Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - or are the Faraway Tree books utterly insane?

189 replies

BaleOfHay · 31/01/2024 07:28

I've started reading these to DD5 at bedtime and they are making my head hurt. I'm all for a bit of magic (we've just finished the Worst Witch) and I loved Enid Blyton a a child (Famous 5) but the Faraway Tree makes me want to scream and throw it out of the window. Is it just me?

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 31/01/2024 10:14

AnglepoisePond · 31/01/2024 09:44

I think she got reinvented as Dame Scold or something in the reissue! Certainly I picked up a copy at some point when DS was of an appropriate age and Jo had become Jo, Bessie had become Betty (I think?) and Fanny was Franny, and the various punitive authority figures were handing out ‘scoldings’ rather than slaps. Which read quite weirdly in some parts.

Yes, I remember my rather nervous dd reading the modern ones and thinking how much the children/elves/etc were over reacting as how dreadful Dame Snap's (I think it was) school was. She didn't see her as particularly scary and yet they were all trembling in terror

I got the original ones and she said they made much more sense.

I can understand them not wanting to show a "good" character being violent as it could be seen to approve of the actions (like when Darryl slaps Gwen in Malory Towers), but to take it out with a "bad" character you're clearly meant to think of as wrong, seems silly.

ShoePalaver · 31/01/2024 10:10

VinegarTrio · 31/01/2024 08:55

If THIS isn’t snobbery, I don’t know what is.

Morals and manners still matter. But the very mid-20th century middle class English morals and manners in Blyton are a problem in many ways.

Specifically what morals and manners do you mean? Can't think of anything that's problematic to the extent that children shouldn't be allowed to read about it?

IrritatingIrritant · 31/01/2024 10:05

I had a miserable childhood. The stories properly helped me ‘escape’.

OrlandointheWilderness · 31/01/2024 10:04

Oh completely bonkers. I loved them as a kid!

IrritatingIrritant · 31/01/2024 10:03

SilkyMoonfaceSaucepanMan · 31/01/2024 08:44

They’re incredible.

see my username (which was not changed for this thread).

Excellent name! I often tell my daughter that she reminds me of silky!

EasternStandard · 31/01/2024 09:59

I think I still have these from childhood

I don’t remember them well enough to know if insane

cocunut · 31/01/2024 09:58

I loved these books as a child; and I’m only in my 20s! Shocked at PPs calling them dated! I’m not that old 😱

Flamme · 31/01/2024 09:50

Roastiesarethebestbit · 31/01/2024 07:56

I loved them as a child and I really enjoyed reading them to my own child. She found them very exciting and engaging.

Thomas the tank engine on the other hand, I had to hide them as I found them
painful to
read.

I enjoyed them, as did my children.

DS absolutely loved Thomas and we had to plough through one of the books every night. I didn't mind them but for the fact that they were just that bit too long, and I really struggled to keep awake myself while reading them. If I tried to miss a page he would be wide awake telling me off.

AnglepoisePond · 31/01/2024 09:44

javamum · 31/01/2024 09:33

Kids and I loved it. Still get a sense of fear thinking of Dame Slap’s school! The forerunner to every fairytale baddie for me…

I think she got reinvented as Dame Scold or something in the reissue! Certainly I picked up a copy at some point when DS was of an appropriate age and Jo had become Jo, Bessie had become Betty (I think?) and Fanny was Franny, and the various punitive authority figures were handing out ‘scoldings’ rather than slaps. Which read quite weirdly in some parts.

borntobequiet · 31/01/2024 09:41

Loved them as a child, but yes they are utterly bonkers. Still far better than much of the trash aimed at children nowadays.

OddityOddityOdd · 31/01/2024 09:40

I absolutely loved them but my DC didn't take to any Enid Blyton. They loved Just William though, do any DC still read these books ?

VickyEadieofThigh · 31/01/2024 09:38

We had them read to us at primary school in the 60s. I have very fond memories.

Whynoholiday · 31/01/2024 09:37

Dd refused to listen to Faraway Tree she thought the books so awful and I was incredibly disappointed! I think they are really cool stories actually.
Years ago I heard that Sam Mendes had obtained the film rights though nothing seems to have come of that.

javamum · 31/01/2024 09:33

Kids and I loved it. Still get a sense of fear thinking of Dame Slap’s school! The forerunner to every fairytale baddie for me…

LIZS · 31/01/2024 09:31

Loved them as a child. Used to dream about lands rotating. There is a film in the offing too.

3WildOnes · 31/01/2024 09:28

All the slapping has been removed from recent editions.

My children all adored these books.

AnglepoisePond · 31/01/2024 09:21

SilkyMoonfaceSaucepanMan · 31/01/2024 08:44

They’re incredible.

see my username (which was not changed for this thread).

It was Silky, Moonface and the bloody Saucepan Man that I loathed, even as a child who adored virtually all other Enid Blyton — the basic scenario of a magic tree whose topmost branches are visited by different magic countries is a good one, but the characters are either completely generic (you could switch the names of Jo, Bessie and Fanny around without changing the story in the slightest, other than Jo bossily thinking he has to ‘protect’ the girls) or the generic wrong’un child who gets reformed (Connie, Dick) or idiotic/ cantankerous (Angry Pixie (angry), Saucepan Man (comedy-deaf and stupid), Whatsisname (sleeps).

I always felt I should like it more than I did, as EB is clearly trying to convey that the children’s family is actually poor (they have to walk the five miles from the station, the mother wants to take in washing, the children do all the housework and grow food in the garden), rather than the UMC world of the Famous Five or Five-Find Outers, with their cooks and maids and deferential farmers’ wives and WC Ern being sent to have tea in the kitchen, but I think it’s a weirdly violent fictional universe. The kids get slapped at home for not doing their jobs properly, and there’s also a lot of punishment, smacking, scolding etc in the fantasy parts.

I think the recent reissues changed the children’s names and took out all the slaps.

kerstina · 31/01/2024 09:19

I used to love these but I sometimes felt they never went quite far enough. They are probably the reason I have quite a creative brain! I don’t think there were any other stories around like these .

PontiacFirebird · 31/01/2024 09:16

Yabu- the Faraway Tree books were amazing!
Someone upthread commented on how it was sad that the mum wanted her “DC” out all day and to ask for nothing. That made me snort a bit, as that was normal childhood for me in the 70s / 80s! Running wild, tons of freedom, no money, no material expectations. Good things and bad things about that of course, but it meant we could relate to the idea of roaming the woods and finding adventure. The idea of take what you want for children now probably seems redundant now as children are surrounded by unlimited goodies.
I loved the “ Adventure” series too.

Bemyclementine · 31/01/2024 09:11

I loved them as a child, gave read them to my sons, they love them and have read them themselves.

I really struggled with the Narnia books, I ADORED these as a child, read them over and over. Recently ploughed through The Magician's Nephew, the children were not engaged with it at all and the language was really difficult. None of us enjoyed it and haven't moved on through the series

BaleOfHay · 31/01/2024 09:09

(They were a present - I think the reason I didn't read them as a child, despite devouring other Blytons, is that my mother also couldn't face them!)

I think those of you mentioning the fantasty genre have hit the nail on the head. I don't do fantasty. I like magic, but somehow grounded in the real world, if that makes any sense (the Worst Witch for example), but fantasy leaves me cold. I never liked Narnia as a child and Lord of the Rings/the Hobbit do not interest me one jot. Maybe I'm too boring. I even buy lottery tickets monthly just so that I can day drea about winning, I cound't justify the day dream if there was zero chance of winning!

Still - I'll read them for DD as clearly they are a wonderful memory for some of you. I just might need a stiff drink when I come downstairs to reset the madness!

OP posts:
Strugglingtodomybest · 31/01/2024 09:07

Roastiesarethebestbit · 31/01/2024 07:56

I loved them as a child and I really enjoyed reading them to my own child. She found them very exciting and engaging.

Thomas the tank engine on the other hand, I had to hide them as I found them
painful to
read.

Me too. I'd fall asleep reading Thomas books they were so boring.

I absolutely loved the Faraway Tree when I was little, it was so exciting. I love travelling as an adult too, all those faraway lands to explore!

lollipoprainbow · 31/01/2024 09:06

@soupfiend precisely

FuzzyCaoraDhubh · 31/01/2024 09:05

I loved The Enchanted Wood and the Faraway Tree when I was a kid. I've found old copies of these on WOB. Great memories (photos attached).

AIBU - or are the Faraway Tree books utterly insane?
AIBU - or are the Faraway Tree books utterly insane?
Pickingmyselfup · 31/01/2024 09:03

Absolutely the Faraway Tree books are insane, complete fantasy but it's what makes them great. I loved them as a child and as an adult rebought them for my kids, they aren't fussed but I still love them.

Moonface is still my favourite.

Swipe left for the next trending thread