Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think charging an electric car with just the 3 pin plug for 4 months is not a good idea

59 replies

Catsinacot · 31/01/2024 03:40

DH has ordered himself a new electric car. We have spoken about it for a while and agreed it's a good call for us. However, he's ordered the car and then arranged for an at home charger to be installed through our energy supplier who have told us it's likely to be 16 weeks until they can install.

DH says this is fine, we'll just charge it at home using the 3 pin plug. DH does a lot of miles, probably 300 a week so this feels completely unfeasible to me given the charge will be so slow. Also, im worried trying to change that much on a normal plug will overheat the plug. We did have our electric mains fuse board upgraded 3 years ago so DH says there's no risk but I'm worried.
WIBU to tell him to cancel the order and just wait until the at home charger arrives? He ordered through an online retailer so he can cancel.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhatWouldTheDoctorDo · 31/01/2024 23:08

I'm assuming the 16 wait time is Octopus OP. We had the same thing recently, so decided to get a local electrician to install one for us, it cost a bit more, but it was worth it to get something installed quickly. Using a 3-pin plus for a length of time didn't appeal to me.

Has he paid for the charger install already? Can he cancel if you find an alternative installer?

fiftiesmum · 31/01/2024 23:03

@LongTimeListener1 the two types of home charger are both fine - it is the rapid chargers on the road which can cause problems if used too much.
The problem we have found with a three pin plug is having it dangling out of the window or through a letter box

toastandtwo · 31/01/2024 22:27

We’ve been charging two cars off 3 pin plugs for nearly 5 years now. Nothing has spontaneously combusted yet (touch wood!)

LongTimeListener1 · 31/01/2024 22:21

fiftiesmum · 31/01/2024 13:11

Slow charging is better for the car - the rapid chargers can make the battery heat up.
Plug in every night and if you have night tariff then you will have almost free fuel.

Yes but in practice the difference in heat generation per kWH between charging at 3kW off the plug or 7kW off a home charger is really small.

fiftiesmum · 31/01/2024 13:11

Slow charging is better for the car - the rapid chargers can make the battery heat up.
Plug in every night and if you have night tariff then you will have almost free fuel.

MrsJamin · 31/01/2024 12:55

If you're on Octopus you can keep the car plugged in but hand over the charge/don't charge signal to them, so that you only charge when you get a low tariff. This has a great benefit that the whole house is then covered by a low tariff, even if it's the middle of the day. This is to take care of surplus in the grid (windy days it seems) and is pretty unpredictable but at the moment it seems that we always get it when we plug in and the car needs to charge. Then it presents a big saving and we do a bunch of washing / batch cooking.

GasPanic · 31/01/2024 10:56

The short answer is that charging with a granny charger (3 pin plug) is fine provided your electrical infrastructure is in good shape. Manufacturers would not produce systems to do this unless it was safe.

The caveat in the above statement of course is "provided your electrical infrastructure is in good shape". A granny charger will draw about 10A. There is nothing pluggable in your house that will draw that amount of current for that long a time (many hours to charge). Kettles and toasters maybe, but for short periods. Tumble driers possibly the only thing that will come close, cookers will, but are normally hardwired. In other words, nothing is going to test out better whether or not your wiring and connections are in good shape.

And let's face it, a lot of houses have electrical wiring that is in a pretty shocking state and has not been rewired for half a century and checked in 20 years.

I have recently acquired a hybrid and use the granny charger off a dedicated spur. You need to be careful if for example you are running it off a ring, because if you are running other high power devices off the same ring that may cause the fuse to trip, or worse overload the wiring without the fuse tripping if it is in a bad state. When I ran mine for the first time I ran it on half power (5A) and checked everything was not getting too hot. I then started running at 10A. The sockets and wires (in what I consider to be a well maintained installation) rose in temperature by about 5C, so you can tell that the system is being worked.

What I would not do is plug in a system on full power for the first time on an old and poorly maintained electrical installation and then skip off merrily down the park for 8 hours with your kids and then leave it to the gods to decide whether by the time you come back your house isn't a smoldering wreck. If you have any doubts at all about the integrity of your wiring it should be checked out by a competent electrician beforehand in my opinion.

Re the chargers, you can get I think 3.2kW and 7.2kW installed at home easily. 3.2 will charge about 1.5x faster than the plug (2.4kW), 7.2 3x faster. So faster but still not particularly quickly. When the dedicated charges are installed the electrician will make sure the wiring is highly rated to account for the demand. I think the DNO (which people incorrectly call the "National Grid" on here) need to be notified for a 7.2kW charger. Not so sure about the 3.2kW. You may need the DNO fuse (next to the meter) upgraded from 60A to 100A for the 7.2kW and if your house is on a shared supply that may need to be split. I do not know whether the DNO charges for this or not. Personally I think getting a wall box installed is a great way of making sure your infrastructure is up to the challenge and that the wiring is all correctly rated. There are also some other things about wallboxes that make them more suitable for long term charging, but you can look then up on the web if you are interested.

Re the range, I can charge about 30 miles in 4 hours. So with a granny charger you should easily be able to charge 300 miles per week.

Re the cost, obviously you will save more with a tariff, but you do not need one to save money.

My last car was a diesel and very efficient at 50 mpg. That works out to about 12 miles per litre. One litre of diesel is about £1.50, so that is about 12.5p a mile.

At the current price cap electricity is about 30p per kWh. My car takes 4 hours @ 2.4 kW to charge for 30 miles, ie about 10 kWh per 30 miles, or 3 miles per kWh which works out to be about 10p per mile. So cheaper than the very efficient diesel and hopefully the electric price will come down soon.

Flopsythebunny · 31/01/2024 10:43

Hereyoume · 31/01/2024 08:16

I hope you haven't bought that car, leasing maybe, but not actually bought.

The value of EV's is going to crash dramatically over the next 12 months, most industry people are predicting at least 40 percent.

And a 3 pin plug isn't even a consideration, tell your DH to forget that fantasy. It's public chargers for the next few months.

This is all nonsense. Many ev owners only use a granny charger without a problem.
An ice car will depreciate at least 30% in its first 3 years

MoFoFlo · 31/01/2024 10:39

Does your DH have chargers at his place of work? DH has an EV as his company car, there are chargers provided at two of the offices he works at so rarely needs to charge it outside of work time. He occasionally uses local charging stations. Never had to charge at home and has now decided not to bother getting a charge point fitted.

LongTimeListener1 · 31/01/2024 10:32

Hereyoume · 31/01/2024 09:00

I'm assuming the OP's DH is going to be travelling more than 65 miles a day for business. Maybe 100 miles Monday, 20 on Tuesday, 120 on Wednesday . .

In which case he would a proper fast charge, not a trickle from a 3 pin plug.

A trickle from a 3-pin plug will still be fine for this usage. A little bit annoying depending on where OP’s nearest plug socket is, but it’s only a few weeks.

MrsAvocet · 31/01/2024 10:32

We were on this situation for a while when we got our EV. Not 3 months though. I think it took about 6 weeks to get our charger installed. It's perfectly safe. VERY slow though and meant that we couldn't restrict charging to the cheap tariff so that, plus the fact that we needed to use public chargers a few times as it wasn't ready prior to longish journeys made it more expensive than it is now. It's much more convenient with a proper home charger but you can make do with a 3 pin plug. I wouldn't like to do so long term, but for a short while it's doable.

QuietlyAppalled · 31/01/2024 10:23

And it's not for long - after months of promises, the council are installing an on-street one this week!😀

QuietlyAppalled · 31/01/2024 10:22

It's a very quiet street. And the best quality (designed to drive over in a warehouse so hardly any disturbance) cable cover. I make DH pack it in at dusk to just in case. What really brought home the beauty of EV and, yes, made me feel decidedly unselfish, was a small incident the other day. I was stopped at a corner, waiting to turn, and a dad and a very young child crossed the road immediately behind me. My initial reaction was a guilty 'oh that child is very close to the exhaust' and then I remembered there is no exhaust – so whatever the debate about EVs, the undeniable fact is that a child walking near one is not sucking in particulates or fumes. That's worth having to have a few charging apps on my phone and being a little creative on long journeys.

TedWilson · 31/01/2024 10:22

@Midnightstares yeah we purchased ours via Podpoint then received a letter from the national grid saying it would need an inspection!

DeathStarCanteenGal · 31/01/2024 10:15

A proper charger at home isn't necessarily a fast charger @EilonwyWithRedGoldHair
At home charges can charge at 7kwh max, while a fast charger somewhere else can be up to 50kwh
So while it takes me several hours overnight to charge my car, which has a 51 kwh battery, I could do it in an hour on a fast charger
the good thing though about charging at home is the low cost....both myself and DH have EVs and our electricity bill is about £100 per month, where as previously we were spending £350-£400 on petrol and diesel
And would second what a PP said about getting an EV tariff from your electricity provider - we have this and also run washing machine, dishwasher etc overnight when our electricity costs are much cheaper

TheReturnoftheSmartArse · 31/01/2024 10:13

We've been doing it for 6 years ...! Like the PP, we're in London with no off-street parking, but we run from an outside plug point in our garden and use a heavy-duty trip protector to cover the cable. No idea if it's actually allowed, but no one has complained (yet!). In fact, there are several cars in our road now doing the same. It is of course slow to do it that way, but I find I get around 20 miles overnight, which is fine for day-to-day use.

I don't think there's any danger with a 3-pin plug though.

floralrainbows · 31/01/2024 10:13

DD has an electric car which when fully charged says the range is 220 - it goes down 2 miles for every mile she drives though. Utter waste of time but she is stuck with it for another 2 years.

She charges in public chargers which isn't an issue at all, juts the actual range

WaxhamSeals · 31/01/2024 10:08

QuietlyAppalled · 31/01/2024 08:32

We live in London with no off-street parking and manage this. It never occurred to us that charging off the normal home socket (which we’ve done for just over two years) was an issue. DH runs the cable under a trip protector , through the tiny front garden and either through the letterbox to a switch by the front door or through the front window to a switch. It’s not our main mode of charging - there’s a great fast charger in our local supermarket (so rather than paying to park I’m paying for charge) and if I go shopping I choose an on street charger if I need it rather than paying £4+ per hour to park. There’s so much negativity about EV and people do love to point out why they’d be impossible, but we just crack on and it’s the best car we’ve ever had.

Selfish. Trip protectors just make the public pavement bumpy for wheelchairs, mobility scooters and pushchairs. The pavement is not for your personal charging convenience. Use a proper charger

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 31/01/2024 10:03

TedWilson · 31/01/2024 09:13

It really depends on the state of your electrics so I wouldnt risk it. When you have a proper charger fitted the National Grid come
Out and check it and even with relatively new electrics at our house they still made some form of adjustment.
I would identify where your nearest fast charger is and if that is feasible. Ps I bloody hate charging!

But a 'proper' charger is a fast charger. If you're just plugging it into a normal socket it will charge slowly and surely there wouldn't need to be any adjustment. A quick Google suggests it's perfectly safe and won't use more electricity than an electric kettle or an immersion heater, ok kettles aren't on for hours, but for a while I had to plug our immersion heater into a normal socket and there were no issues.

Midnightstares · 31/01/2024 10:00

TedWilson · 31/01/2024 09:13

It really depends on the state of your electrics so I wouldnt risk it. When you have a proper charger fitted the National Grid come
Out and check it and even with relatively new electrics at our house they still made some form of adjustment.
I would identify where your nearest fast charger is and if that is feasible. Ps I bloody hate charging!

Do they? We’ve had chargers installed at two different houses now and never knowingly had the National Grid come and check it?

rainydaysaway · 31/01/2024 09:59

We had a hybrid for 3 years, fully electric for 3 years and have just gone back to hybrid and have only ever charged on a 3 pin plug.

It’s slow but works perfectly for what we need. I’d estimate that we do around 250 miles per week.

whosaidtha · 31/01/2024 09:56

My sil just plugs hers in at Morrisons when she does the weekly shop. And occasionally at KFC

ntmdino · 31/01/2024 09:54

Also, on the safety/will-the-car-blow-up point...slower charging is safer than fast charging when unattended. The same goes for everything with a battery in it; faster charging generates more heat, which in turn increases the chance of swelling/fire.

BillStickersWillBeProsocuted · 31/01/2024 09:49

Hereyoume · 31/01/2024 09:00

I'm assuming the OP's DH is going to be travelling more than 65 miles a day for business. Maybe 100 miles Monday, 20 on Tuesday, 120 on Wednesday . .

In which case he would a proper fast charge, not a trickle from a 3 pin plug.

What are you basing that assumption on? OP Has said 300 miles per week. Most EVs have a range around 300 miles now anyway so even if he doesn't get to 100% each day he'll easily be able to stretch out to a week

Worst case he'll have to use a fast charger on the road occasionally if he has 2 longer days back to back, but it's ridiculous to say "not even a consideration" and "forget that fantasy"

Do you have a source for the 40% drop in value claim?

PremiumRaa · 31/01/2024 09:47

Our charges on a three pin plug overnight it's totally normal. The car range is 220 miles, it charges 10mph from a 3 pin plug.

Just charge it up fully then top up overnight a couple of times a week. No reason why he couldn't have it fully charged each morning.