in the number of parents asking the Head to authorise at their discretion? (which is my cousin’s experience as a primary school head, and she says she links it to both growing entitlement in everyone for everything, and the “breakdown in social contract” that everyone is talking about re attendance generally.

Would you mind explaining what you have written?
Is it that Heads are being given increasingly spurious requests?
A genuine question because I'm trying to see how increasingly requests for genuine reasons are being lumped in to request's for holidays.
If it is a case of so many parents requesting time off impacts on those asking for exemptions for genuine reasons then that's so sad.
I'm not for one second blaming schools for not allowing these absences. Biut it's the lack of common sense.
To differentiate between a family taking an AI holiday to Mexico and a family prioritising family member and relationships seems to have become blurred.

It's so sad that they are both being treated the same under the current situation

TinyYellow · 31/01/2024 12:03

Don’t lie to the school about your children being sick. They will know it’s a lie and lose any respect for you.

Just tell the truth. Your reasons are valid, it’s too little time to be referred for a fine, and it makes no difference to you or your children if they have a couple of unauthorised absences on their record.

Testina · 31/01/2024 12:00

“Whatever happened to 'at the Heads discretion'?”

Possibly a huge increase in the number of parents asking the Head to authorise at their discretion? (which is my cousin’s experience as a primary school head, and she says she links it to both growing entitlement in everyone for everything, and the “breakdown in social contract” that everyone is talking about re attendance generally.

Testina · 31/01/2024 11:58

“I got lost down the trail of thought that if they were from this country it would have been approved.”

That seems quite the leap!
I’m not surprised that you had a standard form letter back. I also don’t see why time abroad to scatter ashes would be approved even if it was a personalised response - it didn’t sound like there was any cultural restriction on how quickly that should happen, so I don’t see that it had to involve missed school. Which is not to say that you shouldn’t miss school for it - I personally think that’s fine for otherwise good attendance. But I’d expect authorised to be for when you really don’t have a choice - and here, you did.

For the current request - I don’t see any harm in a day off for children with good attendance for family reasons, I’d just do it. I wouldn’t lie to anyone. But I also wouldn’t expect authorisation. In my email to school I’d probably say, “I know that you can’t authorise this, but Lucy has 99.2% attendance, and we’ll make sure that she checks with a classmate what she missed.”

drivinmecrazy · 31/01/2024 10:23

I think it's so sad these days that the rules are so rigidly enforced.
Many years ago when DD1 was in year 2 (she's now 23) we were able to take her out for almost half a term with no ramifications from the school or on her education.
My Dad was terminal, coming to the end of his life living overseas.
We went with the schools blessing.
I know that's an extreme example but hearing that parents are put in the position of lying or getting fined for spending a few precious days making memories with their family is infuriating and heartbreaking.
Whatever happened to 'at the Heads discretion'?

TempleOfBloom · 31/01/2024 09:59

The non-approving of holiday absence isn’t personal, they simply don’t have an absence code for holiday / family time that can be approved.

You won’t get fined for the two days, just say they will be absent for an important family occasion.

ObsidianTree · 31/01/2024 09:55

As an ex teacher that never got to go on any term time holidays, this year have booked a holiday and taking my kids out of school before half term for a few days.

As a teacher I know parents take their kids out of school a lot! It never bothered me personally. Your child's teacher probably isn't going to get annoyed or offended. Especially as it sounds like your kids are in 99% of the time...which in itself is amazing considering a lot of kids get sick often!

So take them out of school. Don't ask for permission. I bet quite a few kids from the class are out on hols at various points in the year. You wont be the only one.

Bluevelvetsofa · 31/01/2024 09:49

The letter is the standard response to a holiday request ( even though you didn’t regard it as a holiday). Schools are not permitted to authorise holidays during term time and it is policy, rather than a decision by individual schools.

You'll probably have noticed that there’s a big push by the government to improve attendance. It isn’t aimed at people like you, who rarely do this, but the policy states no term time holiday and that’s what they have to abide by.

Just, as others have said, tell them the dates that the children won’t be in school. They can’t authorise it, but that’s all.

Londonrach1 · 31/01/2024 09:41

Don't lie. Your child will tell their teacher they saw Granny etc. sounds like other letter was standard response they have to send. Did you get fined for that time. Have lovely birthday with your family member x

Bartlebum · 31/01/2024 09:38

Wolfiefan · 31/01/2024 09:25

Ex teacher and a stickler for ensuring my kids have the best attendance possible.

Just go and enjoy it. Let the school know what is happening. They can’t and won’t authorise it. It’s not personal. Schools are under huge pressure to optimise attendance. Ignore!

@Wolfiefan thanks so much, that makes me feel so much better.

OP posts:
Wolfiefan · 31/01/2024 09:25

Ex teacher and a stickler for ensuring my kids have the best attendance possible.

Just go and enjoy it. Let the school know what is happening. They can’t and won’t authorise it. It’s not personal. Schools are under huge pressure to optimise attendance. Ignore!

TealSapphire · 31/01/2024 09:13

Wow I just googled and there was an article that nearly 350,000 parents got fines last year, mainly for holidays. 350,000 x $120 = $42,000,000. Sorry to go off topic but my little mind is blown!

Do you pay school fees? Here in Aus we pay around $45 for primary and $75 for high school 'voluntary contribution' so you don't HAVE to pay. Then maybe a little more for some elective subjects in high school.

Bartlebum · 31/01/2024 09:09

@user1492757084 yes we did take them in the end, and weirdly the school closed those days due to the water supply being cut off!!!

OP posts:
Bartlebum · 31/01/2024 09:07

@TealSapphire the fine is £60 per parent per child I believe. You can't refuse to pay else it just increases and people that have taken it to court have lost.

I have a friend who took her kids out for a week and she said the total fine she had was nearly £500. But most people I know haven't been fined at all.

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 31/01/2024 09:06

If you apply for permission, are refused then say they are sick the school will know any way.
Just be honest and enjoy the party.

For your last trip... the school couldn't officially give permission. Doesn't mean they actually minded. The rules are extremely limited.

user1492757084 · 31/01/2024 09:06

Did you end up taking the kids overseas to spread their grandparent's ashes? I hope so.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 31/01/2024 09:06

Tell the truth and enjoy your holiday.
My children have just lost their grandma and I'd take a million fine/unauthorised absences to give them just one more memory if I could x

TealSapphire · 31/01/2024 09:02

I can't believe you get fined for absences!! No wonder posters are so stressed about kids being off school. I would just tell the truth but then again I'd probably refuse to pay a fine as it's ridiculous. You'd think in the most part the children who have poor attendance are those with special needs or challenging home lives so need support not fining.

HappyAsASandboy · 31/01/2024 09:01

Just be honest. You are very unlikely to get a fine for a single day absence.

Personally, I'd apply for the day as authorised absence (knowing they'll say no) and then inform the school that the kids won't be in that day anyway because of a family occasion.

Nothing will happen. The teachers and office staff will appreciate the honesty (and secretly agree with you taking them out for a one off family occasion).

Worst case is that you get a fine. It won't be much because it is only one day!

Bartlebum · 31/01/2024 09:00

@Charliebreadness that's great to know. I wish I had done this before! You can save incredible amounts by going a couple of days out for a holiday and we often don't go at all because it's not affordable.

I hate breaking the rules 😭

OP posts:
Bartlebum · 31/01/2024 08:56

I wouldn't have told the children to lie by the way, I just wouldn't have said anything to them. The more I think about it the more I realise that saying they are sick is pointless.

OP posts:
Charliebreadness · 31/01/2024 08:54

Just seen your update, I have had SLT tell me well we obviously cannot approve but have a wonderful time and I wish we could take advantage of term time holidays. That was both in primary and secondary when we took them out for 2 days.

DinnaeFashYersel · 31/01/2024 08:54

Don't lie.

Just take them out and tell them why.

TrixieFatell · 31/01/2024 08:53

Bartlebum · 31/01/2024 08:49

@44PumpLane thank you. I think I did take it personally as we didn't see it as a holiday and it was emotionally charged for us after what the kids had been through. It was a cold standard response, but like you said probably just.the same.foe everyone.

I got lost down the trail of thought that if they were from this country it would have been approved.

Not necessarily. My children have had to miss a day because of their grandads funeral and that's marked as an absence.

Charliebreadness · 31/01/2024 08:52

Just take them out and stop worrying about it. It is 2 days. Missing school is far more problematic when it is regular like once a fortnight, not 2 days once a year. Children are often ill for longer than that and off school. Schools don't authorise holidays in term time as a blanket ban.

Don't lie, we often had children "sick" who come back with a tan and tell us all about their Spanish holiday and all the Spanish words they learned to be able to order an ice cream. It also is an awful thing to make your child do as you see their scared faces when they realise they have fucked up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread